Polkadot Cake Shop Introduce
For New Jersey residents planning any event, from an intimate baby shower to an extravagant wedding, **Polkadot Cake Shop** in Lyndhurst offers a full-service, custom solution for all dessert and mobile bar needs. Far exceeding the typical bakery experience, Polkadot Cake Shop has cemented its reputation as a premier destination for edible works of art that are as delicious as they are visually stunning. Customers consistently rave that the cakes and custom treats not only capture their vision with "flawless perfection" but are also incredibly **moist and flavorful**, proving that custom design never compromises taste.
This Bergen County gem operates as a dedicated **Cake shop, Dessert shop, Mobile caterer**, and specialized **Wedding bakery**. The shop's commitment to quality is evident in their use of high-quality ingredients, like real butter and pure Madagascar vanilla beans, baking all treats from scratch in small batches. Owner and lead designer Arlene Murray, who **identifies as women-owned**, leads a team focused on transforming creative visions into reality, whether it's an elegant tiered wedding cake, a fun-themed birthday masterpiece, or a full **Dessert Table** spread.
Polkadot Cake Shop is particularly celebrated for its expansive and creative menu, which includes highly praised **custom cookies** that defy expectations of decorated sugar treats. They offer a wealth of flavors, including signature options like **Maple French Toast** and **Guinness® Chocolate** cakes, alongside traditional favorites. Importantly for many New Jersey families, Polkadot Cake Shop is a **peanut-free** establishment, and they gladly offer **Gluten-Free and Egg-Free** options by request, ensuring everyone can enjoy their sweet creations.
Polkadot Cake Shop is centrally located at **137 Stuyvesant Ave, Lyndhurst, NJ 07071, USA**. Situated in the heart of Lyndhurst, this location is easily accessible for customers throughout Northern New Jersey and even parts of Central New Jersey and New York, thanks to their dedicated **Delivery** service.
Given their focus on customer appointments and order pickups, the shop is designed for smooth visits. Patrons will find a **wheelchair accessible entrance** and **wheelchair accessible parking lot**, providing necessary convenience for all guests picking up orders. It is important to note that the shop operates on an **Appointment required** basis, ensuring that every customer receives dedicated attention during their consultation or pickup. This structure, combined with easy access via major regional roads, makes Polkadot Cake Shop a convenient choice for securing high-quality custom desserts for any event.
Polkadot Cake Shop provides a comprehensive suite of services that extend far beyond a traditional storefront, specializing in high-end event catering.
- **Custom Cake Design:** Specializes in tiered cakes, single layer cakes, and sculpted cakes for all occasions, using both buttercream and fondant, with custom designs beginning at $175.00.
- **Custom Dessert Tables:** Offers a full-service setup for dessert tables, featuring a wide variety of treats like **Signature Cannoli Cones, French Macarons, Decorated Sugar Cookies, Mason Jar Pies**, and many others, customizable by theme and color.
- **Mobile Camper & Bar Services:** Utilizes the **Polkadot Cake & Cocktail Camper** for **Onsite services**, providing unique event packages that include desserts, custom DIY stations (like s'mores and ice cream sundaes), and professional **Cocktail service** with fully insured and certified bartenders.
- **Catering Packages:** Offers structured packages like the "Classic Package" and shorter "Drive-By" options, perfect for weddings, corporate events, and large parties, with custom additions like a Lemonade Bar or Coffee/Hot Cocoa Bar.
- **Allergen-Friendly Options:** Provides **peanut-free** products with requested options for **Gluten Free** and **Egg Free** cakes and desserts.
- **Consultations and Tastings:** Operates as an appointment-only shop. Tasting consultations are available via phone or in-shop when necessary, with convenient **To-Go Tasting Boxes** available for purchase online.
- **Delivery and Pickup:** Offers **In-store pickup** (by appointment) and flexible **Delivery** service across Northern and Central NJ, and parts of NY (delivery fee applies).
Polkadot Cake Shop’s success is built on a range of exceptional features that draw repeat customers from across the region for their special events.
- **Edible Artistry & Taste:** Renowned for producing treats that are beautiful ("magnificent") and exceptionally delicious, with "perfect proportions of cake to filling." They excel in making custom sugar cookies that are "unbelievable."
- **Extensive Customization and Flavor Variety:** Boasts a vast menu of signature, classic, premium, and even **Liquor Infused** cake and cupcake flavors, offering rare choices like **Guinness® Chocolate, Maple French Toast, Cookies & Cream**, and **Toffee Caramel Crunch**.
- **Award-Winning Mobile Catering:** Their **Polkadot Cake & Cocktail Camper** provides a unique and memorable catering service, blending custom desserts with professional cocktail bar service for a true "one stop shop" event solution.
- **Safety and Dietary Accommodations:** Operates as a **peanut-free custom bake shop**, offering peace of mind to guests with severe allergies, along with excellent **Gluten Free and Egg Free** options.
- **Exceptional Customer Service:** Highly praised for the team's professional, quick, and easy communication, from initial inquiry and quoting to design coordination, payment, and final delivery.
- **Full Event Support:** Offers essential add-ons like rentals for towers, displays, stands, backdrops, and linens, allowing the cakes and treats to be elegantly displayed as the centerpieces of any party.
To begin planning your custom cake, dessert table, or mobile catering service with the Polkadot Cake Shop team, please use the following contact details:
**Address:** 137 Stuyvesant Ave, Lyndhurst, NJ 07071, USA
**Phone:** (551) 333-3195
For New Jersey residents, choosing **Polkadot Cake Shop** is choosing a seamless, creative, and delicious catering partner for life's most memorable moments. What makes this local business unequivocally worth choosing is its ability to deliver stunning, highly customized aesthetics without ever sacrificing quality or flavor. Unlike bakeries that may prioritize looks over taste, Polkadot Cake Shop ensures the dessert is the highlight of the event, with moist cakes, perfect fillings, and highly lauded custom cookies that everyone will enjoy.
The dual service of a high-end **custom cake shop** and an innovative **mobile catering and cocktail service** through their vintage camper provides unique flexibility for large and small events across New Jersey and the greater Tri-State area. From its commitment to being **peanut-free** and offering numerous **allergen-friendly** alternatives to its highly praised, responsive customer service, every touchpoint is designed to make the ordering process easy and enjoyable.
In conclusion, if you are looking for a **women-owned**, **LGBTQ+ friendly** business in Bergen County that combines culinary artistry, innovative catering, and a genuinely delicious product, Polkadot Cake Shop is the premier choice that is highly recommended by local patrons for delivering a "wow factor" every time.
Polkadot Cake Shop Details
From the business
- Identifies as women-owned
Service options
- Delivery
- In-store pickup
- Onsite services
- Takeout
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible entrance
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
Crowd
- LGBTQ+ friendly
Planning
- Appointment required
- Quick visit
Payments
- Checks
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- Credit cards
Polkadot Cake Shop Photos










Polkadot Cake Shop Location
Polkadot Cake Shop
137 Stuyvesant Ave, Lyndhurst, NJ 07071, USA
Polkadot Cake Shop Reviews
cupcakespartycookiesdesignbaby showerideacreativetablebridal showersisters
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1Arlene at Polkadot Cake Shop was wonderful. She helped make my daughter’s party extra special by bringing her vision of the cake she wanted to life. Definitely exceeded our expectations. And to make things even better, the cake was not only beautiful but delicious. We will definitely get our cakes from here again for our next special event. Highly recommended!
September 30 · Miryam JimenezI reached out to a few bakeries for a quote for my sister’s baby shower - polka dot cake shop was recommended by another baker. I reached out and received a quick response with some questions and then there was a quick turn around for a quote.The process was very easy, from choosing the flavors, design, to making the payment and picking up the baked goods. I ordered a custom cake and custom cookies - there are a lot of choices for flavors. Not only were they beautiful, they were all delicious. I did not believe customized sugar cookies could actually be delicious - these were unbelievable and proved me wrong. I highly recommend this bakery and look forward to working with Arlene again.
July 02 · Dalia ElachiPolkadot Cake Shop is the absolute best!!Their staff is super friendly and accommodating, prices are good, and they are master bakers!I sent them a photo of my friend’s dog, and they somehow created a cake with the dogs head as the topper. It looked so real, it would’ve won any baking competition on TV. The best part is that it was truly one of the most delicious cakes I’ve ever eaten in my entire life!!I can’t recommend polkadot cake shop highly enough! Try them out - you will not be disappointed
July 15 · Michael GriffoPolkadot is my go-to for all our truly special occasions, she did my husband's 50th and now my daughter's college graduation. This was a black and white cake bottom with espresso filling and a vanilla top with chocolate. Everyone just raved about it.I sent them a small picture idea and this marvelous piece was received. Excellent all the way around, service is amazing!!
June 10 · Rose LafargaArlene and her team were such a pleasure to work with. She made our dreams come true and her work is just stunning! The dessert table was the highlight of my party with multiple guests telling me they were the best cupcakes they have ever had. Cannot recommend highly enough and will definitely be using her again in the future! Thank you!! 💕💕
August 15 · Nicole L
More restaurants near me

1 Stuyvesant Ave, Lyndhurst, NJ 07071, USA

33 Ridge Rd, Lyndhurst, NJ 07071, USA

263 Ridge Rd, Lyndhurst, NJ 07071, USA

30 Kingsland Rd, Clifton, NJ 07014, USA

167 Park Ave, Rutherford, NJ 07070, USA

200 Park Ave, Rutherford, NJ 07070, USA

70 Kingsland Rd, Clifton, NJ 07014, USA

6 Highland Cross, Rutherford, NJ 07070, USA

98 Kingsland Rd, Clifton, NJ 07014, USA

106 Kingsland Rd, Clifton, NJ 07014, USA

323 Riverside Ave, Rutherford, NJ 07070, USA

38-88 Felician Way, Rutherford, NJ 07070, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Trending Dining Insights Posts





