Michael Anthony's

- 1383 Jerusalem Ave, Merrick, NY 11566

For residents and visitors in the New York region, specifically within Nassau County, Long Island, finding an authentic and high-quality Italian eatery that truly understands the local palate can be a delightful journey. Michael Anthony's, a well-regarded establishment in Merrick, New York, perfectly blends the classic atmosphere of a local pizza joint with the extensive menu of a full-service Italian restaurant. It’s a versatile spot known for its commitment to fresh ingredients, fast service, and a broad selection that caters to every craving, from a quick slice on the go to a full, satisfying family dinner.

This venue has carved out a niche as a reliable destination for both traditional Italian-American comfort food and innovative specialty dishes. The atmosphere is consistently described as casual, making it an ideal choice for various occasions—from a simple weeknight dinner to a celebratory gathering. Whether you are a college student looking for a quick and satisfying meal, a family needing kid-friendly options, or a solo diner seeking a pleasant dining experience, Michael Anthony's is structured to provide a welcoming setting with attentive table service.

The core of Michael Anthony's appeal lies in its diverse and expansive menu. While the name suggests a focus on pizza, which is indeed a highlight, the selection extends far beyond. The culinary offerings cover a wide spectrum of Italian-American favorites, ensuring that pizza lovers, pasta enthusiasts, and fans of classic meat entrées all have something spectacular to choose from. This comprehensive approach to Italian cooking is what solidifies its reputation as a complete Italian restaurant experience in the Merrick area.

The dedication to quality and service is palpable in customer feedback, with many highlighting the cleanliness, inviting atmosphere, and the excellence of the food. It’s clear that this local spot is more than just a place to grab a bite; it’s a community staple that focuses on providing a genuinely great dining experience from start to finish. Patrons often mention the delicious pizza and the outstanding customer service as reasons they consistently return, proving that Michael Anthony's understands the importance of both food quality and the diner's experience.

Michael Anthony's is conveniently located at 1383 Jerusalem Ave, Merrick, NY 11566. This Long Island address places it centrally for local residents in the Merrick area and surrounding Nassau County communities. Its location is designed for easy access, catering to customers who wish to dine in or quickly pick up their orders.

Accessibility is a key priority for the establishment, ensuring a welcoming environment for all patrons. The facility is equipped with:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot (Free street parking is also available)
• Wheelchair accessible restroom
• Wheelchair accessible seating

The option of free street parking nearby adds to the convenience for local New York drivers, mitigating one of the common hassles of dining out in the region. This attention to ease of access makes the restaurant a practical choice for a wide demographic, including families and individuals with mobility considerations.

Michael Anthony's provides a variety of service options to meet the needs of the modern Long Island diner, whether they prefer to eat on-site or enjoy their meal at home. Available services include:

• Dine-in service with comfortable seating and table service.
• Takeout, allowing customers to quickly pick up their prepared orders.
• Delivery for convenient at-home dining.
• No-contact delivery, offering an extra layer of safety and convenience.
• Curbside pickup for maximum convenience, minimizing wait time.
• Outdoor seating, providing an enjoyable option during favorable weather.

Beyond the standard restaurant offerings, Michael Anthony's distinguishes itself with specific features and highlights that enhance the dining experience. These features collectively contribute to the restaurant's reputation in the local New York community:

• Fast Service: A key highlight mentioned by patrons, ensuring a minimal wait time, which is perfect for lunch or a quick dinner.
• Extensive Menu: Categories include Appetizers, Soups, Salads (such as Antipasto, Greek, Caribbean, and their notable New York Salad), Wraps (like Grilled Chicken Caesar and Italian), Paninis, Heroes (including their signature Michael Anthony's Hero and Philly Cheesesteak), and a full array of Baked Dishes like Stuffed Shells and Baked Ziti.
• Signature Specialty Pizzas: The pizza selection is vast and creative, featuring unique items like the Cataleya Pizza, Caesar Salad Pizza, Ziti-Macaroni On Top, Grandma Pie, Deep Dish, and the White Pie. The variety, including options like the Vegi Pizza and Meat Lover Pizza, showcases their pizza expertise.
• Full Italian Entrées: They offer a comprehensive selection of Chicken Entrées (including Chicken Francese and Chicken In Marsala Sauce), Veal Entrées (such as Veal Francese and Veal Michael Anthony's), and Seafood Entrées (like Shrimp Fra Diavolo and Mussels Marinara), making it a true Italian dining destination.
• Family-Friendly Amenities: The restaurant is considered good for kids and provides high chairs and a specific Kids' menu.
• Alcohol Offerings: The menu includes Alcohol and Wine selections, perfect for pairing with classic Italian dishes or enjoying a glass with dinner.
• Payment Versatility: Customers can easily pay using Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

To place an order, make inquiries, or find out more about their services, you can reach Michael Anthony's at the following:

• Address: 1383 Jerusalem Ave, Merrick, NY 11566
• Phone: (516) 414-4541
• Mobile Phone (Direct Line): +1 516-414-4541

The location on Jerusalem Avenue ensures easy navigation for local Long Island customers.

Michael Anthony's stands out in the competitive New York/Long Island dining scene for several compelling reasons, making it a truly worthwhile choice. First and foremost is the combination of a stellar pizza program—highlighted by highly praised, full-flavored specialty pies like the Caesar Salad Pizza—and a complete, traditional Italian kitchen. This means you don't have to compromise: you can satisfy a craving for classic New York-style pizza or indulge in a full Veal Francese dinner. The quality of the baked goods, including fresh, perfect crusts, is frequently commended.

Secondly, the commitment to service and convenience is a major differentiator. The "Fast service" and wide array of service options—including dine-in, curbside pickup, and no-contact delivery—reflect an understanding of the busy New Yorker’s lifestyle. This ensures a quick and efficient experience without sacrificing the quality of the meal. The atmosphere is casual and welcoming to all, from families utilizing the kids’ menu and high chairs to college students enjoying a quick bite. The extensive menu, which includes comfort food, quick bites, small plates, and full entrées, ensures there is always something appealing, whether you are stopping by for lunch or planning a relaxing dinner with wine. Ultimately, Michael Anthony's offers a highly accessible, quality-driven, and versatile local Italian-American dining experience in the heart of Merrick, making it a reliable favorite for Nassau County residents.

Michael Anthony's

1383 Jerusalem Ave, Merrick, NY 11566, USA