Froggy's Sandwiches: The Best Specialty Deli for Breakfast and Lunch in Brewster, NY

Froggy's Sandwiches Introduce

Froggy's Sandwiches, located conveniently on NY-22 in Brewster, New York, is far more than your typical neighborhood deli—it is a destination for inventive, high-quality, and generously portioned breakfast and lunch fare. Embodying the spirit of a modern New York-style sandwich shop, Froggy's has built a reputation on taking classic comfort food and elevating it with unique, signature creations that have quickly become local legends. This establishment prides itself on serving fast, fresh, and quality food, making it an ideal stop for residents in the New York region, whether you are starting your morning commute or grabbing a hearty lunch.

The menu is exceptionally diverse, ensuring there is a compelling option for every appetite and dietary need. Their offerings span two main categories: an extensive breakfast selection and a robust lunch lineup. For breakfast, the focus is heavily on classic egg and cheese combinations, but with a dramatic and creative twist. Lunch features massive, specialty sandwiches and wraps built around freshly breaded, made-to-order chicken cutlets, premium deli meats, and fresh mozzarella. A notable highlight is the availability of all their signature sandwich creations as "Bowls," served over a bed of home fries or lettuce, a fantastic feature for those seeking a lower-carb or even healthier alternative to the traditional bread-based meal.

Patrons enjoy a casual atmosphere where the service is known to be fast, perfect for busy professionals or families on the go. The entire operation is geared toward speed and quality, setting it apart in the local food scene. Froggy’s commitment to providing a superior food experience is evident in its creative naming conventions and its dedication to accommodating various preferences, including offering vegetarian and other healthy options alongside its famous comfort food items.

Location and Accessibility

Froggy's Sandwiches is ideally situated in Brewster, New York, a key location in Putnam County that serves both the local community and traffic traveling along the busy Route 22 corridor. The shop's exact address is 1620 NY-22, Brewster, NY 10509, USA, placing it in a highly accessible area for commuters and local businesses.

Accessibility is a key priority for the shop, ensuring a convenient visit for all customers. The building features a wheelchair-accessible entrance, providing easy access from the street and parking area. For drivers, both a free parking lot and the option of free street parking are available, eliminating the hassle of finding a spot during busy service times. While not specifically noted, the ample parking and clearly defined access points contribute to a welcoming environment. The centralized location on a main route makes it a simple and efficient stop for a quick meal.

Services Offered

The operational model at Froggy's Sandwiches is designed for maximum customer convenience, offering multiple ways to order and enjoy their food, from a quick on-the-go option to a relaxed dining experience. This flexibility caters perfectly to the varied, fast-paced lifestyles of New York residents.

Dine-In Seating: The shop offers casual indoor seating for guests who wish to enjoy their meal on-site.
Takeout: Quick and efficient service for customers picking up orders to eat elsewhere.
Curbside Pickup: An added convenience feature allowing customers to receive their order directly to their car.
Delivery and No-Contact Delivery: Full delivery services are available, accommodating customers who prefer the convenience of having their food brought directly to their home or office.
Catering Services: Froggy's extends its expertise to larger orders, providing catering for office meetings, parties, and other group events, featuring large party wedges and specialized catering bowls.
Online Ordering: The ability to order online is a core part of their service model, streamlining the process, especially during peak lunch hours when the shop can get very busy.

Features / Highlights

Froggy's Sandwiches is particularly well-known for its creative and expansive menu, high-quality ingredients, and a dedication to both comfort and healthy eating. These features combine to create a distinct and highly recommendable local eatery.

The Signature Sandwich Lineup: A core highlight is the collection of cleverly named, over-the-top specialty sandwiches, such as the famous 'Froggy' (Chicken Cutlet, Bacon, Mac & Cheese Bites, and Yellow American Cheese with Chipotle Mayo) and the equally notorious 'Lawsuit' (Chicken Cutlet, Muenster Cheese, and Bacon with Russian Dressing), named after a local competition dispute.
Inventive Breakfast Options: Beyond the classic BEC (Bacon, Egg, and Cheese), the menu features creations like the 'Dr. Raj' (BEC with French Toast Sticks and Maple Syrup) and the 'BEC Smash' (Smash Burger Patty, Bacon, Over Easy Egg, Cheddar, Sautéed Onions, Chipotle Mayo, and Mike’s Hot Honey) that redefine breakfast.
Healthy and Vegetarian Options: The shop is highly accommodating, featuring dedicated vegetarian and healthy offerings, including the 'NYSEG' breakfast sandwich (Turkey, Egg Whites, Swiss, Avocado, Sautéed Onions) and numerous build-your-own options, as well as being highly praised for its Gluten Free cheese bread sandwich alternative.
Customization with "Frog It Up!": Nearly every menu category—sandwiches, bowls, and omelettes—allows for custom creation, inviting customers to "Frog It Up!" and build their perfect meal from the ground up.
All-Day Dining Categories: The breakfast menu is extensive, including sandwiches, breakfast bowls, omelettes, and sides, ensuring a substantial start to the day. Lunch mirrors this with sandwiches, wraps, and lunch bowls.
Beverage Variety: The shop offers a wide array of drinks, including regular and iced coffee, specialty Lotus Refreshers (Red, Green, Blue), various bottled teas and sodas, and energy drinks, catering to all thirst levels.

Contact Information

To plan your visit or place an order with Froggy's Sandwiches in Brewster, please use the following contact details:

Address: 1620 NY-22, Brewster, NY 10509, USA

Phone: (845) 490-4013

Mobile Phone: +1 845-490-4013

What is Worth Choosing

Choosing Froggy’s Sandwiches is worth it for anyone in the New York region seeking a superior, local alternative to standard chain delis or fast-casual spots. The high level of creativity and quality applied to everyday food is the most compelling reason to visit. This is a place where a simple chicken cutlet is freshly breaded and made to order daily, not pre-prepared.

The commitment to fresh, complex flavor combinations makes the specialty sandwiches the number one recommendation. For a truly unique experience, you must try the 'Lawsuit' or the 'Froggy' sandwich—they are local icons that offer a perfect blend of rich, comforting ingredients and textures. The flexibility of being able to order any of these massive sandwiches as a 'Bowl' (over home fries or lettuce) provides a healthy and satisfying alternative that is rarely found elsewhere. Furthermore, their breakfast menu is a serious contender for the best in the area, offering everything from a flawless classic BEC to the truly unique and indulgent Goliath.

Patrons appreciate the shop's use of a variety of payment methods, including credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, making transactions quick and easy. Despite the occasional minor ordering mix-up—an understandable consequence of being a "really busy place at lunchtime"—the overall quality, speed of service, and staff friendliness consistently shine through, solidifying Froggy’s Sandwiches as a must-try local eatery in Brewster, NY.

Froggy's Sandwiches Menu

Breakfast Sandwiches
BEC $7.49
Bacon, Two Eggs, and Yellow American Cheese on a Roll
SEC $7.49
Sausage, Two Eggs, and Yellow American Cheese on a Roll
Tusker $9.25
Bacon, Two Eggs, Yellow American Cheese, Hashbrown, and Hot Sauce on a Roll
Grand Slam $9.49
Bacon, Sausage, Ham, Two Eggs, and Yellow American Cheese on a Roll
Eggstacy $10.75
Steak, Bacon, Two eggs, Hashbrown, and Yellow American Cheese on a Roll
NYSEG $10.25
Turkey, Three Egg Whites, Swiss Cheese, Avocado, and Sauteed Onions on Rye Toast
Dr. Raj $9.99
Bacon, Two Eggs, Yellow American Cheese, with French Toast Sticks, and Maple Syrup on a Roll
Goliath $13.50
Bacon, Two Eggs, Yellow American Cheese, Chicken Cutlet, Hashbrown, and Hot Sauce on a Roll
Frog It Up! [Custom Sandwich] $2.50
Build Your Sandwich Your Way!
Frog It Up! [Custom No-Eggs Sandwich] $2.50
Build Your Sandwich Your Way!
Frogito Burrito $9.75
Three Scrambled Eggs, Chorizo, Cheddar Cheese, and Hashbrown on a Toasted Wrap
Avocado Toast $10.48
Toasty sourdough bread with creamy avocado, topped with fresh tomatoes, and everything seasoning.
BEC Smash $11.50
Seasoned Smash Burger Patty, Bacon, an Over Easy Egg, Cheddar Cheese, Sauteed Onions, Chipotle Mayo, and Mikes Hot Honey on a Roll
EC $6.25
Two Eggs, and Yellow American Cheese on a Roll
HEC $7.49
Ham, Two Eggs, and Yellow American Cheese on a Roll
TEC $7.49
Turkey, Two Eggs, and Yellow American Cheese on a Roll
Steak EC $7.49
Steak, and Two Eggs, and Yellow American Cheese
Turkey-Sausage, EC $7.49
Turkey-Sausage, Two Eggs, and Yellow American Cheese on a Roll
BE $6.75
Two Eggs, and Bacon on a Kaiser Roll
SE $6.75
Sausage, and Two Eggs on a Roll
HE $6.75
Ham and Two Eggs on a Roll
TE $6.75
Turkey, and Two Eggs on a Roll
Steak & Egg $6.75
Steak, and Two Eggs on a Roll
Turkey-Sausage & Egg $6.75
Turkey-Sausage, and Two Eggs on a Roll

Breakfast Sandwiches
BEC $7.49
Bacon, Two Eggs, and Yellow American Cheese on a Roll
SEC $7.49
Sausage, Two Eggs, and Yellow American Cheese on a Roll
Tusker $9.25
Bacon, Two Eggs, Yellow American Cheese, Hashbrown, and Hot Sauce on a Roll
Grand Slam $9.49
Bacon, Sausage, Ham, Two Eggs, and Yellow American Cheese on a Roll
Eggstacy $10.75
Steak, Bacon, Two eggs, Hashbrown, and Yellow American Cheese on a Roll
NYSEG $10.25
Turkey, Three Egg Whites, Swiss Cheese, Avocado, and Sauteed Onions on Rye Toast
Dr. Raj $9.99
Bacon, Two Eggs, Yellow American Cheese, with French Toast Sticks, and Maple Syrup on a Roll
Goliath $13.50
Bacon, Two Eggs, Yellow American Cheese, Chicken Cutlet, Hashbrown, and Hot Sauce on a Roll
Frog It Up! [Custom Sandwich] $2.50
Build Your Sandwich Your Way!
Frog It Up! [Custom No-Eggs Sandwich] $2.50
Build Your Sandwich Your Way!
Frogito Burrito $9.75
Three Scrambled Eggs, Chorizo, Cheddar Cheese, and Hashbrown on a Toasted Wrap
Avocado Toast $10.48
Toasty sourdough bread with creamy avocado, topped with fresh tomatoes, and everything seasoning.
BEC Smash $11.50
Seasoned Smash Burger Patty, Bacon, an Over Easy Egg, Cheddar Cheese, Sauteed Onions, Chipotle Mayo, and Mikes Hot Honey on a Roll
EC $6.25
Two Eggs, and Yellow American Cheese on a Roll
HEC $7.49
Ham, Two Eggs, and Yellow American Cheese on a Roll
TEC $7.49
Turkey, Two Eggs, and Yellow American Cheese on a Roll
Steak EC $7.49
Steak, and Two Eggs, and Yellow American Cheese
Turkey-Sausage, EC $7.49
Turkey-Sausage, Two Eggs, and Yellow American Cheese on a Roll
BE $6.75
Two Eggs, and Bacon on a Kaiser Roll
SE $6.75
Sausage, and Two Eggs on a Roll
HE $6.75
Ham and Two Eggs on a Roll
TE $6.75
Turkey, and Two Eggs on a Roll
Steak & Egg $6.75
Steak, and Two Eggs on a Roll
Turkey-Sausage & Egg $6.75
Turkey-Sausage, and Two Eggs on a Roll

Breakfast Bowls
BEC Bowl $8.75
Bacon, Two Eggs, and Yellow American Cheese Over a Bed of Home Fries - Served in a Bowl
SEC Bowl $8.75
Sausage, Two Eggs, and Yellow American Cheese Over a Bed of Home Fries - Served in a Bowl
Tusker Bowl $10.50
Bacon, Two Eggs, Yellow American Cheese, Hashbrown, and Hot Sauce Over a Bed of Home Fries - Served in a Bowl
Grand Slam Bowl $10.75
Bacon, Sausage, Ham, Two Fried Eggs, and Yellow American Cheese Over a Bed of Home Fries - Served in a Bowl
Eggstacy Bowl $11.99
Steak, Bacon, Two eggs, Hashbrown, and Yellow American Cheese Over a Bed of Home Fries - Served in a Bowl
NYSEG Bowl $11.25
Turkey, Three Egg Whites, Swiss Cheese, Avocado, and Sauteed Onions Over a Bed of Home Fries - Served in a Bowl
Dr. Raj Bowl $11.25
Bacon, Two Eggs, Yellow American Cheese, with French Toast Sticks, and Maple Syrup Over a Bed of Home Fries - Served in a Bowl
Goliath Bowl $14.75
Bacon, Two Eggs, Yellow American Cheese, Chicken Cutlet, Hashbrown, and Hot SauceOver a Bed of Home Fries - Served in a Bowl
Frogito Burrito Bowl $11.99
Three Scrambled Eggs, Chorizo, Cheddar Cheese, and Hashbrown Over a Bed of Home Fries - Served in a Bowl
BEC Smash Bowl $12.75
Seasoned Smash Burger Patty, Bacon, an Over Easy Egg, Cheddar Cheese, Sauteed Onions, Chipotle Mayo, and Mikes Hot Honey Over a Bed of Home Fries - Served in a Bowl
Frog It Up! [Custom Bowl] $6.75
Build Your Bowl Your Way! Over a Bed of Home Fries - Served in a Bowl

Omelettes
Veggie Omelette $13.74
Three Eggs with Sautéed Peppers, Sautéed Onions, Spinach, Tomatoes - Served with Home Fries and Your Choice of Toast in a Bowl
Western Omelette $13.74
Three Eggs with Ham, Sautéed Peppers, Sautéed Onions - Served with Home Fries and Your Choice of Toast in a Bowl
Meat Lovers Omelette $13.74
Three Eggs with Ham, Bacon, Sausage, Yellow American Cheese - Served with Home Fries and Your Choice of Toast in a Bowl
Frog It Up! [Custom Omelette] $8.20
Build Your Omelette Your Way! - Served with Home Fries and Your Choice of Toast in a Bowl

Breakfast Bowls
BEC Bowl $8.75
Bacon, Two Eggs, and Yellow American Cheese Over a Bed of Home Fries - Served in a Bowl
SEC Bowl $8.75
Sausage, Two Eggs, and Yellow American Cheese Over a Bed of Home Fries - Served in a Bowl
Tusker Bowl $10.50
Bacon, Two Eggs, Yellow American Cheese, Hashbrown, and Hot Sauce Over a Bed of Home Fries - Served in a Bowl
Grand Slam Bowl $10.75
Bacon, Sausage, Ham, Two Fried Eggs, and Yellow American Cheese Over a Bed of Home Fries - Served in a Bowl
Eggstacy Bowl $11.99
Steak, Bacon, Two eggs, Hashbrown, and Yellow American Cheese Over a Bed of Home Fries - Served in a Bowl
NYSEG Bowl $11.25
Turkey, Three Egg Whites, Swiss Cheese, Avocado, and Sauteed Onions Over a Bed of Home Fries - Served in a Bowl
Dr. Raj Bowl $11.25
Bacon, Two Eggs, Yellow American Cheese, with French Toast Sticks, and Maple Syrup Over a Bed of Home Fries - Served in a Bowl
Goliath Bowl $14.75
Bacon, Two Eggs, Yellow American Cheese, Chicken Cutlet, Hashbrown, and Hot SauceOver a Bed of Home Fries - Served in a Bowl
Frogito Burrito Bowl $11.99
Three Scrambled Eggs, Chorizo, Cheddar Cheese, and Hashbrown Over a Bed of Home Fries - Served in a Bowl
BEC Smash Bowl $12.75
Seasoned Smash Burger Patty, Bacon, an Over Easy Egg, Cheddar Cheese, Sauteed Onions, Chipotle Mayo, and Mikes Hot Honey Over a Bed of Home Fries - Served in a Bowl
Frog It Up! [Custom Bowl] $6.75
Build Your Bowl Your Way! Over a Bed of Home Fries - Served in a Bowl

Omelettes
Veggie Omelette $13.74
Three Eggs with Sautéed Peppers, Sautéed Onions, Spinach, Tomatoes - Served with Home Fries and Your Choice of Toast in a Bowl
Western Omelette $13.74
Three Eggs with Ham, Sautéed Peppers, Sautéed Onions - Served with Home Fries and Your Choice of Toast in a Bowl
Meat Lovers Omelette $13.74
Three Eggs with Ham, Bacon, Sausage, Yellow American Cheese - Served with Home Fries and Your Choice of Toast in a Bowl
Frog It Up! [Custom Omelette] $8.20
Build Your Omelette Your Way! - Served with Home Fries and Your Choice of Toast in a Bowl

Breakfast Sides Menu
Bagel $1.50
Your Choice of a Bagel and What you want in it!
Hashbrown $1.75
Potato Patty Fried to Perfection!
Buttered Roll $4.50
The Classic Buttered Kaiser Roll!
French Toast Sticks $3.99
Cup Of Home Fries $4.49
Grilled Potatoes with Peppers, Onions and Seasoning
Side Of Toast $2.00
Side Of Bacon $4.75
5 Strips of Bacon Your Way!
Side Of Sausage $2.50
Sausage Patty
Side Of Turkey-Sausage $2.50
Turkey-Sausage Patty
Croissant $2.25

Breakfast Sides Menu
Bagel $1.50
Your Choice of a Bagel and What you want in it!
Hashbrown $1.75
Potato Patty Fried to Perfection!
Buttered Roll $4.50
The Classic Buttered Kaiser Roll!
French Toast Sticks $3.99
Cup Of Home Fries $4.49
Grilled Potatoes with Peppers, Onions and Seasoning
Side Of Toast $2.00
Side Of Bacon $4.75
5 Strips of Bacon Your Way!
Side Of Sausage $2.50
Sausage Patty
Side Of Turkey-Sausage $2.50
Turkey-Sausage Patty
Croissant $2.25

Lunch Sandwiches
Froggy $13.99
Chicken Cutlet, Bacon, Mac & Cheese Bites, and Yellow American Cheese with Chipotle Mayo on a Roll
Lawsuit $13.50
Chicken cutlet, Muenster Cheese, and Bacon with Russian Dressing on a Roll
Tony Soprano $13.50
Chicken Cutlet, Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Red Peppers with Oil & Vinegar on a Roll
Blazin' Buffalo $13.25
Chicken Cutlet, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Pepper Jack Cheese, Hot Sauce and Blue Cheese Dressing on a Roll
Mama Russo $12.25
Fried Eggplant, Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Red Peppers, Lettuce and Oil & Vinegar on a Roll
Chicken Caesar Wrap $12.75
Grilled Chicken, Lettuce, Parmesan Cheese, Croutons with Caesar Dressing in a Wrap
Classic Tuna $12.50
Tuna Salad, Lettuce, and Tomatoes on a Roll
South Beach $13.75
Grilled Chicken, Pepper Jack Cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Avocado with Russian Dressing on a Wrap
Pastrami Reuben $13.99
Pastrami with Swiss Cheese , Sauerkraut, and Russian Dressing on Grilled Rye Bread
Turkey Reuben $13.25
Turkey with Swiss cheese and sauerkraut with Russian dressing on grilled rye bread
Philly Cheesesteak $12.75
Steak with Peppers, Onions, and Yellow American Cheese on a Roll
Chicken Cheesesteak $13.50
Grilled Chicken with Peppers, Onions, Yellow American Cheese with Chipotle Mayo on a Grilled Wrap
Maxed Out $14.25
Roast Beef, Cheddar Cheese, Cole Slaw with Russian Dressing on a Roll
Italian Combo $12.75
Ham Cappy, Salami, Pepperoni, Provolone Cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes with Oil & Vinegar on a Roll
Chicken Parm $13.25
Chicken cutlet, Melted Mozzarella, with Marinara Sauce on a Roll
Eggplant Parm $12.75
Eggplant, Melted Mozzarella, with Marinara Sauce on a Roll
Classic Ham $11.75
Ham, Swiss Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, with Spicy Mustard on a Rye Bread
Turkey BLT $12.75
Turkey, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, with Mayo on a Roll
BLT $10.25
Bacon, Lettuce, and Tomato on White Toast
Grilled Cheese $4.50
Cheese Melted on Sliced Bread
Frog It Up! [Custom Lunch Sandwich] $2.50
Build Your Sandwich Your Way!
Frog It Up! [Veggie/Cheese Only Custom Sandwich] $2.50
Build Your Veggie Sandwich Your Way!
Frog It Up! [Grilled Custom Sandwich] $2.50
Build Your Grilled Sandwich Your Way!
Chicken Parmageddon *SOTM $12.50
Homemade Chicken Cutlet, Marinara Sauce, Sliced ozzarella, Fried Mozzarella Bites on a Toasted Roll

Lunch Sandwiches
Froggy $13.99
Chicken Cutlet, Bacon, Mac & Cheese Bites, and Yellow American Cheese with Chipotle Mayo on a Roll
Lawsuit $13.50
Chicken cutlet, Muenster Cheese, and Bacon with Russian Dressing on a Roll
Tony Soprano $13.50
Chicken Cutlet, Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Red Peppers with Oil & Vinegar on a Roll
Blazin' Buffalo $13.25
Chicken Cutlet, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Pepper Jack Cheese, Hot Sauce and Blue Cheese Dressing on a Roll
Mama Russo $12.25
Fried Eggplant, Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Red Peppers, Lettuce and Oil & Vinegar on a Roll
Chicken Caesar Wrap $12.75
Grilled Chicken, Lettuce, Parmesan Cheese, Croutons with Caesar Dressing in a Wrap
Classic Tuna $12.50
Tuna Salad, Lettuce, and Tomatoes on a Roll
South Beach $13.75
Grilled Chicken, Pepper Jack Cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Avocado with Russian Dressing on a Wrap
Pastrami Reuben $13.99
Pastrami with Swiss Cheese , Sauerkraut, and Russian Dressing on Grilled Rye Bread
Turkey Reuben $13.25
Turkey with Swiss cheese and sauerkraut with Russian dressing on grilled rye bread
Philly Cheesesteak $12.75
Steak with Peppers, Onions, and Yellow American Cheese on a Roll
Chicken Cheesesteak $13.50
Grilled Chicken with Peppers, Onions, Yellow American Cheese with Chipotle Mayo on a Grilled Wrap
Maxed Out $14.25
Roast Beef, Cheddar Cheese, Cole Slaw with Russian Dressing on a Roll
Italian Combo $12.75
Ham Cappy, Salami, Pepperoni, Provolone Cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes with Oil & Vinegar on a Roll
Chicken Parm $13.25
Chicken cutlet, Melted Mozzarella, with Marinara Sauce on a Roll
Eggplant Parm $12.75
Eggplant, Melted Mozzarella, with Marinara Sauce on a Roll
Classic Ham $11.75
Ham, Swiss Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, with Spicy Mustard on a Rye Bread
Turkey BLT $12.75
Turkey, Bacon, Lettuce, Tomato, with Mayo on a Roll
BLT $10.25
Bacon, Lettuce, and Tomato on White Toast
Grilled Cheese $4.50
Cheese Melted on Sliced Bread
Frog It Up! [Custom Lunch Sandwich] $2.50
Build Your Sandwich Your Way!
Frog It Up! [Veggie/Cheese Only Custom Sandwich] $2.50
Build Your Veggie Sandwich Your Way!
Frog It Up! [Grilled Custom Sandwich] $2.50
Build Your Grilled Sandwich Your Way!
Chicken Parmageddon *SOTM $12.50
Homemade Chicken Cutlet, Marinara Sauce, Sliced ozzarella, Fried Mozzarella Bites on a Toasted Roll

Lunch Bowls
Froggy Bowl $15.25
Chicken Cutlet, Bacon, Mac & Cheese Bites, and Yellow American Cheese with Chipotle Mayo on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
Lawsuit Bowl $14.75
Chicken cutlet, Muenster Cheese, and Bacon with Russian Dressing on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
Tony Soprano Bowl $14.50
Chicken Cutlet, Fresh Mozzarella, and Roasted Red Peppers with Oil & Vinegar on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
Blazin' Buffalo Bowl $14.50
Chicken Cutlet, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Pepper Jack Cheese, Hot Sauce, and Blue Cheese Dressing on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
Mama Russo Bowl $13.50
Fried Eggplant, Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Red Peppers, Lettuce and Oil & Vinegar on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
Chicken Caesar Bowl $13.75
Grilled Chicken, Lettuce, Parmesan Cheese, and Croutons with Caesar Dressing on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
Classic Tuna Bowl $13.75
Homemade Tuna Salad and Chopped Tomatoes on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
South Beach Bowl $14.99
Grilled Chicken, Pepper Jack Cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Avocado with Russian Dressing on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
Pastrami Reuben Bowl $15.25
Pastrami with Swiss Cheese, Sauerkraut, and Russian Dressing on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
Turkey Reuben Bowl $14.50
Turkey with Swiss cheese and sauerkraut with Russian dressing on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
Philly Cheesesteak Bowl $14.25
Steak with Peppers, Onions, and Yellow American Cheese on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
Chicken Cheesesteak Bowl $14.75
Grilled Chicken with Peppers, Onions, Yellow American Cheese with Chipotle Mayo on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
Maxed Out Bowl $15.50
Roast Beef, Cheddar Cheese, Cole Slaw with Russian Dressing on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
Italian Combo Bowl $13.99
Ham Cappy, Salami, Pepperoni, Provolone Cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes with Oil & Vinegar on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
Classic Ham Bowl $12.99
Ham, Swiss Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, with Spicy Mustard on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
Turkey BLT Bowl $13.99
Turkey, Bacon, Lettuce, and Tomato, with Mayo on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
Frog It Up! [Custom Bowl] $4.50
Build Your Bowl Your Way!

Lunch Bowls
Froggy Bowl $15.25
Chicken Cutlet, Bacon, Mac & Cheese Bites, and Yellow American Cheese with Chipotle Mayo on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
Lawsuit Bowl $14.75
Chicken cutlet, Muenster Cheese, and Bacon with Russian Dressing on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
Tony Soprano Bowl $14.50
Chicken Cutlet, Fresh Mozzarella, and Roasted Red Peppers with Oil & Vinegar on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
Blazin' Buffalo Bowl $14.50
Chicken Cutlet, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Pepper Jack Cheese, Hot Sauce, and Blue Cheese Dressing on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
Mama Russo Bowl $13.50
Fried Eggplant, Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Red Peppers, Lettuce and Oil & Vinegar on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
Chicken Caesar Bowl $13.75
Grilled Chicken, Lettuce, Parmesan Cheese, and Croutons with Caesar Dressing on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
Classic Tuna Bowl $13.75
Homemade Tuna Salad and Chopped Tomatoes on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
South Beach Bowl $14.99
Grilled Chicken, Pepper Jack Cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes, and Avocado with Russian Dressing on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
Pastrami Reuben Bowl $15.25
Pastrami with Swiss Cheese, Sauerkraut, and Russian Dressing on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
Turkey Reuben Bowl $14.50
Turkey with Swiss cheese and sauerkraut with Russian dressing on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
Philly Cheesesteak Bowl $14.25
Steak with Peppers, Onions, and Yellow American Cheese on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
Chicken Cheesesteak Bowl $14.75
Grilled Chicken with Peppers, Onions, Yellow American Cheese with Chipotle Mayo on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
Maxed Out Bowl $15.50
Roast Beef, Cheddar Cheese, Cole Slaw with Russian Dressing on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
Italian Combo Bowl $13.99
Ham Cappy, Salami, Pepperoni, Provolone Cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes with Oil & Vinegar on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
Classic Ham Bowl $12.99
Ham, Swiss Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, with Spicy Mustard on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
Turkey BLT Bowl $13.99
Turkey, Bacon, Lettuce, and Tomato, with Mayo on a bed of Lettuce, in a Bowl
Frog It Up! [Custom Bowl] $4.50
Build Your Bowl Your Way!

Apps & Sides
Pickle (Quartered) $1.75
Side Of Dressing $0.50
French Fries $4.99
Curly Fries $5.50
Chicken Fingers $3.99
Mozz Bites $4.99
Mac & Cheese Bites $4.99

Apps & Sides
Pickle (Quartered) $1.75
Side Of Dressing $0.50
French Fries $4.99
Curly Fries $5.50
Chicken Fingers $3.99
Mozz Bites $4.99
Mac & Cheese Bites $4.99

Chips
Joe Chips $2.50
Large Joe Chips $8.75
Other Chips $2.49

Chips
Joe Chips $2.50
Large Joe Chips $8.75
Other Chips $2.49

Coffee + Hot Tea
Hot Coffee $2.50
Cold Brew $4.25
Bottled Coffee
Hot Tea
Hot Chocolate

Lotus Refreshers
Red Lotus $4.50
A refreshing burst of juicy watermelon and sweet strawberry blended with the clean energy of White Lotus. Served iced and sparkling, this vibrant mix delivers a crisp, fruity lift that powers your day without the crash.
Green Lotus $4.50
Tart green apple meets tropical pineapple in a sparkling White Lotus base. Served over ice, this energizing blend is bright, tangy, and refreshing with a smooth plant-powered boost.
Blue Lotus $4.50
Bold blue raspberry swirled with smooth cream over a sparkling White Lotus base. Served on ice, this dreamy mix is sweet, silky, and energizing — a perfect pick-me-up that feels like a treat.
Random Lotus $4.50
Feeling adventurous? Let our staff surprise you! We’ll pick a flavor combo just for you — always iced, always powered by White Lotus, and always delicious.

Cold Teas
Joe Tea Bottles $3.50
Joe Tea Cans $2.75
Pure Leaf Bottles $2.75
Gold Peak Bottles $2.50
Liquid Death Tea Cans $3.50

Soda
Soda $3.00
Seltzer $3.00
Soda - Glass Bottles $2.75
Liquid Death Sparkling Water $2.99

Juice
Juice $2.99

Water
Water $1.50

Energy
Red Bull $3.25
Monster $3.50
Celsius $3.75

Other Tasty Beverages
Gatorade $2.75
Nesquik $2.99
Vitamin Water $2.99
Yoohoo

Coffee + Hot Tea
Hot Coffee $2.50
Cold Brew $4.25
Bottled Coffee
Hot Tea
Hot Chocolate

Lotus Refreshers
Red Lotus $4.50
A refreshing burst of juicy watermelon and sweet strawberry blended with the clean energy of White Lotus. Served iced and sparkling, this vibrant mix delivers a crisp, fruity lift that powers your day without the crash.
Green Lotus $4.50
Tart green apple meets tropical pineapple in a sparkling White Lotus base. Served over ice, this energizing blend is bright, tangy, and refreshing with a smooth plant-powered boost.
Blue Lotus $4.50
Bold blue raspberry swirled with smooth cream over a sparkling White Lotus base. Served on ice, this dreamy mix is sweet, silky, and energizing — a perfect pick-me-up that feels like a treat.
Random Lotus $4.50
Feeling adventurous? Let our staff surprise you! We’ll pick a flavor combo just for you — always iced, always powered by White Lotus, and always delicious.

Cold Teas
Joe Tea Bottles $3.50
Joe Tea Cans $2.75
Pure Leaf Bottles $2.75
Gold Peak Bottles $2.50
Liquid Death Tea Cans $3.50

Soda
Soda $3.00
Seltzer $3.00
Soda - Glass Bottles $2.75
Liquid Death Sparkling Water $2.99

Juice
Juice $2.99

Water
Water $1.50

Energy
Red Bull $3.25
Monster $3.50
Celsius $3.75

Other Tasty Beverages
Gatorade $2.75
Nesquik $2.99
Vitamin Water $2.99
Yoohoo

Sandwich Boxes
Small Breakfast Box $30.00
Enjoy 5 Sandwiches, cut in half and individually wrapped, all packed in a box. Party on!
Large Breakfast Sandwich Box $55.00
Enjoy 10 Sandwiches, cut in half and individually wrapped, all packed in a box. Party on!
Small Lunch Sandwich Box $55.00
Enjoy 5 Sandwiches, cut in half and individually wrapped, all packed in a box. Party on!
Large Lunch Sandwich Box $105.00
Enjoy 10 Sandwiches, cut in half and individually wrapped, all packed in a box. Party on!

Wrap Platters
Small Lunch Wrap Platter $55.00
Enjoy 5 Sandwich Wraps, cut in half on a platter. Party on!
Large Lunch Wrap Platter $99.00
Enjoy 10 Sandwich Wraps, cut in half on a platter. Party on!

Coffee
Box Of Joe $20.00
Froggy's Coffee Labs Roasters Coffee to pour 8-10 glasses of coffee!

Packages
Breakfast Catering Package For 20 People $155.00
A quick and easy solution to feed 20 people breakfast! *Includes: Sandwiches [All wrapped in 1/2], Home Fries, and 2 Boxes of Coffee, Plates, Napkins, Forks, Cups, Creamer, and Sugar.

Sandwich Boxes
Small Breakfast Box $30.00
Enjoy 5 Sandwiches, cut in half and individually wrapped, all packed in a box. Party on!
Large Breakfast Sandwich Box $55.00
Enjoy 10 Sandwiches, cut in half and individually wrapped, all packed in a box. Party on!
Small Lunch Sandwich Box $55.00
Enjoy 5 Sandwiches, cut in half and individually wrapped, all packed in a box. Party on!
Large Lunch Sandwich Box $105.00
Enjoy 10 Sandwiches, cut in half and individually wrapped, all packed in a box. Party on!

Wrap Platters
Small Lunch Wrap Platter $55.00
Enjoy 5 Sandwich Wraps, cut in half on a platter. Party on!
Large Lunch Wrap Platter $99.00
Enjoy 10 Sandwich Wraps, cut in half on a platter. Party on!

Coffee
Box Of Joe $20.00
Froggy's Coffee Labs Roasters Coffee to pour 8-10 glasses of coffee!

Packages
Breakfast Catering Package For 20 People $155.00
A quick and easy solution to feed 20 people breakfast! *Includes: Sandwiches [All wrapped in 1/2], Home Fries, and 2 Boxes of Coffee, Plates, Napkins, Forks, Cups, Creamer, and Sugar.

Froggy's Sandwiches Details

Service options
Curbside pickup
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service

Popular for
Breakfast
Lunch
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Coffee
Comfort food
Healthy options
Quick bite
Vegetarian options

Dining options
Breakfast
Brunch
Lunch
Catering
Dessert
Seating

Amenities
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Atmosphere
Casual

Crowd
Tourists

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
Kids' menu

Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking

Froggy's Sandwiches Photos

Froggy's Sandwiches Location

Froggy's Sandwiches

New York Putnam County Brewster New York 22

1620 NY-22, Brewster, NY 10509, USA

Froggy's Sandwiches Reviews

An average rating of ★4.4 from 98 user reviews.

delibreakfast sandwichomeletteegg sandwichbacon egg and cheesebowlgluten freelunch sandwichesphilly cheese steakwrap

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

First time at this froggys location. I ordered a BEC on a roll and Home fries. Home fries were ice cold in the middle. Only the bottom and sides were “warm” meaning they microwaved them and not fresh. I included a picture of The sandwich. I don’t believe I’ve had any experience like this. They did reheat the homefries.
May 18 · Aaron D
Love the Gluten free cheese bread sandwiches!! So good!!Do really like their regular coffee & iced coffee.The orders came out wrong on 2 different occasions though when called to order at the Brewster location, but probably someone new still learning... They are also a really busy place at lunch time.
June 10 · Rhay D
Revising my original review, and increasing to 4-stars.Decent deli, good location. Clean and eat-in tables available.Good quality food, not Boar's Head meat, which in retrospect is probably a good thing these days 🤔Make sure you get your froggy's sandwich card!My original complaint stands; limited selection of sides, only Joe's Potato Chips and Doritos. It would be nice to have a bigger selection. What's wrong with pretzels? You guys got something against potato sticks or plantain chips?
March 18 · Rich H.
I just discovered you guys on DoorDash recently and OMG. My new favorite deli in the world . I get the Philly cheesesteak bowl now weekly, because it is absolutely delicious. But I have also ordered sandwiches and sides and everything is delicious, fresh. I can't say enough . So glad I found this place!
June 02 · Renee Cellio
This deli is fantastic. I've been stopping in on my lunch break for the last few months and I always get a great sandwich whether it's off their breakfast menu or their signature lunch sandwiches. The staff and management are amicable and really pleasant even if you're arriving a few minutes before they close. I usually get a lunch sandwich as a wrap but they're also available as wedges or kaiser rolls
May 25 · Jonathan Gonzalez