Maine Artisan Cafe: Authentic New England Lobster Rolls and Gourmet Sandwiches in Edgewater, NJ

Maine Artisan Cafe Introduce

For New Jersey residents craving the authentic, fresh flavors of the New England coastline without the long drive north,

Maine Artisan Cafe

in Edgewater offers a truly exceptional local dining experience. This unique establishment functions as both a dedicated sandwich shop and a specialized seafood restaurant, focusing heavily on bringing the simplicity and quality of Maine's coastal cuisine right to the Bergen County area. It's quickly become a must-visit spot for those who appreciate high-quality ingredients and straightforward, expertly prepared food.

Located strategically along the New Jersey side of the Hudson River, Maine Artisan Cafe stands out from typical local delis. While the menu includes delicious, carefully crafted deli sandwiches, the true heart of the cafe lies in its New England specialties, particularly its celebrated lobster rolls. Local users who may have been skeptical about finding a "real Maine/New England style lobster roll" in New Jersey are consistently "blown away," comparing the offerings favorably to those found in iconic Maine coastal towns like Kennebunkport and Portland. The cafe’s commitment to sourcing fresh Maine lobster and preparing it simply—with perfect balance and lightly toasted, buttered artisan rolls—is what sets it apart.

Beyond the signature seafood, Maine Artisan Cafe is a fantastic choice for an elevated lunch or a casual dinner. Their menu features a selection of gourmet sandwiches built with premium ingredients, alongside rich, comforting soups like their "perfectly creamy" clam chowder. The atmosphere is described as a 'cute shop' with friendly customer service, offering a counter service model that ensures quick yet welcoming interactions. This combination of top-tier food, professional service, and a desirable waterfront location makes Maine Artisan Cafe an essential stop for a memorable meal in Edgewater, NJ.

The setting, modeled after a typical eatery found along the North Atlantic coastline, provides a cozy yet rustic feel. For those in New Jersey who love comfort food and fresh ingredients, the cafe manages to deliver an upscale taste experience in a friendly, casual environment. It’s a perfect spot for solo dining, a friendly lunch, or grabbing a meal for the family.

Location and Accessibility

Maine Artisan Cafe is conveniently situated at

254 Old River Rd, Edgewater, NJ 07020, USA

. This address positions it in a picturesque area of Edgewater, often providing visitors with a charming backdrop. Being located near the waterfront promenade means that New Jersey patrons can often enjoy striking views of the Manhattan skyline while strolling nearby, making the trip a worthwhile experience.

Accessibility is a key factor for any local business, and the cafe ensures it is welcoming to all members of the community by providing a

Wheelchair accessible entrance

. The Edgewater location is easily reachable for residents throughout Bergen County and other nearby communities via major local roads. While parking in the area can sometimes be competitive, the scenic location and the quality of the food make it a destination worth seeking out. Its presence on Old River Road is ideal for those living or working in the immediate Edgewater-Fort Lee corridor, establishing it as a highly accessible lunch and dinner option in Northern New Jersey.

Services Offered

Maine Artisan Cafe offers a full suite of modern service options to make dining as convenient as possible for New Jersey customers, whether they are stopping in or ordering from home.

Curbside pickup: Provides a swift and contact-free method for collecting pre-ordered meals.
No-contact delivery: Ensures a safe and convenient option for food to be dropped off at the customer’s specified location.
Delivery: Regular delivery services are available, bringing fresh sandwiches and seafood directly to local homes and businesses.
Takeout: Fast and efficient service for customers who want to grab their order and be on their way.
Dine-in: Customers can enjoy the casual seating and comfortable ambiance of the shop during meal times.
Catering: Offering their unique menu items for larger events, office luncheons, or family gatherings in the New Jersey area.
Counter service: Facilitates a quick and friendly ordering process for both dine-in and takeout patrons.
Payments: Accepting a variety of convenient payment methods, including Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Features / Highlights

Maine Artisan Cafe differentiates itself through several unique highlights that draw customers from across the New Jersey region:

Authentic Maine Lobster Rolls: The biggest draw, offering an experience that is consistently reviewed as being "just as good if not better" than those found in Maine, featuring fresh lobster on a perfectly toasted, buttered roll.
Dual Cuisine Focus: Functioning effectively as both a top-tier
Sandwich shop
and a specialized
Seafood restaurant
, catering to diverse cravings from gourmet deli items to coastal classics.
Premium Gourmet Sandwiches: Beyond seafood, the deli offerings, such as the
Prosciutto & Mozzarella
,
Roast Beef & Brie
, and
Turkey, Avocado & Bacon
sandwiches, are noted for their quality ingredients and delicious flavor combinations.
Exceptional Soups: Featuring comforting and rich classics like the
Lobster Bisque
and the highly praised, perfectly creamy
Clam Chowder
with generous chunks of potato and clam.
Fresh Salad Bar Options: Offering a variety of fresh greens and toppings, including popular options like the
Greek Salad
and
Strawberry Spinach Salad
, for lighter or vegetarian meals.
Diverse Offerings: The menu includes comforting items, a dedicated
Salad bar
, and even specialized coffee options, ensuring choices for every meal need.
Family-Friendly: Rated as
Good for kids
, making it an excellent, reliable option for family outings in the Edgewater area.

Contact Information

For New Jersey locals planning a visit or needing to place an order, here is the contact information for Maine Artisan Cafe:

Address: 254 Old River Rd, Edgewater, NJ 07020, USA

Phone: (201) 496-6984

What Is Worth Choosing

For anyone in New Jersey, especially those in Bergen County and surrounding areas, Maine Artisan Cafe offers a uniquely valuable dining proposition. What is truly worth choosing here is the promise of authentic, high-quality, and flavorful food that transports you straight to the New England shore.

The absolute top-choice item is the

Maine Lobster Roll

. Customers consistently affirm that this roll is authentic, delicious, and a superior version of the New England classic found right here in the Garden State. It allows patrons to "save money on the travel" while enjoying a product that is perfectly balanced and expertly prepared. For a heartier seafood indulgence, the

Lobster BLT

and the desire to try the

crab sandwich

(as mentioned by reviewers) are also highly recommended explorations into their specialty seafood menu.

However, Maine Artisan Cafe is not just a seafood haven. It’s an excellent choice for an elevated deli experience. The

Roast Beef & Brie

and the

Turkey, Avocado & Bacon

sandwiches stand out as exceptional gourmet deli options. Pairing any sandwich with a cup of the rich

Clam Chowder

provides a satisfying and comforting meal, perfect for any season. The availability of fresh salads, a

Salad bar

, and

Vegetarian options

also ensures that those seeking lighter fare will find delicious choices.

Ultimately, The Maine Artisan Cafe is worth choosing because it delivers a specialized, authentic product in a convenient, local setting. The professional and friendly customer service, coupled with a menu that blends irresistible seafood classics with high-quality sandwiches, ensures that every visit is a rewarding one. For Edgewater locals and visitors, this spot is a true New Jersey gem for both a quick bite and a memorable meal.

Maine Artisan Cafe Food & drink

Lunch
Maine Lobster Roll $18.95
Fresh Maine Lobster meat, on a lightly buttered toasted split top roll with a touch of mayo, melted butter, and spritz of lemon
Lobster BLT $19.95
Fresh Maine Lobster meat on a lightly toasted Brioche roll, Apple smoked bacon, vine ripened tomato, crisp lettuce, touch of mayo
Prosciutto & Mozzarella $10.95
Prosciutto, fresh mozz, (dressed Arugula & cherry tomato optional)
Roast Beef & Brie $10.95
roast beef, herb aioli mayo, vine ripened tomato, Brie Cheese on Brioche
Turkey, Avocado & Bacon $10.95
Oven Roasted Boarshead Turkey, fresh avocado, bacon, tomato, mayo on wheat
Greek Salad $9.95
Mixed Greens, fresh peppers, cucumber, Feta cheese, Kalamata olives, red onions, homemade Greek dressing. Add Lobster 10
Strawberry Spinach Salad $9.95
Baby spinach, strawberries, goat cheese, homemade sweet poppy/sesame seed dressing. Add Lobster 10
Garden Salad $5.00
Mixed Greens, tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, carrots, house vinaigrette. Add Lobster 10 Add Chicken 5.00
Lobster Bisque $6.00
minced sweet lobster meat simmered in rich cream broth, and hint of sherry
Clam Chowder $5.00
New England Style, thick and rich, made with sweet cream and flavorful clam broth, loaded with tender clams and potatoes

DRINKS
Coke $1.25
Diet Coke $1.25
Snapple $2.50
Poland Spring Water $1.25

Maine Artisan Cafe Details

Service options
Curbside pickup
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance

Offerings
Coffee
Comfort food
Salad bar

Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Counter service
Dessert
Seating

Amenities
Restroom

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids

Maine Artisan Cafe Photos

Maine Artisan Cafe Location

Maine Artisan Cafe

New Jersey Bergen County Edgewater Old River Road

254 Old River Rd, Edgewater, NJ 07020, USA

Maine Artisan Cafe Reviews

An average rating of ★4.6 from 27 user reviews.

lobster rolllobster bisquecrabclam chowdertoasted

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Cute shop with friendly customer service and yummy food! I am spoiled by huge lobster rolls down the shore but definitely one of the best lobster rolls you'll find around this area! The roast beef sandwich was also great. Not usually a huge fan of roast beef but couldn't not get this sandwich. Their clam chowder soup is perfectly creamy with chunks of potato and clam. I can't wait to go back to try their crab sandwich!
January 21 · Hannah
My friend suggested this place for lunch.I was a bit skeptical about it being a real Maine/New England style lobster roll.I Was Blown Away.This is just as good if not better what you can get in the likes of Kennebunkport, Portland, and Bangor ME. Plus you save money on the travel.I had the 1/2 crab and 1/2 lobster. The mayonnaise and meat were balanced perfectly. The roll was lightly toasted and buttered.I look forward to trying the key lime pie.
August 03 · Nicole Bacarro
I have a feeling all reviews are paid. First of all, its not “overstuffed” as other claimed. The taste is ok, nothing extraordinary. The most delicious part (surprisingly) was a bun. But I can buy buns from Balthazar bakery directly if I want one. No side dish as in Lobster Shack. When you hungry you’ll it it for sure but if not … not the first choice for sure.
August 07 · Alma Mater
Cute little placeOwners super friendly food a true original lobster rollSoups were also pretty goodOverall great place to enjoy an awesome lobster roll
February 28 · Marcello Chi
Had been wanting to try for sometime and finally did it.We had a lobster roll and a salad topped with lobster.Both were very good and tasty. The quality and freshness was very good and I’m quite a stickler.Would have liked some unsweetened tea options but otherwise good.Service friendlyWould go back when feeling the urge for some New England style food.
June 12 · John Vlachos