Kelly's Sea Level in Rye, NY: Your Local Hub for Historic Comfort Food and Great Value

Kelly's Sea Level Introduce

Kelly's Sea Level, nestled in the charming city of Rye, New York, is far more than just a place to grab a meal; it is a beloved neighborhood institution. For New Yorkers looking for a classic American restaurant experience that blends history, hearty comfort food, and a genuinely welcoming atmosphere, Kelly’s Sea Level is a standout destination in Westchester County. This local favorite has solidified its place in the community by consistently delivering satisfying pub fare and fresh seafood at excellent value, making it an ideal gathering spot for families, friends, and solo diners alike.

The restaurant's vibe is often described as "homey," a cozy neighborhood pub that has drawn locals for generations. It successfully merges the best of a traditional American grill with the spirit of an inviting local bar. Customers consistently praise the friendly staff, the prompt and accommodating service, and the comfortable setting that encourages patrons to relax and enjoy their time. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick lunch, a casual dinner, or a Sunday brunch, Kelly’s Sea Level promises a relaxed and dependable dining experience that feels a world away from the fast pace of the greater New York region.

Kelly’s Sea Level has a storied past that adds a layer of historic charm to its casual atmosphere. The building itself has been a community fixture for over a century, having previously operated as a German restaurant, a local bar known as Wally's Five Point Tavern, and even a speakeasy during the Prohibition era. This long and vibrant history ensures that every visit is steeped in a tradition of community gathering, making the dining room an inherently cozy and authentic space.

The menu at Kelly's Sea Level is expansive and focused on delivering high-quality, generously portioned comfort food. It covers all the bases for classic American dining, from celebrated burgers and hot dogs to full steak dinners and an impressive selection of seafood. The kitchen ensures that, despite the pub-style setting, fresh, well-prepared ingredients are a priority, resulting in delicious and reliable dishes that keep patrons coming back. The variety means there is truly something for every palate, whether you crave a juicy burger, a fresh lobster roll, or a classic shepherd’s pie.

The restaurant’s commitment to providing great value is another key factor in its popularity. Patrons often highlight the affordability of the menu items relative to the generous portions and the quality of the food. In the competitive New York dining scene, finding a dependable spot that offers both an excellent meal and great prices is a significant advantage, and Kelly’s Sea Level delivers on this promise time and again.

Location and Accessibility

Kelly’s Sea Level is conveniently located in the city of Rye, New York, easily accessible for residents and visitors throughout Westchester County and the greater New York metropolitan area. Its exact location is 413 Midland Ave, Rye, NY 10580, USA. Rye itself is a city with a great community feel, situated just over 30 miles from New York City. For those traveling by car, customers have consistently reported that free street parking is readily available, often finding a spot right out front, which is a rare amenity in this region. The restaurant is committed to accessibility, offering a wheelchair-accessible entrance and seating to ensure that all members of the community can enjoy their dining experience comfortably.

Services Offered

Kelly's Sea Level provides a diverse range of services to cater to all dining preferences and schedules, solidifying its role as a full-service local hub:

Dine-in Service: Enjoy the casual, cozy, and historic atmosphere with comfortable table service.
Takeout and Curbside Pickup: Convenient options for enjoying the menu at home.
Delivery: The restaurant offers delivery through various food delivery platforms.
Catering: Services available for special events and gatherings.
Dining Throughout the Day: Serving Breakfast, Brunch (with a popular Sunday Brunch menu), Lunch, and Dinner.
Full Bar Service: Featuring an excellent selection of Beer, Wine, and Cocktails, along with Hard Liquor and late-night food options.
Family Amenities: The establishment is family-friendly, offering a kids' menu and high chairs.
Onsite Amenities: Includes a Bar onsite, Restrooms, and Wi-Fi.

Features / Highlights

What truly sets Kelly’s Sea Level apart is a combination of its celebrated menu items, historic atmosphere, and accommodating service:

Famous Char-Grilled Burgers: The 10-ounce burgers, a mix of fresh ground sirloin and chuck, are a legendary staple, praised for their quality and flavor, available in varieties like the Chili Cheese Burger and Jerry’s BEC Burger.
Acclaimed Seafood and Pub Favorites: Beyond the burgers, favorites include solid Fish and Chips, generous All Meat Lobster Rolls (available Connecticut-Style, warm with butter, or Maine-Style, cold with Old Bay Mayo), and the satisfying All Beef Shepherd's Pie.
Historic and Cozy Atmosphere: The restaurant operates in a building with a history spanning over 100 years, including time as a speakeasy and tavern, providing a uniquely warm and historic backdrop for a casual meal.
Exceptional Value: Customers consistently note the generous portions and high quality of the food at very reasonable prices.
Outdoor Seating: A favorite feature is the covered patio and outdoor seating area, providing a relaxed and breezy spot to enjoy a meal, especially during warmer months.
Great Drink and Dessert Selection: High marks are given to the excellent beer and cocktail menus, and the dessert offerings, including Longford's ice cream, are a popular finishing touch.
Veteran and Women-Owned: The establishment proudly identifies as both veteran-owned and women-owned.
Sunday Brunch: A dedicated weekend offering featuring classic brunch items like Eggs Benedict and Sirloin Steak & Eggs.

Contact Information

For reservations, takeout, or general inquiries, you can reach Kelly's Sea Level using the following details:

Address: 413 Midland Ave, Rye, NY 10580, USA
Phone: (914) 967-0868

What is Worth Choosing

Kelly's Sea Level is a prime choice for New York residents seeking authentic, satisfying American comfort food in a genuinely friendly setting. You should choose Kelly's Sea Level because it is a place where every visit feels like coming home. The combination of a menu offering both familiar pub classics and quality seafood, all served in an atmosphere steeped in local history, is unmatched.

The restaurant's focus on affordability and generous portions ensures that you are getting great bang for your buck, a true rarity in the New York area. For first-time visitors, the must-try items are one of their famous, perfectly char-grilled burgers or a generous portion of the fresh, well-regarded lobster roll. Whether you’re planning a casual lunch, a family dinner, or simply looking for a dependable local spot to catch a quick bite or late-night food, Kelly's Sea Level stands as a dependable, celebrated, and deeply rooted part of the Rye community, promising a delightful and unpretentious dining experience.

Kelly's Sea Level Food & drink

Salads
Grilled Shrimp Caesar $15.95
Crisp Romaine, Croutons & Shaved Parmesan
Garden Salad $5.95
Romaine, Mixed Greens, Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Croutons, Green Peppers & Red Onions
Caesar $7.95
Crisp Romaine, Croutons & Shaved Parmesan
Chef Salad $10.95
Turkey, Ham, Swiss Cheese & American Cheese
Cobb Salad $13.95
Grilled Chicken, Crumbled Blue Cheese, Hard Boiled Eggs, Bacon and Avocado
Iceberg Wedge $8.95
Cold Crisp Chunks of Iceberg Lettuce topped with Crisp Bacon, Red Onions, Tomatoes & Creamy Blue Cheese
Craisins & Greens $10.95
Our Garden Salad, with Walnuts, Craisins, Crumbled Feta, Red Onions with a Balsamic Glaze
Gorgonzola $6.95
Crumbled Blue Cheese, on a Garden Salad with Balsamic Dressing

Soups
French Onion Soup $5.50
Lovely Beef Broth with White Onions, Croutons and Melted Mozzarella Cheese
New England Clam Chowder $5.50
Creamy Chowder with Clams
Soup of the Day $5.50
We make amazing speciality soups daily, call us at (914) 967-0868 and find out what's cooking!

Chili
Chili $6.95
Famous Homemade Chili - when you're ordering ask for some cheese on top for $1.00 more

Appetizers
French Fries $4.50
Huge order of Steak Cut Potato Fries - add chili & cheese $4.00 • add gravy $1.00
Sweet Potato Fries $4.50
Delicious Sweet Potato Fries adds a smile to any Entree - add chili & cheese $4.00 • add gravy $1.00
Onion Rings $4.50
Onion Rings fried to perfection
Tater Tots $4.50
Tots! We've got Tots! - add chili & cheese $4.00 • add gravy $1.00
Chili Cheese French Fries $8.50
These deserve a listing all their own. Our Steak Fries with Chili and Cheese
Quesadilla $6.95
Flour Tortilla with cheddar & jack, salsa, sour cream & homemade guacamole -- add chicken + $4.00 or steak + $8.00 extra guacamole +$2.50
Chicken Fingers $7.95
All-White Meat Chicken Plain or Tossed in Buffalo Sauce - No Bones about it!
Jalapeño Poppers $7.95
Breaded Jalapeños Stuffed with Cheddar Cheese served with a side of Sour Cream
Beer Battered Mozzarella Sticks $7.95
Mozzarella Cheese Breaded and Fried to Perfection - served with Delicious Marinara Sauce
Nachos $9.95
Tortilla Chips with Melted Jack & Cheddar Cheese, Salsa, Chili, Homemade Guacamole & Sour Cream
Irish Nachos $10.95
A Crowd Pleaser! Crispy Battered Potato Spirals with Melted Jack & Cheddar Cheese, Bacon, Scallions & Sour Cream - OMG Level good!
Spicy Chicken Wings $7.95
Breaded and Served with Blue Cheese
Buffalo Wings $8.95
Traditional Buffalo Sauce, Thai Chili Sauce or Teriyaki served with Celery & Blue Cheese
Buffalo Cod Bits $10.95
Succulent Cod Breaded and Fried served with Chili Mayo
Sunday’s Special Wings $0.75
Sundays only in house --- at 75 cents each available in Thai Chili, Teriyaki, Hot, Mild or Medium Wings

Entrées
16oz Rib Eye Steak Dinner $21.95
16 oz. Rib Eye Steak served with mashed potatoes with your choice of vegetable
Meatloaf Dinner $12.95
Meatloaf Dinner served with mashed potatoes and your choice of vegetable
Grilled Chicken Dinner $12.95
Grilled Chicken Dinner served with mashed potatoes and your choice of vegetable
Salmon Dinner $14.95
Salmon Dinner served with mashed potatoes and your choice of vegetable
Fried Chicken in a Basket with French Fries $12.95
Fried Chicken in a Basket with French Fries - savory & crispy breast, thigh, leg & wing
Sirloin Steak Dinner $14.95
Sirloin Steak Dinner served with mashed potatoes and your choice of vegetable
Shepard’s Pie $9.95
Shepard's Pie
Saturday Night Special Prime Rib Roast $22.95
Saturday Night Special Prime Rib Roast a homemade slow-cooked prime rib roast, grilled to your liking, served with mashed potatoes and grilled asparagus

Seafood
Beer Battered Fish & Chips $14.95
Beer Battered Fish & Chips - atlantic cod, served with tartar sauce and lemon
Hand Breaded Jumbo Shrimp $13.95
Hand Breaded Jumbo Shrimp available regular or Cajun served with crispy fries, tartar sauce and lemon
Steamed Little Neck Clams $12.95
Steamed Little Neck Clams served with melted butter
Super Clam Strips $11.95
Super Clam Strips served with crispy fries, tartar sauce and lemon. You can order them on a hot dog roll!
Buffalo Cod Bits $10.95
Buffalo Cod Bits served with chili mayo
Grilled Shrimp Caesar Salad $15.95
Grilled Shrimp Caesar Salad crisp romaine, with croutons & shaved parmesan

Burgers
Our Famous Hamburger $5.95
10 oz. mix of fresh ground sirloin & chuck, char-grilled to your preferred temperature. Served on a fresh kaiser roll
Sliders $7.95
Sliders two mini three-ounce hamburgers on soft rolls, with cheese and chili & served with tater tots.
Chili Cheese Burger $7.95
Chili Cheese Burger -its our delicious burger topped with our famous chili with your choice of cheese
Bacon Cheese Burger $7.95
Bacon Cheese Burger topped with grade A bacon & melted cheese
Baja Burger $9.95
Baja Burger served with bacon, avocado, scallions, jalapeno cheese & chipotle sauce
Jerry’s BEC Burger $8.95
Jerry’s BEC Burger (BEC - bacon, egg & cheese) with melted cheese, crisp bacon & a fried egg!
Cheese Burger Patty Melt on Rye $8.95
Cheese Burger Patty Melt with Melted Swiss, Sautéed Onions on Grilled Rye Bread
Kelly’s Classic Burger $5.95
Kelly’s Classic Burger served on an English Muffin with Lettuce, Tomato, Onion & Russian Dressing
Blue Cheese Burger with blue cheese, bacon, lettuce & tomato $8.00
Blue Cheese Burger blue cheese, bacon, lettuce & tomato

Sandwiches and Wraps
Fitz Blitz $10.95
The Fitz Blitz is a grilled chicken breast with long hot peppers, sauteed onions & melted pepper jack cheese
Beer-Battered Cod Sandwich $9.95
Beer-Battered Cod Sandwich served with lettuce, tomato, onions, tartar sauce & lemon
8oz. Sirloin Steak Sandwich $13.95
8oz. Sirloin Steak Sandwich served with mushrooms, onions & horseradish sauce on garlic bread
Steak-Um $6.95
Steak-Um served with peppers and onions
Ahi Tuna Wrap $13.95
Ahi Tuna Wrap with seaweed salad, avocado, mixed greens, wasabi sauce & pickled ginger
Grilled Portobello $9.95
Grilled Portobello with roasted peppers, melted mozzarella, spinach & basil mayo
Grilled Chicken Sandwich $8.95
Grilled Chicken Sandwich served on a Kaiser Roll
Baja Chicken Sandwich $9.95
Baja Chicken Sandwich served with bacon, avocado, scallions, jalapeno cheese & chipotle sauce
Grilled Cheese Sandwich $4.95
Grilled Cheese Sandwich - available with any of our toppings and cheeses
Ham & Cheese $6.95
Ham & Cheese Sandwich served on a kaiser roll
Kielbasa Melt $7.95
Kielbasa Melt with sauteed onions & melted brie
Balboa hot roast beef & melted swiss on a toasted garlic bun $7.95
The Balboa is hot roast beef with melted swiss served on a toasted garlic bun
Hot Pastrami or Corned Beef $8.95
Hot Pastrami or Corned Beef on Rye or your choice of bread
Reuben $8.95
Reuben with your choice of pastrami, corned beef or kielbasa - piled high with sauerkraut & melted swiss
Roast Beef or Turkey Sandwich $7.95
Roast Beef or Turkey Sandwich - Fresh delicious deli meats on a kaiser roll
Open-Face Tuna Melt $8.95
Open-Face Tuna Melt with Swiss, Bacon & Tomato
B.L.T. $6.00
B.L.T. Bacon, Lettuce and Tomato
Turkey Club $8.95
Turkey Club - a 3-tiered sandwich with Fresh Sliced Turkey, Lettuce, Tomato, and Bacon
Tunafish Salad $6.95
Fresh Tunafish Salad on your choice of bread
Veal Cutlet Parm $7.95
Veal Cutlet Parm Sandwich on a Roll
Meatloaf w/Swiss Cheese & Gravy $8.95
Meatloaf w/Swiss Cheese & Gravy on a Roll

Burger, Sandwich, Entrée and Salad Toppings
Bacon $1.00
Extra Bacon
Chili $1.00
Extra Chili
Onion Rings $1.00
Extra Onion Rings
Hot Peppers $1.00
Extra Hot Peppers
Fresh Jalapeños $1.00
Extra Jalapeños
Scallions $1.00
Extra Scallions
Mushrooms $1.00
Extra Mushrooms
Avocado $2.50
Extra Avocado
Guacamole $2.50
Extra Guacamole
Cheeses $1.25
Extra Cheeses - American, Swiss, Pepper Jack, Brie, Mozzarella, Provolone, Cheddar, Gorgonzola or Blue Cheese

Hot Dogs
Hebrew National™️ $3.50
Hebrew National™️ all-beef kosher hot dog
Chicago Style $4.95
Chicago Style Hot Dog - with celery salt, pickle, relish, sport peppers, chopped onion, mustard & tomato on a poppy seed bun
Death Dog $5.50
Death Dog - Hot Dog with Bacon, Chili, Cheese, Onion & Sauerkraut on a Hot Dog Bun
Texas Dog $4.50
Texas Dog - with chili and onions

Desserts
Ice Cream $3.00
Your choice of Vanilla Bean or Chocolate Chip Mint
Carrot Cake $5.00
Carrot Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting and Walnuts
Reese’s Peanut Butter Pie $5.00
Reese’s Peanut Butter Pie
Brownie Sundae $5.00
A Brownie Sundae served warm, topped with ice cream, chocolate sauce & whipped cream
Chocolate Lava Cake $5.00
Chocolate Lava Cake with a warm chocolate center - topped with whipped cream

Sunday Brunch served on Sundays from 12 noon until 3:00 pm
Eggs Benedict $12.95
Eggs Benedict - two halves of an English muffin topped with poached eggs, bacon or ham, and hollandaise sauce.
8 oz. Sirloin Steak & Eggs $14.95
8 oz. Sirloin Steak & Eggs with homefries
Poached Egg Caesar Salad $8.95
Poached Egg Caesar Salad
Ham, Bacon or Sausage Egg Sandwich $4.50
Ham, Bacon or Sausage Egg Sandwich
Breakfast Burrito $7.95
Breakfast Burrito - scrambled eggs, salsa, potatoes, bacon and cheese
Egg in the Middle $6.00
A hole is carved out of your toast and a fried egg is cooked inside.
French Toast $7.95
French Toast - Battered Bread Grilled and Served with Maple Syrup
Pancakes $7.95
Pancakes - piled high with butter and maple syrup
Corned Beef Hash & Eggs $8.95
Corned Beef Hash & Eggs served with toast and homefries
Side of bacon $3.00
Extra Bacon
Side of Ham $3.00
Extra Ham
Side of Sausage $3.00
Extra Sausage
Side of Homefries $3.00
Extra Homefries
Three Egg Omelettes $7.95
Three Egg Omelettes - served with homefries and toast and three topping choices
California Omelette $9.95
California Omelette with bacon, tomato, avocado, mozzarella
Omelette Choices
Egg Whites, Bacon, Sausage, Ham, Turkey, Chili, or Hot Peppers - $1.00 Jalapeños, Peppers, Broccoli, Scallions or Mushrooms - $0.50 Avocado - $2.50 Cheeses-$1.00 American, Swiss, Pepper Jack, Brie, Mozzarella, Provolone, Cheddar, Gorgonzola.

Kelly's Sea Level Details

From the business
Identifies as veteran-owned
Identifies as women-owned

Service options
Outdoor seating
Curbside pickup
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Great dessert
Serves local specialty
Sports

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Hard liquor
Late-night food
Quick bite
Small plates
Wine

Dining options
Breakfast
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Bar onsite
Restroom
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Historic

Crowd
Family-friendly
Groups

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Kids' menu

Parking
Free street parking
Parking

Kelly's Sea Level Photos

Kelly's Sea Level Location

Kelly's Sea Level

New York Westchester County Rye Midland Avenue

413 Midland Ave, Rye, NY 10580, USA

Kelly's Sea Level Reviews

An average rating of ★4.6 from 442 user reviews.

pricespubfish and chipsdive barfood and servicepatiochilisandwichlobster rollparking

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Kelly’s consistently delivers a great meal. The lobster roll is fresh and generously portioned, especially for the price. Eating outdoors on the covered patio is a real treat—relaxed and comfortable. The staff is always friendly, and the menu has a wide variety of dishes, all priced really well. The fish and chips are solid, and the Philly cheesesteak is massive—packed with tender steak, onions, and peppers.We’ve never had trouble finding street parking, and today we even scored a spot right out front. A dependable go-to spot with great value.
August 02 · Louise F
Great local spot in Rye. Vast menu with many options at a great price point. Longford’s ice cream on the dessert menu is a nice touch. Indoor & outdoor seating available
July 25 · William Montanaro
I love a good locals known bar and grill, and this was perfect. Food came out quickly, hot and flavorful, and the beer was ice cold. Steady stream of locals in and out, if a chain restaurant could steal the vibe they would try but they can’t.
April 07 · Steven DeLaurentis
We stopped here for a bit to eat on the way home from a shipping day in NYC.We walked in and waited a few minutes while multiple employees walked by us. We asked one staff member, later it was our server, if there were any open seats, she stated "she didn't know" and kept moving. Finally, a woman sat us outside. We waited 15 minutes while the woman Kelly shot the shut with a customers kids... 15 minutes.. no drinks no menus. I finally got out menus myself. Service was a ZERO. The server takes our order, drinks apps and meals, returns with water 10 minutes after, LS short, the bland food comes, we finish and had to practically beg to pay the bill. A bus boy got our bill. I left cash and left....Worst place ever...
April 30 · Jesse Gonzalez
I ordered pickup and wish I had ordered to dine in. The atmosphere was no frills, cozy, welcoming, and clearly looks like a locals place. I ordered a CT style lobster roll and it, along with the fries were piping hot. I will certainly come back next time Im in Rye.Street parking but I lucked out with a spot right out front.
August 13 · Pickle Relish