Dominick's Italian-American Deli

- 401 Herricks Rd, New Hyde Park, NY 11040

When New Yorkers talk about a great deli, they’re looking for more than just sliced meat—they’re looking for a local institution that delivers on quality, portions, and that unmistakable, old-school Italian-American flavor. In New Hyde Park, Long Island, one name consistently rises to the top: Dominick’s Italian-American Deli. This veteran-owned establishment has firmly cemented its reputation as the go-to spot for everything from specialty heroes piled high with premium ingredients to comprehensive catering for any event. A visit here is a classic Long Island experience—always bustling, always worth the short wait, and always satisfying.

Dominick’s Italian-American Deli isn't just a sandwich shop; it's a full-service deli, caterer, and Italian grocery store, serving the New Hyde Park community and beyond. The consistent stream of local customers is a testament to the quality and value they offer, proving that in a region famous for its delis, Dominick’s stands out. From the moment you step in, the commitment to fresh, high-quality meats, cheeses, and homemade Italian specialties is evident, making it a beloved local treasure and a vital part of the area's food culture.

A significant part of the Dominick's appeal is its specialty sandwich menu, which features creative and generously sized options that have become local legends. Many customers rave about the sheer value and superior taste compared to national chains, noting that the combination of top-tier ingredients and hearty portions is unmatched. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick lunch or planning a major family celebration, Dominick's provides the authentic, delicious Italian-American fare that Long Island relies on.

Dominick's Italian-American Deli is conveniently located at 401 Herricks Rd, a central hub for those in New Hyde Park and surrounding Long Island towns. Its location makes it easily accessible for locals running errands or commuters needing a quick, hearty meal. For those driving, the deli has prioritised ease of access, offering both a complimentary parking lot and free street parking, a true convenience in the busy New York area.

The deli is committed to being welcoming to all members of the community. In terms of accessibility, Dominick’s ensures a smooth experience with a wheelchair-accessible entrance and a designated wheelchair-accessible parking lot. This attention to customer convenience, from the physical space to the variety of service options, contributes to its status as a reliable, local favorite for a quick visit and consistently good food.

Dominick's provides a diverse range of services to meet the needs of their busy New York clientele, blending traditional deli service with modern convenience.

• Catering: Offering an extensive catering menu perfect for birthdays, office parties, christenings, and other significant events. Their catering services cover everything from hot entrees like Chicken Parmigiana and Baked Ziti to large cold cut buffet platters and party heroes, providing authentic Italian-American feasts for gatherings of any size.
• Delivery and Takeout: For customers on the go or those who prefer to dine at home, the deli offers flexible service options including local delivery and quick takeout, making it easy to enjoy their delicious food regardless of your schedule.
• In-store Pickup and Shopping: Customers can place orders for in-store pickup to minimize wait times, or enjoy the experience of in-store shopping to browse their selection of specialty Italian groceries, freshly prepared salads, and daily specials.
• Onsite Services: The deli provides onsite services, ensuring a comprehensive, in-person customer experience for selecting and preparing fresh deli meats, cheeses, and specialty products.

Dominick’s Italian-American Deli has built its reputation on several key features that set it apart in the competitive Long Island food scene. These highlights are frequently cited by loyal customers and are what make the deli a memorable and consistent choice.

• The Famous Chicken Fingers: Widely regarded as the "Home of Dom’s Famous Chicken Fingers," this item is a crowd-pleaser and a signature feature, drawing patrons from far and wide for its superior quality and flavor. They are available in individual portions and in trays for catering.
• Specialty Heroes and Sandwiches: The deli is known for its creative, generously portioned specialty sandwiches and heroes made with the freshest meats and cheeses. Notable mentions from satisfied customers include the Kevincito Special (Chicken Cutlet, Fresh Mozzarella, and Broccoli Rabe) and the Fitz & Slip (Fried Chicken Cutlets, Hot Soppressata, Prosciutto, Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Red Peppers, and Balsamic Glaze on a Semolina Hero).
• Veteran-Owned Business: Dominick's proudly identifies as a veteran-owned establishment, adding a layer of community pride and service commitment to its operations.
• High-Quality Ingredients: A core principle of the business is the commitment to using only the best and freshest ingredients, from premium deli meats to house-made mozzarella and fresh-baked bread.
• Payment Convenience: Dominick’s makes transactions easy by accepting a variety of payment methods, including all major Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC mobile payments.
• Exceptional Value: Customers consistently point out that the portions are generous and the prices are very fair, especially when considering the superior quality and freshness of the food, often outperforming higher-priced competitors.

For direct inquiries, placing an order, or learning more about their catering options, you can contact Dominick's Italian-American Deli using the following information:

Address: 401 Herricks Rd, New Hyde Park, NY 11040, USA

Phone: (516) 746-2116

For a first-time visitor or a returning customer looking to try something new, the sheer variety at Dominick’s can be overwhelming—but a few menu items consistently garner high praise and are truly worth choosing. You simply cannot visit without experiencing the legendary Dom's Famous Chicken Fingers. They are often cited as the best in the area, offering a perfect, crispy texture and savory flavor. They serve as an excellent stand-alone snack, a great side, or the core component of some of their best sandwiches.

For a true taste of a specialty hero, the highly-praised Kevincito Special is an ideal choice, featuring the delicious combination of breaded chicken cutlets, fresh mozzarella, and sautéed broccoli rabe for a flavorful and hearty meal, priced affordably at around $12.95. Another must-try is the Fitz & Slip sandwich, which encapsulates the Italian-American spirit of the deli, piling together fried chicken cutlets with hot Soppressata, Prosciutto, fresh Mozzarella, roasted red peppers, and a balsamic glaze on a fresh semolina Hero, offering a rich and complex blend of flavors. Customers consistently highlight that even with specialty ingredients, the prices remain highly competitive, especially when comparing the quality and portion size to other local options.

Beyond the signature heroes, consider the quality of their side dishes, such as the excellent homemade cole slaw, which provides a fresh counterpoint to the rich sandwiches. If you are planning an event, Dominick’s catering menu, with its vast selection of hot entrees and impressive party heroes, is a guaranteed way to bring authentic, high-quality Italian-American fare to your guests. In New Hyde Park, Dominick’s Italian-American Deli is more than just a place to grab a quick bite; it's a neighborhood staple built on tradition, quality ingredients, generous portions, and truly superior deli offerings.

Dominick's Italian-American Deli

401 Herricks Rd, New Hyde Park, NY 11040, USA