S&P Lunch

- 174 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010

Introduction / Overview

In a city that is constantly reinventing itself, S&P Lunch stands as a cherished and enduring piece of New York’s culinary history. Located in the Flatiron District, this restaurant is more than just a place to eat; it is a time capsule, a classic diner with a historic feel that has been a beloved fixture of the neighborhood for decades. The atmosphere is immediately welcoming, with a vibe that a customer perfectly described as "home-cooked diner food." The narrow interior, complete with counter seating and the classic sounds of a bustling kitchen, evokes a sense of nostalgia that is hard to replicate. S&P Lunch is celebrated for its commitment to classic, comforting fare, with a menu that focuses on what it does best: sandwiches, soups, and diner staples. While the menu is simple, the quality is where it shines. Their classic sandwiches, especially the pastrami on rye, are renowned among locals and tourists alike for their incredible flavor and a satisfying blend of tradition and deliciousness. This is a place that values substance over flash, where the food is prepared with "lots of love and flavor" and the service is fast and efficient, even during the busy lunch rush. Whether you're a long-time New Yorker who remembers its previous life as Eisenberg's or a visitor looking for an authentic taste of the city, S&P Lunch offers a unique and memorable experience. It’s a place where you can sit at the counter, watch your meal being prepared, and feel the genuine, hardworking energy of a classic New York establishment. It’s not just a meal; it's a slice of history and a taste of the city’s heart and soul.

Location and Accessibility

S&P Lunch is perfectly situated at 174 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA, placing it in one of Manhattan's most recognizable and dynamic neighborhoods. Its location on 5th Avenue, a short walk from the iconic Flatiron Building and Madison Square Park, makes it a prime spot for both local office workers and tourists. The restaurant's accessibility is excellent due to its proximity to several major subway lines, including the N, Q, R, W, and 6 trains, which serve the 23rd Street station. This makes it an easy destination from nearly anywhere in the city. The area is also highly walkable, with a constant flow of pedestrian traffic that contributes to the lively atmosphere. For those who drive, the area offers paid street parking and paid parking garages, which, while typical for New York, are a consideration for visitors. The restaurant's commitment to accessibility is highlighted by a wheelchair-accessible restroom, a crucial amenity that ensures a more inclusive dining experience. While the space can be a bit tight, as noted by a customer review about waiting and cramped tables, the fast service and table turnover help to manage the crowds. The presence of both an indoor and outdoor seating option, with curbside pickup, delivery, and takeout, provides flexibility for all types of patrons, whether they want to dine in and soak up the historic atmosphere or grab a quick bite to enjoy elsewhere. This strategic and well-connected location is a key factor in its popularity and success.

Services Offered

• Curbside pickup: A convenient service for quick and easy order collection.
• Delivery: S&P Lunch offers delivery, allowing you to enjoy their classic dishes from the comfort of your home or office.
• Takeout: For customers on the move, takeout is a popular and efficient option.
• Dine-in: Sit down and enjoy the cozy, historic atmosphere with table or counter service.
• Breakfast, Brunch, Lunch, Dinner: The restaurant serves meals throughout the day, catering to every dining need.
• Table Service & Seating: A full dining experience with dedicated seating and staff.
• Quick bite: Known for fast service, making it an excellent choice for a hurried meal.
• Catering: While not explicitly mentioned in the provided data, a deli-style restaurant often offers catering for events and business lunches.
• Alcohol: The restaurant offers a selection of alcoholic beverages, including beer, to complement your meal.

Features / Highlights

• Historic and Cozy Atmosphere: The restaurant’s biggest highlight is its historic charm and cozy, old-school diner feel. It’s described as having a "good atmosphere of home cooked diner food" and a "historic" quality.
• Fast and Efficient Service: Despite the potential for a line, customers consistently praise the fast service and the hardworking, efficient staff. This focus on speed is a major asset for a busy city crowd.
• Serves Local Specialties: S&P Lunch is renowned for its classic Jewish deli-style fare, including its delicious pastrami and matzo ball soup, which are considered local specialties.
• Exceptional Comfort Food: The menu is built around comfort food that tastes "spectacular" and is made with "lots of love and flavor," as noted by a customer who called their BLT the best they've ever had.
• Versatile Dining: S&P Lunch is popular for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, and is a great option for solo diners, groups, and families, with high chairs available.
• Views of Food Preparation: The counter seating provides a unique feature where diners can watch their food being made, adding to the engaging and authentic diner experience.
• Wheelchair Accessibility: The presence of a wheelchair-accessible restroom demonstrates a commitment to inclusivity.

Contact Information

• Address: 174 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA
• Phone: (212) 691-8862

What is worth choosing

For New Yorkers and visitors alike, S&P Lunch is a restaurant that is truly worth choosing for its authentic, historic charm and its exceptional comfort food. The most compelling reason to dine here is the genuine atmosphere. In a city of trendy new spots, S&P Lunch offers a warm and cozy escape that feels both historic and timeless. The fact that you might have to wait in a small line is a testament to its popularity and a sign that the experience is worth it. Once inside, the chance to sit at the counter and watch the skilled team at work adds an extra layer of enjoyment to the meal. Beyond the ambiance, the food itself is the star of the show. S&P Lunch isn't just serving sandwiches; they are serving New York classics. The menu's focus on deli fare, including the legendary pastrami on rye, is a major draw. The quality of the food is consistently praised, with customers raving about everything from the "best BLT" to the "fantastic" turkey reuben. This is a place where every dish is made with a clear commitment to flavor and tradition. Furthermore, S&P Lunch is incredibly versatile. It's the perfect spot for a solo diner looking for a quick bite at the counter, a family in need of a casual meal with high chairs for the kids, or a group of friends wanting a satisfying and delicious lunch or dinner. The fast service ensures that even during peak hours, you won't be waiting long for your food, making it a reliable choice for a busy schedule. By choosing S&P Lunch, you are not just getting a meal; you are partaking in a New York tradition, enjoying a slice of history, and savoring classic comfort food prepared with heart. This combination of historic charm, fast service, and spectacular food makes it a must-visit destination in the city.

S&P Lunch

174 5th Ave, New York, NY 10010, USA