Galloway’s Bakery

- 69 Harney Rd, Scarsdale, NY 10583

For generations of New York area residents, particularly those in Westchester County, the weekend tradition of picking up fresh, classic American baked goods starts and ends at one legendary location: Galloway’s Bakery in Scarsdale. This is not just another neighborhood bakery; it is a long-standing institution, proudly established in 1956. Originally started as a luncheonette in Bronxville where customers couldn't get enough of their pies, the demand led the Galloway family to relocate and focus entirely on baking, eventually settling into their current location on Harney Road.

Galloway's Bakery represents the heart of old-school, quality baking, specializing in time-honored recipes that evoke a comforting nostalgia. The shop’s renown is such that customers, even those traveling from as far as Las Vegas, consider the trip worthwhile just to get a taste of their famously fresh creations. The limited operating hours—open exclusively from Friday through Sunday—only intensify the demand, often leading to a line that stretches down the sidewalk, a clear testament to the unmatched quality and local loyalty the bakery commands.

The core of Galloway's appeal lies in its commitment to simple, perfect execution of American classics. While many bakeries chase trendy, complex offerings, Galloway's dedication to traditional pies, donuts, cookies, and breads has secured its status as one of the best specialty bakeries in the region. Their pies, baked from the same basic recipe for decades, are the stuff of local legend, particularly around the holidays when the small, cupboard-sized retail area is a hive of activity.

While a wide variety of baked goods are available, it is the pies and donuts that frequently draw the highest praise. Customers rave about the flaky-crusted cream pies, including the rich Chocolate Cream and creamy Banana Cream, alongside fruit-filled classics like Cherry Crumb, Apple, and seasonal favorites such as Pumpkin and Pecan pie. Beyond the impressive selection of full-size and mini pies, the donuts are an incredible draw, with a particularly strong following for the mini jelly donut holes. These are consistently hailed as "the very best in Westchester," described as soft, fresh, and filled with a hand-pumped, perfectly balanced jelly that is neither too sweet nor overwhelming, all finished with just the right dusting of powdered sugar.

Location and Accessibility

Galloway’s Bakery is located in the community of Scarsdale, a key area within Westchester County, New York, making it a convenient destination for local residents and weekend visitors. The exact address is:

69 Harney Rd, Scarsdale, NY 10583, USA

The bakery is tucked away in an unassuming spot, a location that has served the community since 1962. It is situated just off White Plains Road. Despite its modest size, the bakery prioritizes accessibility for its customers:

• Wheelchair Accessible Entrance
• Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot
• Free Street Parking

For those planning a quick visit to grab their weekend treats, the ample parking and focus on snappy turnover, even during crowded times, help manage the high volume of eager customers.

Services Offered

As a highly focused, specialty retail bakery, Galloway's operational model is designed for efficiency and quality, concentrating on providing the freshest products possible:

• Takeout: All products are intended for takeout, with customers often pre-ordering to ensure availability.
• Onsite Services / In-store Shopping: The small retail space allows customers to view and select from the daily offerings.
• Pre-Ordering / Pick-Up: Given the massive demand for their popular items, particularly around holidays, customers are strongly encouraged to ORDER IN ADVANCE for pick-up to guarantee they get their favorite pies and baked goods.
• Coffee: Available as a simple offering to pair with morning treats.
• Breakfast Dining Options: The products are geared towards a quick, delicious breakfast or brunch experience enjoyed off-site.

Features / Highlights

Galloway's Bakery is defined by several unique characteristics that set it apart in the competitive New York culinary scene:

• Weekend-Only Operation: The bakery is open exclusively Friday, Saturday, and Sunday. This limited schedule allows the small family operation to dedicate the weekdays to preparing the immense volume of products necessary to keep the shelves full for the weekend rush, ensuring maximum freshness.
• Cash-Only Policy: The bakery maintains an old-school approach to business, accepting Cash and Checks only for payment. Visitors should plan accordingly before arriving.
• Famous Jelly Donuts and Holes: Arguably the top local highlight, these treats are a must-try and represent the peak of their donut offerings.
• Generational Pie Recipes: Their pies, including classic fruit and indulgent cream varieties (Chocolate, Banana Cream, Coconut Custard, Lemon Meringue), are celebrated for their authentic, flaky crust and rich, traditional fillings.
• Community Atmosphere: The bakery is noted for its friendly environment, where the line outside often includes gregarious regulars. The space is noted as being LGBTQ+ friendly, reinforcing its welcoming nature to all members of the community.

Contact Information

To ensure a successful visit to this iconic Westchester spot, here is the essential contact and operating information:

Address: 69 Harney Rd, Scarsdale, NY 10583, USA

Phone: (914) 725-4074

Operating Hours (Subject to change and holiday closures):

• Monday – Thursday: Closed
• Friday: 7:00 AM – 5:00 PM (Note: Some sources indicate 6:00 PM, but 5:00 PM is a safer estimate.)
• Saturday: 7:00 AM – 5:00 PM (Note: Some sources indicate 6:00 PM, but 5:00 PM is a safer estimate.)
• Sunday: 7:00 AM – 3:00 PM

What is Worth Choosing

Choosing Galloway’s Bakery is a deliberate choice for quality, tradition, and a taste of local New York history. For residents of the New York region, the bakery offers an unparalleled commitment to classic American baking that is increasingly rare.

What makes it truly worth choosing is the experience of their signature items: the legendary jelly donuts and their vast array of holiday-worthy pies. Customers know that they are getting a product made with generational expertise, not mass-produced filler. The community support is evident in the enthusiastic reviews and the willingness of customers to endure a wait, a clear indicator that the reward—the taste of a fresh, homemade-style baked good—is substantial.

Furthermore, the bakery's unique weekend-only schedule emphasizes that freshness and tradition are paramount. It’s a place that forces the local consumer to plan their weekend around a sweet treat, which, in a fast-paced environment like New York, is a welcome, grounding tradition. Just remember to bring cash and, especially around major holidays, call ahead to place your order for pick-up. Galloway’s is more than just a bakery; it's a Westchester County landmark providing delicious, simple comfort food, one perfectly baked pie and melt-in-your-mouth jelly donut hole at a time.

Galloway’s Bakery

69 Harney Rd, Scarsdale, NY 10583, USA