II Fornaretto Bakery Introduce
Introduction / Overview
For generations of New Yorkers, particularly those rooted in Brooklyn, the aroma of a classic, family-run bakery is the very scent of home. In the heart of Bay Ridge, the
II Fornaretto Bakery
stands as a cherished institution that perfectly embodies this nostalgic, high-quality baking tradition. More than just a simpleBakery
, this spot on 5th Avenue combines the best of a traditional Italian brick oven bread shop, a cozyCoffee shop
, and a delightfulDonut shop
, making it a crucial stop for any local with a discerning sweet tooth.II Fornaretto is celebrated for its truly delightful array of freshly baked goods and its warm, inviting atmosphere. Customers are consistently impressed by the 'attractively displayed goods' and the bakery’s commitment to quality that harks back to its roots. The offerings range from superb, artisanal breads to rich, decadent pastries and cakes. It is widely known as an
Italian bakery
, a destination for authentic goods like their acclaimedseven layer raspberry cookies
andcannolis
, with one excited customer noting that 'Everything looks fresh and delicious.'This bakery is particularly famous for a few signature items that draw patrons from all over the New York area. Most notably, their
black and white cookie
is considered a classic and a must-try. Beyond the sweets, they are highly regarded for their breads, including the belovedsemolina bread
andsourdough loaves
. Patrons who have visited have praised the affordability, making high-quality baked goods accessible to a wide audience. Despite the occasional mixed review for some items, the overall consensus is that II Fornaretto excels in providing high-quality treats that evoke a sense of Brooklyn nostalgia. The combination of a visually stunning selection, reasonable pricing, and 'super fast, knowledgeable service' makes this bakery a true find and a local landmark well worth exploring.Established as a staple in Bay Ridge, the bakery is noted for its ability to appeal to both traditional and contemporary tastes, ensuring its continued relevance in the competitive New York food scene.
Location and Accessibility
II Fornaretto Bakery is strategically situated on one of Bay Ridge’s main thoroughfares, ensuring excellent visibility and accessibility for the New York community. The bakery is located at
7612 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA
. This prime spot on 5th Avenue places it at the center of the neighborhood’s commercial activity, making it a convenient stop for locals running errands or commuters passing through.The bakery demonstrates a commitment to making its tempting array of goods available to everyone by offering a
Wheelchair accessible entrance
. This dedication to accessibility is a key factor for a community-focused institution. For those utilizing New York City’s reliable public transportation, the 5th Avenue location is easily accessible via the MTA bus lines that service the area and is within reasonable reach of the R train subway line.Patrons planning a visit should be aware of the payment options, as one reviewer noted a possible 'cash only' policy. However, the provided data confirms that the bakery
Accepts Credit cards
andDebit cards
, suggesting flexibility in payment methods to accommodate modern consumer preferences. While the information does not detail parking availability, the surrounding Bay Ridge streets typically offer metered or free street parking, which requires the familiar New York diligence to secure, but is well worth the effort for a visit to this beloved bakery.Services Offered
II Fornaretto Bakery focuses on providing high-quality products with speed and efficiency, making it the perfect destination for the busy New Yorker.
- Takeout: The primary service, allowing customers to quickly and easily purchase their favorite pastries, breads, and cakes to enjoy at home or on the go.
- Onsite services: Offers the full in-store experience, allowing patrons to browse the 'vibrant displays' and select their fresh baked goods.
- Quick visit: The operational model is designed for efficiency, ensuring 'super fast' and knowledgeable service for customers needing a quick stop.
- Coffee Service: Provides fresh
Coffee
to complement their wide range of donuts, pastries, and sweet slices. - Diverse Baked Goods: Offers a comprehensive selection of items, including
breads
(semolina, sourdough),cookies
(black and white, butter),danishes
(coconut, raspberry),pies
(cherry crumb, apple crumb), andcakes
(cheesecake slices). - Multiple Payment Options: Accepts both
Credit cards
andDebit cards
, catering to the financial preferences of most customers.
Features / Highlights
The features of II Fornaretto Bakery are deeply rooted in its tradition and the specific high-quality products that have made it a Bay Ridge landmark for decades.
- The Famous Black and White Cookie: A signature item that the bakery is 'famous for' and a quintessential New York treat, often praised for its fresh, cake-like texture.
- Exceptional Bread Selection: Renowned for its artisanal breads, specifically the
semolina bread
andsourdough loaves
, which are noted for their quality and traditional preparation. - Classic Italian Specialties: A go-to spot for authentic Italian treats like fresh
cannolis
, seven layer raspberry cookies, and tiramisu (based on search results), upholding the standards of an 'Italian bakery.' - Quality Desserts: Offers a compelling selection of cakes and pies, including the rich
raspberry cheesecake
and affordable slices ofStrawberry Cheesecake
andBlueberry Cheesecake
(both $4.95). - Affordable Indulgence: Customers frequently note the affordability of the products, making it a budget-friendly destination for high-quality baked goods.
- Modern and Clean Appearance: Described as 'Very modern looking and clean, with attractively displayed goods,' offering a pleasant and welcoming shopping environment.
- Positive Customer Experience: Highlighted by 'super fast, knowledgeable service' and staff who are described as 'so warm and friendly.'
Contact Information
For New York residents looking to place orders, check availability of their famous black and white cookies, or inquire about their artisanal breads, the contact details for II Fornaretto Bakery are:
Address:
7612 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USAPhone:
(718) 680-2323 or +1 718-680-2323What is worth choosing
II Fornaretto Bakery is a truly worthwhile choice for any New Yorker seeking the perfect blend of tradition, quality, and community feel in their baked goods. Choosing this bakery is an affirmation of classic Brooklyn neighborhood culture and a guarantee of delicious, satisfying treats.
The most compelling reason to choose II Fornaretto is its status as a local institution that consistently delivers high-quality products at reasonable prices. Where else can you find a bakery that is famous for its artisanal
semolina bread
and, in the same visit, satisfy a craving for a perfect, classic New Yorkblack and white cookie
? The bakery’s commitment to its Italian heritage is evident in the quality of itscannolis
and specialized cookies, offering an authentic taste that can be hard to replicate.Furthermore, the value for money is outstanding. With popular items like Glazed Donuts available for just $1.95 and cheesecake slices for $4.95, this bakery makes everyday treats and special indulgences affordable. The fast, friendly, and knowledgeable service, noted by multiple customers, ensures that even on a hurried schedule, a visit to II Fornaretto is a stress-free and positive experience—perfect for a
Quick visit
during a busy Brooklyn day. The combination of its convenient 5th Avenue location, its commitment to accessibility with aWheelchair accessible entrance
, and its celebrated signature items solidify II Fornaretto Bakery as a must-choose destination for anyone who loves great bread and classic desserts in New York City.II Fornaretto Bakery Menu
Cookies
- Fudge Brownie with Nuts $4.55
- Butter Cookies
Half a pound of soft sweet butter cookies
Danishes & Croissants
- Coconut Danish $3.25
- Raspberry Danish $3.25
Pie
- Cherry Crumb Pie 7" $15.50
Feeds 6-8 people
- Apple Crumb Pie 7" $15.25
Feeds 6-8 people
Doughnuts
- Glazed $1.95
- Powder Cream $1.95
Cakes
- Slice of Strawberry Cheesecake $4.95
- Slice of Blueberry Cheesecake $4.95
II Fornaretto Bakery Details
Service options
- Onsite services
- Takeout
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Offerings
- Coffee
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
II Fornaretto Bakery Photos










II Fornaretto Bakery Location
II Fornaretto Bakery Reviews
pricesblack and white cookiesrollsdanishesloafcashjelly donutspeanut butter and jellyitalian breadsweet
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1It’s getting tough to find a good bakery. Well, I found a terrific one. Very modern looking and clean, with attractively displayed goods. The rolls and bread are very delicious, as are their pastries. Very welcoming young lady behind the counter offering super fast, knowledgeable service. A real find. ♿️
March 29 · PhilYouInI came here for the first time yesterday due to all the rave reviews I read on Facebook. This place is an institution in Bay Ridge and justifiably so. Everything looks fresh and delicious. I opted to get some donuts and cannolis, which were both very good. I want to come back in the future to get their bread (I heard the soda bread is great), black and white cookie (that they are famous for) and the danishes. The lady behind the counter was so warm and friendly. But, be forewarned. This place is cash only and prices are very reasonable.
January 12 · Lisa SIf you want to get a loaf of bread or anything else less than $10, then make sure you have cash because what they are doing is illegal asking for a minimum of $10 on debit cards. Nobody should support sketchy places like this.
July 24 · Peter GogolliOld style Scandinavian bakery. Everything we bought was fresh and tasty. Standouts were the crumb cake, and cheese danish. A nice remnant of old Bay Ridge.
August 14 · cee BOCKOkay pastries. I purchased four danishes, but they tasted a little dry. I will have to come back again to try some of their cookies.
July 06 · S. Reid
More restaurants near me

7616 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA

7609 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA

7525 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA

484 77th St, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA

7526 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA

7702 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA

7519 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA

7704 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA

7518 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA

7701 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA

7718 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA

7717 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Trending Dining Insights Posts





