Pelham Pizza

- 113 Fifth Ave, Pelham, NY 10803

For residents of New York and the surrounding areas, finding that perfect neighborhood pizza spot is a serious matter. It's not just about a quick slice; it’s about tradition, quality ingredients, and a welcoming atmosphere. **Pelham Pizza**, located in Pelham, NY, stands as a prime example of a classic, family-friendly Italian-American restaurant that has consistently delivered on all fronts for decades, earning its place as a true local favorite.

More than just a pizzeria, Pelham Pizza is a full-service dining establishment renowned for its extensive menu that spans far beyond the traditional pie. It's a place where you can grab a quick, satisfying lunch, enjoy a relaxed family dinner, or cater your next big event. Known for its quick service and dedication to serving authentic, flavorful Italian comfort food, this spot offers a reliable and enjoyable dining experience every time you visit.

Testimonials from long-time customers, like those from a patron who returned decades after his first visit as a teenager, attest to the restaurant's enduring quality and consistency. Now run by the original owner’s son, the commitment to the classic recipes and service style that made it popular remains the core of their business. Whether you’re stopping in for a regular slice, indulging in their highly-praised **Grandma slice**, or sitting down for a full dinner, you're experiencing a piece of local New York culinary history.

The vibe at Pelham Pizza is described as **casual, cozy, and trendy**, creating an approachable setting that appeals to everyone from college students and tourists to local families and large groups. With options for everything from a quick bite to a full, seated dinner, it’s a versatile choice for nearly any occasion.

## Location and Accessibility

Pelham Pizza is conveniently situated at **113 Fifth Ave, Pelham, NY 10803, USA**. This address places it right in the heart of Pelham, making it easily accessible for local residents and those traveling from other parts of the New York metropolitan area. Pelham itself is a charming village in Westchester County, just a short distance from the bustling city, making it a perfect spot for an authentic suburban New York dining experience.

For those driving, the location offers **paid street parking** options nearby. Crucially, the restaurant is committed to welcoming all members of the community and visitors, featuring excellent accessibility with both a **wheelchair-accessible entrance** and **wheelchair-accessible seating** within the dining area.

The central location on Fifth Avenue also means the restaurant is easily found and often a stop recommended by other local businesses, underscoring its reputation within the community.

## Services Offered

Pelham Pizza provides a variety of service options designed to accommodate the modern New Yorker's busy schedule and diverse dining preferences. Whether you’re looking to grab and go or settle in for a long meal, they have you covered.

• **Dine-in:** Full table service is available, providing a comfortable seating arrangement for lunch, dinner, or dessert. This option includes the use of the restaurant’s amenities like the restroom.
• **Takeout:** Perfect for quickly picking up your favorite dishes to enjoy at home or on the go.
• **Delivery:** The convenience of having Pelham Pizza’s delicious offerings brought directly to your door.
• **Catering:** Specialized service to provide large orders for parties, corporate events, or family gatherings, ensuring your guests enjoy authentic Italian food.
• **Reservations:** The establishment accepts reservations, which is helpful for planning visits, especially for larger groups or during peak dining hours.

## Features / Highlights

Pelham Pizza distinguishes itself through a combination of fast, professional service, an extensive menu, and an atmosphere that makes every customer feel at home. Their commitment to quality and variety shines through in the following key features:

• **Fast Service:** A core highlight that ensures customers can enjoy their meal without unnecessary delay, ideal for lunch breaks or busy evenings.
• **Serves Local Specialty:** Beyond standard pies, the kitchen excels at local culinary favorites, appealing to traditional New York tastes.
• **Extensive Menu Variety:** The offerings go well beyond pizza to include full Italian dinners, generous pasta dishes, calzones, rolls, seafood, hot wedges, and an array of appetizers and salads.
• **Comfort Food and Healthy Options:** The menu balances traditional Italian comfort food (like Lasagna, Baked Ziti, and Chicken Parmigiana) with options like various salads, grilled chicken dishes, and vegetarian alternatives.
• **Dining Versatility:** Popular for lunch, dinner, and solo dining, making it a flexible choice for all times of the day.
• **Family-Friendly Environment:** The atmosphere is welcoming to children, with high chairs available, and the casual crowd includes families and groups.
• **Beverage Selection:** The full offerings include **Alcohol, Beer, Wine**, as well as **Coffee, Cappuccino, Tea**, and various sodas.
• **Payment Flexibility:** Accepts all major payment methods including **Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments**.

## Contact Information

Customers can easily get in touch with Pelham Pizza for orders, reservations, or inquiries using the following information:

Address: 113 Fifth Ave, Pelham, NY 10803, USA

Phone: (914) 738-3554 or +1 914-738-3554

## What is Worth Choosing

Choosing Pelham Pizza offers a multi-faceted dining experience that consistently exceeds the expectations of a typical pizzeria. What truly makes it a worthwhile choice is the blend of decades-long tradition with a modern, all-inclusive dining approach.

First and foremost, the **pizza** is a standout. With a reputation for an incredible flavor profile and a perfect crust, the traditional pies are a must-try. New York locals and visitors alike have specifically praised their specialty slices, with the **Grandma Slice** being highlighted as "absolutely the best" by one patron. The variety is substantial, ranging from a basic **Regular Slice** and the deep-dish **Sicilian Slice** to full pies like the **Buffalo Chicken Pizza**, **Arugula Pizza**, or the unique **Reverse Crush Pizza**. They also thoughtfully offer a **Gluten Free Pizza (10")** option.

Beyond pizza, the depth of their **Italian Dinners and Pasta Specials** sets them apart. You can enjoy classic comfort food favorites such as **Baked Ziti**, **Lasagna**, or various pasta dishes with sauces like **Vodka Sauce** or **Carbonara Sauce**. Their dinner menu is equally impressive, featuring a wide selection of chicken and veal entrees, including **Chicken Parmigiana**, **Veal Francese**, and the flavorful **Chicken Scarpariello**. For those who enjoy seafood, their specialized dishes like **Shrimp Scampi** and **Calamari Marinara** are excellent choices.

Finally, the overall experience is enhanced by the staff and atmosphere. The owners and team are known for their friendly service and ability to make both regulars and new visitors feel like family. As a customer noted, the food, the service, and the memories it creates are all five stars. For anyone in the New York area seeking a reliable, high-quality Italian meal that balances tradition with variety, **Pelham Pizza** delivers a satisfying and memorable experience, whether you’re there for a fast slice or a full, relaxed dinner.

Pelham Pizza

113 Fifth Ave, Pelham, NY 10803, USA