Gencarelli's Bakery

- 446 Broad St, Bloomfield, NJ 07003

A Taste of Tradition: Why Gencarelli's Bakery is a North Jersey Favorite

For residents of North Jersey, few names evoke the sweet aroma of tradition and high-quality baking quite like Gencarelli's Bakery. Rooted deeply in the Bloomfield community since 1975, Gencarelli's has become far more than just a place to buy bread; it is an authentic Italian institution, a go-to spot for everything from a simple morning coffee to a spectacular custom wedding cake. Known for maintaining the perfect balance between old-world Italian techniques and the freshest, high-quality ingredients, this bakery continues to be a staple for families celebrating life's most important moments and for locals simply seeking a daily moment of sweetness.

Walking into Gencarelli's is an experience in itself. The charming establishment is instantly welcoming, filled with the intoxicating scent of freshly baked goods. The visual display of pastries, cakes, and cookies is enticing, showcasing genuine Italian craftsmanship in every meticulously prepared treat. From light-as-air cannoli stuffed with sweet ricotta cream to their delightful assortment of cheesecakes and seasonal specialties, the quality and care put into each item ensure a fresh, homemade taste that keeps customers coming back time and time again. The friendly staff and warm atmosphere only enhance the overall experience, making every visit enjoyable.

Gencarelli's reputation is built on consistency and variety, catering to various occasions with exceptional desserts offered at fair prices. Whether you are stocking up on holiday cookies, picking out a decadent birthday cake, or simply grabbing a fresh loaf of Italian bread, Gencarelli’s Bakery stands out as a beloved gem in Essex County, a true representation of authentic Italian delights that warm the heart and satisfy the senses.

Location and Accessibility for the Local New Jersey User

Gencarelli's Bakery is conveniently situated in the heart of Bloomfield, New Jersey, making it highly accessible for residents throughout Essex County and beyond. The location on Broad Street is a well-known landmark, easily reachable whether you are driving or making a quick stop. Understanding that convenience is key for busy New Jersey families, the bakery has implemented several features to ensure a seamless visit.

The location is:

446 Broad St, Bloomfield, NJ 07003, USA

For those traveling by car, there is a free parking lot available, a valuable amenity in a bustling North Jersey town. Furthermore, Gencarelli's is committed to accessibility for all members of the community. They provide a wheelchair-accessible entrance and a wheelchair-accessible car park, ensuring that everyone can comfortably visit and enjoy their authentic Italian offerings.

Contact Information

For placing custom cake orders, checking on seasonal availability, or simply inquiring about opening hours, the bakery can be reached via phone. We always recommend calling ahead for large orders, particularly during the holidays, as this local favorite gets incredibly busy.

Address: 446 Broad St, Bloomfield, NJ 07003, USA

Phone: (973) 743-1480

Services Offered

Gencarelli's Bakery offers a comprehensive range of services tailored to meet both everyday needs and special occasions. Their offerings reflect a commitment to traditional Italian baking while providing the modern conveniences that today's customers expect.

• Wide Selection of Baked Goods: Featuring everything from freshly baked breads to an extensive variety of Italian pastries, cookies, and specialty desserts.
• Custom Cake Orders: The bakery accepts custom cake orders for special events, including birthdays, weddings, anniversaries, and other large gatherings. Customers are advised to place these orders in advance to ensure availability.
• Pastry Assortments: Decadent treats like cheesecakes, brownies, and seasonal favorites such as key lime pie are always available.
• Takeaway/Takeout: Customers can quickly stop in and pick up their orders to enjoy at home or on the go.
• In-Store Pickup: Pre-orders can be picked up conveniently inside the store.
• On-Site Services: While seating may be limited and busy during peak hours, there is the option to enjoy your coffee and pastry on-site.
• Breakfast Offerings: Perfect for starting your morning right with a fresh pastry and a cup of coffee.
• Payment Flexibility: Accepts credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments for fast and easy transactions.
• Coffee Service: Freshly brewed coffee is available to pair with any of their sweet or savory treats.

Features and Highlights That Make Gencarelli's Special

What sets Gencarelli's Bakery apart and why has it maintained its status as a top-tier North Jersey bakery for decades? It comes down to a few standout features and the consistent quality they deliver, a quality that is frequently praised by local customers.

• Authentic Italian Heritage: Opened in 1975, the bakery has a long-standing history in Northern New Jersey, remaining a recognized name for genuine, traditional Italian desserts and bread.
• Acclaimed Cannoli: Often highlighted by customers in Essex County as a must-try item, their cannoli are known for being light-as-air and perfectly stuffed with sweet ricotta cream.
• High-Quality Ingredients: A commitment to preparing each item with care and using high-quality ingredients ensures that the final product always feels fresh and tastes homemade.
• Signature Cakes: The selection includes classics like Black Forest Cake, Carrot Cake with cream cheese filling, Napoleon Cake with Bavarian cream, and various Tres Leches options, catering to diverse preferences.
• Famous Rainbow Cookies: They are often cited as producing some of the best rainbow cookies in the area, a beloved Italian-American staple.
• Exceptional Customer Service: As noted by a customer, the staff, such as Josie, are frequently praised for being friendly, enthusiastic, and providing great recommendations and service, contributing to the bakery's inviting and warm vibe.
• Italian Cheesecake: Their Italian cheesecake is known to be lighter than the traditional New York style and often features a subtle hint of citrus, converting even the most loyal traditional cheesecake fans.
• A Quick Visit Option: Perfect for those on a tight schedule, the bakery is set up for a quick and satisfying stop.

What is Worth Choosing at Gencarelli's?

For first-time visitors or long-time patrons looking for a recommendation, the display cases at Gencarelli’s offer an overwhelming yet exciting array of options. However, local feedback and reputation consistently point to a few non-negotiable choices. The cannoli are a requirement; they are a benchmark of what a great Italian bakery should offer. Similarly, if you enjoy Italian cookies, you absolutely must try their rainbow cookies—many locals consider them the gold standard in North Jersey.

Beyond the classics, the cakes are celebrated for their quality and craftsmanship. Whether you need a full cake for a party or a creative individual pastry, you will find something to delight. The hazelnut mousse cake has been specifically called out as being creative and absolutely delicious, demonstrating the bakery’s ability to execute both traditional and slightly more modern treats flawlessly. Their commitment to making everything with genuine Italian craftsmanship ensures that any choice, from a simple piece of bread to a complex specialty cake, will be a high-quality experience.

Gencarelli's Bakery has been a cornerstone of the Bloomfield community for decades, a testament to their unwavering dedication to quality, tradition, and friendly service. It's a place where the love of baking and the warmth of the Italian spirit meet, creating a truly 'sweet spot' in North Jersey that is definitely worth a visit. Whether you're planning a major event or just need a delicious pick-me-up for your afternoon coffee, Gencarelli's Bakery is the authentic choice.

Gencarelli's Bakery

446 Broad St, Bloomfield, NJ 07003, USA