Jersey Mike's Subs

- 180 W Old Country Rd, Hicksville, NY 11801

For New York residents in the Nassau County area who appreciate a truly authentic, Northeast-style submarine sandwich, Jersey Mike's Subs in Hicksville is a recognized local fixture. Situated directly on West Old Country Road, this popular establishment offers a welcome alternative to typical fast-food fare by specializing in fresh, made-to-order subs. The core philosophy here is built around the freshness of the ingredients, a commitment evident in their practice of slicing meats and cheeses right in front of the customer, guaranteeing a high-quality, flavorful foundation for every sub.

Jersey Mike's distinguishes itself in the highly competitive New York food market by sticking to tradition, particularly with the time-honored preparation known as "Mike's Way." This signature style involves dressing the sub with a zesty and flavor-enhancing blend of onions, lettuce, tomatoes, red wine vinegar, olive oil, and a blend of oregano and salt. This 'juice,' as locals often call it, saturates the freshly baked bread and melds the flavors of the meat and cheese, creating a truly distinct and satisfying taste that resonates with those who grew up enjoying authentic East Coast deli sandwiches.

The menu provides a wide array of options, successfully catering to the diverse needs of the New York consumer, whether for a quick bite during a busy workday or a relaxed lunch with family. Popular items include the quintessential cold subs, such as the famous The Original Italian (#13), stacked with multiple quality cold cuts, and the lighter but equally satisfying Turkey and Provolone (#7). Beyond the cold cuts, the shop offers a tempting selection of hot subs, notably the well-regarded Mike's Famous Philly Cheese Steak (#17), prepared fresh on the grill with onions, peppers, and melted cheese.

While the focus is on traditional subs, the Hicksville location also makes efforts to accommodate a broader clientele. The inclusion of Halal food options ensures that a wider range of the local community can enjoy their offerings, and readily available vegetarian options, such as The Veggie (#14), further broaden its appeal. As a versatile food service provider, Jersey Mike's acts as a deli, a fast-casual restaurant, and a reliable caterer, making it an excellent resource for lunch, dinner, or corporate and private events across Long Island.

It is important to note that while the quality of ingredients and signature style are major draws, customer reviews occasionally point to issues with order accuracy, particularly regarding specific dietary requests like no cheese, and cleanliness. New Yorkers with strict dietary restrictions should be diligent when placing their order and might consider confirming the details upon pickup or delivery. Despite these isolated concerns, the overall model—fresh-sliced meat, Mike’s Way preparation, and broad service options—keeps Jersey Mike's a significant contender in the local sandwich scene.

The Jersey Mike's Subs location in Hicksville is conveniently situated in the heart of Nassau County, making it highly accessible for New York area customers traveling through or residing in the central Long Island region.

The shop’s address is: 180 W Old Country Rd, Hicksville, NY 11801. This position on West Old Country Road is a major thoroughfare, which is ideal for both drive-by traffic and local residents. Accessibility for all customers is a priority, as demonstrated by the available amenities:

• Wheelchair Accessibility: The location features a wheelchair accessible entrance, a dedicated wheelchair accessible parking lot, and a wheelchair accessible restroom and seating area, ensuring a comfortable experience for patrons with mobility needs.
• Parking: Customers benefit from a free parking lot and the availability of free street parking nearby, alleviating one of the common hassles of dining in the New York metropolitan area.
• Transportation: The location's presence on a major road means it is well-served by local transport options, facilitating easy access for college students, families, and tourists alike.

Operating seven days a week from 10 AM to 9 PM, the store provides consistent service hours tailored for busy lunch and dinner crowds.

This Jersey Mike's location offers a comprehensive suite of dining and convenience services, positioning it as a highly adaptable fast-casual option:

• Dine-in: Comfortable seating and a casual atmosphere allow for a quick, enjoyable meal on-site.
• Takeout & Counter Service: Rapid service available for customers who wish to grab their order and go.
• Delivery: Standard delivery options are available via third-party services, ensuring accessibility to homes and offices in the surrounding New York region.
• No-contact delivery: A safe and convenient option that caters to ongoing preferences for minimal interaction.
• Curbside pickup: A highly efficient service allowing pre-ordered meals to be collected without leaving the vehicle.
• Catering Services: Providing various options, including 'Subs By The Box,' 'Subs By The Bag,' and 'Personal Boxed Lunches,' ideal for corporate meetings, private parties, and large group events in Long Island.
• Kid-Friendly Amenities: The shop is good for kids and provides high chairs and a dedicated kids' menu.

The key features of Jersey Mike's that draw local New York customers include a strong emphasis on tradition, quality, and community:

• Fresh Slicing: Meats and cheeses are sliced fresh for every order, a deli practice that ensures maximum flavor and freshness, distinguishing it from competitors.
• "Mike's Way" Preparation: The signature dressing of onions, lettuce, tomatoes, red wine vinegar, olive oil blend, and spices provides a unique, savory, and memorable flavor profile.
• Popular Sub Varieties: Highlighting classics like The Original Italian and Mike's Famous Philly, which are staples of Northeast deli culture.
• Halal & Vegetarian Options: Offering specific Halal food choices and dedicated vegetarian subs like The Veggie (#14), catering to diverse local dietary needs.
• Robust Catering Menu: An easy-to-order catering system that simplifies meal planning for large groups, making it a reliable partner for Long Island offices and events.
• Family and Crowd Appeal: The casual atmosphere, free Wi-Fi, and amenities like high chairs and good-for-kids options make it a comfortable spot for families, college students, and solo diners alike.
• Dedicated Parking: The availability of a free parking lot is a significant convenience in a densely populated area like Hicksville.

For New York customers in the Hicksville area wishing to contact Jersey Mike's Subs for orders, inquiries, or catering, the following information is provided:

Address: 180 W Old Country Rd, Hicksville, NY 11801

Phone: (516) 730-9500

Mobile Phone: +1 516-730-9500

The phone lines are active during their operating hours from 10 AM to 9 PM, seven days a week, providing a direct means of communication for local ordering and confirming catering details.

Choosing Jersey Mike's Subs in Hicksville is a choice for quality and tradition, delivered with modern convenience. What is most worth choosing here is the genuine "deli experience," particularly the freshly sliced meats and the distinctive flavor of the "Mike's Way" topping. This is not simply a sandwich shop; it's a purveyor of the authentic submarine sandwich style that has been perfected over decades. For local New Yorkers who value their meat sliced to order, the taste difference is palpable and instantly gratifying.

The dual commitment to both cold and hot subs is also a major draw. You can indulge in the savory, multi-layered cold cuts of The Original Italian one day, and satisfy a craving for hot, gooey comfort food with Mike's Famous Philly the next. Furthermore, the extensive service options—from curbside pickup to no-contact delivery and full catering for the office—ensure that a quick, delicious meal is always accessible, regardless of your schedule or preference.

While acknowledging the occasional, isolated customer comments regarding order accuracy and cleanliness, the overall value proposition remains strong. The provision of Halal options, vegetarian choices, and excellent accessibility makes this a truly inclusive and reliable food stop for a diverse community. Ultimately, Jersey Mike's Subs is worth choosing for its uncompromising dedication to fresh ingredients and its signature taste, making it a high-quality, convenient, and flavorful sub shop essential to the Hicksville, NY, food landscape.

Jersey Mike's Subs

180 W Old Country Rd, Hicksville, NY 11801, USA