Pasquale

- 39 Lafayette Ave, Suffern, NY 10901

For New York residents in the Suffern area and across the Rockland/Bergen County border, Pasquale is more than just a local pizzeria—it is a cherished, highly-rated Italian-American staple. Operating primarily as a Pizza restaurant, Pasquale has earned a reputation for delivering exceptional quality and flavor, with customer feedback often comparing its pizza favorably to top-tier Manhattan establishments, but at a "way better price." This combination of high-quality ingredients, consistent flavor, and fair pricing makes it a true gem in the local culinary scene.

The menu at Pasquale is remarkably extensive, covering classic Italian-American comfort food, a massive selection of specialty pizzas, and even surprising additions like Latin Foods. This variety ensures that every member of the family or group can find something to enjoy, from the simple yet perfect Cheese Slice to complex entrees like Chicken Francese Dinner and Veal Parmigiana Dinner. The core focus, however, remains the pizza. Patrons describe the crust as having that "perfectly crisp, golden undercarriage every slice lover dreams of," a critical endorsement for any New York-area pizza joint.

Pasquale caters to the modern needs of local users by offering flexible service options, including convenient Delivery, Takeout, and comfortable Dine-in experiences. The restaurant is consistently noted for its amazing staff, which is not only welcoming but also impressively accommodating, particularly for patrons with dietary restrictions or allergies. One customer review highlighted the willingness of the kitchen to cook virtually "Anything I wanted could be cooked to order," showcasing a dedication to personalized service that is rare and highly valued.

Whether you're looking for a quick, satisfying Lunch slice, a full Dinner with family, or planning a large party with their specialized Catering service, Pasquale on Lafayette Ave provides a cozy, casual, and family-friendly atmosphere where every dollar spent feels well spent.

Pasquale Pizzeria is conveniently located in the heart of Suffern, NY, positioned to serve the local community efficiently for both quick pickups and easy delivery access.

The address is:

39 Lafayette Ave, Suffern, NY 10901

The restaurant is dedicated to accessibility, providing essential accommodations for all visitors:

• A wheelchair accessible entrance ensures that the restaurant is welcoming to every customer.
• Wheelchair accessible parking lot spaces are available for easy access.
• Wheelchair accessible seating is provided within the dining area.
• General Free street parking is typically available, making spontaneous visits for takeout or dining hassle-free.

The atmosphere is described as Casual and Cozy, making it an inviting place for Family-friendly dining and suitable for large Groups of friends or colleagues.

Pasquale Pizzeria ensures that its extensive menu is available through multiple convenient channels, meeting the diverse needs of the New York-area customer base:

• Dine-in: Offering a relaxed dining experience for both Lunch and Dinner, complete with a comfortable, cozy atmosphere.
• Delivery: A highly convenient service for those who prefer to enjoy their meal at home or at the office.
• No-contact delivery: An option for safe, distanced delivery, ensuring peace of mind for customers.
• Takeout: Providing fast service for customers who want to quickly pick up their food and go.
• Catering: Specialized menus are available for events, parties, and large gatherings, offering options like Baked Ziti ($45.00), Chicken Parm ($50.00), and a variety of appetizers and salads in generous portions.

The true appeal of Pasquale Pizzeria lies in the depth and diversity of its menu, which extends far beyond the typical neighborhood slice. Key features and highlights include:

• Award-Worthy Pizza: Praised for its spot-on flavor and consistency and its perfectly crisp, golden undercarriage, a signature trait of high-quality New York-style pizza.
• Gourmet Pizza Selection: A robust selection of specialty pies like the Penne Pizza Pie, Buffalo Chicken Pie, Chicken, Bacon & Ranch Pie, and the savory Shrimp Parmigiana Pie (all $16.95).
• Comprehensive Italian Dinner Menu: Offering full Chicken Dishes (like Marsala, Francese, and Cacciatore), Veal Dishes, Seafood Dishes (including Shrimp Scampi and Mussels Marinara), and a variety of Baked Dishes such as Lasagna and Eggplant Rollatini.
• Affordable Slices: A wide array of specialty slices, including Pepperoni Slice, Buffalo Slice, Hawaiian Slice, and the unique Penne Slice, all available at a very fair price ($3.45).
• Accommodating Kitchen: Noted by patrons for its exceptional willingness to cook dishes to order for those with food allergies or specific dietary needs, providing a rare level of customer care.
• Latin Food Options: A unique feature that sets it apart, including Rice & Beans With / Arroz Y Habichuelas ($11.00), catering to a broader range of regional tastes.
• Extensive Hero and Calzone Menu: Featuring Hot Heros like Chicken Parmigiana Hero and Veal Parmigiana Hero, as well as over-stuffed calzones like the Breaded Chicken & Sautéed Spinach Calzone ($10.00).
• Convenient Payment: Accepts both Credit cards and Debit cards, adding to the ease of transaction.

For placing orders, making catering inquiries, or any other information, please use the following contact details for the Pasquale location in Suffern, NY:

Address:
39 Lafayette Ave, Suffern, NY 10901

Phone:
(845) 357-8599
Mobile Phone: +1 845-357-8599

For New York locals in the Suffern/Mahwah area, choosing Pasquale is a decision to prioritize exceptional pizza quality, menu diversity, and personalized service over standard takeout fare. This establishment is a standout option, not just for pizza, but for a complete, high-value Italian-American dining experience.

The primary reason to frequent Pasquale is the quality of the pizza. The customer reviews confirm that the pizza rivals what you would find in highly competitive markets like Manhattan, but without the prohibitive price tag. For a true "slice lover," the consistent, crisp, golden undercarriage is a non-negotiable feature that Pasquale reliably delivers. The wide selection of Gourmet Pizza options also allows for easy culinary exploration beyond the basic cheese and pepperoni.

Beyond the signature pizza, the sheer breadth of the menu ensures Pasquale can be a one-stop-shop for multiple meals. Whether you're in the mood for a filling Hot Hero like the Shrimp Parmigiana Hero, a classic Baked Lasagna, or a hearty Chicken Marsala Dinner, the options are abundant and the prices are described as "super fair." This variety makes it perfect for feeding families or accommodating groups with diverse tastes.

Finally, the highly praised staff and their willingness to accommodate food allergies is a massive differentiator. In a region where dining out with dietary restrictions can be a challenge, Pasquale’s commitment to cooking items to order provides incredible peace of mind and showcases a level of customer appreciation that is truly worth choosing.

Pasquale

39 Lafayette Ave, Suffern, NY 10901, USA