Locust Valley Deli: Home of Long Island's Best Breakfast Sandwiches and Signature Heroes

Locust Valley Deli Introduce

For anyone living in or passing through the prestigious North Shore of Long Island, particularly in the Locust Valley area, the local deli is more than just a place to grab a quick bite—it's a daily ritual. Locust Valley Deli is a quintessential small business that has perfected the art of the New York-style delicatessen, blending classic comfort food with an impressive variety of gourmet options. It has earned a reputation as a cornerstone of the community, serving up delicious, hearty meals from the early morning rush straight through the lunch hour.

This deli stands out for its commitment to extensive menu diversity, ensuring every patron, from the busy commuter to the student on a quick break, finds exactly what they're looking for. The heart of their menu lies in the robust selection of breakfast items, with a single customer review noting they serve "The best breakfast sandwiches!!!"—a high compliment in the discerning New York food scene. Beyond breakfast, the deli transitions into a sandwich connoisseur's dream, featuring both classic 'Build Your Own' options and a long list of creative, signature sandwiches named after local landmarks and institutions.

Locust Valley Deli emphasizes accessibility and convenience, traits that are highly valued by busy local users. With multiple quick service options like Delivery, In-store Pickup, and Takeout, customers can integrate a high-quality meal into their fast-paced schedules with ease. The business also provides essential modern conveniences, including multiple payment methods and free parking, making any visit, quick or not, completely stress-free.

While the service has faced some isolated critiques concerning rigidness on order changes, the overwhelming focus remains on the quality of the food and the sheer variety offered. As a small business, Locust Valley Deli is a proud part of the neighborhood fabric, providing a friendly, non-judgmental atmosphere, being notably LGBTQ+ friendly, and ensuring all are welcome with full Wheelchair accessibility across its entrance, parking, and seating areas. This commitment to inclusivity and convenience, paired with its lauded menu, ensures its continuous appeal as the area’s premier local deli destination.

***

Location and Accessibility

Locust Valley Deli is conveniently located right on one of the main thoroughfares of its namesake town, making it a highly accessible spot for commuters, local workers, and residents in Locust Valley and surrounding North Shore communities.

The exact address is:

The establishment goes above and beyond to ensure a comfortable and convenient experience for all customers, with a strong focus on accessibility and parking. It is positioned perfectly for a "Quick visit" and provides ample options for vehicular transport, which is a major advantage on Long Island.

Accessibility Details:

Wheelchair Accessible Entrance
Wheelchair Accessible Parking Lot
Wheelchair Accessible Seating

Parking is never a concern with the availability of both a Free parking lot and Free street parking nearby.

***

Services Offered

Full Breakfast Service: A comprehensive menu including omelettes, pancakes, French toast, specialty wraps (e.g., The Hungry Man, Healthy Way Wrap), bagels, and the locally famous Bacon Egg & Cheese sandwich.
Grill and Hot Meals: Features classic grill items like Quesadillas, Reuben sandwiches, Philly CheeseSteak, and Hamburgers.
Extensive Sandwich Menu: Offers a full 'Build Your Own Sandwich' option, alongside a massive list of unique Special Sandwiches and Paninis with creative, local names.
Beverage Selection: Wide array of hot drinks (Hot Coffee, Hot Tea, Hot Choc) and cold beverages (Iced Coffee, Canned and Bottled Sodas, Snapple, Arizona Teas, Poland Spring).
Convenient Service Options: Provides Delivery, In-store Pickup, and Takeout for quick transactions.
Modern Payment Methods: Accepts Credit cards, Debit cards, and modern NFC mobile payments.

***

Features / Highlights

Legendary Breakfast Sandwiches: Customers rave about the quality, with one review proclaiming they have "The best breakfast sandwiches!!!" This includes popular options like the Bacon Egg & Cheese, The Mag, and The Hungry Man hero.
Hyper-Local Specialty Sandwich Menu: A unique and engaging feature is the list of dozens of specialty heroes and paninis named after local Long Island institutions and landmarks (e.g., The Gold Coast, The Valley, The Piping Rock, The LVFD, Friends Academy, The North Shore, The LIRR). This list includes over twenty-five different options, providing incredible variety and local flavor.
Versatile Menu:** The deli offers all three core components of an excellent food service: a full breakfast selection, made-to-order deli sandwiches, and hot grill items, catering to all meal needs from dawn till the afternoon.
High Convenience and Accessibility: Offers excellent amenities including full wheelchair accessibility, complimentary Wi-Fi, and generous Free parking, making it an easy stop for everyone.
Welcoming Atmosphere: The business explicitly supports an LGBTQ+ friendly environment, ensuring a welcoming space for all members of the community.
Focus on Quick Service: Designed for the busy New Yorker, the service options and streamlined operation are ideal for a "Quick visit."

***

Contact Information

Address: 190 Forest Ave, Locust Valley, NY 11560, USA

Phone: (516) 759-2464

***

What is Worth Choosing

Locust Valley Deli is worth choosing for several key reasons that align perfectly with the needs of a local New York clientele. It excels in the areas that matter most: convenience, variety, and the quality of staple food items.

Unmatched Specialty Sandwich Selection: The deli’s greatest strength is its extensive, locally inspired "Special Sandwiches" menu. With over two dozen creatively named options like "The Portledge," "The Falcon," and "The Fifth Street Melt," customers can spend weeks exploring a new combination of high-quality meats, cheeses, and toppings. This selection is a local attraction in itself, catering to the sophisticated tastes of the North Shore and providing exciting, massive heroes perfect for a memorable lunch.

A Guaranteed Great Start to the Day: The repeated praise for the deli's breakfast sandwiches is a clear indicator of a reliable morning stop. For the quintessential Long Island morning, grabbing a hot, perfectly prepared Bacon Egg & Cheese or one of the hearty breakfast heroes like The Hungry Man ensures a fantastic start to any busy day. The availability of fresh items like Crepes, Pancakes, and a Healthy Way Wrap also caters to a range of different dietary preferences and routines.

Convenience and Modernity: For the modern user, the combination of excellent parking (both street and lot), multiple digital payment options (Credit cards, Debit cards, NFC mobile), and fast service options (Delivery and In-store Pickup) eliminates common frustrations. In a busy area like Locust Valley, a deli that respects your time and offers smooth transactions becomes an invaluable resource.

By focusing on fresh ingredients, generous portions, and a menu that appeals to both the craving for a classic deli hero and the need for a quick, quality breakfast, Locust Valley Deli truly lives up to its reputation as a trusted small business and a consistent go-to for great food in the heart of Nassau County.

Locust Valley Deli Services

Deli
Build Your Own Sandwich $8.50
Pick your meat, cheese, bread and addons

Drinks
Iced Coffee $4.45
House brewed iced coffee.
Coke 20oz Bottle $4.95
CocaCola 20oz plastic bottle
SunKist Orange Soda 20oz $3.95
Sunkist Orange Soda 20oz Bottle
Coke Zero 20oz $3.95
CocaCola Zero Calorie 20oz bottle
Sprite 20oz Bottle $3.95
The cold, refreshing flavors of lemon and lime, perfectly blended.
Dr Pepper $3.95
Dr Pepper 20oz bottle
Pepsi Cola 20oz Bottle $3.95
The bold, refreshing, robust cola
Snapple Lemon Tea 16oz $3.95
Snapple Lemon Iced Tea 16oz bottle
Arizona COLD BREW Sweet Tea $3.95
COLD BREW Sweet Iced Tea 20oz Bottle
Diet Coke 20oz Bottle $3.95
Diet CocaCola 20oz plastic bottle
Poland Spring 16 Oz $1.80
16 oz bottle Poland Spring
Sprite Zero 20oz $3.95
The same iconic great taste with zero sugar.
Diet Coke Can $2.50
12oz can Diet Coke
Diet Pepsi 20oz Bottle $3.95
A crisp tasting, refreshing pop of sweet, fizzy bubbles without calories.
Arizona COLD BREW Unsweet Tea $3.95
COLD BREW Unsweetened Iced Tea 20 Oz bottle
A&W RootBeer 20oz $3.95
A&W Root Beeer 20oz bottle
Iced Tea $4.75
House brewed iced tea, Regular, Decaf, Green Tea, Sweet or Unsweet, with lemon
Coke Can 12oz $2.50
12oz Can CocaCola

Grill
Hamburger $13.95
Grilled prime chopped beef on a Kaiser or sesame roll
Quesadilla $12.95
Flour tortilla with cheese. Add Veggies or protein for an additional charge
Grilled Cheese $7.50
Melted american cheese on grilled white bread
Philly CheeseSteak $16.95
Sauteéd thin cut steak, grilled peppers & onions, with melted American Cheese on a hero
Reuben $14.95
Corn Beef & Melted Swiss with Sauerkraut on toasted Rye

Panini
#6 $15.95
Mushroom, Bacon, Tomato & Swiss
#1 $15.95
Breaded chicken cutlet, Bacon & Muenster
#2 $15.95
Black Forest Ham & Swiss
#8 $15.95
Cracked Pepper Turkey & Provolone with Honey Mustard
#9 Cuban $15.95
Roast Pork, Smoked Ham, Swiss Cheese, Sliced Pickle, Mayo, Mustard & Hot Sauce
#10 Italiano $15.95
Ham Cappy, Genoa Salami, Mortadella, Provolone, Sundried Tomatoes, Spinach & Red Onion
#3 $15.95
Roast Beef, Sauteéd Onion & Cheddar
#7 $15.95
Prosciutto, Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Peppers & Pesto
#4 $15.95
Fried Eggplant, Roasted Peppers & Feta
#5 $15.95
Grilled Chicken with Articholes, Tomatoes & Fresh Mozzarella

Breakfast
Crepes $13.59
Grilled crepes with Banana, Strawberry, Nutella and Maple Syrup; Additional Blueberry topping optional for an added cost
Hot Choc $4.20
Iced Coffee $4.45
Fresh brewed Colombian coffee, iced down and served cold
Bagel $3.75
Bagel, Choose Plain, Cinn-raisin, Poppy, Sesame...
Locust 1 $7.99
One egg on a roll with bacon, ham or sausage.
Omelette $12.59
Three egg omelet with two mix-ins and toast.
The Hungry Man $13.49
Three eggs, choice of two meats and cheese on a hero.
McValley Sandwich $7.49
One egg and cheese with ham on a toasted English muffin.
Bacon/ Ham/ Sausage $2.95
Side order of bacon, ham or sausage (please specify).
Hash Browns $3.40
Golden Brown Hash Brown potatoes
Hot Coffee $4.20
Fresh brewed hot coffee.
Pancakes $9.95
Three pancakes with maple syrup.
Bacon On Roll $7.59
Crispy bacon on a kaiser roll.
Muffin $4.75
Choose Blueberry, Raisin-bran, Carrot, Choc chip, Double choc chip, Cranberry.
Healthy Way Wrap $12.59
Three egg whites with grilled turkey and alpine Swiss cheese on a wrap.
French Toast $9.95
Three slices of grilled French toast with maple syrup.
Locust 2 $7.59
Two eggs on a roll with bacon, ham or sausage.
The Mag $7.59
2 scrambled eggs and homefries on a roll.
Buttered Roll (Or Jelly) $3.50
Kaiser roll with butter or jelly.
Bacon Egg & Cheese $7.99
Two Eggs with Bacon and American Cheese
Hot Tea $4.45
Hot tea (Lipton regular, green, celestial lemon, Bigelow chamomile and earl grey tea).

Special Sandwiches
The Gold Coast $15.95
Chicken cutlet, lettuce, tomato and creamy bleu cheese dressing on a hero.
Falcon Pride $15.50
Cracked pepper turkey, melted alpine lace, lettuce, tomato, onion and ranch on a hero.
The Valley $15.95
Turkey, bacon, melted Swiss, lettuce, tomato and Russian dressing on a hero.
The Fifth Street Melt $15.50
Lean roast beef and melted mozzarella on a toasted garlic hero.
The Piping Rock $15.50
Marinated grilled chicken, Swiss cheese, plum tomatoes, romaine and raspberry vinaigrette on French bread.
The Birch Hill $15.50
Lean roast beef, melted American cheese, bacon, lettuce and tomato on a hero.
The JV $14.95
Boar's Head chicken breast served hot with pepperoni and melted mozzarella on a roll.
The Falcon $15.50
Lean roast beef, Muenster cheese and Russian dressing, topped with coleslaw on a hero.
The Locust $15.95
Cracked pepper turkey, Swiss cheese, sun-dried tomatoes and Dijon mustard on French bread.
The LIRR $15.50
Boar's Head oven gold turkey, pepper Jack cheese, roasted red peppers and ranch dressing on a hero.
The Coach $15.50
Genoa salami, pepperoni, ham cappy, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion and Italian dressing on hero.
The Harborside` $15.80
Prosciutto, mortadella, Soppressata, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers and olive oil on a hero.
The Oak Neck $15.50
Boar's Head ham, turkey, melted Swiss, lettuce, tomato and Russian dressing on a toasted hero.
The Portledge $15.95
Fresh Mozzarella, plum tomatoes, roasted red peppers, basil and balsamic vinaigrette on French.
The Lattingtown $15.50
Boar's Head Buffalo chicken breast, pepper Jack cheese, lettuce and bleu cheese dressing on a toasted hero.
The Varsity $15.50
BBQ's chicken or roast beef, melted cheddar, bacon and BBQ sauce on a toasted hero.
The Creek Club $15.50
Roast beef, ham, hard salami, turkey, American, and Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato and onion on a hero.
The North Shore $15.50
Chicken cutlet, bacon, melted American, lettuce, Tomato and Russian dressing on a hero.
The Nassau CC $15.50
Turkey, pastrami, corned beef, melted Swiss, lettuce, tomato and coleslaw on a hero.
The LVFD $14.95
Honey Maple Turkey, Mozzarella, Lettuce, Tomato and honey mustard on a hero.
Friends Academy $14.50
Black forest ham, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, and spicy brown mustard on a hero.
The Brookville $14.95
Chicken salad, American cheese, bacon, lettuce and tomato on a bagel of your choice.
The Forest Ave $15.50
Chicken cutlet, Virginia Ham, melted Swiss and honey mustard on a toasted hero.
The Grenville $14.60
American cheese tuna melt on toasted rye.
LV Rotarian $15.95
Ham, provolone, lettuce, tomato, onions, hot peppers, oil and vinegar on a hero.

Locust Valley Deli Details

From the business
Small business

Service options
Delivery
In-store pickup
Takeout

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Wheelchair accessible seating

Amenities
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Crowd
LGBTQ+ friendly

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking

Locust Valley Deli Photos

Locust Valley Deli Location

Locust Valley Deli

New York Nassau County Locust Valley Forest Avenue

190 Forest Ave, Locust Valley, NY 11560, USA

Locust Valley Deli Reviews

An average rating of ★4.3 from 92 user reviews.

sandwichcoffeebacon

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Didn't like the experience.. I placed an order at the wrong location, and the person who i was speaking to over the phone gave me an attitude, "what am i suppose to do with the sandwhich, I'm going to get in trouble with my boss." that's sounds like a personal problem, to me but I'm kind enough to still pick it up even though it's my fault but there shouldn't be any restrictions when it comes to canceling the orders over the phone and getting in trouble, that's diabolical behavior. I shouldn't have called and left the sandwhich there. The "Boss" should just let the employees either eat it or throw it away. That simple. Losing money? You should be just fine. Will never eat here w| that type of service, and didn't know the place exist.
May 01 · Michael Lavayen
The best breakfast sandwiches!!!
June 22 · Brooke Wheeler
Ask for hash brown on my sandwiche. Pay for hash brown. And then they don't include it on my sandwich.
September 01 · George Wallace
Heavy handed with any sandwich calling for bacon. That's 5 star behaviour right there, in a good way. Service is 5 star, and so is there coffee. Parking available around back.
May 22 · Martha Nelson
I know this place in and out. Beware kitchen is a caos, and the storage room is the worst place.mold and fungus on the floors, they put all their deliveries over milk crastes to keep them away from the dirty water that always flood the basement storage.
October 07 · Carlos Fuentes