Five Star Deli & Grill

- 2127 Pitkin Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11207

Welcome to a comprehensive guide for New Yorkers looking to explore local dining gems. Today, we're focusing on a neighborhood spot that goes beyond your typical corner store: Five Star Deli & Grill in the heart of Brooklyn. Located in the lively East New York area, this establishment serves up the classic convenience and quick service of an NYC deli while also offering a unique and flavorful menu of South Asian-inspired cuisine. For locals in search of a fast breakfast sandwich, a reliable lunchtime sub, or even an unexpectedly authentic curry dinner, Five Star Deli & Grill aims to be a dependable stop.

The New York City deli is an institution, a cornerstone of local life that provides everything from morning coffee and a 'bacon, egg, and cheese' to late-night snacks. Five Star Deli & Grill embraces this tradition, but elevates its offerings with a distinct menu of Indian and South Asian dishes. This combination of classic American deli fare and rich, aromatic curries is what truly sets it apart, catering to the diverse and ever-changing palates of the Brooklyn community. Whether you're rushing to the train or simply craving a quick, satisfying meal, this location aims to provide both speed and flavor.

Location and Accessibility

Five Star Deli & Grill is situated at 2127 Pitkin Avenue in Brooklyn, New York, within the 11207 zip code. This area is part of the East New York neighborhood, a bustling residential and commercial zone in the eastern section of the borough. The deli's location on a main thoroughfare like Pitkin Avenue ensures it is easily accessible for local residents and those passing through.

For those traveling by public transportation, the deli's location is generally well-served by local buses and is not far from subway lines that connect to other parts of Brooklyn and Manhattan. For drivers, the busy nature of Pitkin Avenue means that parking can sometimes be a challenge, though the convenience of a quick stop for takeout often outweighs the parking situation for many New Yorkers. The area is also highly walkable, making it a natural pit stop for local foot traffic on their daily commute or errands. Its accessible location is a key part of its appeal as a true neighborhood deli.

Services Offered

• Takeout Service: The deli is primarily structured for convenient grab-and-go. This service option is ideal for busy New Yorkers who need to pick up a quick meal without waiting.
• Diverse Payment Options: To accommodate all customers, the establishment accepts both major credit cards and debit cards for transactions.
• Classic Deli & Grill Items: As a deli and grill, it offers the staples that New Yorkers expect, likely including made-to-order sandwiches, burgers, chopped cheese, and breakfast favorites like egg sandwiches and coffee.
• Specialized Indian & South Asian Menu: Beyond the typical deli fare, Five Star Deli & Grill features a dedicated menu section for authentic Indian and South Asian dishes, including a variety of curries and appetizers.
• Focus on Quick Visits: The planning information suggests the deli is optimized for a speedy experience, making it a perfect destination for those on a tight schedule.

Features / Highlights

• Unique Fusion Menu: The most notable highlight is the rare combination of a New York-style deli and a grill serving specialized Indian and South Asian cuisine. This offers an exciting choice for customers who want classic comfort food or an aromatic curry in the same convenient location.
• Flavorful Indian and South Asian Dishes: The menu includes popular, authentic Indian dishes that you might not expect to find at a typical Brooklyn deli. Options like Chicken Tikka Masala and Chicken Makhani are available for poultry lovers, while the Lamb Rogan Josh and Lamb Madras offer rich, slow-cooked flavors. Seafood options include Shrimp Saagwala and Garlic Shrimp Bhuna, and vegetarian choices feature Kadhai Paneer and Paneer Makhani.
• Affordable Appetizers: Starters like Vegetable Samosa and Chicken Samosa provide a great way to begin a meal or enjoy a quick, inexpensive snack.
• Local Convenience: Located right on Pitkin Avenue, the deli serves as a crucial neighborhood amenity, providing accessibility and quick service for the daily needs of the East New York community.

Contact Information

Address: 2127 Pitkin Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11207, USA

Phone: (347) 435-3940

What is Worth Choosing at Five Star Deli & Grill

For New Yorkers, the value of a deli often lies in its reliability and diversity—the ability to satisfy a sudden craving, no matter how specific. Five Star Deli & Grill truly excels in offering an unparalleled culinary duality that makes it stand out in the crowded Brooklyn food landscape.

What is truly worth choosing here is the opportunity to transition from the familiar comfort of a deli classic to the exciting world of South Asian flavors. A local could easily grab their morning coffee and a turkey sandwich, and then come back in the evening for a deeply flavored, authentic curry. Specifically, the Indian menu items, with their competitive pricing and array of choices, are a major draw. For a savory and satisfying meal, the Chicken Tikka Masala is a globally recognized dish that offers creamy, spiced tomato goodness, or one might opt for the bolder flavors of the Lamb Rogan Josh. The inclusion of options like Paneer Makhani also ensures that those seeking high-quality vegetarian Indian food have a quick and reliable option in the neighborhood. These curries, generally priced around the $10-$13 range, represent excellent value for a hearty New York meal.

Furthermore, the location’s commitment to providing quick service makes it ideal for a "quick visit," meaning you can count on getting your food fast. In a city where time is money, a spot that respects your schedule while delivering a quality meal is invaluable. The ability to use credit and debit cards also adds to the streamlined, modern convenience that local customers expect.

While some customer feedback has noted service-related concerns, particularly regarding wait times for orders and staff practices, it is important for potential customers to view the deli as a dynamic, local business that consistently offers an extremely broad and unique food selection. For those in the East New York area looking for a deli that not only covers the basics but also provides a surprising, quality journey into Indian cuisine, Five Star Deli & Grill is a culinary option that deserves a closer look. The fusion of fast-paced New York convenience with the rich traditions of Indian food creates a truly unique and appealing local spot, making it a valuable resource for flavorful, quick, and varied meal options in Brooklyn.

Five Star Deli & Grill

2127 Pitkin Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11207, USA