Margaritas Cafe: Williston Park's Authentic Mexican Restaurant and Cocktail Hotspot

Margaritas Cafe Introduce

When New Yorkers crave authentic, flavorful Mexican cuisine paired with perfectly crafted cocktails, the search often leads directly to Margaritas Cafe in Williston Park. Located centrally on Hillside Avenue, this restaurant has established itself as a premier destination in Nassau County, successfully blending traditional Mexican cooking with a lively, welcoming atmosphere. It’s more than just a place to eat; it’s a full dining and social experience.

Margaritas Cafe stands out for its extensive menu, which covers all the beloved classics while introducing diners to unique, regional specialties. Whether you’re interested in popular dishes like Shrimp Fajitas and Enchiladas Suizas, or you are exploring the deeper cuts like Tacos De Birria or the impressive Paella En Cazuela, the culinary journey here is always satisfying. The focus on fresh ingredients and rich, traditional flavors ensures every dish is both filling and memorable.

A significant draw, as the name suggests, is the exceptional bar program. Customers consistently rave about the quality of the drinks, particularly the signature Margaritas, which are famously potent and flavor-forward—not diluted with excessive ice, as reviewers happily note. With a Casual yet Cozy atmosphere, Fast service, and a dedication to both food and drink excellence, Margaritas Cafe is a must-visit spot on Long Island for any fan of Mexican fare.

## Introduction / Overview

Margaritas Cafe is a celebrated Mexican restaurant known for its vibrant atmosphere and authentic, wide-ranging menu. It operates as a full-service dining spot, a lively bar, and a reliable source for high-quality delivery and takeout. Its location in Williston Park allows it to serve a broad segment of the Nassau County community, providing both a family-friendly atmosphere and a popular nightlife spot, especially for Happy hour drinks and Late-night food.

The dining concept embraces a broad spectrum of Mexican and Latin-inspired dishes. The menu is structured into dedicated sections like Guadalajara Steaks (featuring Bistec A La Brasa and Margarita Skillet), Tulum Seafood (showcasing dishes like Mixiote De Salmon and Camarones Yucatecos), and the essential La Calle for street food favorites. For those seeking comfort, sections like Casa Amigo offer traditional combinations, Chimichangas, and the crowd-pleasing Burrito Mojado.

The dual focus on outstanding food and a high-quality bar program—complete with an Bar onsite—makes it a perfect choice for various occasions, from a Quick bite to a full celebratory meal with Great cocktails. The commitment to a colorful, unique, yet clean aesthetic, as described by patrons, enhances the dining experience, making every visit a festive one.

## Location and Accessibility

Margaritas Cafe is conveniently located at 38 Hillside Ave., Williston Park, NY 11596, USA. This position on Hillside Avenue places it in a highly accessible commercial area of Williston Park, making it easy to reach from surrounding Long Island neighborhoods.

The restaurant is dedicated to providing a comfortable experience for all patrons, featuring comprehensive accessibility amenities:

A Wheelchair accessible entrance ensures ease of access for all guests.
A Wheelchair accessible restroom is provided for comfort and convenience.
Wheelchair accessible seating is available in the dining areas.

Parking is accommodating in the local area, offering a mix of Free street parking and Paid street parking options nearby.

To streamline service, Margaritas Cafe supports a variety of modern payment methods:

Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments

## Services Offered

Margaritas Cafe offers a wide array of services that cater to all dining preferences, times, and group sizes.

Full-Spectrum Service Options: Providing Dine-in with Table service, Takeout, Delivery, and No-contact delivery, ensuring maximum flexibility for the New York commuter and resident.
Extended Dining Hours: Open for Lunch and Dinner throughout the week, with extended hours on Friday and Saturday, making it a reliable source for Late-night food.
Comprehensive Bar Program: Featuring a full Bar onsite with a selection of Alcohol, Beer, Wine, and Hard liquor. The bar highlights are the Great cocktails and dedicated Happy hour drinks and Happy hour food specials.
Group and Event Planning: The restaurant Accepts reservations and offers Catering services, making it an excellent choice for parties, family gatherings, or business meals.
Family and Children Amenities: Recognized as Good for kids, the restaurant provides a dedicated Kids' menu (Morritos/Kids) and High chairs, ensuring a comfortable dining experience for families.

## Features / Highlights

The distinguishing features of Margaritas Cafe are centered on quality, variety, and the overall customer experience.

The Signature Margarita: A defining highlight, the restaurant lives up to its name with superior margaritas that are consistently noted for their excellent taste and strength, with customers praising them for not being "filled with ice."
Diverse Culinary Offerings: Beyond the staples, the menu features unique selections such as Tacos De Birria, the fusion Jambalaya, and the high-end Mar Y Tierra (Surf & Turf), appealing to diverse palates. Vegetarian diners are also well-catered to in the Me Late Vegetarian section, including Quesadilla De Calabacita.
Exceptional Dessert Program: With Great dessert as a highlight, choices like the classic Tres Leches, Churros, and the rich Fried Ice Cream provide a compelling reason to stay and linger.
Speed and Friendliness: Customer reviews frequently praise the Fast service and the genuinely Friendly staff, which contributes to the restaurant's reputation for providing an efficient yet welcoming dining environment.

## Contact Information

For reservations, takeout, or delivery inquiries, please use the following contact details:

Address: 38 Hillside Ave., Williston Park, NY 11596, USA
Phone: (516) 493-9045
Mobile Phone: +1 516-493-9045

Given its popularity, especially during peak dining hours, making a reservation is highly recommended.

## What is Worth Choosing

Margaritas Cafe is definitively worth choosing for New Yorkers seeking an authentic and high-energy Mexican dining experience in Nassau County. What sets this restaurant apart is its refusal to compromise on either its food or its drink quality—you get both the "Best tasting Margaritas" and "delicious" steak and shrimp dishes.

The depth of the menu, which expertly handles everything from light Mexican Avocado Salad to large combination platters like La Familia and specialized Guadalajara Steaks, ensures that whether you’re visiting for a Quick bite or a long dinner, your craving will be met with excellence. The restaurant is a reliable choice for any occasion, offering a vibrant backdrop of colorful decor, a comfortable atmosphere, and the convenience of modern service options, including Happy hour drinks and Late-night food. Don't hesitate to "Don't sleep on this place," as local patrons advise; it’s a premier Mexican culinary and cocktail spot on Long Island.

Margaritas Cafe Menu

Salads
Mexican Avocado Salad $12.95
Mixed Salad, romaine, iceberg, red cabbage, red onions, tomatoes and avocado. Served with our house Margaritas dressing.
Taco Salad $14.95
Taco bowl shell salad with romaine, iceberg, cucumber and tomato, with a choice of ground beef or shredded chicken, topped with mozzarella, black beans and balsamic vinaigrette.

Orale Appetizers
La Familia $29.95
Buffalo chicken wings, nachos, chicken taquitos, empanadas, chorizo and cheese, topped with guacamole, sour cream, jalapeños and tamuquepita sauce.
Gringa Quesadilla Pollo $15.95
Guacamole Molcajete $13.95
Avocados, jalapeños, tomatoes, onions, lime and cilantro, served with warm tortilla, chips and salsa.
Tostones Rellenos $14.95
Fried plantains topped with chicken, shrimp, ground beef, oaxaca cheese and cilantro. Served with tamuquepita sauce.
Alitas De Pollo (18und) $19.95
Choice of buffalo BBQ, garlic or chipotle sauce, wings, served with celery sticks, and blue cheese.
Alitas De Pollo (7und) $11.95
Choice of buffalo BBQ, garlic or chipotle sauce, wings, served with celery sticks, and blue cheese.
Nacho Supreme $12.95
Freshly made tortilla chips topped with refried beans, melted cheese, veracruzana sauce, jalapeños, guacamole and sour cream.
Gringa Quesadilla Steak $18.95
Flour tortilla filled with shredded mexican cheese and chicken. Served with tamuquepita sauce, guacamole and sour cream.
Queso Fundido $14.95
Melted mexican cheese, chorizo, salsa roja, baked in a skillet topped with cilantro and scallions, served with a side of flour tortillas.
Alitas De Pollo (12und) $16.95
Choice of buffalo BBQ, garlic or chipotle sauce, wings, served with celery sticks, and blue cheese.
Empanadas $11.95
Three empanadas filled with choice of beef or chicken and cheese. Served with saratoga sauce.
Gringa Quesadilla Shrimp $18.95
Flour tortilla filled with shredded mexican cheese and chicken. Served with tamuquepita sauce, guacamole and sour cream.
La Viagra $18.50
A refreshing citrus marinated ceviche featuring tender octopus, calamari and fish mixed with red onions, cilantro and lime juice
Taquitos De Pollo $12.95
Crispy rolled corn tortilla stuffed with chicken, topped with queso fresco, crema, guacamole and tamuquepita sauce.
Fried Calamari $15.95
Deep fried calamari, served with Willy’s homemade saratoga and tamuquepita sauce.

Guadalajara Steaks
Margarita Skillet $32.95
Grilled and seasoned C.A.B shell steak, pork chop, chorizo and chicken breast. Served with nopales on a sizzling skillet, rice, black beans, and flour tortillas.
Cerdo En Adobo Picante $23.95
Grilled pork chop marinated in chipotle adobe, served with rice and beans and green peppers. Served with rice and black beans.
Bistec A La Brasa $24.95
C.A.B grilled New York steak strip served with roasted seasonal vegetables, moro, rice and margaritas sauce.
Mexican Faldita $24.95
C.a.b. grilled skirt steak strips. served with black beans, topped with queso fresco, rice and avocado.
Carne Ranchera $24.95
C.A.B grilled shell steak strips, topped with onions, peppers, jalapeños, red sauce and avocado mexican. Served with rice and black beans.

Casa Amigo
Make Your Own Comb $20.95
Crispy rolled corn tortillas stuffed with mexican style chicken, peppers, onions, carrots. Topped with tamuquepita sauce, sour cream and guacamole. Served with rice and refried beans.
Chimichangas $19.95
Crispy rolled flour tortilla, choice of shredded beef or shredded chicken, topped with tamuquepita sauce, sour cream and guacamole. Served with rice and refried beans.
Flautas $19.95
Crispy rolled corn tortillas stuffed with mexican style chicken, peppers, onions, carrots. Topped with tamuquepita sauce, sour cream and guacamole. Served with rice and refried beans.
Burrito Mojado $22.95
Soft flour tortilla with Willy’s style C.A.B skirt steak or chicken sautéed in salsa roja stuffed with refried beans, mexican cheese, and lettuce. Topped with green tomatillo sauce, sour cream and guacamole sauce. Served with rice and

La Calle
Tacos De La Casa $17.95
Crispy corn tortilla shells with choice of shredded chicken or ground beef mexican style, topped with lettuce, cheese and tamuquepita sauce. Served with rice and refried beans.
Tacos Mexicanos $23.90
Three soft corn tortillas choice of grilled chicken, chorizo, sautéed beef or pork carnitas, topped with cilantro, onions and salsa verde. Served with rice, pico de gallo and beans.
Enchiladas Suizas $18.95
Three rolled soft corn tortillas, topped with melted mexican cheese, green tomatillo sauce and sour cream. Garnished with onion and cilantro. Served with rice and refried beans.
Enchiladas Rojas $20.95
Three rolled soft corn tortillas, choice of steak, chicken, cheese or chorizo topped with red sauce and three cheeses. Served with rice and refried beans.
Tacos De Birria $20.95
Three fried corn tacos freshly made with our signature meat and consomé, topped with cheese. Served with rice and beans.
Enchiladas De Mole Poblano $18.95
Three rolled soft corn tortillas, stuffed with shredded chicken, topped with mole sauce and melted cheese. Served with rice and refried beans.

Soups
Sopa Negra $6.95
Black bean soup.
Sopa Azteca $7.95
Blended chicken soup with pasilla chile and tomato. Topped with mexican cheese, avocado, sour cream and tortilla strips.
Sopa De Pollo $6.95
Chicken soup with peppers, onions, potatoes, carrots, celery.

Me Late Vegetarian
Make Your Own Comb Veggie $20.95
Quesadilla De Calabacita $19.95
Bean burrito, guacamole taco, cheese tostada or cheese quesadilla. Served with rice and refried beans.
Chile Poblano $19.95
Pan fried poblano pepper in our secret batter and egg mix, filled with wild mushrooms, baby spinach, and oaxaca cheese topped with green tomatillo sauce. served with rice and refried beans.
Cheese Quesadilla $18.95
Flour tortilla stuffed with cheese, topped with salsa tamuquepita, sour cream and guacamole. Served with rice and refried beans.

Tulum Seafood
Mixiote De Salmon $24.95
Grilled salmon filet marinated in guajillo sauce with manchamanteles and sour cream. Served with avocado salad and mexican rice.
Mar Y Tierra $39.95
Lobster tail, tender grilled C.A.B shell steak, shrimp, sautéed with white cheese. Served with black beans and mexican rice.
Paella En Cazuela $38.95
Lobster tail, shrimp, chorizo, scallops, clams and mussels, sautéed in white wine garlic sauce and tossed with saffron rice.
Camarones Yucatecos $22.95
Shrimp in an emulsion of green tomatillo sauce or chipotle sauce. Served with rice and refried beans.
Jambalaya $24.95
Shrimp, chicken, chorizo and crawfish meat, sautéed with green peppers and onions over cajun style mexican rice in tamuquepita sauce. Served with avocado salad.

Dessert / Coffee
Tres Leches $8.95
Decaf $3.95
Sopapilla $9.95
Chocolate Cake $8.95
Ice Cream $5.95
Cafe Italiano $8.95
Expresso $5.95
Churros $8.95
Flan $8.95
Cafe Mexicano $8.95
Cappuccino $6.95
Cafe Leche Mexicano $10.95
Coffee $3.95
Margaritas Flameado $12.95
Decaf Tea $3.95
Dessert Haven $8.95
Fried Ice Cream $8.95

Morritos/Kids
Kid Chicken Fingers $11.95
Includes one soda or apple juice. Served with choice of: Mexican fries, rice or refried beans.
Kid Cheese Quesadilla $11.95
Includes one soda or apple juice. Served with choice of: Mexican fries, rice or refried beans.
Kid Tacos $11.95
Includes one soda or apple juice. Served with choice of: Mexican fries, rice or refried beans.
Kid Burrito $11.95
Includes one soda or apple juice. Served with choice of: Mexican fries, rice or refried beans.
Kid Arroz Con Pollo $11.95
Includes one soda or apple juice. Served with choice of: Mexican fries, rice or refried beans.

Willy's Fajitas
Vegetarian Fajitas $19.95
Shrimp Fajitas $22.95
A fiesta on a plate! Your choice of tender, marinated strips of shrimp, grilled to perfection with vibrant bell peppers and onions.
Salmon Fajitas $24.95
A fiesta on a plate! Your choice of tender, marinated strips of salmon, grilled to perfection with vibrant bell peppers and onions.
Steak Fajitas $22.95
A fiesta on a plate! Your choice of tender, marinated strips of steak, grilled to perfection with vibrant bell peppers and onions.
Fajita Combo $24.95
Chicken Fajitas $20.95
A fiesta on a plate! Your choice of tender, marinated strips of chicken, grilled to perfection with vibrant bell peppers and onions.

Chido Chicken
Pollo Margaritas $21.95
Chicken on the bone, marinated in our oldest secret recipe, fried and baked with white wine, lemon, garlic and cilantro. Served with rice and black beans.
Arroz Con Pollo $20.95
Diced chicken breast sautéed in garlic butter and white wine and tossed with traditional mexican rice with a touch of tampiqueña sauce. served with refried beans and lettuce on the side.
Pollo Aguacate $20.95
Grilled chicken breast with melted mexican cheese topped with a touch of tamuquepita sauce, garnished with avocado. Served with rice and refried beans.

Sides
Chips And Sauce $5.95
Tostones (4) $5.95
Beans $5.95
Sour Cream $1.95
Tortillas (Harina) $1.95
Tortillas (Maiz) $1.95
Sliced Avocado $4.95
Platano Fito Con Crema $5.95
Fried sweet plantains with sour cream.
Melted Cheese $5.95
Rice $5.95
Side Of Guacamole $4.95
Pico De Gallo $3.95
Fries $5.95
Espinaca Al Ajo $5.95
Shredded Mozzarella $2.95

Margaritas Cafe Details

Service options
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service
Great cocktails
Great dessert

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Happy hour drinks
Happy hour food
Hard liquor
Healthy options
Late-night food
Quick bite
Small plates
Vegetarian options
Wine

Dining options
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Bar onsite
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy

Crowd
Groups

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
High chairs
Kids' menu

Parking
Free street parking
Paid street parking
Parking

Margaritas Cafe Photos

Margaritas Cafe Location

Margaritas Cafe

New York Nassau County Williston Park Hillside Avenue

38 Hillside Ave., Williston Park, NY 11596, USA

Margaritas Cafe Reviews

An average rating of ★4.2 from 603 user reviews.

managerbartendermariachipartyshrimpappetizersangriaempanadassingingrefried beans

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Amazing traditional mexican cuisine with a wide variety of different unique dishes. Colorful and unique decor yet still simple and clean. We ordered shrimp fajitas, plantains, and shrimp tacos. Most orders come with side dishes such as rice and refried beans. Food was very good and filling. Service was very friendly and fast.
September 08 · Najeeb Abdullah
We didn't start here, but we ended up here. We were soooo lucky. The food was delicious, The steak was juicy. I don't usually eat the rice, but I ate everything on my plate! The drinks were on point!! We usually order Sangria but chose Margaritas this time. Best tasting Margaritas we've had in a while. It wasn't filled with ice as most places do. Don't sleep on this place. You won't regret it.
July 07 · Wendy Maini
I saw them at the street fair with my girlfriend (I've been in the past in Williston Park and Freeport) I always thought pricey but good. To my surprise, I ordered two empanadas and two tacos, took some photos and videos to promote! But then the manager tells me I can't eat because they only take cash. NOT a single other place in this fair is just taking cash. PUT UP A SIGN. I didn't have any on me so I just had to return our food. This place is really a money grab, don't give them a chance, courtesy is simply not in their vocabulary.
September 21 · Christian Santos
My goodness. Where do i begin? The atmosphere is such a vibe. Loved the decor, decorations like a real restaurant. The service was not only gold standard but the professionalism of the waitress and staff. Amazed. Food? the food is astronomical. Loved every bite, made with love, made with passion. My bestfriend got the Soupa de Azteca and she said it was spectacular, spicy, made it very well. I WILL COME BACK AGAIN FOR SURE. Thank you for the experience.
March 19 · Michael Lavayen
My first time at a Margaritas Cafe! (I know they have around 8 of them on Long Island). Yesterday I went to the one in Williston park for their “taco Tuesdays”. I was not disappointed. The $3 tacos were delicious and full of meat and flavor. The $3 margaritas were even better and strong! Usually when you get deals on drinks at restaurants they make them weak but they did not hold off on the drinks. The food was all delicious. I would definitely come back here and would check out their other locations as well. Yum!
May 29 · Lexi C