Mr. C’s Bakery Introduce
Mr. C’s Bakery: The Home of Sir Conrad’s Legendary Caribbean-American Bakes in Brooklyn
For those who appreciate the rich culinary heritage of **Brooklyn, New York**, the name **Mr. C’s Bakery** carries significant weight. This establishment is not just a standard Bakery; it’s the current chapter of an enduring **Brooklyn institution** founded by the Caribbean-American legend, Sir Conrad. Despite changes in location, the commitment to churning out high-quality, fresh daily goods—a blend of classic baked items and unique Caribbean-style favorites—remains central to its mission in the **11203** area.
Located on East 51st Street, Mr. C’s Bakery serves as a vital daily hub for local residents and dedicated long-time customers who rely on it for everything from their morning sustenance to special occasion treats. Whether you are seeking perfectly crafted **custom cakes**, a basket of warm **fresh daily bread**, or authentic **breakfast food** that includes various traditional “bakes” and savory fillings, this bakery is the definitive source. The atmosphere, while geared toward a **Quick visit**, is often bustling, demonstrating the immense popularity and loyalty this establishment commands among **New York** locals. The bakery ensures modern convenience by accepting various **Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments**, making transactions quick and easy, even during peak rush hours.
Location and Accessibility for Brooklyn Locals
Mr. C’s Bakery is conveniently situated at 5101 E 51st St, Brooklyn, NY 11203, USA. This location places it firmly within a bustling and accessible residential sector of Brooklyn, specifically serving the Flatlands/East Flatbush areas. This spot is a known local landmark for those familiar with the community-focused services in the **11203** zip code.
A major advantage for all local users is the business's commitment to physical accessibility. The premises feature a Wheelchair accessible entrance, ensuring that the bakery is welcoming to every member of the **New York** community. Furthermore, for customers driving to the location, the **Parking** situation offers practical options, including both **Free street parking** and **Paid street parking** available nearby, which is a significant plus in a dense borough like Brooklyn. The bakery's services are designed to facilitate an easy and **Quick visit**, ideal for busy urban life.
Services Offered by Your Neighborhood Bakery
Mr. C’s Bakery provides a full suite of services centered around convenience and quality products, catering to the needs of its diverse Brooklyn customer base:
- **Product Specialization:** Offers a wide range of goods as a dedicated Bakery, including fresh daily breads, various pastries, sweets, and highly sought-after custom cakes for special occasions.
- **Specialty Food:** Features a popular **Breakfast** menu that includes traditional Caribbean-style "bakes" and diverse savory fillings, making it a reliable spot for an early meal.
- **Order Fulfillment:** Provides essential convenience options, including **Delivery**, **In-store pickup**, and simple **Takeout** for those in a rush.
- **Operational Focus:** The internal processes are set up for a **Quick visit**, optimizing for speed, although customer reviews indicate that efficiency can be challenged during peak demand.
- **Modern Payment Acceptance:** Ensures seamless transactions by accepting **Credit cards**, **Debit cards**, and **NFC mobile payments**, catering to modern preferences and minimizing the need for cash.
- **Inclusivity:** Guarantees access for all local customers with a certified **Wheelchair accessible entrance**.
Features / Highlights and Local Institution Status
What truly sets Mr. C’s Bakery apart and elevates it to a local favorite are its unique features and its historical connection to the **New York** community:
- **The Legacy of Sir Conrad:** The bakery is recognized as a continuation of the work of “Sir Conrad,” a celebrated Caribbean-American legend, making every visit a connection to a true **Brooklyn institution** with a rich history in the community.
- **Authentic Caribbean-American Bakes:** Beyond the standard sweets, the bakery’s offering of specialized **Breakfast food**, consisting of various "bakes" and fillings, is a major draw for customers seeking authentic and satisfying morning meals.
- **Reliability for Daily Essentials:** The establishment is a trusted source for essential items like **fresh daily bread**, a product so popular that customers are willing to brave long lines just to secure their daily loaf, highlighting the product's high quality.
- **Diverse Payment Convenience:** The acceptance of **Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments** is a significant modern convenience, ensuring that customers can complete their transactions quickly regardless of whether they have cash on hand.
- **Specialty Cake Expertise:** The ability to provide high-quality **custom cakes** means Mr. C’s is the go-to bakery for major milestones and celebrations across the **Brooklyn** community.
Contact Information for the 11203 Bakery
To place an order for **custom cakes**, arrange **delivery**, or inquire about their daily specials, locals can reach Mr. C’s Bakery using the information below:
- Address: 5101 E 51st St, Brooklyn, NY 11203, USA
- Phone: (718) 773-8266
- Mobile Phone: +1 718-773-8266
What is Worth Choosing at Mr. C’s Bakery
Mr. C’s Bakery is truly worth choosing for residents in the **Brooklyn** area when you are seeking products with heritage, flavor, and high-demand quality. The bakery excels in several key areas that make it a local favorite and a better choice over generic alternatives:
- **For a Unique Morning Meal:** If you’re tired of the usual bagel or bodega fare, choose Mr. C’s for their highly praised **Breakfast** options. The authentic **“bakes” and fillings** offer a culturally rich and deeply satisfying start to your day.
- **When You Need Real, Fresh Bread:** Customers line up specifically for the **fresh daily bread**. If a high-quality, flavorful loaf is essential for your home, this is the destination. Just be prepared for the crowd—it’s a testament to the product’s quality.
- **For All Payment Preferences:** The acceptance of **Credit cards, Debit cards, and NFC mobile payments** means you never have to scramble for exact change. This level of modern payment convenience is vital for a business geared toward a **Quick visit**.
- **To Support a Local Legend:** Choosing Mr. C’s means supporting a genuine **Brooklyn institution** carried on by Sir Conrad’s legacy. This cultural authenticity and local history add significant value to every purchase.
- **For Accessible Service:** The presence of a **Wheelchair accessible entrance** ensures that the bakery is a welcoming and practical choice for all members of the **11203** community.
While some feedback points to internal service issues, the quality of the products—the great breakfast, the good current roll, and the consistent excellence of the daily bread—is the powerful magnet that keeps this **Bakery** thriving as a beloved fixture in **New York City**.
Mr. C’s Bakery Details
Service options
- Delivery
- In-store pickup
- Takeout
- Dine-in
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
Dining options
- Breakfast
Amenities
- Restroom
Planning
- Quick visit
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
Parking
- Free street parking
- Paid street parking
Mr. C’s Bakery Photos










Mr. C’s Bakery Location
Mr. C’s Bakery
5101 E 51st St, Brooklyn, NY 11203, USA
Mr. C’s Bakery Reviews
rollpattiessaltfishbakedpricesbread and pastriesbeefmoneyhard dough breadsalt fish and bake
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1Grateful that Conrad’s Bakery is still around. Sir Conrad is a Caribbean-American legend and his bakery is Brooklyn institution. Despite the closure of his famous Utica Ave and Union Avenue landmark, he and his team are still churning out daily goods on Church Ave and 51st St.If you need fresh daily bread, pastries and sweets, or custom cakes, check them out. They also have breakfast food that consist of various “bakes” and fillings.I offer this feedback, as the lines can be wrapped around this tiny outpost, out the door. Please consider getting a handheld payment device (it’s an investment but worth it!) to expedite purchases for bread only. Not everyone is willing to stand in line for 20mins for bread only, while late comers seeking food get served before them. You have the staff. Less talk, more service. Money keeps walking out the door and this business deserves to win!!!
April 26 · JAY BLESSEDThis establishment needs better management in the front. There are a couple of disgruntled workers that need to be reevaluated. Having miserable and unprofessional people serving food isn’t a good look for business. Nobody wants to digest people gripes and unpleasantness. I had an experience during Labor Day weekend, then yesterday I witnessed another distasteful interaction. The breakfast is good. The pastries are ok and they do have a decent current roll. The customer service is indeed an overall issue.
September 23 · S.B HackshawI’ve been coming here for years—ever since they were on Eastern Parkway. I absolutely love their bread and pastries, and so does my entire family. As long as they’re open, I’ll keep coming back! I always look forward to stopping by whenever I’m in town. It doesn’t even bother me when the line is out the door—if anything, that just proves how worth it this place is. Hands down the best hard dough bread you’ll find. Always fresh, always hot.
June 30 · Supreme QueenI had a very uncomfortable encounter today .At around 5:50pm on July 28 I went in to get a beef patty which they no longer serve at the church ave location . As I entered the store, there was a lady with braids sitting on her phone, and another dark skin lady behind the counter towards the bread oven. I was not greeted by anyone of these two individuals Which is confusing being seen that I was only person Inside the store at that moment.Next I asked about the beef patty and I was told that they weren’t making any anymore so I ordered a current roll instead as I order the current roll, the dark skin lady asked the lady with the braids, who was super close to the current roll container to pass her piece. She blatantly ignored her, which forced the dark skin lady to go around to that side to get me my current roll, Now with that being said the lady with the braids who was on her phone proceeded to walk towards the cash register now I’m being handed my current role from over-the-counter and I haven’t paid yet , I started handing my $10 bill to the dark skin lady that passed me the current roll and I directed to give it to the cashier, which was very confusing because I didn’t see no cashier at the moment there was a lady standing with her phone and oops forget to add her earpiece as well which is not the case I’m reporting this encounter but because I just felt like it’s some animosity happening in the store between the workers and it’s affecting the service that’s being given to the customers and before you say get over it, I go to the store all the time and this is not the first time I had a nasty Encounter with a worker , Most days I bypassed it like everyone has those days but today just felt like that encounter could’ve been avoided. Still enjoy the food though.
July 28 · Kaliyah AlexanderMy hubby got me the coconut cake slice and the red velvet cupcakes. I’m not crazy about the icing on the red velvet cupcakes but that’s a personal choice of mines not to knock the bakery. I prefer buttercream. Overall my first time having coconut cake it was delicious the cake slice was huge, moist and perfect. The red velvet cupcakes were also moist and full. The cost for the 4pack cupcakes and the cake slice was around 9$ and some change which is very affordable. I’ll definitely be back again. Worth the visit and the money spent !
April 23 · Celine Rivera
More restaurants near me

5107 Church Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11203, USA

5023 Church Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11203, USA

5012 Church Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11203, USA

5178 Church Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11203, USA

361 E 52nd St, Brooklyn, NY 11203, USA

876 Utica Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11203, USA

872 Utica Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11203, USA

383 E 52nd St, Brooklyn, NY 11203, USA

856 Utica Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11203, USA

856 Utica Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11203, USA

888 Utica Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11203, USA

310 E 53rd St, Brooklyn, NY 11203, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Trending Dining Insights Posts





