Five Brothers Pizza and Pasta

- 2505 Carmel Ave, Brewster, NY 10509

For New York locals in the Brewster area and throughout Putnam County, **Five Brothers Pizza and Pasta** has established itself as a cornerstone of casual, high-quality Italian-American dining. Functioning as a full-service **Pizza restaurant** and a robust **Takeout Restaurant**, it offers an incredibly comprehensive menu that extends far beyond the traditional slice. Patrons can find everything from authentic **Cheese Pizza** and unique **Specialty Pizzas** to classic **Dinner Entrees** and expansive **Catering** options, all served in a casual, cozy, and family-friendly atmosphere.

The core philosophy of Five Brothers is to provide abundant variety and classic Italian **Comfort food** staples, ensuring there is a dish for every member of the family or large group. The depth of the menu, particularly the full range of chicken, veal, and seafood dinners, elevates it from a simple pizzeria to a reliable neighborhood Italian kitchen. Dishes like **Chicken Marsala**, **Eggplant Rollatini**, and a wide selection of expertly prepared pasta, including **Penne Alla Vodka** and **Fettuccine Alfredo**, make it an excellent choice for a satisfying meal any day of the week.

While the establishment has faced operational challenges, including an unfortunate fire event and temporary service disruptions (which customers should always verify by calling ahead), the dedicated customer base frequently praises the owners and staff for their kindness, amazing hearts, and commitment to preparing authentic food. The goal is clearly to provide not just a quick meal, but a genuine connection with their customers, fostering a serene atmosphere that encourages repeat visits. The experience at Five Brothers Pizza and Pasta is intended to be a blend of speed, quality, and a truly welcoming environment.

---

## Location and Accessibility

Five Brothers Pizza and Pasta is conveniently located at **2505 Carmel Ave, Brewster, NY 10509, USA**. This address places it strategically within a key commercial area in Brewster, making it easily reachable from local residential neighborhoods and major roadways like Route 6.

The restaurant is dedicated to providing a comfortable and accessible experience for all New York patrons:

• **Parking:** Guests will find ample convenience with a **Free parking lot** and general **On-site parking**. There is also the possibility of **Free street parking** nearby. Crucially, a **Wheelchair accessible parking lot** is provided.
• **Accessibility Features:** The building is fully accessible, featuring a **Wheelchair accessible entrance**, **Wheelchair accessible seating** within the dining area, and a functional **Wheelchair accessible restroom**.

These amenities ensure that Five Brothers is an inclusive destination, perfect for a spontaneous meal or a planned family dinner.

---

## Services Offered

Five Brothers Pizza and Pasta is designed to serve the community through a variety of convenient dining and ordering options, accommodating individual and group needs.

• **Dine-in and Reservations:** The cozy setting offers traditional **Seating** and **Table service** for both **Lunch** and **Dinner**. They also **Accepts reservations**, which is helpful for planning group dining.
• **Takeout and Pickup:** Customers can utilize standard **Takeout** and the added convenience of **Curbside pickup** for quick and easy meal retrieval.
• **Delivery:** As a full-service **Pizza delivery** location, they offer standard **Delivery** as well as **No-contact delivery** options.
• **Catering Services:** A major feature is the extensive **Catering** menu, covering appetizers, salads, full pasta dishes, baked pasta, and comprehensive chicken, veal, and seafood entrées for large events.
• **Payment Flexibility:** They accept major **Credit cards**, **Debit cards**, and modern **NFC mobile payments**.
• **Amenities:** The restaurant offers an in-house **Restroom** and provides a dedicated **Kids' menu**, making it truly **Family-friendly**.
• **Beverage Options:** The offerings include **Coffee**, **Soda**, and a selection of **Wine** to pair with your meal.

---

## Features and Highlights

The highlights of Five Brothers Pizza and Pasta stem from its dedication to a complete, authentic Italian-American menu and family-focused service.

• **Unmatched Catering Depth:** The catering menu is exceptional, offering nearly 30 full-pan Italian specialties, from **Chicken Francese Catering** and **Veal Parmigiana Catering** to specialized dishes like **Tortellini Carbonara Catering** and **Mussels Marinara Catering**.
• **Specialty Pizza Variety:** The pizza menu goes well beyond the classic **Cheese Pizza**, featuring numerous unique and flavorful options, including:
  • Signature Pies: **Baked Ziti Pizza, Philly Cheesesteak Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, House Special Pizza**.
  • Creative Options: **Teriyaki Pizza, Chicken Primavera Pizza, Salad Pizza**.
• **All-in-One Family Value:** The **Family Size Dinners**, such as the **Family Chicken Dinner For Four** and **Family Pasta Dinner For Four** (both priced at $39.95), offer excellent value and convenience for local families.
• **Comprehensive Italian Favorites:** The menu provides a full range of dinner entrées, including:
  • Chicken Dishes: **Chicken Francese, Chicken Marsala, Chicken Parmigiana**.
  • Baked Pasta & Classics: **Lasagna, Baked Ziti, Ravioli, Eggplant Parmigiana**.
  • Seafood Options: **Shrimp Parmigiana, Shrimp Francese**.
• **Pizza Rolls and Calzones:** A popular category for a **Quick bite** or casual meal, offering a vast selection of fillings such as **Chicken Pizza Roll**, **Sausage & Peppers Pizza Roll**, and various **Calzones** for a fixed price of $9.00 each.
• **Community-Oriented Service:** The atmosphere is noted as **Casual** and **Cozy**, with strong customer testimonials praising the owner and staff for their personal touch, kindness, and commitment to knowing their regulars.

---

## Contact Information

To confirm operational status, place an order, or make reservations, please use the following contact details for Five Brothers Pizza and Pasta:

• **Address:** 2505 Carmel Ave, Brewster, NY 10509, USA
• **Phone:** (845) 278-4500 (or +1 845-278-4500)

Note: Customers are highly advised to call the restaurant directly before visiting, especially for a pickup order, to ensure the current operating status is confirmed, given previous reports of unexpected closures due to circumstances like fire damage, despite online systems remaining active.

---

## What Is Worth Choosing

Five Brothers Pizza and Pasta is worth choosing for New York locals seeking a dependable source for authentic, high-quality Italian-American comfort food, particularly when needing to feed a family or a large group.

The restaurant’s true strength is its versatility and the quality-to-price ratio offered by the large, diverse menu. For $15.00, you can get a full **Specialty Pizza** like the **Buffalo Chicken Pizza** or **Meat Lover's Pizza**. For a busy weeknight, the **Family Size Dinners** are an economical and easy solution. The depth of the menu, which includes nine different Chicken Dishes and nine different Veal Dishes on the catering side, showcases a kitchen that can capably handle a full-scale Italian dinner, not just quick pizza orders. The availability of **Penne Alla Vodka** and **Fettuccine Alfredo** among the **Pasta Dishes** further cements its reputation as a proper Italian kitchen.

In addition to the food, customers who have an ongoing relationship with the establishment speak highly of the personal, caring service, emphasizing that the owner and chef have an "amazing heart" and genuinely care about their patrons. While recent, publicly available information indicates the business has faced severe operational disruption (such as a fire incident) that led to confusion for some prepaid customers, the core offering—delicious, authentic food served in a welcoming, casual setting—is the reason why many long-time customers remain loyal. Therefore, for the New York user looking for an extensive, value-driven Italian menu with a community feel, a direct phone call to Five Brothers before placing an order is the best way to ensure they enjoy a highly satisfying meal.

Five Brothers Pizza and Pasta

2505 Carmel Ave, Brewster, NY 10509, USA