Gold Star Beer Counter

- 176 Underhill Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238

For beer enthusiasts and locals in search of a genuinely warm and unpretentious watering hole, **Gold Star Beer Counter** is Prospect Heights’ definitive destination. More than just a simple neighborhood **Bar**, this establishment has cemented its status among New Yorkers as a serious craft beer hub without sacrificing comfort or accessibility. It perfectly embodies a style that one reviewer likened to a specialized, high-quality "Starbucks that serves beer instead of coffee"—a place where serious beer appreciation comfortably mixes with socializing and, yes, even quiet work.

The core identity of Gold Star is defined by its commitment to offering a truly **Great beer selection**. The bar rotates 16 highly curated tap beers and keeps a deep, enviable inventory of dozens of bottles and cans available for both consumption on-site and to take home. The atmosphere is famously **Casual, Cozy, and Trendy**, managing to feel both intimate and welcoming. It's a place that appeals to **Groups** looking for a quality hang and is also popular for **Solo dining** or quiet enjoyment. This unique blend of high-caliber offerings and a refreshingly human, non-corporate vibe—with a music selection that is often local and thoughtfully curated—makes Gold Star Beer Counter a necessary addition to any Brooklynite's regular rotation. The seamless transition from morning coffee service to midday beer counter ensures it serves the community throughout the day.

---

Gold Star Beer Counter is strategically located at **176 Underhill Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238, USA**. This address places it squarely in the vibrant, culture-rich neighborhood of Prospect Heights, a short distance from the Brooklyn Museum, the Brooklyn Botanic Garden, and Grand Army Plaza. The location is easily accessible via the 2, 3, 4, B, F, S, and Q trains, making it a convenient meeting point for New Yorkers from across the boroughs.

The location on Underhill Avenue places it right next door to the locally famous Radio Bakery, creating a dynamic culinary corner. It is a spot where you can grab a pastry in the morning and return later for an exceptional craft beer. Accessibility is well-addressed, as the bar features a **Wheelchair accessible entrance** and a **Wheelchair accessible restroom**, ensuring comfort for all patrons. For those who drive, **Free street parking** is available in the vicinity, a valuable amenity in this busy area of Brooklyn. The friendly, local-centric atmosphere makes it a great spot for neighborhood residents to meet and socialize.

---

Gold Star Beer Counter’s operational structure is tailored to serve the community from early morning to late night, maximizing convenience and utility.

• **Indoor Seating & Dine-In:** Comfortable **Indoor Seating** is available for small **Groups** or **Solo dining**.
• **Outdoor Seating:** Features lovely **Outdoor seating (Sidewalk Seating)**, perfect for enjoying a pint during pleasant weather (available every day, weather permitting, until 10:00 PM).
• **Beer To-Go:** A dedicated **Beer to-go Window** allows patrons to easily select from dozens of bottles and cans to take away.
• **Morning Service:** Unique for a beer bar, the establishment offers **Coffee & Pastries** every day from 8:00 AM – 12:00 PM, catering to early-risers and remote workers.
• **Food Service:** **Food at bar** is available, including savory **BAR SNACKS** all day, and substantial **SANDWICHES** served during peak lunch and dinner hours.
• **Transaction Ease:** Payments are made simple with acceptance of **Credit cards, Debit cards**, and **NFC mobile payments**.

---

What truly sets Gold Star Beer Counter apart is its deep commitment to beer quality and its curated neighborhood vibe, making it a standout in the crowded New York bar scene.

• **World-Class Beer Selection:** The core highlight is the **Great beer selection**, featuring 16 rotating taps and a highly sought-after bottle list that specializes in complex, high-end, and often rare styles, particularly from renowned European breweries (including a large concentration of **Lambic - Fruit, Lambic - Gueuze, and Farmhouse Ale** selections).
• **Thoughtful Rotation:** The draft list is designed to “cover the bases,” typically featuring a **cider, a lager or two, saisons/farmhouses, four sours, five hoppy things, and a couple dark things**—ensuring variety for every palate.
• **Fast Service:** Known for **Fast service**, the bar is efficient and well-staffed, allowing patrons to quickly grab a pint or a snack.
• **Dual Identity:** Successfully operates as both a morning cafe, offering **Coffee & Pastries**, and a premier craft beer **Bar** from midday onward.
• **Quality Bar Food:** Offers satisfying options categorized as **Food** and **Food at bar**, including artisanal sandwiches and savory snacks that are more than just an afterthought.
• **Authentic Atmosphere:** Praised for its warm, unforced, and human vibe, featuring a deliberately curated, local music selection that avoids corporate playlist culture.

---

For the latest draft list, sandwich schedule, or any inquiries, here is how to reach Gold Star Beer Counter in Prospect Heights:

**Address:** 176 Underhill Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238, USA

**Primary Phone:** (347) 955-5031

**Detailed Hours of Operation:**

• **Coffee & Pastries:** Everyday, 8:00 AM – 12:00 PM
• **Indoor Seating & Beer To-Go:**
  • Sunday – Thursday: 12:00 PM – 12:00 AM (Midnight)
  • Friday & Saturday: 12:00 PM – 1:00 AM
• **Sidewalk Seating:** Everyday, 12:00 PM – 10:00 PM (Weather Permitting)
• **Sandwiches:**
  • Monday – Thursday: 4:00 PM – 11:00 PM
  • Friday – Sunday: 12:00 PM – 12:00 AM (All day on weekends)

---

For the serious New York beer drinker, the selection at Gold Star Beer Counter is its greatest asset. The bar’s deep appreciation for classic and complex styles means patrons will consistently find high-quality options far beyond the standard IPA offerings. The bar is particularly renowned for its rare European imports, specifically its collection of **Lambic, Gueuze, and Farmhouse Ales**. Patrons frequently find gems from world-class breweries such as Brasserie Cantillon, Brouwerij 3 Fonteinen, and Tilquin. This is the place in Brooklyn to explore complex, barrel-aged, and spontaneously fermented beers, with styles like Lambic - Fruit and Lambic - Traditional always represented on the menu.

While the bottle list is legendary, the 16 rotating drafts offer a perfectly balanced, immediate-consumption experience. The draft selection ensures that accessible styles like **Pilsners** (e.g., Die Todd Die Pilsner) and classic **American Pale Ales** are readily available, alongside modern trends like New England/Hazy IPAs (e.g., Trucks & Buses Must Exit Left). Whatever your preference, the staff’s expertise ensures you’ll find the perfect pour from the constantly rotating roster.

The food menu complements the sophisticated beer selection perfectly, moving far beyond basic pub fare. The **Sandwiches** are a main attraction, particularly during the weekend when they are served all day. New Yorkers highly recommend the **SALAMI PICANTE** ($14.00) with spicy salami, rosemary ham, and provolone, or the equally impressive vegetarian option: the **WHITE BEAN & ARTICHOKE (vegan)** sandwich ($14.00) featuring smashed gigante beans, artichoke, and peppadew peppers. For a smaller bite, the bar snacks offer simple yet satisfying pairings, such as the salty **SPICY FIESTA CORN NUTS** ($4.00) or the **CITRUS MARINATED CASTELVETRANO OLIVES** ($6.00). Whether you are stopping by for a quiet morning coffee, a quick, excellent **Fast service** sandwich, or an exploration of the world’s finest beers, Gold Star Beer Counter truly delivers on its promise of quality and community.

Gold Star Beer Counter

176 Underhill Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238, USA