John's Pizzeria of Times Square

- 260 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036

In a city overflowing with pizzerias, John's Pizzeria of Times Square holds a special place in the hearts of New Yorkers and visitors alike. It's not just a restaurant; it's a piece of New York history, housed within a magnificent former church. The moment you step inside, you are transported into a space where historic architecture meets the classic, buzzing energy of a Times Square institution. This legendary spot has earned its reputation not just for its unique atmosphere but, more importantly, for its authentic, coal-fired brick oven pizzas. Unlike the typical slice shops found on every corner, John's offers whole pies only, staying true to a tradition that has delighted patrons for generations. The combination of its historic setting, classic Neapolitan-style pizza, and lively ambiance makes it a must-visit destination for anyone looking for a truly authentic New York dining experience. Whether you're a local seeking a delicious dinner with friends or a family visiting the city and looking for a memorable meal, John's Pizzeria delivers on every front.

This article is your comprehensive guide to everything you need to know about John's Pizzeria of Times Square. We’ll delve into its remarkable location and accessibility, which is particularly useful in this bustling part of the city. We will outline the range of services offered, from dine-in to takeout, and highlight the key features that make this restaurant so unique, including its historic architecture and renowned menu. We'll also provide essential contact information and offer recommendations on what to choose from their menu to ensure a perfect dining experience. Our goal is to provide a factual and engaging overview that helps you understand why John's has become a beloved landmark in New York City's culinary landscape.

John's Pizzeria of Times Square is perfectly situated at 260 West 44th Street, placing it at the heart of the world-famous Theater District. This location makes it an incredibly convenient and popular choice for theater-goers, tourists, and locals alike. It's just a short walk from Broadway's most iconic theaters and the dazzling lights of Times Square, making it an ideal pre-show or post-show dining destination. The restaurant is easily accessible by New York's extensive public transportation system. It's within a very short walking distance of the Times Square–42nd Street subway station, which is a major hub serving the 1, 2, 3, N, Q, R, W, and S lines, as well as the 42nd Street–Port Authority Bus Terminal station (A, C, E trains). This unparalleled accessibility ensures that no matter where you are in the city, getting to John's is straightforward.

The building itself is a former Gospel Tabernacle Church, and this unique history is a huge part of the restaurant's charm. The intact church ceiling, stained-glass windows, and beautiful chandeliers create an atmosphere that is both grand and intimate, offering a sense of history that is rarely found in a modern restaurant. The space is large, with a main dining area and a second-level seating space, allowing it to accommodate a large volume of customers. However, as it is a highly popular spot, it is often crowded, especially during peak dining hours. It is important to note that while the restaurant is large, there is often a wait, which is a testament to its popularity.

---

### Services Offered

John's Pizzeria of Times Square provides a range of services designed to enhance the dining experience, catering to the diverse needs of its clientele.

• Dine-in: The primary service is a full dine-in experience within the unique, historic setting. It's a place to sit down, enjoy the ambiance, and have a leisurely meal.

• Takeout: For those who want to enjoy John's pizza in a different setting, takeout is a convenient option.

• Delivery: John's also offers delivery, allowing you to get their delicious pizzas and other menu items brought directly to you.

• Catering: For large groups, events, or parties, the restaurant offers catering services, making it a great choice for feeding a crowd with high-quality, authentic New York food.

• Reservations: The restaurant accepts reservations, which is highly recommended for those who want to avoid the wait, especially during busy times.

---

### Features and Highlights

What sets John's Pizzeria apart from other pizza restaurants in New York? It’s the combination of its unique features and high-quality offerings.

• Historic Atmosphere: The most notable highlight is the restaurant's setting in a converted church. The historic architecture, including the ceiling, stained glass, and chandeliers, creates a memorable and unparalleled dining atmosphere.

• Coal-Fired Brick Oven Pizza: The pizzas are cooked in a coal-fired brick oven, a traditional method that gives them a distinctively crispy crust and smoky flavor that cannot be replicated in a standard oven.

• Great Drinks Selection: The restaurant has a full bar with an onsite bartender and offers a great selection of beer, cocktails, and a noteworthy wine list.

• Family-Friendly and Accessible: John's is a great place for families, offering a kids' menu, high chairs, and even a changing table. The venue is also wheelchair accessible with an accessible entrance, seating, and restroom.

• Fast Service: Despite the frequent crowds, the service is known for being quick and efficient, ensuring that you get your food in a timely manner.

• Comfort Food: The menu is full of classic comfort food items, making it a great place to satisfy a craving for something familiar and delicious.

---

### Contact Information

Address: 260 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036

Phone: (212) 391-7560

Mobile Phone: +1 212-391-7560

---

### What is worth choosing

At John's Pizzeria of Times Square, the pizza is the star, and it's what you should choose above all else. The menu offers a variety of specialty pizzas, but the best way to experience the true essence of John's is to start with a Traditional or Margherita pizza. These classic pies allow the quality of the ingredients and the unique flavor from the coal-fired oven to shine through. The crispy, thin crust is a signature feature that makes it a must-try. For those looking for something a bit different, the Buffalo Chicken Pizza is a popular choice that combines the classic pizza form with a spicy, flavorful topping. The Hawaiian pizza is also available for those who enjoy that sweet and savory combination.

In addition to the pizza, the appetizers are worth exploring. The Fried Calamari is often praised for being perfectly crispy and a great way to start your meal. The Garlic Rolls are also a popular choice, providing a warm and savory side that pairs well with the pizza. For a lighter start, the salads are fresh and flavorful; the Caesar Salad or House Salad are excellent options. From the drinks menu, you have a wide range of choices, from a simple soda to a well-selected glass of wine or a signature cocktail. The beer selection is also highly regarded.

Overall, John's Pizzeria is a destination for an iconic meal. While the wait can be a bit long, the experience—from the historic atmosphere to the authentic coal-fired pizza—is absolutely worth it. The true value lies in the classic, whole-pie pizza and the unique dining experience that you simply can't find anywhere else in the city.

John's Pizzeria of Times Square

260 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036, USA