Fratelli’s Pizzeria

- 7203 18th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11204

In a city where pizzerias define neighborhoods, Fratelli’s Pizzeria stands out as a genuine Brooklyn institution, offering far more than just a quick slice. Located in the vibrant Bensonhurst section, Fratelli’s expertly blends the best of a classic New York slice shop with a full-service Italian restaurant menu. It is a dual threat—a reliable go-to for a fast, delicious lunch and a trusted source for complete, satisfying Italian family dinners and substantial entrees. Recognized as a local favorite, the establishment is particularly celebrated for its high-quality ingredients, friendly staff, and the comfortable, casual atmosphere that makes it a welcoming spot for families, groups, and solo diners alike.

The core of Fratelli’s reputation rests on its pizza, which features both traditional and highly creative specialty pies. Customers rave about the unique texture and flavor of the crust, often noting its fresh, airy quality, which for certain specialty items, features a distinctive and delightful sesame seed touch. The menu is structured to offer variety, from the straightforward and classic to elaborate, fully-loaded creations. A glance at the menu reveals a commitment to authentic Italian-American comfort food, extending well beyond pizza to include homemade heroes, substantial pasta dishes, and traditional entrees like Chicken and Veal Parmigiana and Francese.

The extensive menu is organized into major categories, ensuring every craving is covered:

• Traditional Pizza: Features the essential Cheese Pie and the thick, satisfying Sicilian Cheese Pie (priced at $$26.00$ for a whole pie).
• Specialty Pizza: This is where Fratelli’s shines, with highly popular options like the Grandma Square Pie ($$26.00$), Upside Down Square Pie ($$28.00$), Vodka Pie, and innovative options like the Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad Pie and Spinach & Artichoke Square Pie ($$30.00$).
• Slices: Perfect for a quick bite, slices include the Regular Slice ($$3.00$), Sicilian Slice ($$3.50$), and specialty cuts like the Vodka Slice ($$4.00$) and Grandma Slice ($$4.00$).
• Pasta Dishes & Baked Pastas: A full array of Italian classics, including Fettuccine Alfredo, various options with Garlic & Oil, Seafood Combo Pasta ($$22.00$), and baked favorites like Baked Ziti ($$12.00$) and Lasagna ($$16.00$).
• Entrees & Heroes: Hearty main courses like Chicken Parmigiana ($$18.00$) and Veal Marsala ($$20.00$), alongside oversized sandwiches such as the Chicken Parmigiana Hero ($$12.00$) and Philly Cheese Hero ($$12.00$).
• Calzone & Rolls: Classic handhelds including Cheese Calzone ($$7.00$), Chicken Roll ($$7.50$), and various options with Broccoli Rabe.

The beverage selection offers local flavor with Manhattan Special Soda, alongside standard options, and the inclusion of both Wine and Coffee catering to a more traditional Italian dining experience.

Fratelli’s Pizzeria is conveniently located on 18th Avenue in the bustling Bensonhurst neighborhood of Brooklyn, making it easily accessible for a wide local area. Its exact address is 7203 18th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11204, USA. Situated in a popular commercial area, the pizzeria is a straightforward destination for both pedestrians and those using public transit in this part of Brooklyn.

A significant feature of this establishment is its commitment to inclusivity and accessibility, which is essential for serving the diverse New York community:

• Wheelchair Accessible Entrance: Ensures easy entry for all patrons.
• Wheelchair Accessible Seating: Dedicated seating areas are available for maximum comfort.
• Wheelchair Accessible Restroom: Provides necessary convenience for all guests.

While the dine-in area is described as cozy and intimate with "several tables," it maintains a welcoming, casual atmosphere perfect for a quick meal or a relaxed gathering. The staff are frequently noted in customer reviews as friendly and helpful, contributing to a pleasant experience even during busy times.

Fratelli’s Pizzeria caters comprehensively to the modern New Yorker’s need for speed and convenience:

• Dine-in: Provides a casual and comfortable spot to enjoy a meal, though seating is limited. While there are no dedicated table servers, the staff are attentive and provide excellent counter service.
• Delivery and No-contact Delivery: A core offering, catering to the broad Brooklyn area, ensuring food arrives hot and fresh.
• Takeout: Ideal for picking up pre-ordered pies or a quick selection of slices and rolls.
• Catering: Offers full catering services for parties and events, with dedicated menus for Baked Pastas Catering, Salads Catering, Italian Entrees Catering (including Chicken Parmigiana), and various Appetizers Catering.
• Kids' Menu: Features kid-friendly options like Kid's Spaghetti & Meatballs ($$8.00$) and Kid's Baby Pizza ($$10.00$), emphasizing its family-friendly environment.
• Payment Options: Accepts all modern payment methods including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, maximizing customer convenience.

Several key features position Fratelli’s Pizzeria as a top choice in Brooklyn for Italian and pizza cravings:

• Exceptional Specialty Pizza: The Grandma Square Pie, Vodka Pie, and Upside Down Square Pie are consistently highlighted by patrons as must-try items, often praised for their unique crust (sometimes noted to include sesame seeds) and flavorful sauces.
• Diverse Italian Menu: It operates as a full Italian kitchen, offering hearty Baked Pastas (like Lasagna and Baked Ziti), traditional Entrees (such as Chicken Marsala and Veal Francese), and fresh Salads and Homemade Soups, ensuring a meal for every preference.
• Focus on Comfort Food: The entire menu centers around rich, comforting dishes, from the substantial heroes to the large entrees, making it a perfect spot for satisfying cravings.
• Late-Night Accessibility: Availability of late-night food ensures this is a reliable spot for dinner or post-evening bites.
• All You Can Eat Option: The offering of an "All you can eat" option, typically applied to slices or select dishes, provides exceptional value for hungry customers (details should be confirmed directly with the restaurant).
• Crowd Appeal: The casual, family-friendly atmosphere attracts a strong mix of Locals, Groups, and Families for lunch and dinner.

Fratelli’s Pizzeria is conveniently located and easily reachable for orders, inquiries, or catering needs:

Address: 7203 18th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11204, USA

Phone: (718) 256-1222

The mobile phone number, +1 718-256-1222, is also available for direct communication with the restaurant.

For any New Yorker seeking an authentic and high-quality pizza and Italian dining experience in Brooklyn, Fratelli’s Pizzeria is worth choosing for several compelling reasons. The establishment is famous for its square pies—specifically the Grandma Square Pie and the Upside Down Square Pie—which patrons consistently describe as some of the best in the city. The Vodka Slice is another fan favorite, often cited as having one of the best vodka sauces in the neighborhood.

Beyond the pizza, the value and quality of the traditional Italian fare are exceptional. Customer reviews praise the well-prepared entrees, citing the Shrimp Parmigiana and Chicken Parm Hero as standout, high-quality, and generously portioned options. The comprehensive menu, competitive pricing, and availability of full services—including delivery, accommodating dine-in options, and catering—cement Fratelli’s Pizzeria as a reliable, high-performing local choice. The ability to grab a quick and affordable slice or order a full Italian dinner from a single, trusted Brooklyn location provides unmatched convenience and quality.

Fratelli’s Pizzeria

7203 18th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11204, USA