Randall Manor Tavern

- 735 Castleton Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310

As a cornerstone of the Staten Island dining scene, Randall Manor Tavern has established itself as the quintessential local bar and grill experience for New Yorkers. This is not just a place to grab a drink; it is a welcoming neighborhood establishment that consistently delivers on premium pub cuisine, fast service, and a genuinely cozy atmosphere that makes every patron feel like a local. Whether you are looking for a satisfying lunch, a hearty dinner, or a spot for late-night food and drinks, this tavern offers a full spectrum of dining and social options, distinguishing itself with quality and a commitment to a fantastic customer experience.

The appeal of Randall Manor Tavern lies in its perfect blend of a laid-back tavern feel and an upscale menu. They take classic comfort food and elevate it, offering dishes that range from classic pub fare to more sophisticated entrees. It’s a versatile spot, popular for solo dining, a casual get-together with groups, or celebrating a special occasion. Their reputation is built on consistency—a fact proudly highlighted by loyal patrons who refer to it as their number one go-to spot on Staten Island.

The extensive menu is designed to cater to every palate and hunger level. For those craving the best of bar food, the Grilled 8 Oz. Black Angus Burger and the Buttermilk Fried Chicken Sandwich are must-tries, praised by customers for their generous portions and perfect execution. The signature sandwiches section alone provides a variety of satisfying choices, including the famous Pastrami Reuben, The Cuban, and the Nearly Famous Open Face Turkey Sandwich.

Beyond sandwiches and burgers, the kitchen excels at substantial entrées. Diners can indulge in options like the Bacon Wrapped Meatloaf, Chicken Scampi, or the Full Rack Of Baby Back Ribs. Steak lovers can look forward to the premium Grilled 16 Oz. New York Strip Steak or the Marinated Chimichurri Skirt Steak, which rivals experiences found in more formal Manhattan steakhouses, but without the pretense. The variety ensures that every visit can be a new culinary adventure.

Appetizers at Randall Manor Tavern are an event in themselves, perfect for sharing over happy hour drinks or as a quick bite. Customer favorites include the creative Philly Cheesesteak Eggrolls, Pulled Pork Jalapeño Poppers, and the traditional Irish Nachos. For something from the sea, the Jumbo Gulf Shrimp Cocktail and Cornmeal Crusted Calamari are excellent choices. This diverse offering ensures that the tavern is always a vibrant hub of activity, especially for sports enthusiasts looking for a great game-day experience with exceptional food and drinks.

The Tavern’s commitment to providing a full-service experience is evident in its array of offerings, including a noted great beer selection and creative cocktails, which customers often describe as 'mean' in the best possible way. The availability of high-quality alcohol, hard liquor, and wine, alongside great coffee options, makes it a suitable venue for any time of day or evening. The fast service ensures you never have to wait long, a key feature that New Yorkers appreciate.

Location and Accessibility

Randall Manor Tavern is currently located in a convenient spot for local New Yorkers and visitors to Staten Island. The established address is 735 Castleton Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310. This location places it within the heart of the Randall Manor neighborhood, an area known for its strong community feel and accessibility. For those driving, the tavern is especially accommodating, providing a free parking lot, along with the availability of both free and paid street parking, which is a significant amenity in New York City.

The establishment prides itself on being fully accessible to all members of the community. Accessibility features include a wheelchair accessible entrance, a dedicated wheelchair accessible parking lot, and a wheelchair accessible restroom and seating within the premises. This focus on inclusivity ensures that everyone can enjoy the casual, cozy atmosphere and fantastic menu without concern. It's worth noting that, as of recent reports, the tavern has been planning a move to a larger location on Forest Avenue to better serve its growing customer base, indicating its success and commitment to expansion within the Staten Island community. Patrons should confirm the current operating address when planning a visit, especially if the move is recent.

Services Offered

• Dine-in services with comfortable table seating.
• Takeout and Delivery options for enjoying the menu at home.
• Outdoor seating for a pleasant al fresco dining experience.
• Full-service bar onsite featuring a great beer selection, cocktails, hard liquor, and wine.
• Happy Hour drinks and dedicated Happy Hour food specials.
• Service for Lunch, Dinner, Dessert, and Sunday Brunch.
• Late-night food availability for those craving a bite after hours.
• Catering to various crowds, popular for groups, and comfortable for solo dining.
• High chairs and a dedicated Kids' menu, making it very family-friendly.
• Acceptance of major Credit cards and Debit cards for easy payment.
• Full accessibility features, including a wheelchair accessible restroom and seating.

Features / Highlights

• Consistently recognized for exceptionally Fast service.
• Boasts a Great beer selection and Great cocktails, frequently highlighted in customer reviews.
• Serves upscale pub cuisine and comfort food, alongside a steakhouse-quality dinner menu.
• Offers a Cozy and Casual atmosphere, described as a welcoming neighborhood tavern.
• The menu includes unique and highly-rated items like Philly Cheesesteak Eggrolls and Bacon Wrapped Meatloaf.
• A popular spot for watching Sports, enhancing the neighborhood bar experience.
• Excellent Dining Options: Suitable for Brunch, Lunch, Dinner, and Dessert.
• Free parking lot and available street parking (free and paid) for unparalleled convenience on Staten Island.
• Committed to accessibility with a fully wheelchair accessible entrance, parking, and facilities.

Contact Information

Current Address: 735 Castleton Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310

Phone Number: (347) 855-2724

What is Worth Choosing Randall Manor Tavern

The clear reason why New Yorkers should choose Randall Manor Tavern is its unparalleled combination of a comfortable, local bar atmosphere with a surprisingly sophisticated and diverse menu. It manages to feel like a second home, a place where, as one patron remarked, the staff makes you feel like family, yet it serves dishes that go far beyond standard bar fare. The quality and variety of the food are genuinely exceptional for a bar and grill setting. Where else can you find a Grilled Foot Long Frankfurter next to a Marinated Chimichurri Skirt Steak, or a Classic Tuna Melt alongside a Bacon Wrapped Meatloaf? This versatility makes it the perfect choice for any occasion or craving.

Furthermore, the Tavern’s dedication to providing excellent beverage options, from a Great Beer Selection to fantastic cocktails, means it’s a perfect spot to unwind. Fast service ensures that your experience is efficient and enjoyable, whether you are on a quick lunch break or settling in for a long evening. The accessible location with free parking adds a layer of convenience that is invaluable in the New York metropolitan area. From the highly-rated Blackened Chicken Wrap to the comforting Baked Macaroni And Cheese Skillet, and the option for outdoor seating, Randall Manor Tavern consistently over-delivers on the promise of a superior bar and grill experience on Staten Island. It is a true local specialty worth seeking out.

The fact that this establishment is so popular that it is moving to a larger location to accommodate its loyal following speaks volumes about its success and reputation within the New York community. It’s more than just a restaurant; it’s a Staten Island institution built on great food, friendly service, and a welcoming environment for all.

Randall Manor Tavern

735 Castleton Ave, Staten Island, NY 10310, USA