Mattingly's Tavern

- 16 N Main St, Florida, NY 10921

Mattingly's Tavern, nestled in the Village of Florida, New York, is much more than a typical local restaurant; it's a dynamic social and culinary hub that skillfully blends the atmosphere of a top-tier Sports bar with the warmth of a classic tavern. This unique venue has cultivated a distinct, baseball-themed environment, featuring decor reminiscent of nostalgic ballparks like Ebbets Field and the Polo Grounds, creating a fun, engaging, and nostalgic experience for its patrons. It functions as a full-service Restaurant, a lively Sports bar, and a versatile Event venue, making it a cornerstone of entertainment and dining in Orange County.

The food menu at Mattingly's Tavern is inspired by elevated ballpark concessions, focusing on high-quality, generously portioned Comfort food classics with a signature twist. The atmosphere is consistently Casual and Cozy, making it equally popular for Lunch, Dinner, and Solo dining, while also serving as a great gathering spot for Groups and Tourists exploring the Hudson Valley. Their commitment to offering a full experience is evident in their impressive beverage list, featuring a Great beer selection and Great cocktails, alongside regular entertainment and comprehensive services. Whether you’re stopping by for their famous seasoned sides or planning a private event, Mattingly's Tavern aims to hit a 'home run' with every visit.

Location and Accessibility

Mattingly's Tavern is conveniently situated in the heart of the Village of Florida, NY, providing easy access from surrounding areas in the New York region.

• Address: The venue is located at 16 N Main St, Florida, NY 10921, USA, placing it centrally within the community's main commercial area.
• Parking: Guests will find ample parking with a dedicated Free parking lot and the availability of Free street parking, simplifying the arrival process.
• Accessibility: Mattingly's Tavern demonstrates a commitment to inclusivity, featuring a Wheelchair accessible entrance, Wheelchair accessible parking lot, Wheelchair accessible restroom, and Wheelchair accessible seating.
• Atmosphere: The environment is lively yet relaxed, characterized by a Casual and Cozy feel. It is decked out with sports and baseball history memorabilia, offering different spaces for watching a game, enjoying Live music, or simply having a meal.
• Outdoor Seating: The establishment provides Outdoor seating, offering a pleasant alternative for guests to dine or enjoy a drink during favorable weather.

Services Offered

The tavern provides an extensive array of services tailored to meet the needs of diverse patrons, from on-the-go meals to full-scale celebrations.

• Dining Services: Mattingly's serves a variety of meals, including Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, and Dessert. They offer standard Seating and Table service, with a reputation for Fast service.
• Convenience Options: For those who prefer to dine elsewhere, the pub offers Onsite services, Delivery, and Takeout.
• Beverage & Nightlife: An essential aspect of the tavern is the Bar onsite, which serves a wide range of Alcohol, including Beer, Cocktails, Hard liquor, and Wine. They are popular for Happy hour drinks and also offer Late-night food service.
• Specials and Deals: Patrons can enjoy the benefits of both Happy hour food and Happy hour drinks, providing great value.
• Catering to Needs: The menu is accommodating, offering Quick bite options and Vegetarian options (such as the Beyond Burger).
• Amenities: The tavern is equipped with necessary amenities including a Restroom and public Wi-Fi access.
• Payments: Accepted payment methods include Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments for a quick and convenient transaction.

Features and Highlights

Mattingly's Tavern's appeal lies in its unique baseball theme, signature side dishes, and a robust menu centered on satisfying, elevated pub fare.

• Signature Menu Items: The 'Long Relief' menu features their highly-praised Burgers, including the Caramelized Onion Swiss Burger and the massive Triple Crown Steakburger. The side dish, Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats (available plain or loaded with Bacon & Cheese), is a critically acclaimed specialty, often seasoned with their proprietary "Magic Dust" Tavern Seasoning, which is also available for purchase.
• Baseball-Inspired Classics: True to the theme, the menu includes 'Stadium Dogs & Fries,' alongside classic appetizers like Half Order Of Wings, Fried Mozzarella, and a Colossal Pretzel.
• Wings and Sauces: Wings are a major focus, offered in large party sizes (30, 60, or 120 Party Wings), with a variety of Add-On Premium Sauce options, including BBQ Sauce Side, Buffalo Sauce Side, and Jack Honey Bourbon Sauce.
• Gluten-Free Options: The restaurant offers flexibility for dietary needs with a Gluten-Free Bun - Substitution option for their burgers and sandwiches.
• Beverage Excellence: Patrons appreciate the robust selection, noted for a Great beer selection with various domestic and imported bottles, and a full bar crafting Great cocktails. For celebrations, premium selections like Dom Perignon Champagne (2010) are also available.
• Entertainment and Events: As both a Sports bar and Event venue, the tavern offers Live music and screens all major Sports events (including NFL Sunday Ticket), creating a perpetually exciting atmosphere.
• Merchandise: The ability to purchase their signature Magic Dust Tavern Seasoning, as well as Mattingly's Tavern T-Shirt and Hoodie, speaks to the unique brand identity and customer loyalty.

Contact Information

For general information, to check event availability, or to place an order, Mattingly's Tavern is readily accessible.

• Address: 16 N Main St, Florida, NY 10921, USA
• Phone: (845) 508-6675
• Mobile Phone: +1 845-508-6675

What is Worth Choosing

Mattingly's Tavern is a standout choice for local New York users due to its perfectly executed niche: a high-energy, baseball-themed sports bar that serves legitimately great comfort food. The single most compelling reason to visit is to experience the highly-rated signature items, particularly the Tavern-Seasoned Potato Flats and the variety of gourmet burgers served on a pretzel bun. These unique and consistently praised dishes, seasoned with their famous "Magic Dust," set the food experience apart from standard bar fare.

Beyond the food, the tavern delivers an unmatched entertainment package. It’s the ultimate venue to watch any game, providing a dedicated Sports viewing environment, and transitioning into a lively spot for an evening out with Live music. The comprehensive services, including Late-night food, a full bar with a Great beer selection and Great cocktails, and comfortable Outdoor seating, make it a versatile destination for any time of day. Its accessibility (Wheelchair accessible) and multiple service options (Delivery, Takeout) further cement Mattingly's Tavern as a superior and highly recommended local establishment in the Florida, NY area.

Mattingly's Tavern

16 N Main St, Florida, NY 10921, USA