Dugan’s Sandwich Shop

- 1165 Old Country Rd, Plainview, NY 11803

For New Yorkers on Long Island, a truly great local deli and sandwich shop is more than just a place to eat—it's a community fixture. Dugan’s Sandwich Shop in Plainview exemplifies this, carrying a history that spans over 65 years, making it a genuine piece of "vintage Long Island," as noted by long-time patrons. Operating as a classic Deli, Sandwich shop, Fast food restaurant, and Takeout Restaurant, Dugan’s delivers quick, high-quality meals in a casual setting that caters perfectly to the pace of Nassau County life. It is the go-to spot for locals needing a fast, hearty, and reliable meal, from morning till dinner.

The culinary offerings at Dugan’s are designed to satisfy every craving. At its core, the menu is built on robust deli favorites and fresh, customizable fare. The classic 'Sandwiches' selection includes all the staples, such as the filling Roast Beef Sandwich ($12.41), the beloved Chicken Cutlet Sandwich ($12.41), and cold cuts like Smoked Turkey Sandwich ($11.37) and Pastrami Sandwich ($13.44). Beyond the basics, the 'Sandwich Specials' introduce unique and complex combinations, like the Italian Hero ($14.48), the hot Grilled Pastrami Special ($14.48), and the Buffalo Chicken Special ($14.48). Customers looking for more hot favorites can enjoy menu blocks like 'Other Favorites', featuring a cheesy Philly Cheese Steak ($14.48) and the savory BBQ Roast Beef ($14.48). This vast selection ensures that whether you're looking for a quick comfort meal or a traditional deli experience, Dugan's has an appealing option.

Dugan’s is equally renowned for its dedication to the New York breakfast tradition. The 'Breakfast' menu is comprehensive and available for both solo dining and groups. Options range from simple, essential morning fuel like a Buttered Bagel ($3.61) or an Egg On Roll ($4.75) to full, plate-style meals. For those with a large appetite, the Hungry Man ($9.82) provides substantial value, while the omelet selection covers every taste, including the hearty Ham & Swiss Omelet ($11.37) and the lighter Vegetable Omelet ($11.37). Traditionalists can opt for Buttermilk Pancakes W/ Meat ($11.37) or the full 2 Eggs, Meat, Homefries & Toast ($11.37). Critically, the shop is known for its beverages, particularly its Great coffee, served hot (up to $3.61 for large) or iced (up to $4.96 for large), essential for starting any Long Island day.

Completing the full-service menu are popular 'Burgers & Fried Food' items. The highly-rated 1/2 Lb Angus Burger ($10.34), which patrons recommend, is a testament to the deli’s ability to execute comfort food classics. Sides include both French Fries ($4.66) and Onion Rings ($4.66). For a lighter, yet satisfying, option, the daily Soup, available in small ($6.72) and large ($7.23), is praised, often perfectly paired with a sandwich during the cooler months. The large selection of grab-and-go beverages—including fountain sodas, branded drinks like Red Bull ($3.11), and water like Essentia/Core ($4.65)—ensures convenience for takeout customers. The inclusion of healthy options like the Tossed Salad ($13.44) and Grilled Chicken Sandwich ($10.34) also showcases the shop’s effort to cater to diverse nutritional needs.

Finally, the extensive catering menu makes Dugan’s an indispensable resource for local businesses and families. The 'Hero's By The Foot Catering' offers popular choices such as the Italian Hero (C) ($20.65 per foot) and the American Hero (C) ($20.65 per foot). Platter options, including Wrap Platter (C) ($13.44 per person) and Sandwich Platter (C) ($13.44 per person), simplify corporate luncheons. For more formal events, full hot entrees are available, from Chicken Parmigiana (C) and Chicken Marsala (C) to classic pasta dishes like Baked Ziti (C) and Rigatoni A La Vodka (C), cementing its capability as a full-service caterer for any event size, from small office meetings to large family celebrations. They also offer delightful hors d'oeuvres like Fresh Mozzarella Tomato & Basil (C) and Gourmet Cheese Basket (C).

Location and Accessibility

Dugan’s Sandwich Shop is strategically located at 1165 Old Country Rd, Plainview, NY 11803. This central Long Island address offers maximum convenience for customers throughout Nassau County. Accessibility is a key feature of the location, ensuring a positive experience for all patrons. The property offers excellent parking facilities, including a Free parking lot, Free street parking, and dedicated On-site parking.

The facility also ensures compliance and comfort for those needing specific accessibility features. It provides a Wheelchair accessible entrance, a Wheelchair accessible parking lot, a Wheelchair accessible restroom, and Wheelchair accessible seating. The general atmosphere is Casual and inviting, popular with Locals and suitable for Groups and Good for kids. Customers can choose to enjoy their meal at the seating area or take advantage of the Outdoor seating when the weather is favorable.

Services Offered

Dugan's provides flexible, New York-friendly service options:

• Dine-in: Casual seating is available, including Outdoor seating when weather permits.
• Takeout: Efficient service ideal for quick stops, befitting a Fast food restaurant and Deli.
• Delivery: Convenient service to bring your meal directly to your home or office.
• Full Menu Service: Serving a wide range of options for Breakfast and Lunch.
• Catering: Comprehensive food and beverage catering for parties, meetings, and events.
• Payment Versatility: Accepts Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, ensuring a quick checkout.

Features / Highlights

Key highlights that define the Dugan's experience:

• Historic & Local Status: Over six decades of service establish it as a trusted, "vintage" Long Island institution.
• Great Coffee: Specifically highlighted for the quality of their coffee, available both hot and iced in multiple sizes.
• Diverse Offerings: Provides a perfect mix of Comfort food (burgers, fried food) and Healthy options (salads, grilled chicken), catering to all dietary moods.
• Quick Bite Specialist: Efficiently handles fast service, making it ideal for a quick, quality Lunch or Solo dining.
• Comprehensive Parking: Offers multiple free parking options, a significant advantage in the busy metro area.
• Full-Service Catering Menu: An expansive catering service with everything from hero sandwiches to full pasta and meat entrees, all ready for local pickup or delivery.

Contact Information

For placing an order, booking catering, or general inquiries:

Address: 1165 Old Country Rd, Plainview, NY 11803

Phone: (516) 921-1182 or +1 516-921-1182

What is Worth Choosing Dugan’s Sandwich Shop

Dugan's Sandwich Shop is worth choosing because it embodies the enduring appeal of a classic Long Island deli fused with modern convenience. It’s a place where history meets efficiency. While customer feedback, like the review mentioning a dry sandwich and a side error, suggests occasional inconsistencies typical of any high-volume operation, the shop’s decades-long loyalty base—including a customer whose mother "loves this place" for bagels—speaks volumes about its overall quality and essential community role. The staff are described as "nice" and capable, keeping the operation running smoothly even during "chaotic" peak hours.

The sheer depth of the menu ensures that Dugan's is the only stop you need to make. Whether you require a substantial Chicken Burger ($11.17), a traditional breakfast sandwich with Hash Browns ($2.07), or a full catering spread featuring Lasagna (C) and Italian Meatballs (C), Dugan's has the volume and variety to deliver. Its commitment to accessibility and multiple payment options, including mobile NFC, makes every transaction quick and stress-free. For a reliable, historic, and multi-faceted dining and catering option in Plainview, Dugan’s Sandwich Shop stands out as a true New York regional favorite on Old Country Road, offering both the speed of fast food and the quality of a seasoned deli.

Dugan’s Sandwich Shop

1165 Old Country Rd, Plainview, NY 11803, USA