Da Mario Pizzeria

- 25 Park Ave, Rutherford, NJ 07070

Nestled in the heart of downtown Rutherford, Da Mario Pizzeria stands as a true local gem, celebrated across Bergen County not just as a reliable Pizza restaurant, but as a full-service, welcoming Italian restaurant. This establishment, conveniently located on Park Avenue, has captured the loyalty of local Groups, College students, and Families alike, making it a cornerstone of the area’s dining scene. The atmosphere is authentically Casual and Cozy, inviting guests to relax and enjoy generously portioned, high-quality Italian fare.

Da Mario Pizzeria is popular for both Lunch and Dinner, offering an enormous menu that extends far beyond traditional plain pies. Here, New Jersey residents can find comfort in classic, homestyle Comfort food ranging from specialized Neapolitan-style pizzas and massive calzones to elaborate veal and seafood entrees. The establishment proudly Serves local specialty items, ensuring that customers experience dishes unique to this Rutherford favorite. Whether you need a Quick bite during the day or a full family Dinner, Da Mario Pizzeria delivers a consistently friendly and satisfying experience, highly recommended by locals for its courteous service and delicious food.

Da Mario Pizzeria is strategically situated at the bustling address of 25 Park Ave, Rutherford, NJ 07070, USA. This location places it directly in the vibrant downtown area of Rutherford, making it easily accessible for pedestrians and a highly visible spot for local patrons and visitors to the borough. The central location provides proximity to local shops and businesses, positioning it as an ideal stop for a meal while running errands or meeting friends.

Understanding the needs of all members of the New Jersey community, the venue provides essential access features. The facility includes a Wheelchair accessible entrance and dedicated Wheelchair accessible seating, ensuring that all guests can dine comfortably inside the Casual atmosphere. While the location on Park Avenue is excellent for foot traffic, patrons planning to drive should be mindful of local parking regulations, as is common in busy downtown areas. Despite this, the convenience of the central location and the ease of access make it a preferred choice for many locals.

Da Mario Pizzeria provides a comprehensive range of service options designed to meet the diverse needs of Rutherford and Bergen County residents, focusing on speed and convenience for all dining preferences.

• Flexible Dining Options: Customers have multiple ways to enjoy their authentic Italian meal, including relaxing Dine-in service with Table service, quick Takeout options, and reliable Delivery for home enjoyment.
• Modern Delivery: For maximum safety and convenience, the restaurant offers No-contact delivery options, allowing seamless receipt of orders.
• All-Day Service: The restaurant covers key dining periods with service available for both Lunch and Dinner, accommodating the schedules of College students and busy local Groups.
• Specialty Service: For larger events or family gatherings, the restaurant provides Catering services, extending its generous portions and quality menu to bigger parties.
• Quick Options and Amenities: For those grabbing a quick meal, Counter service is available. The venue is Good for kids and features necessary High chairs. Furthermore, a clean Restroom and comfortable Seating are provided for all dining guests.
• Payment Methods: Transactions are kept simple and fast, as the restaurant accepts all major Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

The true highlight of Da Mario Pizzeria is the sheer scope and quality of its menu, presenting a full Italian dining experience in a friendly pizzeria setting. This breadth of offerings is why it is consistently rated a local favorite.

• Specialty Pizza Excellence (Serves Local Specialty): The pizzeria section is extensive, featuring New Jersey favorites and unique creations. Patrons can choose traditional styles like the Large Plain Pizza (16”) or the thick-crusted Sicilian Pizza, or indulge in the celebrated Specialty Pizzas:
  • The Grandma pie, often noted by customers as an excellent square thin-crust option.
  • Savory pies like the Buffalo Chicken, Penne Vodka, Bacon Chicken Ranch, and the fully loaded Mario’s Special.
  • Unique offerings such as the Eggplant Rollatini Pizza and the Cardinal pizza (featuring grilled chicken, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, and balsamic).
• Comprehensive Italian Dinner Specials: Da Mario operates as a full Italian restaurant, evidenced by the vast array of full-plated Dinner Specials, all known for their generous portions:
  • Veal and Chicken Classics: Including Chicken Francese, Chicken Piccata, and rich preparations like Veal Marsala with Mushrooms and Chicken Saltimbocca.
  • Baked Dishes: Featuring comfort favorites such as Homemade Meat Lasagna, Manicotti, and Baked Penne Vodka.
  • Seafood Selections: A selection of fresh Seafood dishes including Shrimp Parmigiana, Calamari Marinara, and Linguini with red or white Clam Sauce.
• Quick and Affordable Lunch Options: The dedicated Lunch Specials (11am-3pm) provide exceptional value for money, allowing locals to enjoy full Italian entrees like Baked Ziti ($7.00), Eggplant Parmigiana ($10.00), and a variety of Chicken dishes like Chicken Marsala with Mushrooms ($10.00), complete with generous portions.
• Heroes and Comfort Food Staples: The menu is rounded out with delicious grab-and-go options including fully stacked Cold Heroes (e.g., Prosciutto, fresh mozzarella, roasted peppers, and Balsamic) and Hot Heroes (e.g., Veal Parmigiana and Cheese Steak), alongside classic appetizers such as Fried Calamari, Mussels, and large portions of Garlic Knots.

To place a takeout order, inquire about delivery, or discuss catering options for your next gathering in Rutherford, please use the following contact details for Da Mario Pizzeria.

• Address: 25 Park Ave, Rutherford, NJ 07070, USA
• Phone: (201) 935-5817
• Mobile Phone: +1 201-935-5817

For anyone in the New Jersey area, Da Mario Pizzeria is the definitive choice when seeking a genuinely satisfying and authentic Italian meal. What makes it truly worth choosing is the successful blend of two worlds: the quick, satisfying convenience of a top-tier Pizza restaurant with the extensive, quality menu of a traditional Italian restaurant. Customers consistently highlight the exceptional value, noting the Very generous portions and the delicious taste of signature dishes like the Chicken Francese with sauteed broccoli.

The restaurant’s commitment to providing a local specialty is a major draw. For pizza enthusiasts, the specialty pies—particularly the highly praised Buffalo Chicken Pizza or the thick-crusted Grandma—offer a taste that stands out in the crowded New Jersey pizza landscape. For those desiring a sit-down meal, the quality of the veal and chicken entrees, combined with the classic Baked Dishes like Homemade Meat Lasagna, ensures a delightful Dinner experience. The overall atmosphere, described by patrons as clean, welcoming, and staffed by courteous, friendly people like Tina, elevates the experience. Da Mario Pizzeria is a dependable, high-quality establishment that feels like a home kitchen, making it a reliable favorite for Locals and Family-friendly dining in Rutherford, NJ.

Da Mario Pizzeria

25 Park Ave, Rutherford, NJ 07070, USA