La Bella Pizzeria

- 342 Lexington Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771

La Bella Pizzeria, located in the charming and historic community of Oyster Bay, NY, stands as a pillar of authentic Italian and classic New York-style pizza culture on Long Island. More than just a simple pizza shop, La Bella has built a reputation among local New York users as a full-service Italian restaurant that seamlessly blends the quick, satisfying nature of a classic pizzeria with an extensive menu of high-quality, traditional entrées, baked dishes, and specialty items.

For decades, New Yorkers have known that the mark of a truly great neighborhood spot lies in the consistency and depth of its offerings, and La Bella Pizzeria delivers on both fronts. The menu goes far beyond the standard slice, featuring everything from hearty, baked pasta dishes like Cheese Ravioli and Homemade Lasagna to an impressive array of hero sandwiches, fresh salads, and full-scale Italian entrées such as Chicken Marsala and Veal Parmigiana. This breadth of choice makes it an ideal destination for any occasion, whether it’s a quick lunch slice, a comfortable family dinner, or catering for a large event.

Customer feedback consistently highlights the quality of the food and the warmth of the service. Real New York customers note the excellence of the pizza—mentioning options like the much-loved Grandma Pie—the generous portions, and the kind, top-notch staff. It's an establishment where the food is always "on point" and the dining area is described as "comfortable and extremely clean," creating a welcoming and reliable dining experience that truly reflects the spirit of Long Island’s best Italian eateries.

La Bella Pizzeria enjoys a prime, easily accessible location at 342 Lexington Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771. Oyster Bay is a well-regarded North Shore community in Nassau County, making this pizzeria a convenient stop for local residents as well as those traveling through the area.

The restaurant’s location on Lexington Avenue, near other community landmarks and thoroughfares, ensures high visibility and ease of navigation. For local patrons in the Oyster Bay community, the address is central and recognizable, making pickup and dine-in visits straightforward. For customers driving from nearby Long Island towns, the accessibility of the area contributes to the overall convenience of choosing La Bella for their Italian food needs. While specific parking information isn't provided, the neighborhood context of Oyster Bay generally allows for a manageable experience for visiting patrons.

The neighborhood setting, distinct from the dense, bustling energy of Manhattan, provides a relaxed, comfortable backdrop for enjoying authentic Italian food, reinforcing the restaurant's reputation as a reliable, local favorite.

To serve the diverse needs of the New York clientele, La Bella Pizzeria offers multiple ways to enjoy its extensive menu, from a quick meal to a fully planned event.

• Dine-in: The restaurant offers a comfortable and clean dining area, allowing customers to enjoy their meals in a relaxed setting, perfect for an intimate dinner or a family gathering.
• Takeout: Ideal for local residents and those on the go, the takeout service ensures quick and efficient preparation of all menu items, from a single slice to large pizza and entrée orders.
• Catering: La Bella Pizzeria provides comprehensive catering services, making it a dependable option for corporate events, parties, and family celebrations across Long Island. The catering menu includes full trays of Baked Stuffed Shells, Penne Alla Vodka, Eggplant Parmigiana, and a variety of salads and appetizers.
• Full Beverage Service: The restaurant enhances the dine-in and takeout experience by offering a selection of beverages, including hot and cold options. Notably, they offer Alcohol, Coffee, and Wine, adding to the full-service dining appeal.

La Bella Pizzeria’s menu is a treasure trove of authentic Italian staples and innovative specialty items, ensuring there is a delicious option for every palate and dietary need. The quality and variety of the menu are the primary highlights that draw customers back repeatedly.

• NY-Style and Specialty Pizza Excellence: The foundation of the business is its pizza, which includes the classic Lg. Neapolitan Round (18"), the thicker Sicilian Square (12 Slices), and the highly praised Grandma Pizza, a must-try thin-crust Sicilian favorite. Unique specialty pizzas like Rigatoni Alla Vodka Pizza, Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza, and the 'Upside Down Sicilian' showcase a creative menu that goes beyond the basics.
• Gluten-Free Options Available: Demonstrating an awareness of modern dietary needs, La Bella offers both a Gluten-Free Personal 12" Pizza and a Cauliflower Gluten-Free Personal 10" Pizza, ensuring that individuals with dietary restrictions can still enjoy a satisfying pizza experience.
• Extensive Italian Entrée Selection: Beyond pizza, the menu features a remarkable range of traditional, full-sized Italian dinners. These include all the classic protein preparations like Chicken Parmigiana, Veal Marsala, and Shrimp Scampi, all served with a choice of pasta and salad.
• Authentic Baked Pasta Dishes: For those craving hearty, home-style Italian food, the menu excels with classics such as Baked Ziti With Ricotta, Baked Stuffed Shells, and Homemade Lasagna, available for both individual dinners and catering trays.
• Variety of Appetizers, Heroes, and Rolls: Quick bites and handheld options are plentiful, featuring fan-favorites like Garlic Knots, Cheese Calzone, Chicken Parmigiana Rolls, and a full lineup of Hero Sandwiches, including Cold Italian and Veal Parmigiana.
• Full Catering Capability: The extensive catering menu, featuring appetizers, baked dishes, and entrées, positions La Bella as a one-stop-shop for event planning in the Oyster Bay area.

For placing an order, booking catering, or making an inquiry, the details for La Bella Pizzeria are provided below, connecting you directly to this esteemed Long Island establishment.

Contact Information

Address: 342 Lexington Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771, United States

Phone: (516) 226-1440 (Also accessible via mobile at +1 516-226-1440)

For New York users, particularly those on Long Island, La Bella Pizzeria is worth choosing because it represents the highest standard of a traditional, comprehensive Italian-American restaurant. The most compelling reason is the unparalleled balance of quality, variety, and reliability.

First, the pizza is widely regarded as some of the best in Oyster Bay, with patrons specifically praising the crust and unique offerings like the Grandma Pie. The ability to order by the slice—both Neapolitan and Sicilian—is a true New York staple that La Bella honors perfectly.

Second, the vast menu ensures that La Bella Pizzeria is a solution for more than just pizza night. Whether you need a comforting dinner of Shrimp Marinara, a quick and fresh Chicken Panini for lunch, or a full catering spread for a party, the restaurant consistently delivers home-style, fresh Italian cuisine. The availability of high-demand dishes like Penne Alla Vodka, specialty heroes, and a full bar menu means it can satisfy nearly any craving.

Finally, the excellent service and welcoming atmosphere—as noted by customers who call the staff "super nice" and the service "top notch"—make the dining experience, whether dine-in or takeout, consistently pleasant and hassle-free. La Bella Pizzeria is the quintessential Long Island local spot where authentic Italian tradition meets modern convenience and exceptional customer care.

La Bella Pizzeria

342 Lexington Ave, Oyster Bay, NY 11771, USA