Mario's Bakery

- 409 Merrick Rd, Oceanside, NY 11572

Mario's Bakery has long stood as a beloved local landmark for residents of Oceanside and the broader Long Island region in New York. For over 30 years, this family-owned and operated establishment has prided itself on upholding generational recipes, delivering a stunning array of scratch-baked goods that are both beautiful to look at and a delight to taste. It is more than just a bakery; it is a destination where community members go to celebrate life’s milestones, from birthdays and graduations to elegant weddings, all marked with a perfectly crafted cake or a platter of authentic Italian sweets.

When you step inside Mario's Bakery, you are immediately greeted by the sweet, comforting aroma of fresh dough, rich creams, and baking spices—a true hallmark of traditional Italian baking. The glass display cases are always brimming with a vibrant selection of cookies, elaborate pastries, and gorgeously decorated cakes, showcasing the dedication of their skilled bakers and decorators. The philosophy here is simple: provide high-quality, delicious products with exceptional, attentive service. The consistent praise from loyal customers highlights not just the quality of the food—like the "absolutely to die for" fruit tart and the beautiful, delicious custom cakes—but also the genuinely warm and family-like atmosphere created by the staff. Even during busy times, the team is known for being "super quick to get you in and out," ensuring a pleasant experience even when the line stretches long.

For New Yorkers across Nassau County and beyond, Mario's Bakery is a reliable source for high-quality baked goods, serving both retail and commercial customers. Whether you are seeking a daily loaf of fresh bread, a quick morning pastry, or planning the centerpiece dessert for a major event, Mario's offers a comprehensive and mouth-watering selection. Their longstanding presence and commitment to traditional methods have cemented their reputation as a premier bakery on Long Island, one that continues to impress both first-time buyers and decades-long patrons.

Mario's Bakery is conveniently located at 409 Merrick Rd, Oceanside, NY 11572, making it an accessible spot for many Long Island residents. Oceanside is situated in the southwestern part of Nassau County, which is easily reachable by car from various points across Long Island. The Merrick Road location ensures good visibility and ease of access.

The bakery understands the importance of convenience and offers several ways for customers to enjoy their products. For those who prefer to browse the full selection in person, in-store shopping is available. The operating hours are designed to accommodate a busy schedule, with the bakery opening early on weekends:

• Monday: Closed
• Tuesday - Thursday: 8:00 AM – 7:00 PM
• Friday: 7:00 AM – 7:00 PM
• Saturday: 7:00 AM – 7:00 PM
• Sunday: 7:00 AM – 5:00 PM

In addition to in-store visits, Mario’s Bakery provides delivery services, making it easy to have a selection of cakes, cookies, and pastries brought directly to your home or event location. Furthermore, for special occasions, customers can place orders in advance for pickup, ensuring their customized cakes and large cookie platters are ready precisely when needed.

Mario's Bakery offers a vast range of baked goods, with a strong emphasis on Italian pastries and custom cakes for special events. Their product line encompasses everything from individual treats to large-scale catering items.

Services Offered:

• Custom Wedding Cakes and Consultation
• Seasonal and Specialty All-Occasion Cakes (e.g., birthday, graduation, showers)
• Photo/Edible Image Cakes for personalized celebrations
• Full Line of Scratch-Baked Breads and Rolls (including Italian loaves, twists, and white bread)
• Specialty Cupcakes (including Cannoli, Tiramisu, Oreo, Red Velvet, Raspberry Lemonade, and Orange Creamsicle flavors)
• Custom Cookie Trays and Bridal Trays
• Retail and Commercial Supply of Baked Goods
• Shipping Available upon Request
• Order Ahead for Pickup or Local Delivery Options

The true star of Mario's Bakery is the sheer variety and quality of its traditional Italian and American desserts. Patrons return time and again for their signature items and the wide selection of mini pastries that are perfect for entertaining or a personal treat.

Features and Highlights of the Menu:

• Signature Cakes: The selection includes Cannoli Cake, Tiramisu Cake, Strawberry Shortcake, Strawberry French Cream, Heavenly Chocolate Cake (with chocolate mousse and ganache), Oreo Cake, Rainbow Cookie Cake, Carrot Cake, and Three Leches Cake.
• Authentic Italian Pastries: A staple of the bakery, the pastry case features classics such as Cannoli, Pasticciotti, Sfogliatelle, Baklava, Tiramisu, Eclairs, Macaroons, Lobster Tails, and various turnovers.
• Extensive Cookie Selection: Options available by the pound and in pre-made platters include Pignoli (also available as Gluten-Free), Hazelnut Biscotti, Rainbow Cookies, assorted Italian Cookies, Butter Cookies, Rugelach, Tollhouse, Oatmeal Raisin, and the classic Black and White Cookie.
• Pies and Cheesecakes: Customers can find a variety of fruit and cream pies (Apple, Cherry, Blueberry, Lemon Meringue, Pecan, Coconut Custard) as well as Plain, Chocolate, Fruit, and Italian Cheesecakes.
• Specialty Items: The bakery also offers savory options like Breakfast Pizza and Tomato Pie, along with other unique treats such as Walnut Rings, Cake Pops, and the highly-praised Fruit Tarts.
• Dietary Options: They provide a limited selection of Sugar-Free items (Pound Cake, Mini Apple Pie, Sfogliatella, Apple Turn Over, and cookies) and select Gluten-Free items (Pignoli Cookies, Creme Brulee, Flan, and Almond Horns).

The consistent quality and fresh ingredients speak volumes about Mario's dedication to its craft. Customers frequently commend the bakery for producing cakes that are not only beautiful showpieces but are also "beyond delicious" and perfectly moist, a crucial factor for wedding and celebration cakes. The use of traditional Italian creams and high-quality chocolate and fresh fruit ensures that every product delivers on flavor.

Contact Information

To place an order, inquire about custom cakes, or simply check on the day's fresh selections, you can reach Mario's Bakery using the information below:

Address: 409 Merrick Rd, Oceanside, NY 11572, USA

Phone: (516) 766-0891

Mobile Phone: +1 516-766-0891

For Long Island residents searching for a reliable, high-quality bakery, Mario’s Bakery is an establishment that truly warrants a visit. What makes Mario's worth choosing? It is the successful blending of tradition, variety, and superior customer service.

What is Worth Choosing at Mario's Bakery:

The cornerstone of Mario's appeal is their specialty in celebratory cakes. When a customer receives a cake that is both a visual masterpiece and a culinary delight—as one reviewer attested, "The cake was beautiful and also delicious"—it solidifies their reputation as the premier choice for special occasions in the area. The ability to create complex, multi-tiered cakes with unique flavor combinations, such as the described strawberry shortcake top layer and a mix of chocolate and vanilla with cannoli filling for the tiers below, highlights their creative capability and baking expertise.

Furthermore, the commitment to authentic Italian pastries offers a genuine taste of tradition, with items like the delicate Lobster Tails, the multi-layered Sfogliatella, and their popular mini cannolis providing a perfect end to any meal or a delightful addition to any party platter. The family-friendly atmosphere, where even children "absolutely love the cookies," and the staff’s attentiveness that makes patrons "feel like family," ensures that a trip to Mario's is a consistently pleasant and rewarding experience. For those in the New York area seeking fresh bread, classic Italian treats, or an unforgettable custom cake, Mario's Bakery is the local favorite that promises quality with every delicious bite.

Mario's Bakery

409 Merrick Rd, Oceanside, NY 11572, USA