Pick A Bagel on 23rd Street: The Quintessential New York Bagel Experience

Pick A Bagel on 23rd street Introduce

For many New Yorkers, the bagel is not just a food item; it’s a way of life. The search for the perfect bagel—crisp on the outside, chewy on the inside, and full of flavor—is a lifelong quest. Nestled in a bustling corner of the city, Pick A Bagel on 23rd street has been a staple in the community, embodying the authentic New York bagel tradition for decades. Since its first location opened in 1988, this bagel shop has perfected the art of hand-rolling and kettle-boiling, creating bagels that are widely regarded as some of the best in the city. It's a place where the air is filled with the aroma of freshly baked goods and the energy of a city ready to start its day.

Pick A Bagel offers a far more extensive menu than what one might expect from a typical bagel shop. While their bagels are the main attraction, they serve as the foundation for an incredible variety of breakfast and lunch options. The shop has cultivated a reputation not just for its bagels, but for its comprehensive menu that includes everything from classic egg sandwiches and gourmet omelettes to an incredible array of cream cheeses and smoked fish. For those who need a quick and satisfying meal, or for an entire office looking to cater an event, Pick A Bagel delivers a reliable, high-quality, and unmistakably New York experience. It’s a classic food establishment that has stood the test of time, maintaining its dedication to fresh ingredients and traditional methods in a city that is constantly evolving.

Pick A Bagel is strategically located at 210 E 23rd St, New York, NY 10010, making it an ideal spot for a quick and convenient visit. The shop’s location places it within easy reach of residents, office workers, and students in the surrounding neighborhoods. Its position on 23rd street means it is well-connected to major public transportation hubs. Multiple subway lines and bus routes service the area, allowing easy access from various parts of Manhattan and beyond. This accessibility is a huge advantage for anyone looking to grab a quick breakfast before work or a delicious lunch during their break.

For those who prefer to drive, it is important to note that the area offers paid street parking. However, as with most of Manhattan, street parking can be challenging to find, especially during peak hours. Patrons are advised to be prepared for this or to utilize the many public transportation options available. Pick A Bagel is also a wheelchair-accessible establishment, with a wheelchair-accessible entrance and seating, ensuring that it is welcoming to all members of the community. This commitment to accessibility allows everyone to enjoy the delicious offerings and vibrant atmosphere of this quintessential New York bagel shop.

Pick A Bagel on 23rd street offers a wide range of services to cater to the diverse needs of its New York clientele.

Delivery: For those who can't make it to the shop, delivery service is a popular option. Whether you're at home, at the office, or at a hotel, you can have your favorite bagels and sandwiches brought right to you.
In-store Pickup & Shopping: The shop offers both in-store pickup for online or phone orders and traditional in-store shopping. This flexibility allows for a quick visit, which is especially beneficial for the fast-paced New York lifestyle.
Takeout & Dine-in: You can choose to take your order to go or stay and enjoy your meal inside. The dine-in option provides a casual setting to savor your food and coffee.
Catering: A significant aspect of Pick A Bagel's business is its comprehensive catering service. As a dedicated catering food and drink supplier, they offer a variety of platters for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, perfect for office events, parties, and family gatherings. Their catering menu includes everything from bagel and cream cheese platters to smoked fish and cold cuts platters, making it a one-stop-shop for event food.
Diverse Menu Offerings: The menu is vast, featuring a wide selection of items beyond bagels. Options include:
- Classic bagels, bialys, flats, and minis.
- A large variety of cream cheeses, including plain, flavored, low-calorie, and even tofu-based options.
- Hearty breakfast sandwiches, omelettes, and pancakes.
- An extensive selection of smoked fish, salads, and cold cut sandwiches.
- Muffins, pastries, and black and white cookies.
- A full coffee and tea menu, with both hot and iced options.

What makes Pick A Bagel a standout among the many bagel shops in New York City? It's a combination of unique features and highlights that have earned it a loyal following.

Best Bagels: Many customers consider their bagels to be among the best in the city. The bagels are hand-rolled, a traditional method that gives them their distinctive chewiness and texture. The "Everything Bagel" is a particular fan favorite, often described as "perfect."
Wide Selection: The sheer variety of the menu is a major highlight. From dozens of cream cheese flavors, including lox spread and unique low-cal and tofu spreads, to an extensive range of smoked fish and deli meats, there's something to satisfy every craving.
Comprehensive Catering: The ability to provide full catering services sets Pick A Bagel apart. Their detailed catering menus, including options like the "Executive Breakfast" and various platters, make them a go-to for corporate and personal events.
Quick & Efficient Service: While some customer experiences may vary, the overall reputation is one of a fast-paced, high-volume establishment that is efficient at getting customers their food promptly. This is crucial for a quick breakfast spot in a busy city.
LGBTQ+ Friendly: The shop is known for being LGBTQ+ friendly, creating an inclusive and welcoming environment for all customers.
Classic New York Feel: It has the feel of a classic New York establishment, offering a genuine taste of the city's food culture. This authentic feel is a major part of its appeal to both locals and visitors.

These highlights solidify Pick A Bagel's position not just as a place for a meal, but as a genuine piece of the New York food experience.

For all your bagel and catering needs, you can connect with Pick A Bagel using the following information:

Address: 210 E 23rd St, New York, NY 10010, USA

Phone: (212) 686-1414

In a city with an abundance of bagel shops, why is Pick A Bagel on 23rd street worth choosing? The answer lies in its ability to consistently deliver on quality, variety, and convenience. The heart of the shop is its bagel, and its commitment to the traditional hand-rolling and kettle-boiling process is evident in every bite. This dedication to craft is what makes their bagels a cut above the rest. When you toast an "Everything Bagel" from Pick A Bagel, you're experiencing a perfect blend of texture and flavor that is hard to find anywhere else.

Furthermore, the sheer scope of the menu means you can get much more than just a bagel. Whether you're in the mood for a classic cream cheese sandwich, a hearty smoked fish platter, or even a full catering service for your office, Pick A Bagel has you covered. The shop’s ability to cater to a wide range of tastes and needs, from vegan and vegetarian options to a plethora of healthy salads and quick bites, makes it a reliable choice for any time of day. While some customer experiences with service can be subjective, the overall consensus is that the quality of the food and the wide selection make it a place to visit repeatedly. It's a true New York institution, and for anyone looking for an authentic and satisfying bagel experience, Pick A Bagel on 23rd street is a must-visit destination.

Pick A Bagel on 23rd street Food & drink

Eggs, Omelettes, Pancakes and Oat Meal
2 Eggs Sandwich $6.50
Western Omelette $14.95
Ham, peppers and onions. On a plate.
Greek Omelette $14.95
Black olives, tomatoes, feta.
Veggie Omelette $14.95
Mushroom, peppers, scallion, broccoli and tomatoes.
L.E.O. Omelette $17.25
Lox, eggs and onions.
Pancakes $10.00
2 large pancakes with maple syrup.
1 Of Each Breakfast Platter $16.75
1 egg, 1 sausage patty, 1 sausage link, 1 pancake and 1 hashbrown.
Hash-Brown Patty $4.25

Bagels, Flats and Minis
BAGELS $2.35
DOZEN BAGELS $28.20
Fourteen to a dozen. Please specify in special instructions if you would like more than one of any kind.
FLAT BAGELS $3.95
DOZEN FLAT BAGELS $39.00
Please specify in special instructions if you would like more than one of any kind.
MINI BAGELS $1.95
AS IS , NO SANDWICHES NOT SLICED
BIALYS $2.35
BAGEL CHIPS $10.95
OUR OWN BAGEL CHIPS PACKED IN A BOX.

Muffins and Pastries
Muffins $6.25
Crumb Cakes And Pound Cakes $5.95
Assorted Danishes And Turnovers $5.95
Assorted Croissants $4.90
Black And White Cookies $5.00
1 Dozen Mini Black And White $13.25

Coffee and Tea
Coffee
Decaf Coffee
Hazelnut Coffee
Hot Chocolate
Tea And Herbal Tea
Latte
Cappuccino
Espresso
Iced Coffee
Iced Decaf Coffee
Ice Hazelnut Coffee
Iced Cappuccino
Iced Latte
Fresh Brewed Ice Tea
Cold Brew Ice Coffee
Coffee Box $39.95
Serves 10-12. Includes milk , cups and condiments.

Cream Cheese Sandwiches
Butter Bagel $4.25
Peanut Butter $7.95
Peanut butter
Plain Cream Cheese Sandwich $6.75
Flavored Cream Cheese $7.95
LOX SPREAD SANDWICH $9.95
LOX CAPERS DILL SANDWICH $10.75
LCD SPREAD

Cream Cheese by the LB'
Plain Cream Cheese By The LB'
Flavored Cream Cheese By The LB'
All flavors and sizes.
Lox Spread By The LB'
LOX CAPERS DILL SPREAD BY THE LB'
LCD ( BY THE LB' )
Peanut Butter By The LB'
Butter By The LB'
Jelly By The LB'

Low-Cal Cream Cheese Sandwiches
Low Calorie Cream Cheese $6.50
Low-Cal Veggie Cream Cheese $7.50
Low-cal reduced fat cream cheese.
Low-Cal Scallion Cream Cheese $7.25
Low-cal reduced fat cream cheese.

Low-Cal Cream Cheese by the LB'
Low-Cal Cream Cheese By The LB'
Low-Cal Scallion Cream Cheese By The LB'
Low-Cal Veggie Cream Cheese By The LB'
Low-Cal Lox Spread By The LB'
Contains fish.

Tofu Cream Cheese Sandwiches
Plain Tofu Cream Cheese $6.50
Vegan and non dairy cream cheese.
Veggie Tofu Cream Cheese $7.50
Vegan and non dairy cream cheese.
Scallion Tofu Cream Cheese $7.50
Vegan and non dairy cream cheese.

Tofu Cream Cheese by the LB'
Plain Tofu Cream Cheese By The LB'
Scallion Tofu Cream Cheese By The LB'
Veggie Tofu Cream Cheese By The LB'

Smoked Fish Sandwiches
Smoked Salmon Sandwich $20.50
A fresh, thinly sliced norwegian salmon.
Belly Lox Sandwich $20.50
An extremely salty norwegian salmon.
White Fish Sandwich $17.25
Baked Salmon Sandwich $18.25
Sable Sandwich $20.75
AVOCADO TOAST $10.50
AVOCADO TOAST

Smoked Fish and Appetizers by the LB'
Nova Scotia Salmon By The LB'
Belly Lox By The LB'
White Fish By The LB'
Baked Salmon By The LB'
Sable By The LB'
AVOCADO TOAST $10.95
AVOCADO ON YOUR CHOICE OF BREAD

Salads and Spreads Sandwiches
Egg Salad Sandwich $9.75
Tuna Salad Sandwich $14.25
Veggie Tuna Sandwich $14.25
Chicken Salad Sandwich $14.25
Baked Salmon Salad Sandwich $15.95
White Fish Salad Sandwich $15.95
AVOCADO TOAST $10.50
AVOCADO TOAST

Salads and Spreads by the LB'
Egg Salad By LB'
Tuna Salad By LB'
Veggie Tuna By LB'
Chicken Salad By LB'
Baked Salmon Salad By LB'
White Fish Salad By LB'

Cold Cuts Sandwiches
Cold Cuts Sandwich $14.95
Boar’s head cold cuts.
BLT Sandwich $10.25
Bacon, lettuce, tomato.

Cold Cuts Combination Sandwiches
Cold Cuts Combination Sandwiches $18.95
Boar’s head cold cuts.

Cold Cuts by the LB'
Roast Beef By LB'
Corned Beef By LB'
Pastrami By LB'
Turkey Breast
Honey Turkey By LB'
Cracked Pepper Turkey By LB'
Ham By LB'
Genoa Salami By LB'

Chicken Sandwiches
Lemon And Herbs Grilled Chicken Sandwich $14.50
Breaded Chicken Cutlet, Schnitzel Sandwich $14.50

Chicken by the LB'
Lemon And Herbs Grilled Chicken By LB'
Breaded Chicken - Schnitzel - By LB'

Hard Cheese Sandwiches
Hard Cheese Sandwiches $7.25

Hard Cheese by the LB'
American Cheese By LB'
Swiss Cheese By LB'
Muenster Cheese By LB'
Provalon Cheese By LB'
Cheddar Cheese By LB'
Jalapeno Pepper Jack Cheese By LB’
Mozzarella Cheese By LB'

Fresh Juice Bar
Juice Bar
Fresh Carrot Juice $8.75
Fresh Squeezed Orange Juice $9.75

Soups
Chicken Noodle Soup

Cold Beverages
Canned Soda $2.95
Bottled Soda $4.25
20 oz.
Snapple $4.25
Poland Spring
Martinelli’s Apple Juice $4.95
Red Bull Energy $4.95
Gatorade $4.25
Vitamin Water $4.25
Tropicana Juices
Pure Leaf Ice Tea $4.50
Nestle Quick $4.75
Chocolate
Vita Coco - Coconut Juice $4.95

Smoked Fish and Appetizers Platter for 2
Nova Scotia Platter $29.50
Fresh cut norwegian smoked salmon with tomatoes, lemon wedge, onions and capers.
Smoked Sable Platter $29.50
Sliced to order smoked sable with tomatoes, onions lemon wedge and capers.
Smoked White Fish $24.50
A fresh cut from a large juicy white fish tomatoes, onions a wedge of lemon and capers.
Smoked Fish Supreme Platter $34.50
Nova scotia salmon, sable and white fish cut to order with all you need to enjoy a brunch for 2. Including cream cheese bagels and vegetables.

Fresh Fruit and Vegetables
FRESH SLICED FRUIT SALAD $4.50
Fruit salad, fruit platters, bowls and parfait.
BANANA $1.50
RED Or GREEN APPLE $1.50

Chips and Snacks
Doritos $2.00
Lay’s Chips $2.00
RUFFLES $2.00

CATERING — BREAKFAST, LUNCH & DINNER
BUILD YOUR OWN CATERING
PICK YOUR PLATTERS MIX & MATCH
BREAKFAST EGGS ON WRAPS / BAGELS $109.95
ASSORTED BAGELS OR WRAP WITH EGGS & CHEESE SERVES 10
OFFICE BREAKFAST - SERVES 10 $164.95
FRESH BAKED BAGEL PLATTER -- -- ASSORTED CREAM CHEESE PLATTER WITH BUTTER & JELLY -- -- FRESH BAKED MINI DANISHES & CROISSANTS
CONTINENTAL BREAKFAST - SERVES 10 $229.95
-- FRESH BAKED BAGEL PLATTER -- ASSORTED CREAM CHEESE PLATTER -- FRUIT BOWL -- COFFEE BOX -- PLATTER OF SWEETS --
THE EXECUTIVE BREAKFAST - SERVES 10 $399.95
-- FRESH SLICED SMOKED SALMON PLATTER WITH VEGGIES -- FRESH BAGEL PLATTER -- ASSORTED CREAM CHEESE PLATTER, BUTTER & JELLY -- A FRESH BAKED MINI DANISHES & CROISSANTS -- FRUIT BOWL -- COFFEE BOX -- ORANGE JUICE --
COLD CUTS PLATTER - SERVES 10 $299.95
- A FRESH BAGEL PLATTER -- AN ASSORTED CREAM CHEESE PLATTER -- VEGETABLE PLATTER -- MACARONI SALAD, POTATO SALAD COLE SLAW & PICKLES -- CAN BE SERVED AS SANDWICHES AS WELL ---

BUILD YOUR OWN CATERING BREAKFAST
BAGEL PLATTER - 1 DOZEN (14 BAGELS) $40.00
FRESH BAKED SLICED BAGELS ON A PLATTER
SMOKED SALMON PLATTER (SERVES 10-12) $184.95
FRESH SLICED SALMON SERVED WITH TOMATOES, ONIONS, LEMON & CAPERS
ASSORTMENT OF CREAM CHEESE ON PLATTER - (SERVES 10-12) $74.95
YOUR CHOICE OF CREAM CHEESES ON A PLATTER
ASSORTMENT OF CREAM CHEESE ON PLATTER - (SERVES 20-25) $159.95
YOUR CHOICE OF CREAM CHEESES ON A PLATTER
SMALL MINI DANISHES & CROISSANTS PLATTER - ( SERVES 10 -12 ) $49.95
ASSORTED MINI DANISHES & MINI CROISSANTS BAKED TO ORDER WITH BUTTER & JELLY
LARGE MINI DANISHES & CROISSANT PLATTER - ( SERVES 20-25 ) $99.95
ASSORTED MINI DANISHES & MINI CROISSANTS BAKED TO ORDER WITH BUTTER & JELLY
LARGE FRUIT BOWL. (SERVES 10-12) $49.95
BOWL OF FRESH SEASONAL FRUIT
LARGE FRUIT PLATTER - (SERVES 20) $154.95
FRESH SLICED SEASONAL FRUIT ON A PLATTER SERVES 20
ORANGE JUICE $24.95
2 - 1/2 GALLON TROPICANA OJ
COFFEE BOX (SERVES 10-12) $39.95
INCLUDES MILK, CUPS & CONDIMENTS
PARFAIT CUP - PER PERSON $11.00
FAT FREE GREEK YOGURT, GRANOLA & FRESH FRUIT

Pick A Bagel on 23rd street Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pickup
In-store shopping
Takeout
Dine-in

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Coffee

Dining options
Breakfast

Crowd
LGBTQ+ friendly

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Parking
Paid street parking

Pick A Bagel on 23rd street Photos

Pick A Bagel on 23rd street Location

Pick A Bagel on 23rd street

New York New York County New York East 23rd Street

210 E 23rd St, New York, NY 10010, USA

Pick A Bagel on 23rd street Reviews

An average rating of ★3.9 from 254 user reviews.

pricecream cheeserevieweverything bagelownercashierchoicesbacon egg and cheesetomatopay

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Best bagels... wide selection. We weren't in the vicinity so got delivery. The Everything Bagel is perfect toasted with Vegemite and cheese!
August 15 · kristylee rackham
I came in & I looked at the menu and was met with stares from the 4 guys behind the counter. They rushed me with their eyes but I took my time to see what I wanted. The man rudely asked me”Can I help you?” I said “One sec, I’m looking at the menu.” They continued to stare as another person entered the store and he shouted out”next!”. I ordered a pastrami egg and cheese. They made my sandwich and charged me $10.99. I’m including a picture of the sandwich, please look at how much pastrami they gave me purposely. Literally 2 pieces of pastrami. To make your customers feel rushed and then mess with the quality of their food and I did nothing but walk in on a beautiful saturday afternoon to just eat. I’ll make sure to skip this place going forward. And please exercise caution when you come here. I guess it depends on how they’re feeling or maybe how you look that determines how you’ll be treated. In times like this, this behavior is very disappointing.
May 31 · Candace Henson
my genuine bagel goat of new york city. wonderful people, more selections than you could ever want, incredibly fast, and so much cream cheese its like the same width as the bagel itself (i love cream cheese). my only critique is that its a little expensive, but obviously its more than worth it. if there are 0 pick a bagel fans on earth i am dead. if you are reading this go to pick a bagel i dont care what time of the day it is
September 12 · Emma Pesa
Thank you Service specially orange juice you have to try especially made. This is the best orange juice I’ve ever tasted. And I must say that they’re bagel or on point fourth time coming here and it’s worth it. Trust me. But a little on the expensive side!!!!!!
March 27 · Perseverance
Absolutely LOVE this place! The bald gentleman behind the counter was very helpful and nice, the first question I asked is if they had tofu cream cheese and not only did they have it I was so pleased to learn that they had multiple flavors and made it in the house! It’s rare to be able to find a really tasty bagel, but then also get to cream cheese if you’re vegan so I will definitely be back to this place and recommending it to my friends in the area :-) the general behind the counter Staff was also very nice. thank you!!
June 10 · Alessandra Delacruz