Michael's Pizza

- 125 Midland Ave, Port Chester, NY 10573

For those living in or visiting the Westchester County area, finding an authentic, high-quality local pizzeria that serves up more than just great slices is a true gem. Michael's Pizza, located in the heart of Port Chester, New York, is exactly that kind of establishment. More than just a pizza shop, it is a beloved, third-generation family-run restaurant renowned for combining traditional Italian flavors with a modern, welcoming atmosphere. It stands out in the competitive New York food scene as a reliable spot for exceptional pizza, classic Italian comfort food, and a genuine neighborhood feel. This is a place where every guest, whether new or a long-time regular, feels instantly at home.

Michael's Pizza has solidified its reputation in the Port Chester community, not just for its signature dishes but for its commitment to a delightful dining experience. It successfully meshes the feel of a classic local bar with a family-friendly restaurant, drawing a diverse crowd of patrons for everything from a quick lunch to a celebratory dinner. The establishment’s history as a long-standing, family-operated business ensures a level of care and tradition in their food preparation that is increasingly rare today. They offer a comprehensive menu that extends well beyond pizza, featuring a variety of appetizers, salads, hearty main courses, and indulgent desserts. Whether you're craving a traditional cheese pie, a signature Italian main dish, or a comfortable place to unwind, Michael's Pizza on Midland Avenue is a top choice in Westchester, NY.

The experience begins with the menu, which is carefully curated to offer something for every palate. The kitchen excels at classic Italian-American dishes, providing generous, homestyle portions that are both filling and satisfying. Customers consistently praise the quality of the ingredients and the flavorful, traditional preparation. The pizza, of course, is the star, with a crust profile that is neither paper-thin nor overly thick, achieving an ideal balance between hand-tossed and thin crust styles. Beyond the famous pies, the rest of the menu is equally compelling, ensuring that multiple visits are necessary to truly appreciate the breadth of Italian culinary offerings available.

The ambiance at Michael's Pizza is a significant part of its appeal. Described as casual and cozy, the dining area, combined with a well-appointed bar, creates an environment where locals gather to talk, dine, and relax. It is the kind of place where, as noted by local reviewers, everyone feels like a regular after just a single visit. This local, community-focused energy contributes significantly to its reputation as an essential eatery and gathering spot in Port Chester. The friendly and non-imposing service further enhances the pleasant dining atmosphere, making it a perfect spot for individuals, families, and groups looking for good food and a warm environment.

The restaurant also caters to modern dining needs, offering a variety of convenience options. With the ability to order takeout and delivery, enjoying Michael's Pizza from the comfort of one's own home is seamless. The business also provides different options for pizza crusts, including gluten-free and cauliflower crusts, catering to various dietary preferences without sacrificing flavor. This blend of traditional, family-run hospitality with modern conveniences makes Michael's Pizza a standout local business. The restaurant is not just surviving but thriving as a multi-generational establishment that has perfected the balance between exceptional food, quality service, and a welcoming neighborhood vibe—a true Port Chester institution that contributes positively to the New York dining scene.

A glance at the menu reveals a commitment to Italian classics done right. The antipasti selection is a great start, featuring staples like crispy Arancini, classic Pasta Fagioli Soup, Fried Calamari, and Eggplant Rollatini. For those seeking lighter fare, the salad menu is diverse, offering options like the classic Mixed Green Salad or the heartier Chopped Salad with roasted pepper, onion, mozzarella, artichoke, and prosciutto. The pasta section offers comforting favorites such as Rigatoni Ala Vodka and Baked Ziti, while the main dishes are a tribute to traditional Italian-American entrees, with Chicken Parmigiana and Chicken Francese being notable choices.

But the pizza is where Michael's truly shines. While the Traditional Cheese pizza is a perfect benchmark, the specialty pies demonstrate a flair for creative and flavorful combinations. The Famous Hot Woodsy and Sweet Woodsy pizzas are must-try items, both featuring the restaurant’s unique blend of peppers, sausage, and mozzarella. For adventurous palates, the White Clam Pizza offers a distinctive, savory, and satisfying experience, while the Sunday Pizza is a meat-lover’s dream, loaded with meatballs, Italian sausage, and fresh ricotta. This commitment to variety and quality ensures that Michael's Pizza remains a top destination for pizza aficionados across the Westchester area.

The restaurant environment itself is set up for a comfortable and enjoyable outing. With a full bar offering a great selection of beer, wine, and cocktails, it serves as an excellent spot to watch a game or simply enjoy a drink. The inclusion of outdoor seating is a significant bonus, especially during pleasant weather in New York. The restaurant's design and amenities also ensure accessibility for all, including a wheelchair-accessible entrance and restroom. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick bite or planning a lengthy family meal, Michael's Pizza is well-equipped to host a pleasant and memorable dining experience.

The reputation of Michael’s as a truly local spot is further cemented by customer reviews, which often highlight the personal touch of the family-owned operation. Patrons frequently mention the friendly service and the quality of the food. One reviewer noted the "fantastic" pies with a desirable "slight char on the bottom" and "top-notch" sauce and cheese flavors, even from a non-thin crust enthusiast. Another praises the family presence, noting, "Lauren and her daughter are great smiles to see when we enter. Nice to see a family owned business taking pride in the food and their customers." This deep connection with the local community is an intangible asset that contributes to the restaurant's enduring success.

For anyone in the New York region, and specifically in Westchester County, seeking an authentic, satisfying, and welcoming Italian and pizza dining experience, Michael's Pizza in Port Chester is an essential stop. It delivers not just a meal, but a taste of local history and family tradition.

Location and Accessibility

Michael's Pizza is conveniently situated at a well-known address in Port Chester, making it an accessible spot for local residents and visitors alike.

The establishment is located near local landmarks such as Hawthorne Beach and Edgewood Park, providing easy reference points.

The restaurant offers several accessibility features to accommodate all guests:

Wheelchair accessible entrance

Wheelchair accessible restroom

Wheelchair accessible seating

Parking is made convenient with free street parking available nearby.

Services Offered

Michael's Pizza provides a wide range of dining and service options tailored for modern convenience:

• Dine-in and Table Service
• No-contact Delivery
• Standard Delivery
• Takeout / Carryout
• Outdoor Seating
• Accepts Reservations
• Catering Services (Available upon inquiry)
• Lunch, Dinner, and Dessert Dining Options

Features / Highlights

Michael's Pizza is celebrated for several key features that enhance the customer experience:

• Famous Pan Pizza: Known for its signature crust—a desirable middle ground between hand-tossed and thin crust—with specialty toppings like the Famous Hot Woodsy.
• Third-Generation Family-Run Pizzeria: A well-established business committed to traditional Italian quality and community pride.
• Inviting Atmosphere: A cozy and casual setting that successfully blends a restaurant environment with a local bar.
• Full Bar Onsite: Offers a great selection of Beer, Wine, Cocktails, and Hard Liquor.
• Entertainment: Hosts Live Music and is a popular venue for Sports viewing.
• Extensive Menu: Offers a wide variety of Italian Comfort Food beyond pizza, including Main Dishes, Pasta, Sandwiches, and classic Desserts like Cannoli.
• Dietary Options: Includes Vegetarian Options as well as Gluten-Free and Cauliflower crust choices for pizza.
• Great for All Occasions: Popular for Lunch, Dinner, Solo Dining, and suitable for Families and Groups.

Contact Information

For inquiries, orders, or to plan a visit, please use the following contact details:

Address: 125 Midland Ave, Port Chester, NY 10573, USA

Phone: (914) 939-2241

What is Worth Choosing

When visiting Michael's Pizza, a few dishes truly stand out as highly recommended choices that capture the essence of the restaurant's quality and tradition:

• The Famous Pan Pizza (especially the 'Famous Hot Woodsy'): This is the establishment's signature item. The Hot Woodsy, featuring spicy Italian sausage and spicy cherry peppers, is a flavorful local favorite.
• Rigatoni Ala Vodka: A classic Italian pasta dish featuring a rich, creamy tomato and vodka sauce, perfect for satisfying a comfort food craving.
• Chicken Parmigiana: Available as a main dish or a hearty wedge sandwich, this is a cornerstone of the Italian-American menu, praised for its fresh preparation and generous portions.
• Pasta Fagioli Soup: Described as large enough for a main dish and tasty enough to crave seconds, this white bean and pasta soup is a comforting and popular appetizer choice.
• Arancini: These risotto rice balls, filled with peas, parmigiana, and mozzarella in fresh tomato sauce, are a classic Italian appetizer that showcases the restaurant's commitment to traditional starters.

Michael's Pizza provides a comprehensive Italian-American dining experience rooted in family history and genuine local connection. For a truly authentic taste of Port Chester’s culinary scene, be sure to stop by and experience their famous pizza and warm hospitality.

Michael's Pizza

125 Midland Ave, Port Chester, NY 10573, USA