Polly's NYC Introduce
In a city filled with countless bars and lounges, finding a place that truly stands out from the crowd is a special discovery. Polly's NYC offers a distinctive and memorable experience, setting it apart as more than just another Midtown bar. It's a "speakeasy" style establishment that plays on the charm and allure of a hidden gem, creating a sense of adventure from the moment you arrive. The atmosphere is a blend of lively energy and cool sophistication, with a vibe that feels both fun and a "step above" the average bar scene. The decor is a key part of this experience, with a level of detail that contributes to the unique and immersive environment. It's the kind of place where you can feel the energy in the air, a perfect backdrop for a night out with friends or a team happy hour. While it can be a bustling and energetic spot, the quality of the drinks and food remains a top priority, ensuring that the experience is as satisfying for your palate as it is for your sense of style. Polly's NYC captures the spirit of New York City nightlife—it's bold, a little mysterious, and ultimately, a great place to have a good time. It’s a popular choice for both small groups and larger gatherings, proving its versatility and appeal to a wide range of customers. For anyone looking to break away from the predictable and explore something a little more exciting, this bar offers an excellent option that is both a destination and a memorable experience in itself.
Polly's NYC is conveniently located at 204 W 55th St, New York, NY 10019, USA. This address places it firmly in the heart of Midtown Manhattan, an area renowned for its theaters, hotels, and vibrant business district. The location is a significant advantage, as it is easily accessible from various parts of the city. The bar's proximity to major transportation hubs is a key feature; it's within a short walking distance of multiple subway lines, including the N, Q, R, W, B, D, E, and F trains. This makes it a perfect destination for both local residents and tourists staying in the area. Its location on West 55th Street, nestled between 7th Avenue and Broadway, puts it just steps away from some of the city's most famous attractions, like Carnegie Hall and Broadway theaters. For those coming from outside the neighborhood, the bar is easy to find, even with its "secret entrance" concept, which is part of the fun. The bustling street provides ample opportunities for cabs and rideshares to drop off and pick up guests. This central, well-connected location is a major reason why Polly's NYC is a great spot for team outings and social gatherings, as it's a convenient meeting point for everyone.
The services offered at Polly's NYC are centered around providing a top-tier bar and dining experience in a unique setting. The core offering is a wide variety of drinks, with a particular focus on craft cocktails and other mixed drinks, as noted by customer reviews. The bar's staff is a key part of the service, with employees like Zoey and KayTee being highlighted for their exceptional service, attentiveness, and friendly demeanor. The establishment also serves food, and its menu includes popular items like brisket nachos, suggesting a focus on elevated bar food that complements the drinks. Polly's NYC is equipped to handle a variety of occasions, from a casual night out for a small group to a large-scale happy hour for a team of 16 people. The bar's ability to accommodate larger groups speaks to its professional and well-managed service. While the atmosphere is lively and sometimes loud, the service remains a priority, with staff ensuring that all of their guests' needs are met. The overall service model is designed to be a step above the ordinary, providing a personalized and memorable experience for every customer who walks through the door.
Services offered include:
- A wide variety of alcoholic beverages, including craft cocktails.
- A selection of food items, such as nachos.
- Accommodations for both small groups and large gatherings like happy hours.
- Professional and highly attentive staff.
- A unique "speakeasy" style atmosphere.
Polly's NYC is defined by its unique features and highlights that make it a compelling destination in New York City's bar scene. The most prominent feature is its "speakeasy" concept, which includes a "secret entrance" and a carefully detailed decor. This creates an immersive and fun experience for guests from the very beginning. The ambiance is another key highlight, described as "lively and fun" and "a step above a normal bar in Midtown." This unique vibe attracts a crowd looking for something different and more exciting than the usual spot. The quality of the food and drinks is also a significant highlight, with patrons consistently praising the drinks and mentioning specific food items like the brisket nachos. This focus on high-quality offerings ensures that the experience is not just about the atmosphere but also about great taste. The staff is repeatedly mentioned in reviews as being a major highlight; employees are described as being wonderful, great, and providing exceptional service. Their ability to handle large groups with ease and their friendly, personable nature contribute significantly to the positive experience. The combination of a creative concept, delicious food and drinks, and outstanding service makes Polly's NYC a standout choice for a memorable night out.
Features and highlights of Polly's NYC include:
- A unique and creative speakeasy-style concept.
- Detailed and immersive decor.
- A lively and fun atmosphere.
- High-quality food and drinks, including craft cocktails.
- Exceptional and attentive staff.
- Ability to host both small and large groups.
To visit or get in touch with Polly's NYC, the address is 204 W 55th St, New York, NY 10019, USA. This central Midtown location is a key part of its appeal and is easy to find for anyone familiar with the area. The primary phone number for the bar is (646) 590-2034. For those calling from a mobile phone or from outside the United States, the number can be reached by dialing +1 646-590-2034. The phone number is a direct way to inquire about reservations, events, or general information, providing a clear path for potential guests to get in touch. This straightforward contact information ensures that despite its "secret" theme, the bar is still fully accessible for planning purposes. The combination of a fixed, well-known address and a clear phone number makes it simple for customers to make arrangements and find the location, allowing them to focus on enjoying the unique experience that awaits them inside.
Polly's NYC is worth choosing for a truly unique and memorable bar experience that goes beyond the typical night out in New York City. The speakeasy concept, with its creative decor and hidden entrance, makes it an adventure from the start. This bar is a great choice for a fun night with friends, a team happy hour, or a date, as the lively and energetic atmosphere is designed to entertain. The quality of the drinks and food is a major reason to visit; you're not just paying for the ambiance, but also for excellent cocktails and delicious bar snacks like the brisket nachos. The exceptional service provided by the staff, as noted by multiple patrons, is a significant differentiator. Their attentiveness and friendly demeanor make every guest feel welcome and well-cared for, which is a rare and valuable quality. While the lively atmosphere may be too loud for intimate conversation, it is perfect for a social outing where the goal is to have a great time and enjoy the vibrant energy. For anyone looking for a bar that offers a creative theme, high-quality offerings, and outstanding service in a central Midtown location, Polly's NYC is a fantastic choice that delivers on all fronts.
Polly's NYC Photos










Polly's NYC Location
Polly's NYC Reviews
Such a cool "speakeasy" place with detailed decor and a "secret entrance." Zoey was great with amazing drinks and food. I loved the brisket nachos, especially. The vibe was lively and fun, although I think it might be too loud for good conversation. All in all, a great find in the Upper mid-town area :)
April 25 · Chris AldrichI held a team happy hour here and it went perfectly!! KayTee was wonderful to work with and all of our needs were met with exceptional service. We were a group of 16. The vibe is unique and fun. It’s a step above a normal bar in Midtown. Everyone had a great time!
May 29 · Jessica OdrichPolly’s is an absolute gem tucked beneath Tanner Smith’s—a true speakeasy experience that transports you straight into 1920s New York. From the moment you descend the steps and push through the hidden door, you’re in for something special.The cocktails are top-notch. I couldn’t get enough of the Mezcal Inferno—smoky, fruity, and dangerously easy to drink (I had three!). Every drink we tried was expertly crafted and full of character.Food-wise, we were equally impressed. The Buffalo spring rolls are a must—crispy, flavorful, and addictive. But the real standout? The flatbreads. Generously loaded with toppings and melty cheese, every bite delivered that perfect cheese pull moment.Whether you’re looking to make new friends or wow out-of-towners, Polly’s nails the vibe. Cool, intimate, and unforgettable. Can’t wait to go back!
May 03 · John AllieVery romantic and accommodating venue locating in a perfect spot. The staff was able to sneak my wife and I in before a later reservations. Drinks were great and wait staff did great for managing so many tables. The atmosphere was very neat and relaxing. Skip the 40 dollar drink bars that paid for article placement and come here. Real deal fun.
September 14 · The LaBranchesSuch a cute find. The vibes of the place are impeccable: intimate, chic, and just fun. The service was excellent and the drinks were so fun. Our group loved First Thirst, and the theatrics that come with the drink made it even better. This will be one of my recommendations for friends visiting NYC for sure!
September 18 · Kiarra Furey
More restaurants near me

411 W 35th St, New York, NY 10001, USA

441 9th Ave, New York, NY 10001, USA

371 W 34th St., New York, NY 10001, USA

445 W 35th St, New York, NY 10001, USA

304 W 34th St., New York, NY 10001, USA

316 W 34th St., New York, NY 10001, USA

316 W 34th St., New York, NY 10001, USA

330 W 34th St., New York, NY 10001, USA

330 W 34th St., New York, NY 10001, USA

325 W 33rd St, New York, NY 10001, USA

402 W 34th St., New York, NY 10001, USA

455 W 34th St., New York, NY 10001, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Trending Dining Insights Posts





