Gage & Tollner

- 372 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11201

Gage & Tollner is not just a restaurant; it is a beautifully preserved piece of New York City history and a celebrated institution that has returned to its former glory in Downtown Brooklyn. Located at 372 Fulton Street, this American restaurant—which reopened after a significant hiatus—offers a deeply satisfying dining experience that is simultaneously historic, upscale, and cozy. It captures the elegance of a bygone era while serving a refined menu of classic American fare, steaks, and exquisite seafood.

For New Yorkers, Gage & Tollner represents a dining destination where quality and atmosphere are paramount. The setting, with its high ceilings and polished fixtures, makes every visit feel like a special occasion, whether you are celebrating a milestone or simply enjoying a sophisticated dinner or brunch. Patrons are drawn to the restaurant for its great cocktails, great wine list, and its dedication to the art of fine dining, earning it a reputation as a must-visit spot in the borough.

The menu is rooted in traditional American steakhouse and seafood classics, but executed with modern flair and top-tier ingredients, including organic dishes and an impressive raw bar. The commitment to excellent service and an inclusive atmosphere—the establishment is LGBTQ+ friendly and a Transgender safespace—ensures a welcoming experience for all groups and tourists. With reservations recommended for both brunch and dinner, Gage & Tollner is clearly a sought-after table in the city's competitive dining landscape.

Gage & Tollner is centrally situated at 372 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA. Its location in Downtown Brooklyn is unparalleled, placing it in a nexus of transportation, commerce, and culture. The building itself is a landmark, and its position on Fulton Street makes it highly visible and easily reachable from numerous subway lines that converge in the area.

The restaurant is committed to full accessibility, featuring a wheelchair accessible entrance, wheelchair accessible restroom, and wheelchair accessible seating. This dedication ensures that all guests can enjoy the historic dining room comfortably.

For those traveling by car, there are options for paid parking lot and paid street parking nearby, though public transit is often the most convenient method in this bustling part of New York.

In addition to the main dining room, the address also houses the Sunken Harbor Club, an intimate hideaway cocktail bar located on the second floor, offering tropical cocktails and small plates in a complementary atmosphere.

Gage & Tollner provides a full suite of upscale dining services that cater to both everyday indulgence and special events:

• Dine-in Only: The restaurant experience is primarily focused on Dine-in service, offering a full Table service experience in a historic setting.
• Full Dining Schedule: Serving guests for Brunch (Saturday & Sunday, typically 11:00 AM - 2:45 PM), Lunch (Interim Menu Saturday & Sunday, typically 3:00 PM - 5:00 PM), Dinner, and, of course, Dessert.
• Reservation Focused: The establishment Accepts reservations, and both Brunch reservations recommended and Dinner reservations recommended are noted due to the high demand. It is wise to book ahead as there is Usually a wait.
• Complete Bar Service: A fully stocked Bar onsite provides a wide selection of Alcohol, Beer, Hard liquor, and a highly acclaimed Wine list, emphasizing their Great cocktails.
• Happy Hour: Guests can enjoy deals on Happy hour drinks and Happy hour food to start their evening.
• Event Planning: A Private dining room is available for celebrations and corporate events, and the restaurant offers specialty Celebration Cakes for pre-order.
• Inclusive Facilities: The amenities include Gender-neutral restroom facilities, contributing to its status as a Transgender safespace.
• Family Accommodations: The venue is Good for kids and provides High chairs.

Gage & Tollner is celebrated by New Yorkers for a collection of distinctive features that elevate the dining experience:

• Historic Atmosphere: The dining room itself is a major draw. Having been beautifully restored, it offers a truly Historic and Romantic setting, one that is both Upscale and Trendy, making it a unique gem in NYC.
• Exceptional Beverage Program: Highlights include a Great wine list and impressive Cocktails, providing perfect pairings for the menu. The upstairs Sunken Harbor Club also offers a separate, intimate tropical cocktail experience.
• Acclaimed Dessert Menu: Under Pastry Chef Caroline Schiff, the Great dessert offerings, such as the famous Coconut Layer Cake and the show-stopping Baked Alaska for Two ($26.00), are often cited as a reason for a return visit.
• Superior Steak and Chops: Specializing in high-quality, large-format cuts like the NY Strip ($64.00), Bone-in Ribeye, and Dry Aged Heritage Pork Chop ($56.00), it lives up to its steakhouse heritage.
• Raw Bar Excellence: The RAW BAR selections are stellar, featuring Daily Selection of East Coast Oysters, Clams on the Half-Shell, Fluke Crudo ($22.00), and the opulent G&T Chilled Seafood Platter ($105.00).
• Dietary Inclusivity: The menu thoughtfully includes Vegan options, Vegetarian options, and Organic dishes, ensuring that diverse dietary needs can be met within a classic American format.

To plan your visit to this renowned Downtown Brooklyn institution, please use the following contact details:

Restaurant Name: Gage & Tollner

Address: 372 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA

Phone: (347) 689-3677

Cuisine Type: American restaurant (Upscale Steak and Seafood)

General Operating Hours (Gage & Tollner Dining Room):

• Monday – Friday (Dinner): 5:00 PM – 10:00 PM
• Saturday – Sunday (Brunch & Dinner): 11:00 AM – 10:00 PM

Sunken Harbor Club (Upstairs Bar) Hours:

• Sunday – Thursday: 5:00 PM – 11:00 PM
• Friday – Saturday: 5:00 PM – 12:00 AM

Note: An Interim Menu is typically offered between 3:00 PM and 5:00 PM on weekends. Reservations are strongly recommended for the main dining room.

For New Yorkers looking for the quintessential Gage & Tollner experience, several items stand out as indispensable choices, combining historical significance with culinary excellence:

• The Baked Alaska for Two ($26.00): This spectacular, tableside-flambéed dessert is a throwback to classic American showmanship and an absolute highlight. It is a perfect capstone to any romantic or celebratory meal.
• Raw Bar Selections: Starting with the freshest Daily Selection of East Coast Oysters or indulging in the G&T Chilled Seafood Platter ($105.00) is essential to appreciate the restaurant's legacy as an outstanding oyster and chop house.
• Steak and Chops: For the main course, you cannot go wrong with the highly praised cuts. The NY Strip ($64.00) or, for larger parties, the impressive Bone-in Ribeye or T-Bone Sirloin (priced by weight), showcase the kitchen's mastery of high-end meats.
• The Coconut Layer Cake ($14.00): This signature dessert is a perennial favorite, famous for its perfect balance of flavor and texture, and is considered one of the best in New York City.
• Signature Appetizers: Be sure to try the Devils on Horseback ($15.00)—dates stuffed and wrapped in bacon—a historic Gage & Tollner item. The Crispy Hen-Of-The-Woods Mushrooms ($18.00) and Crab Cake ($28.00) are also exemplary starters.
• Pairing Tip: Enhance your meal by pairing it with one of the superb Cocktails from the bar program, or enjoy a pre or post-dinner drink upstairs at the Sunken Harbor Club for a full-evening experience.

Ultimately, choosing Gage & Tollner means opting for a full-sensory experience that merges the elegance of New York's past with the culinary sophistication of the present. It is the perfect choice for New Yorkers seeking a high-quality, memorable, and romantic dining occasion.

Gage & Tollner

372 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11201, USA