Mamma Maria

- 40 Washington St, West Orange, NJ 07052

For residents of West Orange and the surrounding Essex County area, Mamma Maria stands out as a quintessential New Jersey pizza restaurant and Italian eatery. More than just a place to grab a slice, this establishment offers a truly expansive menu that covers everything from early morning breakfast to late-night comfort food, making it a reliable and versatile dining spot for the community. The overall atmosphere is casual, cozy, and quiet, providing a comfortable place to relax and enjoy a hearty meal. This welcoming environment, combined with a vast array of affordable and satisfying options, positions Mamma Maria as a beloved local haunt for families, groups, and solo diners alike.

Mamma Maria is known for mastering the classics, specializing in traditional Italian-American fare. Customers can build their own pizza, with options for Medium Pi at $16.00 and Large Pi at $19.99, or take advantage of exceptional deals like the $30.99 Special for two Large Pies and a two-liter soda. But the menu extends far beyond pizza, featuring a long list of comforting pastas—including favorites like Penne Vodka and Chicken Parm With Spaghetti, Ziti Or Lingini (all $19.99 or more)—along with a wide variety of hot and cold subs, wraps, and starters. For those seeking lighter options, a comprehensive list of Salads is also available, such as the Chicken Caesar Salad for $13.99.

Perhaps the most unique and talked-about section of the menu is the Crazy Sandwiches. These monster subs, priced at $14.99 each, include creatively-named options like Big Dog, Fat Bear, Devils Home, and King Kong. The King Kong, for example, famously packs in chicken tenders, cheesesteak, mozzarella sticks, French fries, and honey mustard, offering a truly indulgent, over-the-top comfort food experience that perfectly captures the spirit of New Jersey’s love for massive subs. The availability of food that ranges from simple comfort to these legendary, stuffed sandwiches, ensures there is something for every craving and appetite at any time of day.

While the majority of feedback points to the food being delicious—with one customer specifically raving about the awesome flavor of the eggplant/Italian sausage combination—it’s important to acknowledge varied customer service experiences. One review noted issues with change calculation, excessive noise from a TV, and general dissatisfaction that led to the customer vowing never to return. This suggests that while the quality and scope of the food are generally highly praised, patrons should expect a very casual, unpolished atmosphere and should remain attentive to transactional details. However, many positive reviews highlight friendly service and the owner’s personal touch, suggesting the overall experience is warm and community-focused.

Mamma Maria is ideally situated in a high-traffic, accessible location in West Orange, New Jersey, providing easy access for the local community and those passing through the 07052 area.

The specific address for the restaurant is:

40 Washington St, West Orange, NJ 07052, USA

Being on Washington Street places it near other local businesses and residential areas. A significant benefit for customers traveling by car is the availability of free street parking, a highly convenient amenity in this part of Essex County. Furthermore, the establishment demonstrates a commitment to inclusive accessibility, offering wheelchair accessible seating, ensuring that Mamma Maria is a welcoming space for all members of the community. Its central location makes it an effortless stop for grabbing a quick takeout order, meeting for a casual lunch, or arranging a delivery right to your door.

Mamma Maria provides a full spectrum of dining services designed for modern convenience and local needs.

• Delivery: Full-service delivery is offered, catering to homes and businesses across the West Orange area.
• No-Contact Delivery: A safe and modern option for patrons who prefer minimal interaction upon receiving their order.
• Takeout: A fast and efficient service for customers who prefer to pick up their food.
• Dine-in: Guests are welcome to enjoy their meal in the casual, cozy, and quiet setting with dedicated seating and table service.
• Catering: Services are available for groups, meetings, and local events, drawing from their extensive menu of pizzas, pasta, and subs.
• Full Dining Schedule: The restaurant serves Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch, and Dinner, accommodating customers at virtually any time of day.
• Payment Flexibility: Accepts Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments for easy transactions.

The unique features and extensive offerings at Mamma Maria set it apart as a comprehensive local Italian-American kitchen.

• The Crazy Sandwiches: A signature line of massive, creative subs that draw significant attention and cater to a substantial appetite.
• Extensive Menu Variety: Offers everything from pizza and pasta to hot subs, cold subs, wraps, and platters, ensuring every craving can be met.
• All-Day Availability: Serving Breakfast, Lunch, and Dinner, the restaurant is a dependable food source from morning until late at night.
• Group-Friendly Atmosphere: The restaurant is suitable for Groups and is considered Good for kids, making it a great destination for family dinners or casual get-togethers.
• Comfort Food Focus: The menu is heavily centered on comforting, satisfying options, including quick bites and small plates, with Vegetarian options also available.
• Accessibility Amenities: Provides Wheelchair accessible seating for all guests, along with free street parking for added convenience.

To place an order, make a catering inquiry, or confirm their hours of operation, New Jersey customers can contact Mamma Maria using the details below:

Address: 40 Washington St, West Orange, NJ 07052, USA
Phone: (973) 731-0632
Mobile Phone: +1 973-731-0632

The dual phone contact ensures accessibility for all communication needs, whether a customer is ordering a massive King Kong sub or arranging a large party order for catering.

Mamma Maria is worth choosing for any West Orange or Essex County resident who values a truly massive menu, flexibility in ordering, and the quintessential comfort of Italian-American cuisine. What truly sets this place apart and makes it a worthwhile choice is its ability to cater to virtually any dining need—from a simple Caesar Salad for $7.99 to an indulgent late-night Fat Bear sandwich ($14.99). The special offers, such as the 2 Large Pie & 2 Lt. Soda deal for $30.99, also make it an economically smart choice for feeding a family or a group.

Choosing Mamma Maria means opting for a place where you can get a hot, fresh meal—be it pizza, a Chicken Parm Sub, or Penne Vodka—delivered to your door, picked up quickly, or enjoyed in their cozy, casual dining room. For New Jersey locals, it’s the definition of a dependable neighborhood spot where the portions are generous, the options are limitless, and the convenience is paramount. Despite occasional inconsistencies in service detailed in reviews, the widely praised quality and sheer breadth of the food menu, especially the adventurous Crazy Sandwiches, make it a compelling and essential local eatery.

Mamma Maria

40 Washington St, West Orange, NJ 07052, USA