Papa John's Pizza Hicksville, NY: Better Ingredients, Better Takeout and Delivery

Papa Johns Pizza Introduce

For residents across Long Island, New York, Papa John's Pizza at the Hicksville location provides a familiar and reliable choice for classic American-style pizza, sides, and innovative new items. Committed to the well-known mantra, "Better Ingredients. Better Pizza.", this establishment focuses on delivering a wide range of menu options, from traditional favorites to unique crust styles and savory side items, catering perfectly to families, late-night cravings, and casual dining needs. The Hicksville branch is engineered for convenience, specializing in fast, efficient takeout and delivery services that meet the demands of the busy New York consumer.

The core of the Papa John's appeal lies in its commitment to fresh, quality ingredients—including fresh, never-frozen original dough, vine-ripened tomato sauce, and real cheese made from mozzarella. This focus on premium components is what sets their pizza apart as a high-quality comfort food option in the local market. Whether you are looking for a quick lunch, a satisfying dinner for the family, or late-night fuel, this pizza restaurant offers a diverse menu designed to cover all bases.

Location and Accessibility

Papa John's Pizza is conveniently situated at 285 S Broadway 4 #4, Hicksville, NY 11801. This location, near a bustling commercial artery, is highly accessible for residents of Hicksville and surrounding Long Island neighborhoods. South Broadway is a major roadway, making it simple to navigate to the restaurant for those opting for carryout.

Accessibility is a strong feature of this location, making it easy for all patrons. The facility is equipped with a wheelchair-accessible entrance and a dedicated wheelchair-accessible parking lot. Furthermore, the available parking options are designed for customer ease, including a free parking lot, free street parking, and ample on-site parking. This abundance of parking eliminates the common metropolitan headache of finding a spot, ensuring a quick and stress-free experience for pickup orders. The location's primary focus on delivery and takeout means that while seating is available, the setup is optimized for rapid order fulfillment, ensuring quick service.

Services Offered

The Hicksville Papa John's prioritizes speed and convenience through its comprehensive range of service options. The main focus is off-premise dining, making it ideal for the local community seeking easy meals at home or at work.

Delivery: Standard delivery service is offered, covering a wide local area.
No-Contact Delivery: For maximum safety and convenience, this option allows customers to receive their order without direct interaction with the delivery driver.
Takeout: Orders can be placed online or by phone and picked up directly at the restaurant.
Dining Options: Although primarily focused on delivery and takeout, the location offers seating for casual, quick-service dining. They cater to Lunch, Dinner, Dessert, and even Late-night food demands, with hours often extending until 1:00 AM or 2:00 AM on weekends.
Catering: The restaurant offers catering services, making it a viable option for feeding large groups, parties, or corporate events across the Long Island area.

The environment is distinctly casual, making it a relaxed spot for a quick bite. They are family-friendly, offering high chairs for children and popular items that can function as a simplified kids' menu, such as Cheese Pizza and Cheesesticks. Payment methods are modern and flexible, accepting credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Features / Highlights

The menu at Papa John's is extensive and designed to offer something for everyone, with recent additions and classic staples standing out:

Innovative Crusts: The restaurant consistently introduces new ways to enjoy pizza, highlighted by the popular Epic Stuffed Crust Pizza ($21.49) and the even more decadent Garlic Epic Stuffed Crust Pizza ($22.49), which features signature garlic flavor both stuffed into and drizzled on the crust.
Local Flavor: Recognizing its location, they have introduced the New York Style Crust ($15.49), which is hand-stretched to create oversized, foldable slices with a thinner, crispier texture—offering a taste of the city's iconic style made with Papa John's signature fresh dough.
Dietary Options: They are accommodating to dietary needs by offering a Create Your Own Gluten-Free Crust option ($15.24), made with an Ancient Grains blend, ensuring those with sensitivities can still enjoy a pizza.
Non-Pizza Delights: The menu extends far beyond pizza with the Papadias ($7.00)—a flatbread-style sandwich that comes in varieties like Philly Cheesesteak or Grilled Buffalo Chicken—and the Papa Bowls ($8.49), a crustless option that layers favorite toppings and sauces.
Desserts and Sides: A wide array of sides and desserts rounds out the meal, including savory Garlic Knots ($6.59), Cheesesticks ($9.89), and sweet options like OREO® Cookie Papa Bites ($7.19) and the Cinnamon Pull Aparts ($8.79).
Special Sauce Selection: The famous Special Garlic Sauce is complemented by an array of dipping sauces, including Spicy Garlic Sauce, Blue Cheese Sauce, and the Garlic Sauce Trio ($3.29), allowing for a customizable flavor experience.

Contact Information

For placing an order, checking on a delivery, or obtaining more details about catering, the Hicksville location is easily reachable:

Address: 285 S Broadway 4 #4, Hicksville, NY 11801
Phone: (516) 932-7272
Mobile Phone: +1 516-932-7272

What is Worth Choosing

The Papa John's Pizza in Hicksville is worth choosing for its reliable quality and expansive menu variety, especially when seeking maximum convenience. Local New York consumers can appreciate the new New York Style Crust option, which pays homage to the region's pizza heritage while maintaining the brand's commitment to "Better Ingredients." This crust provides a satisfying, foldable slice that New Yorkers know and love. Furthermore, the Epic Stuffed Crust varieties are an indulgent, noteworthy choice that offers substantial value and a rich, cheesy experience unmatched by basic pizzas.

For individuals or smaller groups, the Papadias and Papa Bowls offer flexible, portion-controlled alternatives to a full pizza, perfect for a quick, affordable lunch bundle. The consistent availability of Late-night food and the sheer convenience of its service options—including No-contact Delivery and easy, free parking for Takeout—make this Papa John's a practical and appealing choice for comfort food at nearly any hour. While some local reviews indicate potential issues with delivery accuracy and service, the corporate backing and strong focus on ingredient quality and menu innovation remain compelling reasons for Long Islanders to choose this popular pizza chain.

Papa Johns Pizza Food & drink

Create Your Own
Create Your Own Gluten-Free Crust $15.24
Our Ancient Grains Gluten-Free Crust is thin, crispy and layered with signature pizza sauce, real cheese made from mozzarella, and your favorite toppings.
Garlic Epic Stuffed Crust Pizza $22.49
Epic Stuffed Crust meets your favorite garlic sauce flavor. The Garlic Epic Stuffed Crust pizza has our signature garlic flavor stuffed into and drizzled on the cheesy crust. Served with our Special Garlic Dipping Sauce — the flavor that inspired it all!
Epic Stuffed Crust Pizza $21.49
Choose your favorite toppings and cheese up your crust. Epicness is now even easier. Indulge in your favorite pizza paired with a pillowy, savory, cheese-filled crust.
Create Your Own Pizza $12.74
Build your own custom pizza and we'll handcraft it for you. With so many delicious options to choose from, your masterpiece is waiting!
New York Style Crust $15.49
NY Style pizza is more delicious than ever when it’s made with Papa Johns fresh, never frozen dough. Oversized, foldable slices with just the right balance of crust and your favorite toppings.

Pizza
Fresh Spinach & Tomato Alfredo Pizza $14.49
Fresh Spinach & Tomato Alfredo Pizza
Hawaiian BBQ Chicken Pizza $14.49
Hawaiian BBQ Chicken Pizza
Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza $14.49
Ultimate Pepperoni Pizza
Zesty Italian Trio Pizza $14.49
Zesty Italian Trio Pizza
The Works Pizza $14.49
The Works Pizza
The Meats Pizza $14.49
The Meats Pizza
Shaq-A-Roni Pizza $21.49
Extra cheese and extra pepperoni on an extra large New York style pizza cut into 8 oversized, foldable slices. Served with our Special Garlic Sauce and a pepperoncini.
Tuscan Six Cheese Pizza $14.49
Tuscan Six Cheese Pizza
Papa Dippa $17.50
A 3-cheese pepperoni pizza cut into 16 strips. Served with four sauces, including NEW Roasted Garlic Parmesan, Creamy Garlic Pesto and Garlic Hot Honey, plus our Special Garlic Sauce.
Garden Fresh Pizza $14.49
Garden Fresh Pizza
Fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza $14.49
Fiery Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Super Hawaiian Pizza $14.49
Super Hawaiian Pizza
BBQ Chicken Bacon Pizza $14.49
BBQ Chicken Bacon Pizza
Philly Cheesesteak Pizza $14.49
Philly Cheesesteak Pizza

Lunch
Cheesesticks $9.89
Cheesesticks
Boneless Wings & Drinks Bundle $2.79
Boneless Wings & Drinks Bundle
Papadia & Drinks Bundle $2.79
Papadia & Pepsi Bundle
20 Ounce Pepsi $2.79
20 Ounce Pepsi
Create Your Own $12.74
Create Your Own

Papadias
Grilled Buffalo Chicken Papadia $7.00
Flatbread-style sandwich made from original fresh dough and loaded with grilled chicken, onions, our signature cheese plus our 3-cheese blend, buttermilk ranch sauce, and buffalo sauce. Served with ranch dipping sauce.
Philly Cheesesteak Papadia $7.00
Flatbread-style sandwich with Philly sauce, cheese, steak, onions and green peppers. Served with garlic dipping sauce.
BBQ Chicken & Bacon Papadia $7.00
Flatbread-style sandwich with grilled chicken, bacon, onions, cheese, and BBQ sauce. Served with BBQ dipping sauce.
Create Your Own Papadia $7.00
Pizza sauce, cheese and up to three favorite toppings. Served with garlic dipping sauce.
Italian Papadia $7.00
Flatbread-style sandwich with Alfredo sauce, cheese, Italian sausage, salami and banana peppers. Served with original pizza dipping sauce.

Papa Dippa
Papa Dippa $17.50
A 3-cheese pepperoni pizza cut into 16 strips. Served with four sauces, including NEW Roasted Garlic Parmesan, Creamy Garlic Pesto and Garlic Hot Honey, plus our Special Garlic Sauce.
Garlic Sauce Trio $3.29
Three garlic-inspired dipping sauces: Roasted Garlic Parmesan, Creamy Garlic Pesto and Garlic Hot Honey.

Papa Bowls
Create Your Own Papa Bowl $8.49
Create Your Own Papa Bowl

Papa Bites
OREO® Cookie Papa Bites $7.19
Eight sweet bites of OREO® Cookie wrapped in our original fresh dough and drizzled in icing. Baked fresh and served with cream cheese icing dipping sauce on the side.
Jalapeño Papa Bites $7.19
Eight spicy bites of flavorful jalapeños, creamy alfredo sauce, and our signature cheese wrapped in our original fresh dough. Baked fresh and served with ranch dipping sauce on the side.
Chicken Parmesan Papa Bites $7.19
Eight savory bites of flavorful chicken and parmesan cheese, wrapped in our original fresh dough. Baked fresh and served with original pizza dipping sauce on the side.

Dipping Sauces
Spicy Garlic Sauce $1.09
Spicy Garlic Sauce
Cream Cheese Icing $0.59
Cream Cheese Icing
Special Garlic Sauce $0.89
Special Garlic Sauce
Blue Cheese Sauce $1.09
Blue Cheese Sauce
Garlic Sauce Trio $3.29
Three garlic-inspired dipping sauces: Roasted Garlic Parmesan, Creamy Garlic Pesto and Garlic Hot Honey.
Buffalo Spicy Sauce $1.09
Buffalo Spicy Sauce
Ranch Sauce $1.09
Ranch Sauce
Original Pizza Sauce $1.09
Original Pizza Sauce
Barbeque Sauce $1.09
Barbeque Sauce

Extras
Jalapeño Peppers $1.09
With honest and authentic ingredients like our jalapeno peppers, great taste comes naturally to Papa John’s. Fresh sliced and packed in a spicy brine with turmeric spice, the real Jalapeno Peppers are perfect when you want just a little extra pizzazz on your pizza.
Banana Peppers $1.09
Some people go bananas for Papa John’s banana peppers. Perhaps because they’re as flavorful as they are colorful. Our real banana peppers are brined with vinegar to keep them bright yellow.
Special Seasonings $1.09
Special Seasonings
Crushed Red Pepper $1.09
Crushed Red Pepper
Pepperoncinis $1.09
Our signature whole pepperoncini peppers are subtly sweet, medium-heat and grown in the Mediterranean regions.
Parmesan Cheese $1.09
Parmesan Cheese

Most Popular
Pepperoni Pizza $12.74
Your choice of crust covered with our signature pizza sauce, real cheese made from mozzarella, and pepperoni. With a pepperoni in almost every bite, it's one of our most popular pizzas.
Cheese Pizza $12.74
Simple, yet simply delicious. Real cheese made from mozzarella on top of our signature pizza sauce with your choice of crust, then baked to a golden brown. It has just what you want, and nothing you don’t.
Sausage Pizza $12.74
Our signature pizza sauce layered with sausage and real cheese made from mozzarella for a taste you’ll crave. Your choice of crust.

Desserts
OREO® Cookie Papa Bites $7.19
Eight sweet bites of OREO® Cookie wrapped in our original fresh dough and drizzled in icing. Baked fresh and served with cream cheese icing dipping sauce on the side.
Cinnamon Pull Aparts $8.79
Bite-sized sweet roll pieces covered in cinnamon and sugar, topped with cinnamon crumbles then baked to a gooey goodness and drizzled with sweet cream cheese icing.
Double Chocolate Chip Brownie $8.79
A decadent delight for chocolate lovers. This cakey on the outside, fudgy in the middle brownie is filled with rich chocolate chips, baked fresh and cut into nine squares, then served warm.
Chocolate Chip Cookie $8.79
Save room for dessert. Papa Johns' family-size Chocolate Chip Cookie is baked fresh, cut into 8 slices and served warm.

Newly Added
New York Style Crust $15.49
NY Style pizza is more delicious than ever when it’s made with Papa Johns fresh, never frozen dough. Oversized, foldable slices with just the right balance of crust and your favorite toppings.
Shaq-A-Roni Pizza $21.49
Extra cheese and extra pepperoni on an extra large New York style pizza cut into 8 oversized, foldable slices. Served with our Special Garlic Sauce and a pepperoncini.
Garlic Sauce Trio $3.29
Three garlic-inspired dipping sauces: Roasted Garlic Parmesan, Creamy Garlic Pesto and Garlic Hot Honey.
Papa Dippa $17.50
A 3-cheese pepperoni pizza cut into 16 strips. Served with four sauces, including NEW Roasted Garlic Parmesan, Creamy Garlic Pesto and Garlic Hot Honey, plus our Special Garlic Sauce.
Garlic Epic Stuffed Crust $22.49
Garlic Epic Stuffed Crust
Epic Stuffed Crust $21.49
Epic Stuffed Crust

Late Night
Pepperoni Pizza, Chzstx, Brownie & Drinks $3.89
Pepperoni Pizza, Cheesesticks, Brownie & Drinks Bundle
Pepperoni Pizza, Brownie & Drinks Bundle $3.89
Pepperoni Pizza, Brownie & Drinks Bundle
Cheese Pizza, Chztx, Brownie & Drinks $3.89
Cheese Pizza, Cheesesticks, Brownie & Drinks Bundle
Oreo Papa Bites $7.19
Oreo Papa Bites
Cinnamon Pull Apart $8.79
Cinnamon Pull Apart
Cheesesticks $9.89
Cheesesticks
8 Piece Buffalo Wings $12.09
8 Piece Buffalo Wings

Sides
Garlic Knots $6.59
Eight Garlic Knots made with fresh dough and garlic Parmesan seasoning, served with original pizza sauce. Share a Papa Johns side that’s sure to please.
Chicken Parmesan Papa Bites $7.19
Eight savory bites of flavorful chicken and parmesan cheese, wrapped in our original fresh dough. Baked fresh and served with original pizza dipping sauce on the side.
Jalapeño Papa Bites $7.19
Eight spicy bites of flavorful jalapeños, creamy alfredo sauce, and our signature cheese wrapped in our original fresh dough. Baked fresh and served with ranch dipping sauce on the side.
Cheesesticks $9.89
Cheesesticks
Tuscan 6-Cheese Cheesesticks $10.99
Enjoy a taste of Tuscany with our fresh dough covered in Special Garlic sauce and smothered in an authentic six-cheese blend of real cheese made from Mozzarella, Parmesan, Romano, Asiago, provolone and Fontina. Sprinkled with our blend of Italian herb seasonings for an extra dash of flavor. Served with original pizza sauce for dipping.
Garlic Parmesan Breadsticks $8.29
Fresh dough baked to a golden brown then topped with our Special Garlic sauce and Parmesan cheese. Served with original pizza sauce for dipping.
Original Breadsticks $7.69
You can’t live by bread alone. On the other hand, some can’t live without our breadsticks. Fresh dough baked to a golden brown. Served with Original Pizza sauce for dipping.
Bacon Cheesesticks $10.99
Original fresh dough covered with Special Garlic sauce, topped with bacon and real cheese made from mozzarella, then baked to a light golden brown. Served with original pizza sauce for dipping.

Wings
Unsauced Boneless Wings $10.99
Our mouth-watering boneless wings are made using juicy all-white meat chicken, then lightly breaded with hints of parmesan and pepper and oven-baked to a crispy golden brown. Enjoy with your choice of dipping sauce.
Honey Chipotle Wings $8.79
A perfect blend of sweet and spicy, honey chipotle sauce adds a savory flavor to our bone-in, oven-baked wings. Includes your choice of dipping sauce.
Unsauced Roasted Wings $8.79
No sauce? No worries. We’ll make your bone-in wings just the way you like them: oven-baked and unsauced so they’re unbelievably tender and tasty. Includes your choice of dipping sauce.
Honey Chipotle Boneless Wings $10.99
Juicy all-white meat chicken, lightly breaded with hints of parmesan and pepper and oven-baked to a crispy golden brown. Covered in our honey chipotle sauce that's the perfect blend of sweet and spicy. Includes your choice of dipping sauce.
Garlic Parmesan Boneless Wings $10.99
Juicy all-white meat chicken, lightly breaded with hints of parmesan and pepper and oven-baked to a crispy golden brown. Covered in our savory garlic parmesan sauce. Includes your choice of dipping sauce.
BBQ Wings $8.79
We never just wing it with Papa Johns BBQ wings. Our made-to-order, bone-in wings are oven-baked and covered in a thick and bold smokehouse-style BBQ sauce. Includes your choice of dipping sauce.
Buffalo Boneless Wings $10.99
Juicy all-white meat chicken, lightly breaded with hints of parmesan and pepper and oven-baked to a crispy golden brown. Covered in our satisfyingly spicy buffalo sauce with just the right amount of heat. Includes your choice of dipping sauce.
Garlic Parmesan Wings $8.79
Bone-in wings are oven-baked and covered in garlic parmesan sauce.
BBQ Boneless Wings $10.99
Juicy all-white meat chicken, lightly breaded with hints of parmesan and pepper and oven-baked to a crispy golden brown. Covered in our thick and bold smokehouse-style BBQ sauce. Includes your choice of dipping sauce.
Buffalo Wings $8.79
Kick it up a notch with our oven-baked bone-in wings covered in satisfyingly spicy buffalo sauce with just the right amount of heat to enhance our juicy wings. Includes your choice of dipping sauce.

Drinks
Pepsi Zero Sugar $2.79
Pepsi Zero Sugar
Brisk Lemonade $2.79
Brisk Lemonade
Schweppes Ginger Ale $2.79
Schweppes Ginger Ale
Aquafina $2.79
Aquafina
Diet Pepsi $2.79
Diet Pepsi
Mountain Dew $2.79
Mountain Dew
Starry $2.79
Starry
Pepsi $2.79
Pepsi
Crush Orange $2.79
Crush Orange

Papa Johns Pizza Details

Service options
No-contact delivery
Delivery
Takeout

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Comfort food
Late-night food
Quick bite

Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual

Planning
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
High chairs
Kids' menu

Parking
Free parking lot
Free street parking
On-site parking
Parking

Pets
Dogs allowed outside

Papa Johns Pizza Photos

Papa Johns Pizza Location

Papa Johns Pizza

New York Nassau County Hicksville South Broadway

285 S Broadway 4 #4, Hicksville, NY 11801, USA

Papa Johns Pizza Reviews

An average rating of ★3 from 359 user reviews.

callorderpricemanagerwingscoldpiepayglovesheadphones

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

I ordered 2 pizzas for delivery on PI day, so they arrived late. I expected them to arrive late, so I wasn't too upset. What was disappointing though, was how it arrived. One of them got smushed and they were both room temperature. If I crave fast food pizza, I will try somewhere else.
March 14 · Jenny L
This Papa John’s did not honor 2 for 1 bogo, they did not give me a pepperoni pizza but only cheese, and when I called to speak with the store, the person at the other end of the phone said if you ordered with Uber why don’t you complain to them. I asked for his name, and when he said why I said I have the right to ask for his name I don’t appreciate the way he’s speaking to me &! I d like to report him to a supervisor and he hung up on me. He hung up on me more than once and I am going to write to Papa John’s corporate. He was disgustingly rude and obnoxious. I will find out who he was and report him.
June 14 · Theresa M
Received the most amazing customer service experience from my guy Devender Singh! Quick with the order too. Pizza tasted true to standard, hot n fresh and not missing a beat.
December 19 · Shunpei O.
Ooh if you call them about a concern’s they hang up on youHave you wonder why? Because they don’t understand English. Ooh yeah. This business need to be closed at this location or train the stuff or a new ownerThanks
September 22 · Sheikh G
No extra cheese on pizza even though it was ordered that way. You could still see sauce and dough. Minimal toppings ever though extra of each was ordered. Worst papa johns experience ever. Don't recommend.
October 16 · Trey Lane
I usually order from here almost every week, especially for pizza. But after this experience, I won’t be ordering again. I ordered wings but received nuggets instead. When I reached out about the mistake, they had no intention of offering a credit, refund, or any kind of apology. Very disappointing customer service.
May 17 · SK P