Court Pastry Shop

- 298 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231

Introduction / Overview

For over 75 years, Court Pastry Shop has been a beloved and essential fixture of the Carroll Gardens neighborhood, standing proudly at 298 Court St in Brooklyn, NY. Founded by the Zerilli family in 1948, this pastry shop is not just a place to buy dessert; it is a vital slice of New York history and tradition, dedicated to providing authentic, high-quality Italian and Sicilian pastries. Stepping inside Court Pastry is often described by New Yorkers as being "transported back in time," with its traditional decor and timeless ambiance perfectly preserving the charm of an earlier Brooklyn era.

Court Pastry Shop is renowned across the city for its consistently excellent quality, making it a go-to destination for cakes, cookies, and classic Italian pastries. The establishment is famous for its "Great dessert" and offers a decadent selection that includes celebrated items like their cannoli birthday cake, Italian Butter Cookies, and summer favorites such as custard ice. The shop maintains a friendly, professional tone, with one customer specifically praising the owner, G. Zerilli, as "one of the nicest people you will ever find."

While the popularity of this local gem can lead to extended lines during peak times, such as holidays and summer weekends, patrons consistently advise that the wait is always worthwhile. The shop is well-prepared to serve the quick-moving pace of New York, focusing on a Quick visit model and offering convenient services like Delivery. Whether you are a lifelong New Yorker or a visitor seeking an authentic, traditional taste of Brooklyn, Court Pastry Shop promises fresh, delicious, and deeply satisfying Italian sweets.

Location and Accessibility

Court Pastry Shop is ideally located at 298 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA, placing it directly in the heart of Carroll Gardens. This section of Court Street is a central artery for the neighborhood, ensuring high visibility and easy access for local residents and visitors traveling to the area for its renowned dining and shopping.

Accessibility is a key priority for the shop, which features a Wheelchair accessible entrance, ensuring all members of the community can enjoy their delicious offerings. For those driving, Paid street parking is available nearby, though New Yorkers are advised to plan for typical city parking conditions. The shop accepts all major modern payment methods, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, ensuring a quick and seamless transaction whether you are grabbing a single pastry or an entire birthday cake. Additionally, the shop provides Delivery service, bringing the authentic taste of Sicily directly to your doorstep.

Services Offered

• Delivery: Convenient service to bring the shop's famous desserts and pastries directly to customers' homes or events.
• In-Store Shopping: Provides a traditional, authentic experience inside the historic shop, designed for a quick visit.
• Custom Cake Orders: Specializes in custom cakes, including their celebrated cannoli birthday cake, for celebrations and events.
• Beverages: Offers Coffee to pair perfectly with the selection of Italian pastries and cookies.
• Wide Range of Payments: Accepts Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments for customer convenience.

Features / Highlights

• Historic Brooklyn Institution: Founded by the Zerilli family in 1948, the shop maintains a timeless ambiance and traditional decor that transports visitors back in time, making it a cherished neighborhood fixture.
• Authentic Sicilian Desserts: Specializes in high-quality, fresh, and decadent authentic Sicilian and Italian desserts, ensuring a taste that is true to tradition.
• Celebrated Specialties: Renowned for specific offerings such as the famous cannoli birthday cake, classic Italian Butter Cookies topped with jam and sprinkles, and traditional summer favorites like custard ice.
• Allergy-Friendly Options: Offers almond paste cookies that are naturally gluten and dairy free, catering to friends with common allergies while staying true to the authentic preparation method.
• Classic Pairings: Sells the highly-praised Anisette toast, often enjoyed with a nice tea or coffee, providing a perfect light, traditional treat.
• High-Quality Reputation: Consistently praised by customers for the high quality and freshness of its desserts and cakes, with many affirming that the quality makes the occasional long line "worthwhile."

Contact Information

Address: 298 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA

Phone: (718) 875-4820

What is worth choosing

A visit to Court Pastry Shop is a quintessential New York dessert experience, and selecting just one item can be a delightful challenge. For an authentic and decadent taste of Sicilian tradition, New Yorkers should absolutely choose the Cannoli. The shop's reputation for its cannoli is so strong that it features a celebrated cannoli birthday cake, making it a must-try for any first-time visitor.

Another highly recommended item is the Italian Butter Cookies, particularly those topped with jam and sprinkles. These are a classic treat and a perfect example of the shop's consistently high quality. For customers who have friends or family with dietary restrictions, the almond paste cookies are an excellent choice, as they are naturally gluten and dairy free—a rare find for such authentic quality.

Finally, for a more subtle, traditional pairing, consider the Anisette toast. As one loyal customer noted, it is the perfect accompaniment to the shop’s coffee or a nice tea. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick, single-serving treat or planning a major celebration, Court Pastry Shop guarantees a taste of time-honored tradition and delicious decadence that has kept Brooklyn coming back for over seven decades.

Court Pastry Shop

298 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, USA