Prime Catch: A Cozy and Trendy Steakhouse in New York's Theatre District

Prime Catch Introduce

In the bustling heart of New York’s Theatre District, where dining options are abundant,

Prime Catch

distinguishes itself as a destination for those seeking a classic steakhouse experience with a cozy, modern twist. This trendy and intimate restaurant and bar offers a warm and inviting atmosphere that feels like a welcome escape from the city’s non-stop energy. With a menu that specializes in both high-quality steaks and fresh seafood, Prime Catch caters to a wide range of tastes. The romantic and trendy vibe, complemented by features like a cozy fireplace and live music, makes it an ideal spot for a special night out. Whether you’re celebrating a birthday, planning a romantic dinner, or simply looking for a quality meal before catching a show, Prime Catch provides a setting that is both sophisticated and comfortable.

---

Prime Catch is ideally located at

140 W 46th St, New York, NY 10036

, placing it in a highly convenient and accessible area of Manhattan's Theatre District. Its central location makes it a great choice for tourists visiting Times Square and Broadway, as well as for locals working in the area. The restaurant is easily reachable via multiple subway lines and bus routes, making it a simple commute from almost anywhere in the city. The availability of both

paid street parking

and nearby parking garages provides options for those driving.

The restaurant is committed to accessibility for all guests, offering a

wheelchair accessible entrance

wheelchair accessible restroom

, and

wheelchair accessible seating

. This ensures that all patrons can enjoy their dining experience comfortably. The option for

outdoor seating

is also a popular feature, allowing guests to enjoy their meal while taking in the lively street atmosphere. It's a great spot for a quick bite or a full dinner, and reservations are accepted and

recommended

for dinner, especially on busy nights.

---

Services Offered

Dine-in and Outdoor Seating:
The restaurant offers a full dine-in experience in a trendy and cozy atmosphere. The addition of outdoor seating provides a chance to enjoy the urban environment while dining.
Takeout and Delivery:
For those who prefer to eat at home, Prime Catch offers
takeout
,
curbside pickup
, and
delivery
services, making it easy to enjoy their menu wherever you are.
Extensive Bar Service:
The onsite bar serves a wide selection of beverages, including a
great beer selection, great cocktails, and a great wine list
. They also offer a
happy hour
, which is a perfect opportunity to enjoy their drinks at a reduced price.
Diverse Menu:
While specializing in steaks and seafood, the menu includes a variety of other offerings, such as appetizers, soups, salads, and non-steak entrees like
Chicken Parmesan
and
Prime Catch Burger
.
Dessert and Coffee:
The restaurant provides a full dessert menu and a selection of coffee, allowing for a complete dining experience from appetizer to dessert.

---

Features & Highlights

Cozy and Romantic Atmosphere:
Prime Catch is known for its romantic and cozy ambiance, which is enhanced by a fireplace and stylish decor. This makes it an ideal spot for a date night or a special celebration.
Great Drinks Menu:
The bar is a highlight, with an impressive selection of cocktails, beer, and a particularly noteworthy wine list. The happy hour specials are a great way to experience this aspect of the restaurant.
Live Music:
The presence of
live music
adds to the sophisticated and entertaining atmosphere, making a night at Prime Catch a more memorable experience than a typical dinner out.
Diverse Offerings Beyond Steak:
Although a steakhouse, the menu's variety is a key feature. Diners who may not be in the mood for a steak can still find delicious options, such as the
Chicken Parmesan
or a seafood dish like the
Lobster Vodka Pasta
, which received positive feedback.
Inclusive and Friendly:
The restaurant is welcoming to all types of groups, from couples to tourists to larger parties. The amenities like Wi-Fi and restrooms contribute to a comfortable visit.

---

Contact Information

Address:

140 W 46th St, New York, NY 10036

Phone:

(646) 609-6113

---

What Is Worth Choosing

When dining at Prime Catch, the menu offers a wide range of options, but a few dishes are particularly noteworthy. For a classic steakhouse experience, the

Bone-In Ribeye

and

Filet Mignon

are popular choices that showcase the restaurant’s primary focus. It's recommended to inquire about the cooking process and express your preference clearly to ensure the steak is cooked to your liking.

Beyond the steaks, a standout dish that has received positive feedback is the

Chicken Parmesan

. One reviewer called it "so delicious," giving it a perfect rating, which suggests it is a reliable and well-prepared option. The

Lobster Vodka Pasta

is also a good choice, combining a rich flavor profile with fresh seafood. For sides, the classic

Mac & Cheese

Mashed Potatoes

are excellent complements to any main course. To round out your meal, be sure to ask about the dessert specials, as they are known for being a highlight of the dining experience.

For an enjoyable visit, consider making a

reservation

and perhaps starting your evening with a cocktail from their well-regarded bar. The romantic and cozy atmosphere is a key part of the appeal, making it a great spot for a special occasion.

Prime Catch Menu

Sides
French Fries $12.00
Fried potatoes.
Onion Rings $12.00
Fried battered onion.
Asparagus $12.00
Long Hot Peppers $12.00
Sautéed Onions $12.00
Mac & Cheese $12.00
Add lobster for an additional charge.
Hash-Brown $12.00
Fried shredded potatoes.
Broccolini $12.00
Mashed Potatoes $12.00
Sautéed Mushrooms $12.00
Cooked in oil or fat over heat.
Sautéed Spinach $12.00
Cream-Less Creamed Spinach $12.00
Baked Potato $8.00

Soups & Salads
Lobster Bisque $15.00
Topped with oyster crackers.
Caesar Salad $14.00
Add chicken, shrimp per for an additional charge.
French Onion $12.00
Wedge Salad $15.00
Iceberg lettuce served with tomatoes, chopped thick cut bacon and crumbled blue cheese dressing.
Prime Catch Salad $16.00
Spring mix salad with cucumber, onion, carrots, tomatoes & topped with feta cheese.

Entrées
Veal Chop Milanese $54.00
Panko breaded veal topped with arugula, fresh mozzarella, tomato & onion served with balsamic vinegar.
Chicken Parmesan $36.00
Panko breaded chicken topped with homemade marinara sauce & melted fresh mozzarella.
Chicken Milanese $30.00
Panko breaded shrimp topped with arugula, fresh mozzarella, tomato & onion served with balsamic vinegar.
Veal Chop Parmesan $54.00
Panko breaded veal topped with homemade marinara sauce & melted fresh mozzarella.
Prime Catch Burger $19.00
Served with lettuce, tomato, onion & pickles choice of American or provolone cheese.

Appetizers
Baked Clams $16.00
Baked in white wine garlic sauce.
Fried Calamari $18.00
Squid.
Thick Cut Bacon $5.50
Per.
Prime Catch Mussels $16.00
Selection of white wine or marinara sauce.
Burrata $18.00
Topped with roasted peppers over a bed of arugula, cherry tomatoes & prosciutto with a balsamic glaze.
Baked Shrimp $22.00
Baked in white wine garlic sauce.
Prime Catch Clams $16.00
Selection of white wine or marinara sauce.
Shrimp & Lobster Avocado $24.00
Served with a side of ponzu sauce.

Steaks & Chops
Lamb Chops $52.00
Bone-In Ribeye $78.00
Tomahawk $150.00
Bone-In NY Strip $72.00
Filet Mignon $54.00
Veal Chop $52.00
Beef from a young cow.

Seafood
Whole Lobster 2 Lb $105.00
Grilled Salmon $38.00
Cooked on a rack over a grill.
Prime Catch Seafood Pasta $65.00
Lobster, shrimp, clams, mussels & calamari served over choice of penne or linguine & a selection of white wine or marinara sauce.
Shrimp Parmesan $38.00
Panko breaded shrimp topped with homemade marinara sauce & melted fresh mozzarella.
Shrimp Milanese $38.00
Panko breaded shrimp topped with arugula, fresh mozzarella, tomato & onion served with balsamic vinegar.
Whole Grilled Branzino $52.00
Deboned with lemon herb seasoning.
Lobster Vodka Pasta $32.00
Lobster chunks over selection of penne or linguine served with homemade vodka sauce.

Prime Catch Details

Service options
Outdoor seating
Curbside pickup
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights
Fast service
Fireplace
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Great dessert
Great wine list
Live music

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance
Wheelchair accessible restroom
Wheelchair accessible seating

Offerings
Alcohol
Beer
Cocktails
Coffee
Happy hour drinks
Hard liquor
Small plates
Wine

Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities
Bar onsite
Restroom
Wi-Fi
Wi-Fi

Atmosphere
Cozy
Romantic
Trendy

Crowd
Groups
Tourists

Planning
Dinner reservations recommended
Accepts reservations

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids
High chairs

Prime Catch Photos

Prime Catch Location

Prime Catch

New York New York County New York West 46th Street

140 W 46th St, New York, NY 10036, USA

Prime Catch Reviews

An average rating of ★4.2 from 395 user reviews.

happy houroysterscalamariservice chargetimes squarelobster bisquebranzinochicken parmesanlobster ravioliwedge salad

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Writing this review for my husband and his cousin: This restaurant has sliding glass window type of doors to let fresh air in, which is nice, but it also lets in cigarette smoke from people walking by on the street - not so nice. As for the food, it LOOKED good, but the steaks were very bland. The Tomahawk was not cooked to order (it was undercooked) and the server brought back what looked to be the same steak that was burnt by a blow-torch. Sadly, the meal highlights were the bread basket, calamari, mozzarella sticks and side salad. Regarding the service, the server, Sal, brought the check to the table (which includes a surprise service charge) and stared down my husband while standing over him in an intimidating manner (as if to prepare for dine-and-dashers). Two thumbs down to the food & service. Will never come here again when visiting NYC. Highly disappointed.
July 13 · Olivia F
I went to celebrate my birthday whit my girlfriend last Monday and we order some plates some of the was really good like the chicken Parmesan whit the pasta was so delicious 10/10But the lobster was not good for a plate that cost me $110.00 they just boiled and that is it nothing special no butter or garlic or any recommendations from the waiter the others plate that we order was ok the Alfredo pasta and the lamb rims whit spinach was ok.
August 12 · Angelo Cruz
Bait and switch.Dishonest.$1.75 an Oyster special.Told staff I wanted to eat the special Oysters, they sat me at a table knowing full well I had just requested the Oyster special.When my party of 2 arrived we asked if we could eat more Oysters on the special.They then disclosed it was $4.50 per Oyster.We paid the bill and left.DO NOT GO TO THIS RESTAURANT.
May 15 · SAVVAS SAVVA
We came here for dinner before we went to a show. The lobster à la vodka with linguine was the best I ever had. The staff was wonderful. I will be back.
June 05 · Madison Hutchinson
They have great Oysters promotion $1.5 per piece. This is pretty good deal considering that they located close to time square.I have been there a couple times.If you love steak do not order here but if you love Italian food and oysters they're the one.Their oysters are extremely fresh and they have a lot of sauce that you can eat with them.The lobster ravioli was one of my favorite ever. You should try it.And I highly recommend you sit at the bar. This is NYC you always have chance to meet someone awesome.
August 24 · LilyAlice ST