Peppino's

- 469 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215

Peppino's is more than just a local pizzeria; it's a neighborhood staple that has been serving up authentic Italian cuisine and award-winning brick oven pizza in Brooklyn for years. The Park Slope location, situated on 5th Avenue, is a beloved spot where the tradition of family pizza-making meets a warm, welcoming, and casual dining atmosphere. The establishment, which expanded from its original Bay Ridge location in 2008, continues the legacy of two brothers carrying on their family's rich culinary heritage.

The focus at Peppino's is on high-quality ingredients, classic Italian flavors, and a full-service experience that extends far beyond a simple slice. From specialty brick oven pies to hearty pasta dishes, robust appetizers, and full catering options, Peppino's offers a genuine taste of old-school Brooklyn-Italian dining. Whether you are a lifelong New Yorker or just visiting the borough, Peppino's in Park Slope promises a consistent and satisfying meal in a cozy, community-focused setting.

For local residents, Peppino's represents reliability and quality, a place where the food is consistently good and the atmosphere is always family-friendly. It’s a perfect spot for a casual dinner, a quick lunch, or for feeding a large group, offering a versatile menu that caters to a wide variety of tastes, including excellent vegetarian options and comforting Italian-American classics.

The commitment to authenticity shines through, particularly in their brick oven pizzas, which deliver that signature, perfectly charred crust that Brooklyn pizza enthusiasts crave. The restaurant’s popularity is evident, often drawing a crowd, but the dedication of the staff and the quality of the food make it well worth the visit or the wait for delivery.

A notable example of their dedication to the craft is their acclaimed 'Pizza I Dunno,' which has been recognized as one of the best in Brooklyn, a testament to their innovative yet classic approach to pizza making.

The extensive menu is designed to please everyone at the table, ensuring that Peppino's is a go-to destination for full Italian dining, not just pizza. The blend of a full restaurant experience with quick-service options makes it a highly convenient and appealing choice in the bustling Park Slope neighborhood.

***

Location and Accessibility

Peppino's Park Slope location is conveniently positioned on one of the neighborhood's main arteries, making it easily accessible for Brooklynites and visitors alike. This prominent spot on 5th Avenue is known for its blend of local shops, eateries, and residential buildings, placing Peppino's right in the heart of a vibrant community.

The full address is: 469 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, USA.

For those traveling by public transportation, the restaurant is highly accessible, often just a block away from major subway lines that serve the area. This makes it a quick trip from surrounding Brooklyn neighborhoods and Manhattan.

If you are driving, paid street parking is available nearby, which, while typical of a busy New York City neighborhood, provides an option for those who prefer to travel by car.

A significant point of accessibility for all guests is that Peppino's facility is wheelchair accessible, including a wheelchair accessible entrance, restroom, and seating. This inclusive design ensures that everyone can enjoy a meal comfortably.

The physical location in Park Slope, known for its friendly, residential feel, complements the warm, cozy, and casual atmosphere of the restaurant itself. It’s a prime spot for both a pre- or post-activity meal, whether you've been strolling through Prospect Park or running errands along 5th Avenue.

***

Services Offered

Peppino's offers a comprehensive range of services to accommodate all dining preferences, from a quick meal on the go to a full, seated dinner. Their commitment to customer convenience is reflected in the multiple service options available:

• Dine-in: Enjoy the cozy, casual atmosphere with full table service. Reservations are accepted, which can be particularly helpful during peak hours, especially on weekends.
• Takeout: Place an order and pick up your meal at the restaurant for a quick and easy option.
• Delivery: Have your favorite Italian dishes brought right to your door. They offer standard and no-contact delivery options for maximum convenience and safety.
• Catering: Peppino's specializes in catering, making it a reliable choice for parties, gatherings, and corporate events that require authentic Italian food and pizza.
• Lunch and Dinner Service: Available for both midday and evening meals, catering to individual diners, families, and groups.
• Full Bar Offerings: The restaurant provides both beer and wine options to perfectly complement your pizza or pasta dish.
• Digital Payments: Accepts credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments for a seamless and modern transaction experience.

***

Features / Highlights

What sets Peppino's apart is a combination of its rich family history, the authenticity of its food, and the overall quality of the dining experience. These are the standout features that make it a local favorite:

• Authentic Brick Oven Pizza: The core of the Peppino's experience, featuring pizzas like the classic Margherita, Pizza Parlor (New York style), and specialty pies such as Pizza Alla Vodka and the famous Pizza I Dunno.
• Extensive Italian Menu: Beyond pizza, the menu includes a wide variety of classic comfort food and small plates, such as robust appetizers like Antipasto For 2 and Mozzarella & Tomato, a full array of pasta dishes (Penne Alla Vodka, Shrimp Marinara), and hot heroes (Chicken Parmigiana Hero, Cheese Steak Hero).
• Family-Friendly Atmosphere: The environment is casual and cozy, ideal for families and groups. High chairs are available, and the restaurant is recognized as being good for kids.
• Commitment to Quality Ingredients: Customers frequently praise the impeccable ingredients used in dishes like the authentic baked ziti and bruschetta.
• Vegetarian and Quick Options: The menu offers numerous vegetarian options (Veggie Pie Pizza, Spinach Roll, various pasta and side dishes) and is known for being an excellent spot for a quick bite during lunch or dinner.
• Great Beverages: Offers high-quality coffee, which is highlighted by patrons, alongside beer, wine, and standard drinks.
• Historic Brooklyn Presence: Part of a family legacy of pizza making that dates back decades, with the current iteration founded in 2004 and the Park Slope location opening in 2008.

***

Contact Information

To plan your visit, place an order, or inquire about catering services for the Park Slope location, you can use the following details:

Address: 469 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, USA

Phone: (718) 768-0176

***

What is worth choosing

If you are new to Peppino's, or a longtime patron looking for a perfect order, the reason to choose this Brooklyn favorite lies in its ability to deliver authentic, satisfying Italian comfort food with a personal touch. The consistent quality, a result of decades of family experience, makes it stand out in a neighborhood crowded with dining options.

The number one choice remains the Brick Oven Pizza. The Margherita Pizza is a fantastic entry point, featuring fresh mozzarella, sauce, and basil, embodying the traditional pie. For a more adventurous choice, try the Pizza Alla Vodka or the famous Pizza I Dunno (which requires asking the staff about the day's special creation).

Beyond pizza, Peppino's excels in its classic Italian-American entrees and sides. Highly recommended items that showcase the restaurant’s authentic flair include:

• Pasta Dishes: The Penne Alla Vodka is a creamy favorite, and the Penne Rustico or Penne Alla Boscaiola offer hearty, flavorful alternatives. For seafood lovers, the Shrimp Marinara or Shrimp Oreganata Pasta are excellent choices.
• Appetizers and Sides: Don’t overlook the Meatballs in Sauce (Polpette)—an old-school classic—or the generous Antipasto For 2, which is perfect for sharing. For sides, the Broccoli Rabe or Escarole sautéed with oil and garlic are flavorful, authentic accompaniments.
• Heroes and Rolls: For a portable and filling meal, the Chicken Parmigiana Roll or a classic Cheese Steak Hero are customer favorites, often praised for their generous portions and high-quality ingredients.

The final reason to choose Peppino's is the overall welcoming experience. Patrons consistently mention the polite staff and the family-like environment, where the owner often takes the time to chat with guests. This combination of top-tier food and warm hospitality is what solidifies Peppino's status as a true Park Slope gem. For an authentic slice of Brooklyn-Italian life, Peppino's is the clear choice.

Peppino's

469 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, USA