For New Yorkers in the vibrant Flatbush neighborhood of Brooklyn, Exquisite Supreme stands out as an eatery that perfectly encapsulates the borough's rich culinary diversity, proudly operating as both a beloved Caribbean restaurant and an essential source for American restaurant style comfort food. Situated conveniently near Brooklyn College, this establishment serves up dishes that are deeply authentic to the islands and profoundly satisfying as hearty, traditional meals. The owners' confidence in their food is well-placed, as diners consistently rave about the main courses, confirming that staples like the Oxtail, Curried Goat, Jerk Chicken, and Stewed Chicken & Dumplings are "Fantastic" and represent genuinely "Good food!" The restaurant proudly Serves local specialty, bringing the rich, complex flavors of the Caribbean directly to the 11210 area code and establishing itself as a local culinary favorite.
The menu at Exquisite Supreme is extensive, thoughtfully structured to cover every meal period, making it highly Popular for Breakfast, Lunch, Dinner, and Catering. For those starting their day, breakfast options include the popular Bake & Ackee ($9.00), featuring Jamaica's favorite exotic fruit, and Bake & Codfish ($6.50), a fluffy fresh dough treat served with sautéed codfish. The heart of the lunch and dinner menu lies in its substantial and flavorful mains. The highly-rated Oxtail is a signature choice, praised for its "Juicy flavor... cooked and simmered in tasteful seasonings" ($21.00). The flavorful Jerk Chicken ($14.00), marinated in a delightful blend of fresh island herbs and spices, then grilled over an open flame and finished with their signature jerk sauce, is repeatedly listed as a top-liked item. Side orders are equally crucial to the experience, with options like the rich and cheesy, baked Mac & Cheese ($7.00) and the classic, expertly prepared Rice & Peas ($5.50), made with red kidney beans, coconut milk, and island spices. The atmosphere is generally described as Casual and Trendy, featuring a steam table for quick service and ample seating, welcoming a diverse crowd that includes nearby College students, Tourists, and neighborhood residents seeking a satisfying Comfort food fix.
Exquisite Supreme is strategically located at 2905 Glenwood Rd, Brooklyn, NY 11210, USA. Its position in the Flatbush neighborhood, situated just off Flatbush Avenue and near the Brooklyn College campus, makes it a convenient and regular stop for both the student body and area residents. Located between East 29th Street and Nostrand Avenue, the eatery is central to a vibrant and high-traffic part of the borough.
Accessibility for patrons is a clear priority, especially in a bustling urban environment. For those driving, the restaurant provides a valuable combination of both Free street parking and Paid street parking, offering essential flexibility regardless of local street conditions. This dual parking option is a significant advantage for customers picking up large Catering orders or coming from outside the immediate neighborhood, minimizing the typical stress of parking in Brooklyn. As a highly accessible and visible spot, it welcomes foot traffic from the college and surrounding areas. The combination of easy road access and reliable parking ensures that securing your authentic Caribbean and American comfort food from Exquisite Supreme is a straightforward process, whether you are stopping by for a Quick bite or placing a large dinner order. The overall environment is designed for convenient entry and swift service, supporting its reputation as a local hub.
Exquisite Supreme is committed to providing maximum convenience, ensuring their delectable fusion of Caribbean and American comfort foods are available to all New York residents through various reliable service options:
- Dine-in: Customers can enjoy the casual, comfortable atmosphere with seating and the convenience of a steam table service for an on-site dining experience.
- Takeout: Available for rapid meal pickup, perfect for busy individuals or workers needing a Quick bite to carry home.
- Delivery: Full delivery service is provided, bringing the rich flavors of Jerk Chicken, Oxtail, and other mains directly to the customer's home or office.
- Catering: The restaurant is fully equipped to handle large orders, offering Catering services for events, which is essential for New Yorkers planning parties, gatherings, or large office luncheons.
- Payment Flexibility: They accept modern, convenient payment methods, including major Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, making transactions quick and effortless for any customer.
- Full-Day Service: The restaurant offers dining options for Breakfast, Lunch, and Dinner, ensuring they are a reliable source for authentic food throughout the entire day.
- Children Welcome: The venue is designated as Good for kids, indicating a welcoming and inclusive environment for families.
Exquisite Supreme distinguishes itself in the highly competitive Brooklyn dining landscape through its unique specialization, generous portions, and dedication to serving high-flavor food:
- Dual Cuisine Mastery: Recognized as both a Caribbean restaurant and an American restaurant, it offers a perfectly balanced menu, featuring authentic Caribbean staples like the highly-rated Oxtail ($21.00) and Jerk Chicken ($14.00), alongside essential American comfort food favorites like rich Mac & Cheese ($7.00) and crispy Fried Chicken ($14.00).
- Generous and Flavorful Portions: Diners consistently praise the food, noting that portions are generous and the prices are reasonable for the quality received, often resulting in a satisfying, hearty meal.
- Signature Menu Depth: Their Oxtail is a major draw, celebrated for its tender texture and rich, savory seasonings. Other customer favorites include the Curry Goat ($19.00) and the Brown Stew Chicken ($14.00), showcasing their expertise across various cooking styles.
- Extensive Variety: The menu's depth caters to all tastes, including traditional dishes like Ackee & Codfish ($17.00), several seafood options (e.g., Fried Whiting $16.00, Salmon $19.00), and healthy options like the Veggie Plate ($13.00) and various salads, including a Jerk Chicken Salad ($13.00).
- Ideal Location and Crowd: The establishment is ideally located near Brooklyn College, catering effectively to College students seeking affordable, filling meals, as well as welcoming Tourists and neighborhood locals with its Casual, Trendy atmosphere.
- Breakfast Specialties: They offer unique Caribbean breakfast items, notably the popular Bake & Ackee ($9.00) and Bake & Codfish ($6.50), available for early diners.
- Convenient Parking: The availability of both Free street parking and Paid street parking is a highly valuable amenity in this busy area of Brooklyn.
For New Yorkers ready to experience the fantastic Caribbean and American comfort food offered by Exquisite Supreme, the restaurant is easily accessible in the Flatbush section of Brooklyn:
- Address: 2905 Glenwood Rd, Brooklyn, NY 11210, USA
- Phone (Local): (347) 533-6453
- Mobile Phone: +1 347-533-6453
Whether you are placing a large catering order, planning to dine in, or just grabbing a quick bite, the team is ready to serve the community with their highly-rated cuisine throughout their breakfast, lunch, and dinner hours.
A visit to Exquisite Supreme should undoubtedly focus on their highly celebrated, core Caribbean comfort food dishes. The Oxtail ($21.00) is a premium and essential choice, consistently praised by local patrons for its tender texture and rich, savory seasoning, securing its place as a menu highlight. For poultry lovers, the Jerk Chicken ($14.00) is a must-try, famed for its spicy, flavorful marinade and the smoky complexity imparted by grilling over an open flame, often described as "bursting with flavor." Patrons looking for a lighter, stewed option should try the classic Curry Chicken ($14.00) or the satisfying Brown Stew Chicken ($14.00).
When compiling your plate, ensure you include the perfect pairings. The Rice & Peas ($5.50), cooked with coconut milk and island spices, is the essential base for any of the main entrees, providing depth and authenticity. For a true taste of the American comfort food influence, don't miss the rich and cheesy, baked Mac & Cheese ($7.00). The availability of Small plates and sides like Steam Vegetable “Cabbage” ($6.00) allows for customized, budget-conscious meals, especially popular among College students. While the overwhelming feedback confirms the delicious quality of the food, New Yorkers expect and deserve the highest standards in food service. Exquisite Supreme continues to earn its fantastic reputation by focusing on delivering flavorful meals and maintaining vigilance in its service to the Flatbush community.