Mario's Metro Pizza & Pasta

- 357 North Ave, New Rochelle, NY 10801

Introduction / Overview

For residents and visitors in the New Rochelle area of New York, the search for authentic, high-quality pizza often ends at Mario's Metro Pizza & Pasta. Located conveniently on North Avenue, this establishment is recognized by local patrons as arguably THE BEST in New Rochelle for classic New York-style pizza. It’s more than just a pizzeria; it’s a full-service Italian-American restaurant, salad shop, and sandwich shop rolled into one cozy, casual, and highly efficient operation.

Mario's has garnered a loyal following, largely thanks to its unwavering commitment to quality. The food is noted for its rich cheese, perfectly balanced sauce, and, most notably, a standout crust—described by happy customers as thin, crispy, and crunchy, designed to "fold really well." This is the quintessential New York slice experience, perfected right here in Westchester County.

The welcoming atmosphere makes it a popular spot for a diverse crowd, including local college students, groups, and tourists seeking a quick, delicious, and satisfying meal. Whether you're stopping by for a Plain Slice ($4.50) at lunchtime, grabbing a substantial Paul's Chicken Parm Hero ($12.95), or settling in for a classic Italian dinner like Homemade Lasagna ($15.95), Mario's Metro Pizza & Pasta promises fast service and a genuinely friendly experience. The owner, Mario (or 'Paulie,' as referred to by some loyal customers), is known for his stand-up personality and dedication to his craft, embodying the spirit of a hard-working, goal-oriented local business owner.

Location and Accessibility

Mario's Metro Pizza & Pasta is strategically situated at 357 North Ave, New Rochelle, NY 10801, USA. This prominent location in New Rochelle makes it easily accessible for the surrounding residential areas, the business community, and the local college student population.

Accessibility is a key priority for the restaurant. It is fully equipped with a Wheelchair accessible entrance, a Wheelchair accessible parking lot, and Wheelchair accessible seating to ensure all customers can dine in comfort. For those driving, the location offers highly desirable parking options, including a Free parking lot right near the premises, as well as free street parking and paid street parking nearby. This variety ensures convenience regardless of how you arrive. For indoor dining, the restaurant offers comfortable seating and counter service, and while walk-ins are always welcome for a quick bite, the business also Accepts reservations for those planning a group meal or a relaxed dinner.

Services Offered

• Dine-in and Counter Service: Enjoy a meal in the casual, cozy atmosphere with ample seating and the option for quick counter service for slices and quick bites.
• Delivery and Takeout: Offering extensive service options including standard Delivery, Takeout, Curbside pickup, and even No-contact delivery, making it ideal for busy New Yorkers, especially late into the evening (generally until 10:00 PM).
• Catering: With a comprehensive menu of pastas, large entrees, and gourmet pizzas, Mario's provides reliable catering services for events and gatherings in the Westchester area.
• Full Meal Service: Serving customers for both Lunch and Dinner, this is a go-to spot for both daytime meals and evening feasts.
• Beverage Service: The restaurant offers Alcohol and Wine options to complement your Italian meal, as well as a selection of Coffee and other popular soft drinks (Soda Bottle, Snapple, Gatorade).
• Family Amenities: Mario's is Good for kids, featuring a dedicated Kids' menu with options like Spaghetti Meatballs ($9.95) and High chairs for younger diners.

Features / Highlights

• Authentic NY-Style Pizza Excellence: The pizza is a genuine highlight, praised for its thin, crispy crust, high-quality cheese (which is RICH), and a perfectly balanced sauce. This delivers the quintessential New York pizza experience.
• Expansive Gourmet Pizza Menu: Beyond the classic slice, the menu features a remarkable range of specialty pies, including the crowd-pleasing Chicken Parmigiana Pizza ($23.95), the hearty Meat Lovers Pizza ($23.95), and the sophisticated Arugula Prosciutto Pizza ($23.95).
• Comprehensive Italian Offerings: Mario's seamlessly blends a pizzeria with a full Italian-American restaurant. Diners can enjoy classic Pastas (like Penne Alla Vodka, $14.95, and Homemade Lasagna, $15.95) and robust Entrees such as Paul's Chicken Parm ($20.95) and Chicken Marsala ($20.95).
• Fast Service: A key highlight for busy customers, especially students and those on a tight schedule, is the Fast service offered for both dining in and taking out.
• The 'Hero' Selection: The menu of Heroes, including the classic Meatball Parm ($10.95) and the Philly Cheesesteak ($11.95), provides excellent, substantial options for lunch or a quick dinner.
• Variety of Dining Options: Caters to all types of appetites with Comfort food, Quick bite options, Small plates (Appetizers like Fried Ravioli, $8.95), and a wide selection of fresh Salads (Mario's Salad, $12.95).

Contact Information

Address: 357 North Ave, New Rochelle, NY 10801, USAPhone: (914) 632-5734 or +1 914-632-5734

What is Worth Choosing

Mario's Metro Pizza & Pasta is absolutely worth choosing for local users in the New York region, specifically those in Westchester, who are seeking an authentic, unpretentious, and consistently high-quality Italian meal. The primary reason to choose Mario's is its reputation for having THE BEST New Rochelle-style pizza—a classic, foldable New York slice with a perfect ratio of crunchy crust, rich cheese, and balanced sauce. The customer reviews, which praise the quality of the ingredients and the standout crust, serve as a genuine testimonial to the pizza’s excellence.

Beyond the pizza, the sheer breadth of the menu provides exceptional value and variety. Whether you are a college student looking for an affordable, filling lunch, a family in need of a reliable dinner spot, or a tourist craving classic Italian-American fare, Mario's delivers. The menu offers great portions and options across salads, heroes, appetizers, and full pasta and entree dinners. The availability of diverse services—from no-contact delivery to fast counter service and the convenience of a free parking lot—solidifies Mario's as a reliable, community-focused choice. Choosing Mario's means supporting a hard-working local business, getting fantastic New York-style pizza, and enjoying a menu that has something delicious for everyone.

Mario's Metro Pizza & Pasta

357 North Ave, New Rochelle, NY 10801, USA