Pegasus Brooklyn: Bay Ridge's Favorite All-Day Breakfast and Brunch Haven

Pegasus Brooklyn Introduce

Introduction / Overview

In a city that never stops, the need for a quality, consistent, and comforting Breakfast Restaurant is paramount. Pegasus Brooklyn, situated in the bustling Bay Ridge section of Brooklyn, is precisely that—a local institution that has evolved from a cozy neighborhood spot into a premier destination for modern American diner food, focusing heavily on spectacular Brunch and Lunch offerings. Known by locals as a long-standing, family-owned staple, Pegasus Brooklyn delivers generous portions of freshly cooked, high-quality food in an environment that is both Casual and Cozy.

The menu is a testament to elevated diner cuisine, moving far beyond simple scrambled eggs. It features creative and indulgent brunch classics such as the popular Bananas Foster French Toast and the signature Chicken And Waffle. For the health-conscious New Yorker, options like the Sunny And Kale served over tri-color quinoa, or the array of Healthy options and Vegetarian options, ensure there is truly something for everyone. Whether you're rushing in for a quick Bacon And Egg On A Roll or settling in for a luxurious weekend Brunch, Pegasus provides prompt service and a warm atmosphere.

Pegasus Brooklyn proudly caters to the Bay Ridge community's diverse needs. The atmosphere is genuinely Family-friendly and welcoming, embracing the inclusive spirit of the neighborhood by also being LGBTQ+ friendly and a Transgender safespace. Operating daily from 8:00 AM (and 7:30 AM on some days, per recent information) until late afternoon/early evening, it perfectly covers the essential meal times for Brooklynites seeking an exceptional dining experience that feels like home.

---

Location and Accessibility

Pegasus Brooklyn is perfectly located at 8610 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA. This address places it squarely on 3rd Avenue, a vibrant commercial artery in Bay Ridge, making it easily accessible for the neighborhood's Locals.

Accessibility features are designed to welcome all patrons, with a confirmed Wheelchair accessible entrance. For those driving in one of the city's most parking-intensive neighborhoods, Paid street parking is available nearby, though New Yorkers know to expect potential limitations during peak meal times. The restaurant's popularity means there is Usually a wait during prime hours, but the food is widely considered worth the time. The interior provides Seating in a clean, Casual setting, often praised for its comfort and cleanliness. Furthermore, the establishment is well-equipped with amenities, including a Restroom and a Gender-neutral restroom, adding to its family-friendly and inclusive environment. Customers have the flexibility of paying with Credit cards, Debit cards, or NFC mobile payments, streamlining the end of the dining experience.

---

Services Offered

Pegasus Brooklyn provides a versatile range of services focused on a high-quality, full-service dining experience, available for a majority of the day:

Complete Meal Service: Dedicated to Breakfast, Brunch, and Lunch, with options extending into early Dinner hours on some days. Their diverse menu also makes them an excellent option for Dessert and Quick bite moments.
Full Table Service: Offering comfortable Dine-in service with dedicated Table service in a Cozy and Casual atmosphere.
Takeout and Delivery: For the fast-paced New York lifestyle, Takeout is readily available, as is delivery service via major platforms.
Beverage Variety: Serving Great coffee and a wide range of specialty drinks including Espresso, Latte, Iced Matcha Latte, and refreshing items like Homemade Mint Lemonade and Milkshake.
Alcoholic Beverages: Provides a selection of Alcohol, Beer, Cocktails, and Wine, allowing it to transition seamlessly from a breakfast spot to a leisurely brunch or lunch destination.
Catering: Offers Catering services, making it a reliable choice for local Bay Ridge events and large gatherings.
Reservations and Waiting: Accepts reservations to help manage the popular demand, though patrons should still prepare for the possibility of a wait during busy times.

---

Features / Highlights

The enduring popularity of Pegasus Brooklyn is driven by several key highlights that appeal directly to the discerning New York diner:

Elevated Brunch Menu: The extensive and creative brunch section, featuring unique takes on classics like Kick A** Benedict, Avocado Pesto Smash, and the rich Bananas Foster French Toast, positions it as a true Brunch restaurant destination.
Focus on Freshness: Highly praised for its commitment to fresh ingredients, particularly highlighted by the inclusion of Fresh Squeezed Juice (Orange and Grapefruit) and dishes like Sunny And Kale.
Inclusive Atmosphere: Creating a welcoming space for the entire community, the restaurant is explicitly Family-friendly, LGBTQ+ friendly, and recognized as a Transgender safespace, which is a significant factor for many choosing a local eatery.
Specialty Comfort Food: Beyond breakfast, the menu offers a range of high-quality Comfort food like the Philly Cheesesteak Egg-rolls and the highly rated burgers, satisfying lunchtime cravings.
Wide Omelette Selection: An impressive list of Eggs and Omelettes, including seven unique Pegasus Special Omelettes such as the Avocado, Bacon, Cheddar And Salsa Omelette, ensures customizability for the breakfast connoisseur.
Local Recognition: Mentioned by locals as the "best diner" in Bay Ridge, indicating strong community support and a reputation for Serves local specialty and quality.

---

Contact Information

For reservations, takeout orders, or inquiries about menu items at Pegasus Brooklyn, please use the following contact details:

Address: 8610 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA
Phone: (718) 748-6977 (also +1 718-748-6977)
Hours: Generally open Monday and Wednesday-Saturday from 8:00 AM – 5:00 PM (some sources say 5:30 PM), and Sunday from 8:00 AM – 4:00 PM. Note that the restaurant is typically Closed on Tuesdays.

---

What is Worth Choosing

Pegasus Brooklyn is definitively worth choosing for any New Yorker in search of a high-quality, elevated diner experience, especially for Breakfast or Brunch. The sheer quality of their food, with highly-praised dishes like the Bananas Foster French Toast and the meticulously prepared Benedicts, sets it apart from typical diners. It successfully combines the cozy, familiar feel of a neighborhood staple with a modern, creative menu.

For the busy urban professional or resident, the Fast service and generous portion sizes ensure a satisfying meal that is well worth the potential wait time during peak hours. Moreover, the restaurant's commitment to creating an Inclusive and Cozy atmosphere makes it a genuinely pleasant place to spend time, whether you are enjoying Solo dining or bringing the whole Family-friendly crowd. By offering a vast selection of both traditional and inventive dishes, along with essential amenities and payment options, Pegasus Brooklyn has solidified its reputation as the essential Brunch restaurant and Lunch restaurant hub in Bay Ridge.

Pegasus Brooklyn Menu

Brunch
Tex Mex Breakfast Burrito $19.55
2 scrambled eggs, Hass avocado, pork chorizo salsa, cheddar cheese, black beans wrapped in a flour tortilla, served with homefries. Add jalapenos for an additional charge.
Chicken And Waffle $19.55
Chicken strips coated with a crispy panko crust, served with a Belgian waffle and our own honey-Dijon maple butter sauce on the side.
Bananas Foster French Toast $19.55
Challah bread French toast topped with caramelized bananas in a rum maple butter sauce, topped with a scoop of vanilla ice cream and roasted pecans.
Kick A** Benedict $19.55
Toasted ciabatta bread topped with country ham, 2 XL farm-fresh eggs poached with our own spicy hollandaise sauce, sprinkled with red pepper flakes served with homefries vegetarian option: avocado instead of country ham.
Sunny And Kale $19.55
Sunny side up eggs served over tri-color quinoa, complimented with organic baby kale, Hass avocado, sliced tomato and topped with our own reduced balsamic glaze.
Avocado Pesto Smash $19.55
English muffin topped with smashed Hass avocado, prosciutto (pork), 2 XL farm-fresh basted eggs and our own basil pesto with side of seasoned waffle fries.
Breakfast Tacos $19.55
2 soft tacos with scrambled eggs, chopped bacon, smashed Hass avocado, our own pico de gallo salsa and queso fresco with a side of waffle fries.
Greek Benny $19.55
Thomas' English muffin, toasted and layered with a mixture of spinach and feta cheese, 2 XL farm-fresh eggs poached, topped with our spicy hollandaise served with homefries.
Peaches And Cream French Toast $19.55
Challah bread French toast topped with sliced fresh peaches, simmered in a light syrup, topped with our own mascarpone cream and fresh blueberries.
Huevos Rancheros $19.55
2 crunchy corn tortillas topped with 2 XL farm-fresh eggs sunny side up, a mild pork chorizo salsa, Hass avocado, queso fresco and fresh cilantro.
Avocado Toast $19.55
2 basted XL farm-fresh eggs served over ciabatta toast with Hass avocado served with mesclun greens drizzled with our own reduced balsamic glaze.

Brunch Side
Side Order Tri-Color Quinoa $5.65

From the Griddle
Pancakes $10.95
Whole Wheat Pancakes $10.95
Flavor Pancakes $14.50
Blueberry, banana, chocolate chip, or peanut butter.
Silver Dollar Pancakes $10.95
French Toast $10.45
Old fashioned, challah, or whole wheat.
Multi-Grain French Toast $10.95
Belgian Waffle $11.50
Regular or whole wheat. Add toppings for an additional charge.

Eggs and Omelettes
2 Eggs Any Style $9.35
2 Eggs Any Style With Meat $12.95
Served with ham or bacon or sausage.
Corned Beef Hash And Eggs $14.00
Spinach And Feta Omelette $13.80
Broccoli And Cheese Omelette $13.80
Your choice of cheese.
Fresh Mushroom And Onion Omelette $13.80
Greek Omelette $13.80
Feta, tomato and onion.
Cheese Omelette $12.75
Your choice of cheese.
Ham And Cheese Omelette $13.80
Your choice of cheese.
Western Omelette $14.00
Ham, pepper and onion.

Pegasus Special Omelettes
#1. Fresh Mushroom, Onion, American Cheese, Kalamata Olives And Peppers Omelette $16.25
#2. Fresh Turkey, Spinach, Tomato, And Mozzarella Omelette $17.25
#3. Sausage, Mozzarella, Fresh Mushrooms, Tomato, And Kalamata Olives Omelette $16.25
#4. Bacon, Feta, Tomato, Onion, And Kalamata Olives Omelette $16.25
#5. Zucchini, Fresh Mushrooms, Tomato, Onion, And Kalamata Olives Omelette $16.25
#6. Wild Western With Peppers, Onions, Ham, Jalapenos, And Cheddar Omelette $16.25
Spicy.
#7. Avocado, Bacon, Cheddar And Salsa Omelette $17.25

On the Side
Ham $5.65
Bacon $5.65
Boars head.
Sausage $5.65
Turkey Bacon $6.45
Canadian Bacon $6.45
Corned Beef Hash $6.45
Gyro $6.45
Chicken Gyro $6.45

Cereal and Yogurt
Hot Oatmeal $7.00
Yogurt $11.65
Berries, granola, chia seeds, and honey.

Salads
Pegasus Salad $17.90
Iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, Kalamata olives, green peppers topped with grilled chicken and hard-boiled egg.
Cobb Salad $18.95
Mixed greens, tomatoes, shredded carrots, real bacon, chopped egg, cheddar and grilled chicken with our own avocado ranch dressing on the side.
Caesar Salad $12.70
Mesculin Salad $13.75
Mixed greens, tomatoes, walnuts, feta cheese and croutons in our own Mediterranean dressing.
Greek Salad $13.75
Iceberg lettuce, tomatoes, onions, peppers, cucumber, Kalamata olives, feta cheese, and grape leaf.
Power Salad $18.95
Organic baby kale, tri-color quinoa, tomatoes, carrots, corn, feta, avocado, dried cranberries, sliced hard-boiled egg tossed in our own Mediterranean dressing.

Sandwiches
Egg Sandwich $3.95
Bacon And Egg On A Roll $5.95
Double Egg, Bacon And Cheese On A Roll $8.95
Ham And Cheese Omelette On A Roll $7.25
Western Omelette On A Roll $7.25
Tuna Fish Salad Sandwich $10.05
Chicken Salad Sandwich $10.05
BLT Sandwich $9.65
Bacon, lettuce and tomato.
Roasted Turkey Sandwich $12.75
Gyro On Pita $12.75
Chicken Gyro On Pita $12.75
Grilled Cheese Sandwich $7.35
Your choice of cheese.
Turkey Club Sandwich $18.95
Fresh Roasted Turkey, Lettuce, Tomato, Bacon And Mayonnaise, Served with French Fries

Soup of the Week
Vegetable Soup (Only Monday)
Chicken Rice Soup (Monday-Wednesday-Saturday-Sunday)
Beef Barley Soup (Only Wednesday)
Split Pea Soup (Only Thursday)
Chicken Noodle (Thursday-Friday)
Cream Of Turkey Soup (Friday)
Cream Of Broccoli Soup (Saturday)

Burgers
Hamburger $10.95
Cheeseburger $12.50
Beyond Burger $12.70
Plant-based.
Veggie Burger $10.95

Wraps
#1. Grilled Chicken Wrap $18.95
Served with fresh mozzarella and roasted peppers.
#2. Chicken Gyro Wrap $17.95
Traditional Greek style with lettuce, tomato, onion, and our own tzatziki sauce.
#2. Beef Gyro Wrap $17.95
Traditional Greek style with lettuce, tomato, onion, and our own tzatziki sauce.
#3. Prosciutto Wrap $18.95
Boar's Head. Served with fresh mozzarella and roasted peppers.
#4. Philly Cheesesteak Wrap $17.95
Sauteed onions and American cheese.
#5. Turkey Avocado BLT Wrap $18.95
Served with chipotle mayo.
#6. Tuna Salad Wrap $17.95
Served with lettuce and tomatoes.
#7. Caesar Salad Wrap $17.95
Served with chicken.
#8. Greek Salad Wrap $17.95
Served with chicken.
#9. Mesculin Salad Wrap $17.95
Served with chicken, feta cheese, walnuts, tomatoes and croutons in our own Mediterranean dressing.
#10. Vegetarian Wrap $17.95
Mixed grilled vegetables. Broccoli, fresh mushrooms, corn, onions, American cheese and our own vinaigrette dressing.
#11. Chicken Salad Wrap $17.95
Served with walnuts, cranberries and mesculin greens.
#12. Kale And Quinoa Wrap $18.95
Fried chicken cutlet (made to order) cut up and tossed with baby kale, tri-color quinoa, avocado, tomatoes, shredded carrots, corn and dried cranberries mixed with our own avocado ranch dressing.
#13. Buffalo Chicken Wrap $18.95
Served with boneless Buffalo wings, iceberg lettuce and bleu cheese dressing.

House Specialities
Boneless Buffalo Wings $14.95
Served with bleu cheese.
Chicken Fingers $18.95
Served with french fries.
Philly Cheesesteak $18.95
On kaiser roll with fried onions and french fries.
Quesadilla $18.95
Steak or chicken with french fries.

Side Orders
French Fries $7.00
Add cheese for an additional charge.
Seasoned Waffle Fries $8.10
Add cheese for an additional charge.
Sweet Potato Fries $8.10
Onion Rings $8.95
Battered Mozzarella Sticks $10.55

Fresh Squeezed Juice
Orange Juice
Grapefruit Juice

Specialty Beverages
Espresso
Cappuccino
Latte
Matcha Latte
Mochaccino
Iced Mochaccino
Iced Capuccino
Iced Latte
Iced Matcha Latte $7.20

Beverages
Hot Coffee
Regular or decaf.
Iced Coffee
Regular or decaf.
Tea
Regular or decaf.
Iced Tea
Herbal Tea
Hot Chocolate $3.40
Cold Brew Coffee
Frappe $5.75
Whipped Iced Coffee
Homemade Mint Lemonade $6.20
Chocolate Milk $4.70
Milkshake $6.20
Bottled Water $2.45
Canned Soda $2.70
Apple Juice $4.20
Tropicana Orange Juice $4.20
Snapple $2.95

Pegasus Brooklyn Details

Service options
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service
Great coffee
Serves local specialty

Popular for
Breakfast
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Comfort food
Healthy options
Quick bite
Vegetarian options
Wine

Dining options
Breakfast
Brunch
Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Gender-neutral restroom
Restroom

Atmosphere
Casual
Cozy
Trendy

Crowd
Family-friendly
LGBTQ+ friendly
Transgender safespace

Planning
Accepts reservations
Usually a wait

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
High chairs

Parking
Paid street parking
Parking

Pegasus Brooklyn Photos

Pegasus Brooklyn Location

Pegasus Brooklyn

New York Kings County Fort Hamilton 3rd Avenue

8610 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11209, USA

Pegasus Brooklyn Reviews

An average rating of ★4.6 from 647 user reviews.

brunchdinerpancakesorange juiceeggs benedicthome frieschicken and wafflesvenmobananas foster french toastfeta

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

We got up late and wanted Brunch. I checked Google maps and Pegasus Brooklyn was rated high. Although it was away from our direction of travel we decided to give it a try. Boy was that the right choice! My wife ordered Sunny and Kale and I the Bananas Foster French Toast. Both were delicious. The service was prompt, friendly and accommodating. Do yourself a favor and try Pegasus Brooklyn.
September 04 · Emilio Garcia
First time trying this place. Overall it was a good experience. The place is very clean. Staff could definitely be a tad more welcoming but it’s not a deal breaker. They were there and attentive. No smile, no small talk, no suggestions. I get they are a busy place but the slightest bit of friendliness goes a long way. Our drinks (lattes and orange juice) were great and we all got different omelets that were also very good. The potatoes were a favorite and the portions are big. We probably could’ve shared.
June 08 · A Snow
Pegasus Brooklyn is truly a local gem. Every time I walk in, it feels like family — warm, welcoming, and homey in the best way. The breakfast here is absolutely premium, with dishes that make every visit feel like a special occasion. It’s a small, cozy spot, so I definitely recommend calling ahead, but it’s hands down my go-to place whenever I want to enjoy a top-notch breakfast with my family.
September 08 · Jadore Love Photography
The perfect spot for brunch! The Benedict and chicken & waffles were spectacular. The waffles were perfectly soft & fluffy which complimented the crispy fried chicken so well. The Benedict sauce and home fries were to die for and the service was excellent too. The staff were so friendly which really adds to the overall experience. Highly recommend as it will quickly become one of your favorite places to enjoy a delicious meal. I cannot wait to come back with more friends.
February 15 · Nicole Montana
Food was good, waffle and chicken was on point and fluffy. Kick axx egg Benedict with bacon was good, wish the ciabatta would hold up more, but the time I got it, it was too wet to hold its texture. Omelette was light and fresh, so customers can adjust the sodium level themselves, I like that.We had cold brew coffee, had mine black, and it was good, acidity and taste were balanced.Our server was friendly and attentive.Would recommend this place for brunch, price is good for the portion received. Wish it was closer to home, def will be a spot I would frequent.Our wait time to be seated on a Saturday around 11 am was 40 minutes.
July 08 · Wien Loo