Gourmet Bake Shop

- 775 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park, NY 11040

For New Yorkers in the Long Island and Queens border neighborhoods, the name Gourmet Bake Shop is synonymous with quality, freshness, and celebration. Rooted in a rich history that traces back to the 1940s, this establishment has been a steadfast community favorite, serving generation after generation with exceptional baked goods. Located in New Hyde Park, the shop is not merely a place to buy a dessert; it is a full-service bakery and coffee shop committed to crafting everything from scratch using only the finest ingredients. This dedication to tradition and quality ensures that every bite—whether it’s a morning pastry, a loaf of fresh bread, or a spectacular custom cake—delivers an experience that is truly unforgettable.

Gourmet Bake Shop’s commitment to excellence is evident in its wide array of offerings. While the bakers pour their hearts into a dazzling showcase of miniature French and Italian pastries, cookies, and heavenly layer cakes (including favorites like tiramisu and red velvet), their defining specialty is custom cakes. They are masters at creating everything from whimsical kids' birthday cakes to elaborate, showstopping wedding centerpieces. As attested by local customers, the ability of the talented bakers to take a vague idea and bring it to life as a beautiful and delicious confection is a source of community pride. The welcoming, clean environment and friendly staff further cement its status as a highly-rated local institution for all things sweet and savory.

Gourmet Bake Shop is perfectly situated at a highly accessible spot in Nassau County, right on the border of Queens, making it a convenient stop for a wide base of New York customers. The official address is 775 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park, NY 11040, USA. Hillside Avenue is a major artery, ensuring easy travel for customers driving from Queens neighborhoods like Floral Park, Bellerose, and Glen Oaks, as well as those coming from deeper within Long Island.

Understanding the importance of ease and convenience in the metropolitan area, the bakery is well-equipped to handle high traffic and ensure a comfortable visit for everyone. Key accessibility features make it stand out:

• The facility includes a

  Wheelchair Accessible Entrance

  for ease of entry.
• For drivers, there is a dedicated

  Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot

  , complemented by both

  Free Parking Lot

  options and

  Free Street Parking

  .
• Inside, patrons will find a

  Wheelchair Accessible Restroom

  and

  Wheelchair Accessible Seating

  for a comfortable dine-in experience.

This thoughtful approach to accessibility ensures that Gourmet Bake Shop is a welcoming spot for all members of the New Hyde Park and surrounding New York communities.

The scope of services at Gourmet Bake Shop is designed to cater to both the rush of a morning commuter and the thoughtful planning of a special event organizer. They blend traditional bakery offerings with modern convenience options to serve the New York lifestyle effectively.

• Custom Cake Consultations: Dedicated design services for creating personalized masterpieces for weddings, birthdays, graduations, and other special occasions, from charming small cakes to grand centerpieces.
• In-Store Shopping: Customers are invited to browse the extensive selection of fresh breads, pastries, cookies, and cakes, taking in the delightful aroma of a classic bakery.
• Dine-in Service: Patrons can enjoy their fresh pastries and coffee right on site, perfect for a relaxing morning breakfast or a quick afternoon treat.
• Takeout and In-store Pickup: Quick and convenient options for pre-ordered items or spur-of-the-moment purchases, ideal for New Yorkers on a tight schedule.
• Curbside Pickup: An added convenience that allows customers to get their purchases brought directly to their car without having to step inside.
• Breakfast Options: The bake shop is open early and offers a variety of pastries and coffee specifically for a great start to your day.

Gourmet Bake Shop's reputation is built on specific, high-quality offerings and a foundational commitment to baking excellence. These are the aspects that keep local residents returning year after year:

• Custom Cakes as a Specialty: The undisputed highlight. The bakery excels in creating stunning, personalized cakes for all events, with a particular passion for whimsical and playful

  Kids' Cakes

  . They can design a cake for any size gathering, from intimate family events to celebrations hosting 300 guests.
• The Quality of Ingredients: The core philosophy is to craft goods from scratch using only the finest, freshest ingredients, guaranteeing a superior taste in every product, from bread to buttercream frosting.
• A Wide Variety of Baked Goods: Beyond cakes, their showcase is a dazzling display of fresh daily creations, including exceptional

  breads and rolls

  , various

  Danish

  pastries,

  croissants

  ,

  muffins

  , and

  brioche

  . They also feature classics like

  pies

  ,

  donuts

  , and an assortment of

  miniature pastries

  .
• Exceptional Cookies and Italian Pastries: Highly praised by customers, the selection includes melt-in-your-mouth

  butter cookies

  , classic

  Italian biscotti

  perfect for coffee dipping, and beloved treats like

  Cannoli

  .
• Layer Cake Selection: The shop offers heavenly layer cakes, including ever-popular favorites such as

  Tiramisu

  and

  Red Velvet

  , with layers stacked and topped with fruit fillings and rich buttercream.
• In-House Coffee Service: The establishment operates as a Bakery & Coffee shop, offering a selection of hot and cold coffee options to perfectly complement any fresh pastry or bread selection.
• LGBTQ+ Friendly Environment: The shop proudly fosters a welcoming atmosphere, identified as an

  LGBTQ+ friendly

  spot in the community.

To plan your next visit, order a custom creation, or inquire about their daily offerings, please use the following contact details:

• Address: 775 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park, NY 11040, USA
• Phone: (516) 354-3930
• Mobile Phone: +1 516-354-3930

The bakery’s operating hours are typically

Tuesday through Saturday, 6:30 AM to 7:00 PM

For New York residents seeking a consistently outstanding bakery experience, Gourmet Bake Shop is truly worth choosing for several key reasons, most notably its reputation for custom cakes and its long-standing commitment to the community.

Firstly, if you are planning any special occasion—a birthday, anniversary, or wedding—this bakery is the definitive choice. The talent of their bakers in the realm of custom cakes is frequently highlighted in reviews. One satisfied customer shared their experience needing a cake for a god son's first birthday, noting that they "gave them my idea and they brought it to life! Everyone loved it. It was amazing!!!" Another local patron, whose family considers this their "go to bakery," praised the baker as "so talented" after ordering a 60th birthday cake over the phone, adding that the cake "tasted great!" The ability to deliver on complex custom designs, consistently backed by exceptional flavor, is the bakery’s top selling point.

Secondly, beyond the showstoppers, the daily-made staples are essential. Patrons love the variety of fresh goods, emphasizing that the bakery is clean, the staff is friendly, and the selection is large. The cookies, in particular, receive high marks, being described as "delicious" and a permanent family favorite. For those in a rush, the fact that they offer

In-store pickup

Curbside pickup

Gourmet Bake Shop

775 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park, NY 11040, USA