Brother's Seafood

- 407 North Ave, New Rochelle, NY 10801

Welcome to the ultimate guide to Brother's Seafood, a true local gem nestled in the heart of New Rochelle, NY. For New York residents and visitors with a serious craving for perfectly seasoned, high-quality seafood and comforting Southern-style American fare, this restaurant is a must-visit destination. Brother's Seafood has earned a stellar reputation for delivering exceptional flavor, generous portions, and a warm, friendly atmosphere that makes every customer feel right at home.

This is more than just a seafood spot; it’s a culinary experience built on great tradition and a commitment to fresh, delicious food. Whether you’re looking for a quick and satisfying lunch, a hearty dinner, or a special Sunday brunch, Brother's Seafood offers a diverse menu that goes far beyond the basics. From crispy, golden fried fish to succulent baked lobster and the creamiest Mac and Cheese, every dish is prepared to satisfy that deep, comforting food desire. The customer reviews consistently highlight the incredible flavor, freshness of the ingredients, and the wonderful service provided by the staff.

Known for its commitment to community and quality, Brother's Seafood proudly identifies as Black-owned, veteran-owned, and women-owned, adding layers of authenticity and character to its local New Rochelle presence. The focus here is on comfort food, quick bites, and small plates, making it a casual and family-friendly spot that accepts reservations for those planning ahead. When you dine here, you’re not just eating a meal; you’re supporting a local New York business with a dedicated passion for food.

Location and Accessibility

Brother's Seafood is conveniently located in New Rochelle, a prime area in Westchester County, making it highly accessible for residents throughout the New York metropolitan region.

The full address is: 407 North Ave, New Rochelle, NY 10801, USA.

Accessibility for local New York users is generally excellent. North Avenue is a major thoroughfare in New Rochelle. For those driving, the location is near various municipal parking options. Street parking availability can vary, but metered on-street parking is generally available in the area for up to 2 hours at a time, enforced from 8 AM to 12 AM, Monday through Sunday. Additionally, there are multiple municipal surface lots and garages nearby in downtown New Rochelle, such as the North Avenue at Thruway Lot or the Lawn Avenue Lot, which offer longer-term metered parking options for a less expensive rate. It's always a good idea to check local signage and use the Passport Parking app for easy payment.

For those utilizing public transit, the restaurant is located within the highly connected New Rochelle area, not far from the New Rochelle Transit Center (which serves Metro-North and Amtrak), allowing for a convenient short ride or walk from the station to North Avenue. Its central location ensures that whether you’re coming from the Bronx, another part of Westchester, or even further into New York, Brother's Seafood is an easy destination to reach for great food.

Services Offered

Brother's Seafood is dedicated to accommodating the diverse needs of the busy New York crowd by offering a range of convenient dining and service options:

• Dine-in: Enjoy a meal in the casual and welcoming atmosphere of the restaurant.
• Takeout: Perfect for a quick and delicious meal on the go.
• Delivery: The restaurant offers delivery services, including no-contact delivery, through popular platforms like Postmates, DoorDash, and Seamless, bringing your favorite Southern seafood directly to your home or office.
• Catering: Specialized family-style combos and large-format dishes are available for events, parties, and family gatherings (with a minimum order for delivery).
• Accepts Reservations: Guests have the option to call ahead and book a table, which is useful for groups or during peak dining times.
• Menu Options: Serves a full menu for Lunch, Dinner, and a dedicated Brunch menu on Sundays.
• Payment Options: Accepts all major Credit Cards and Debit Cards for easy transactions.

Features / Highlights

The standout features of Brother's Seafood solidify its reputation as one of the best local seafood restaurants in the New York area:

• Signature "Boat" Combos: The menu boasts unique and massive seafood combos like the famous Fish Boat (Whiting, shrimp, and clam strips) and the luxurious Yacht (lobster tail, whiting, catfish, salmon nuggets, shrimp, and clam strips), all served with natural cut fries. These platters are perfect for sharing and sampling a variety of their best fried seafood.
• Diverse Cuisine & Ownership: It is a Black-owned, veteran-owned, and women-owned establishment, focusing on Southern American and Seafood comfort food—a distinctive and highly sought-after combination in New York dining.
• Focus on Fried and Baked Specialties: Whether you prefer your seafood crispy or healthily prepared, the menu excels with options like Fried Whiting, Fried Catfish, and Fried Lobster Tail, alongside savory Baked Salmon (available as a combo with shrimp) and the whole Baked Red Snapper meal, often paired with seasoned yellow rice and garlic sautéed broccoli.
• Exceptional Homemade Sides: Customers rave about the authentic Southern sides, including the rich and creamy Mac and Cheese, the sweet and tender Yams, flavorful Collard Greens (cooked with smoked turkey meat), and fresh Homemade Cornbread.
• Sunday Brunch Menu: A special menu offers Southern comfort classics like Shrimp and Grits and various Chicken & Waffles (including Cinnamon Strudel and Red Velvet), along with fried fish baskets for a perfect weekend start.
• Fresh & Homemade Beverages and Desserts: Quench your thirst with a variety of fresh-made drinks such as Homemade Lemonade, Wild Berry Pomegranate, and even specialized Fresh Pressed Juices. Finish the meal with classic desserts like Lloyd's Carrot Cake (Plain) and Lloyd's Pineapple Coconut Cake.
• High Customer Satisfaction: The restaurant maintains strong ratings, with reviewers frequently praising the food for being "flavorful, perfectly cooked," "fresh and well-seasoned," and noting the generous portion sizes.

Contact Information

To experience the highly-rated comfort food and seafood offerings, or for questions regarding catering or reservations, here is the direct contact information for Brother's Seafood North Avenue:

Address: 407 North Ave, New Rochelle, NY 10801, USA

Phone: (914) 740-3690

What is Worth Choosing

For local New York food lovers, choosing what to order at Brother's Seafood is a delightful challenge, given the array of excellent options. Based on the menu, customer feedback, and the restaurant’s specialties, there are a few items that truly stand out and are worth making the trip to New Rochelle for.

For a true immersion into their offerings, you must consider the Specialty Fried Combos. The Fish Boat ($31.20) is a customer-favorite platter, loaded with four pieces of Fried Whiting, five Fried Shrimp, and Clam Strips, all served with natural cut fries. This combo provides a hearty and delicious sampler of their most popular fried items. For those celebrating or with a bigger appetite, the Cruise Ship ($46.80), which adds a Fried Lobster Tail to the standard Fish Boat components, offers an unparalleled luxury seafood experience.

If you lean towards a healthier, less-fried option, the Baked Salmon Combo ($30.00) is highly recommended. It features a delicious 8 oz Baked Salmon filet and five extra-large shrimp, beautifully paired with seasoned yellow rice and garlic sautéed broccoli, a perfect balance of flavor and nutrition. Similarly, the Baked Red Snapper Combo ($44.40) is a massive and satisfying choice, including a whole Red Snapper and five shrimp, paired with the same delicious rice and vegetable sides.

A meal at Brother's Seafood would be incomplete without trying the famous side dishes that anchor the Southern comfort experience. The Mac and Cheese ($7.50) is legendary, consistently praised for its creamy, classic, and cheesy perfection. The Yams ($6.00), which are deliciously baked and candied, are also a top recommendation. Don't forget to grab an order of the crispy Cajun Fries ($7.20) for an extra kick of spice with your meal. Finally, customers speak highly of the generous portions and the quality of the seafood—the fish is reportedly always seasoned correctly and never dry, a testament to the kitchen's dedication. Whether you crave the crispy crunch of the Fried Shrimp ($12.00) or a satisfying combination, Brother's Seafood delivers delicious comfort and quality with every order.

Brother's Seafood

407 North Ave, New Rochelle, NY 10801, USA