Denville Seafood & Codmothers Cafe

- 61 Broadway, Denville, NJ 07834

For generations of New Jersey residents, Denville Seafood & Codmothers Cafe has been the undisputed local source for the absolute freshest seafood. Located right in Denville, this establishment is far more than a conventional restaurant; it operates as a specialized Fish store and a beloved, full-service Seafood restaurant under one roof. Since its establishment in 1952, this Denville institution has been committed to bringing the best of the ocean inland, sourcing its daily catch straight from the renowned Fulton Fish Market. The local ownership and deep community roots, highlighted by a history of resilience and commitment to quality, make this a truly unique Morris County dining experience.

The dual nature of the business—a vibrant retail fish counter adjacent to the cozy Codmothers Cafe dining room—is the ultimate guarantee of quality. Customers can literally browse the raw, uncooked fish before sitting down to enjoy their meal, ensuring that the selection is current and pristine. The atmosphere is consistently described as Casual, Cozy, and Quiet, creating a welcoming, nautical-themed space where the focus remains squarely on the food. While the dinner menu prices reflect the true quality and cost of fine, fresh seafood, many guests agree that the generous portion sizes and expertly prepared dishes are well worth the investment in an exceptional meal.

The kitchen prides itself on serving a Local specialty that celebrates the rich flavors of the sea. Whether it is a rich bowl of Lobster Bisque, a hearty cup of New England Clam Chowder, or an expertly cooked Swordfish Steak, the staff provides attentive and Table service, making every visit a pleasant and memorable occasion for Locals, Groups, and Family-friendly gatherings alike.

Location and Accessibility

Located in the heart of Denville, Denville Seafood & Codmothers Cafe is a convenient dining and retail destination for North Jersey residents.

The address is:

61 Broadway, Denville, NJ 07834, USA

Accessibility is thoughtfully addressed to accommodate all guests:

• The location is fully accessible, featuring a Wheelchair accessible entrance, Wheelchair accessible parking lot, Wheelchair accessible restroom, and Wheelchair accessible seating.
• Parking is readily available, with both a dedicated Free parking lot and Free street parking options near the Broadway location, easing the stress of a visit during peak hours.

Services Offered

Denville Seafood & Codmothers Cafe offers a comprehensive range of services tailored to meet the needs of every customer, from a quick solo lunch to a major catered event.

• Dine-In and Takeout: Guests can enjoy the full dining experience with comfortable Seating in the cafe, or opt for Outdoor seating on pleasant days. All menu items are available for Takeout, with the added convenience of Curbside pickup and Delivery options.
• Retail Fish Market: A core service is the adjacent Fish store, where customers can purchase fresh, uncooked seafood, including various fish, clams, oysters, and more, to prepare high-quality meals at home. Staff at the counter are often available to provide recipes and tips.
• Reservations and Group Dining: The restaurant Accepts reservations, which is highly recommended for Groups, especially during the busy Dinner service, to ensure a smooth and timely experience.
• Beverage and Amenities: The establishment focuses on the food quality. While they offer a variety of hot drinks like Coffee, Espresso, and Cappuccino, and cold drinks like Boylan's Bottled Soda and San Pellegrino, guests should note the absence of a liquor license, making it an ideal local spot for a BYOB experience (customers may bring their own wine to pair with their seafood). The restaurant also provides High chairs and a dedicated Kids' menu (Minnow Meals) for family dining.
• Catering Services: Full Catering services are available, allowing customers to bring the restaurant’s renowned fresh fish and classic chowders to their special events.

Features and Highlights

The primary highlight of Denville Seafood & Codmothers Cafe is the unparalleled freshness and diversity of its menu, focusing on genuine quality and customization.

• The Ultimate Fresh Fish Selection: The market-to-table connection ensures the menu is consistently stocked with high-demand catches and specialty items. Customers can select from numerous fish varieties, including Flounder, Scrod, Red Snapper, Chilean Sea Bass, King Salmon, Grouper, and the daily catch (Fish Of The Day).
• Customized Preparations: Nearly all entrées offer a choice of preparation style—Broiled, Fried, Sautéed, or Baked—and can be customized with various sauces, including the classic white wine-butter sauce, or more adventurous options like Rosemary, Lemon-caper, Scampi, or Teriyaki sauces. This ensures a dish is perfectly tailored to your preference.
• Signature Shellfish and Soups: The soup menu is a local legend, featuring five different options, including the rich and creamy New England Clam Chowder and the tomato-based Manhattan Clam Chowder. Shellfish highlights include appetizers like Shrimp Cocktail and Jumbo Lump Crabmeat Cocktail, and full entrées from The Lobster Pot, offering Steamed Lobster (per Lb.) and specialty South African Lobster Tail.
• Value-Focused Lunch Options: The lunch menu is highly valued, with a vast selection of fish (e.g., Flounder at $14, Shrimp Scampi at $14) and "Landlubbers" options (e.g., Chicken Parmigiana at $12) that are served until 3:00 PM. All lunches come with coleslaw and a choice of side, providing a fantastic value proposition for a fresh midday meal.
• Options for Every Taste: The menu features extensive Comfort food choices, alongside many Healthy options. For non-seafood fans, the Landlubbers section includes Chicken Tenders and pasta choices like Linguini And Broccoli. The children’s Minnow Meals menu is also varied, offering classics like Mrs. A's Fish Sticks and Chicken Tenders.

Contact Information

For the latest daily specials, market hours, or to make a reservation for a group, please use the following contact details:

Address: 61 Broadway, Denville, NJ 07834, USA

Phone (Primary): (973) 627-2987

Mobile Phone: +1 973-627-2987

What is Worth Choosing: A True Taste of the Shore in Morris County

Choosing Denville Seafood & Codmothers Cafe is choosing a commitment to freshness that is unmatched in the Morris County area. The unique structure of the business—operating as both a premier retail fish market and a dining cafe—provides a level of quality assurance that a traditional restaurant cannot replicate. The fact that the fish is sourced from the Fulton Fish Market, a detail highlighted by the staff and owner, means you are dining on fish of metropolitan caliber, right here in New Jersey.

The dining experience is entirely focused on the plate. The expertly prepared dishes, whether you opt for a simple Broiled fish in a light white wine sauce or an indulgent Shellfish Sauté in a spicy marinara, showcase the main ingredient perfectly. The ability to customize your meal with your choice of preparation and sauce, and to combine items in the Fried Combinations for a mixed platter, ensures a personalized and satisfying dining experience every time.

Furthermore, the convenience and value make this spot an easy choice for local users. The excellent Lunch pricing, the flexible Takeout and Delivery options, and the convenience of bringing your own beverage for a BYOB experience all contribute to a dining value proposition that is hard to beat. For Denville and the surrounding New Jersey communities, Denville Seafood & Codmothers Cafe is not just a seafood restaurant; it is a long-standing tradition of quality, making it the perfect choice for your next meal or fresh fish purchase.