Sage Deli Mamaroneck NY: Authentic New York Deli, Catering & Gourmet Combos

Sage Deli Introduce

A cornerstone of classic New York-style deli culture in Westchester County, Sage Deli in Mamaroneck is much more than a simple sandwich shop. It represents the authentic, friendly, and comprehensive service that defines the region’s best delis. Locally beloved, Sage Deli is renowned for its commitment to fresh and well prepared food, offering an expansive menu that covers every need, from the essential morning coffee run to catering a large family or corporate event.

The core appeal lies in its dedication to high-quality ingredients, featuring reputable brands alongside a vast selection of homemade specialties, including savory hot heroes and comforting, daily-made soups. Customer reviews consistently highlight the warm, welcoming staff, describing them as great and friendly and very helpful, which transforms a quick stop into a positive local experience.

For busy New Yorkers, Sage Deli is a reliable, high-value destination. Whether you’re stopping in for a Quick visit to grab a specialty sandwich or utilizing their robust delivery service for a hearty meal, this deli has cemented its place as a trusted source for quality comfort food in the Mamaroneck area.

Location and Accessibility

Sage Deli is conveniently situated in the heart of Mamaroneck, making it a highly accessible stop for locals and those traveling through Westchester County.

The exact address is 394 Palmer Ave, Mamaroneck, NY 10543, USA. Its location on Palmer Avenue places it perfectly within the local commercial landscape, ensuring easy access for customer pickup and delivery operations.

The deli is equipped to ensure a smooth visit for all customers:

Wheelchair accessible entrance is provided, demonstrating a commitment to serving the entire community.

While the primary service model caters to takeout and delivery, the convenience of the location, coupled with easy entry, supports its reputation as the perfect spot to grab a few items quickly and efficiently.

Services Offered

Sage Deli provides a full complement of services expected of a top-tier New York deli, emphasizing flexibility and efficiency for the modern customer.

Primary Service Methods:

Takeout
In-store pickup
Delivery

Planning and Amenities:

Designed for a Quick visit, maximizing speed and convenience.
Extensive Catering options available for many menu sections, including Sandwiches, Salads, Triple Deckers, and Mozzarella Combos.

Accepted Payment Methods:

Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments (Accepting modern digital payments)

Features / Highlights

Sage Deli's distinguishing feature is the immense depth and variety of its menu, offering a comprehensive selection of classic and creative deli fare that speaks directly to the sophisticated New York palate.

The Ultimate Customizable Deli Counter: The "Create your own Deli Sandwich" section features a curated selection of high-quality meats, including Boar's Head products such as Deluxe Ham, Oven Gold Turkey, Corned Beef, and Pastrami. Additional premium options like Fresh Roast Beef, Italian Prosciutto, and Breaded Chicken Cutlets ensure customers can customize the perfect New York sandwich, hero, or wrap.
Hearty Homemade Heroes and Hot Combos: The "Homemade Hot heroes" are a major draw, providing substantial comfort meals. Highlights include the classic Philly Cheesesteak Hero, Chicken Parmesan, and the savory Sweet Sausage, And Peppers Hero. Complementing this are the extensive "Hot & Juicy Baked Combos" (B-1 through B-11), which offer various pre-designed, fully satisfying hot sandwich creations.
Comprehensive Breakfast Service: Serving a full "Breakfast until 12:00," the deli is an essential morning stop. The menu includes classic New York staples like Bagel Butter and Bagel Cream Cheese, alongside hearty meals such as the Big Breakfast Plate and classic egg sandwiches (e.g., Bacon 2 Eggs on a Roll). The morning is perfectly paired with Fresh brewed coffee in specialized roasts like Double Barrel French Vanilla Roast and Double Barrel Hazelnut Roast.
Gourmet Specialty Sections: Sage Deli elevates its offerings beyond the standard. The Fresh Mozzarella Combos (such as the Majestic Mozzarella and Mozzarella with Prosciutto) showcase fresh Italian ingredients. Even more uniquely, the "For Brie Lovers" section presents six different specialty combinations centered around the creamy cheese, proving the deli's commitment to creative, high-quality flavor pairings.
Fresh and Homemade Comfort Soups and Sides: A strong indication of quality is the daily rotation of "Homemade Soup," featuring classics like Minestrone, Chicken Noodle, and unique regional favorites such as Escarole With Little Meatballs and Lentil With Ham. The side selection includes both classic American (American Potato Salad, Home Made Macaroni Salad) and specialty sides (German Potato Salad (No Mayo) and Bowtie Pasta, Spinach, Feta Salad).
Extensive Catering and Catering Size Platter Options: The deli’s ability to handle large orders is a major highlight. Nearly every menu section, including the Signature Creative Cold Combos, Fresh Mozzarella Combos, Wraps, and Fresh Salads, offers Catering: On A Large Platter pricing, making it a reliable partner for office lunches, parties, and group events in the Westchester area.
Diverse Salad and Beverage Selections: For lighter fare, the "Fresh Salads" section is comprehensive, offering Grilled Chicken Caesar, Greek Salad, and protein-focused plates (Tuna, Chicken Salad, Seafood Salad). The beverage selection is equally vast, featuring a wide range of popular 20 oz Cold beverages and Hal’s 2oz. Potato chips, ensuring a perfect combo for any meal.

Contact Information

For placing an order for takeout, delivery, or discussing catering options, Sage Deli can be reached using the following information:

Address: 394 Palmer Ave, Mamaroneck, NY 10543, USA
Phone: (914) 698-4305
Mobile Phone: +1 914-698-4305

What is Worth Choosing

Sage Deli is unequivocally worth choosing for New Yorkers seeking an authentic, full-service New York deli experience in Westchester County. The primary draw is the unparalleled menu breadth and quality, which effortlessly handles all dining needs—from a hearty Big Breakfast Plate to a fully customized lunch utilizing premium Boars Head cold cuts. This extensive variety, which includes Homemade Hot heroes like the Chicken Parmesan and specialty items like Fresh Mozzarella Combos, means the deli is equipped for daily reliability and special occasion catering alike.

Beyond the food, the establishment is defined by its outstanding local reputation for having friendly, helpful employees who ensure food is always fresh and well prepared. This combination of high-quality ingredients, expert preparation, and warm, local service, all supported by convenient services like Delivery and a model designed for a Quick visit, makes Sage Deli a highly valuable and frequently revisited local food staple in Mamaroneck.

Sage Deli Vibe

Breakfast until 12:00
Bagel Butter $3.95
Your choice of bagel toasted or not with butter
B.L.T. $9.75
Bacon, lettuce tomato on your choice of toasted bread
Bagel Cream Cheese $4.75
Our fresh bagels with a good amount of cream cheese
Western Omelet $8.95
2 Egg grilled omelette with ham, sweet peppers, and onions on your choice of bread
Toasted Muffin With Butter $4.75
Our fresh muffins, buttered, and toasted on our grill
Grilled Cheese $7.95
Grilled melted American cheese on your choice of buttery toasted bread
Big Breakfast Plate $10.95
Includes 2 Eggs, any style,choice Toast, Home Fries ,, choice of Ham, Bacon or Sausage.
Ham And 2 Eggs $5.75
Ham and eggs prepared to your liking on the bread of your choice
2 Eggs On A Roll $4.50
Two eggs prepared to your liking on your choice of bread
Sausage & 2 Eggs $5.75
Sausage patty, and two eggs on your choice of bread prepared as you like
Turkey Bacon, 2 Eggs Choice Of Bread $6.95
Roll Butter $2.95
Bacon 2 Eggs $5.75
Bacon and two eggs on your choice of bread prepared as you like
Grilled Ham & Cheese $8.75
Grilled Boars Head, ham and American cheese on buttery toasted bread

Fresh brewed coffee
Double Barrel French Vanilla Roast $3.00
Hot Chocolate $3.25
From our whipped cappuccino dispenser., has sugar
Double Barrel Hazelnut Roast $3.00
Original Coffee Cappuccino $3.25
From our whipped cappuccino dispenser, made with cream and sugar
French Vanilla Cappuccino $3.25
16 ounce cup from our whipped cappuccino dispenser.. made with cream and sugar
Double Barrel Colombian Decaf $3.00
16 ounce coffee
Double Barrel Colombian Roast $3.00
16 ounce coffee

For Brie Lovers
3 $11.95
BBLT - Brie, Bacon, Lettuce, Ripe Tomato, Served on Toasted Sliced Bread.
6 $11.45
Brie, Sliced Cucumbers, Onion, Lettuce, Lite Mayo, Served on Whole Grain Bread.
4 $11.95
Boars Head Ham, Lettuce, Tomato, Brie, Sweet Honey Mustard, Served on Rye.
1 $12.95
Sliced Fresh Turkey, Brie, Leaf Romaine, Cranberry Sauce, Mayo, Served on Whole Grain Bread.
2 $11.95
Fresh Cooked Roast Beef, Lettuce, Horseradish, Brie, Served on Kaiser Roll.
5 $11.95
Breggie - Brie, Leaf Romaine, Roasted Red Peppers, Ripe Tomato, Eggplant Cutlet, Served on Whole Grain Bread with Lite Balsamic Dressing.
Catering: On A Large Platter $79.00
1 of each of our Brie Combos,cut into half on a large platter.. please order three hours in advance

Fresh Mozzarella Combos
Majestic Mozzarella $14.95
Thick sliced fresh mozzarella, sweet, roasted peppers, lettuce, Italian herb dressing on a sesame seed hero
Prosciutto $16.95
Thin, sliced prosciutto with fresh mozzarella, sweet peppers, Romain, lettuce, balsamic dressing on a sesame seed hero
Eggplant $15.95
Our homemade, eggplant cutlet, fresh mozzarella hot or sweet peppers, on a sesame seed, Italian hero
Catering: On A Large Platter $129.00
3 of each of our Fresh Mozzarella Hero’s,cut into thirds on a large platter. Please order three hours in advance.

Hal’s 2oz. Potato chips.
Plain Classic $3.00
Sour Cream And Onion $3.00
Salt And Vinegar $3.00
Barbecue Kettle Chips $3.00
Sea Salt And Pepper $3.00
Jalapeño Chips $3.00

Fresh Muffins
Fresh Yogurt Muffins $4.00
Fresh muffin to enjoy with your coffee

Homemade Hot heroes
Philly Cheesesteak Hero $13.95
Chicken Parmesan $14.95
Breaded chicken cutlets on a Italian hero with melted mozzarella cheese featuring our homemade tomato sauce
Sweet Sausage, And Peppers Hero $13.96
Our Homemade Meatballs, Hero $13.95
Chicken Parmesan Hero $13.95

Signature Creative Cold Combos
C-1 $13.95
Boars Head Ham, Salami, Provolone, Lettuce, Tomato, Italian Dressing.
C-9 $13.95
Boars Head Ham Capicola, Salami, Provolone, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Italian Dressing.
C-10 $14.95
In store, Roast Beef, Roast Turkey, Swiss Cheese, Pepper, Russian Dressing… please note the hero is 50% larger than the kaiser roll
C-13 $13.95
(Veggie wedgie) Any Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Artichokes, Sweet Roasted Peppers.
C-12 $13.95
Boars Head’s Turkey Breast, chicken breast, Swiss Cheese, Lettuce, Pepper, Russian Dressing.
Catering: On A Large Platter $139.00
2 of each #1,#3,#5,#10,#15 on Heros cut into thirds on a large platter.. please order three hours in advance..
C-11 $13.95
Boars Head (German combo) Bologna, German Potato Salad, Mustard, Lettuce, Tomato, Pepper.
C-2 $13.95
Boars Head Pepperoni, Hard Salami, Provolone, Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Mustard, Italian Dressing.
C-5 $14.95
(Italian combo) Genoa Salami, Pepperoni, Italian Capicola, Provolone, Tomato, Onion, hot or sweet peppers
C-8 $13.95
Boars Head, Baked Virginia Ham, Chicken Salad, Lettuce, sweet peppers
C-6 $13.95
(American Combo) boars Head, Boiled Ham, Turkey Breast, American Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato, Mayo.
C-15 $14.95
Kitchen Grilled Chicken, Lettuce, Tomato,sweet Roasted Peppers.
C-7 $13.95
Boars Head Pepper Ham, Pepperoni, Provolone, Onion, Pepper Salad (Hot or Sweet).
C-4 $13.95
(Greek combo) Boars Head Ham, Tomato, Feta Cheese, Onion, Oreganato Blend dressing
C-14 $13.95
Majestic Mozzarella, Fresh Mozzarella, Sweet Roasted Peppers, Lettuce, Herbs, Italian Dressing.
C-3 $13.95
Boars Head Turkey Breast, Swiss Cheese, Coleslaw, Pepper, Tomato, Russian Dressing.

Homemade Soup
Minestrone $6.95
Soup Of The Day $6.95
Escarole With Little Meatballs $6.75
Beef Barley $6.95
Lentil With Ham $6.95
Chicken Noodle $6.95
Split Pea $6.95

Triple Deckers
TD-1 $11.95
Store cooked roast beef, turkey, Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, Russian on 3 pieces of your choice toasted bread
Td-6 $11.95
Our in-store cooked roast beef, cheddar cheese, horseradish sauce, lettuce, and onion, triple decker style
TD-2 $11.95
Traditional country club BLT triple-decker style.. two hands required
Td-4 $11.95
Tuna salad, lettuce, onion, tomato, sweet peppers on three slices of toast the bread
Td-5 $11.95
Our homemade chicken salad, sliced Virginia, ham, lettuce, tomato, and fresh cucumber, and three slices of toast the bread
Td-3 $11.95
Boars Head, pastrami and corned beef melted Swiss cheese with coleslaw and mustard and toasted bread
Catering: On A Large Platter $79.00
1 of each of our triple-deckers (6)cut in half on a large platter.. please order 3 hours in advance

Hot & Juicy Baked Combos
B-5 $14.95
Roast Beef, Tomato Sauce, melted Mozzarella Cheese, Spices.
B-11 $9.95
Boars Head chicken breast , Swiss Cheese, Garlic Bread.
B-3 $14.95
Roast Beef, Butter, melted American Cheese, Spices.
B-2 $13.95
Boars Head, ham, Tomato, Onion, melted Swiss Cheese, Mustard.
B-6 $14.95
Boars Head Turkey Breast, Brown Gravy melted, Swiss Cheese, Spices.
B-4 $15.95
Pastrami, melted Swiss Cheese, Mustard, Coleslaw.
B-8 $13.95
Boars Head, Virginia Ham, Onion, melted, Swiss Cheese, Mustard, Spices.
B-7 $14.95
Genoa Salami, Capicola, Artichokes, Onion, melted Swiss Cheese, Spices.
B-1 $14.95
Roast Beef, Ketchup, melted American Cheese, Spices.
B-9 $15.95
Boars Head Corned Beef, melted, Swiss Cheese, Mustard, Coleslaw.
B-10 $13.70
(Our famous love combo!) boars Head, Ham ,melted Provolone, Tomato, Onion, Secret Spices.

Deli prepared side salads, 8 ozs
Home Made Coleslaw $3.00
Our Homemade Tuna Salad $5.76
American Potato Salad $3.00
German Potato Salad(No Mayo) $4.00
Home Made Macaroni Salad $3.00
Bowtie Pasta, Spinach, Feta Salad $5.00
Our Homemade Chicken Salad $6.85
Homemade white meat, chicken salad with cranberries and celery we only use Hellmann’s mayonnaise
Bean Salad $3.00

20 oz Cold beverages
Gatorade Orange $3.00
A crisp, satisfying taste to quench thirst and energize without caffeine
Diet Snapple, Iced Tea $3.00
Diet Snapple, Raspberry Iced Tea $3.00
Pepsi $3.00
The bold, refreshing, robust cola
Hals Seltzer $3.00
Coke $3.00
The cold, refreshing, sparkling classic that America loves.
Diet Ginger Ale $3.00
Snapple Raspberry Iced Tea $3.00
Lemonade $3.00
24 Ounce Poland Spring Water $3.00
Diet Snapple Peach Iced Tea $3.00
Snapple Peach Iced Tea $3.00
16 Ounce Poland Spring Water $2.00
Diet Coke $3.00
A crisp, refreshing taste you know and love with zero calories.
Dr.Pepper $3.00
Mountain Dew $3.00
Exhilarate and quench your thirst with a one of a kind taste.
1 L Poland Spring Water $4.00
Ginger Ale $3.00
Snapple Iced Tea $3.00
Orange Crush $3.00
Gatorade, Lemon, Lime $3.00
A crisp, satisfying taste to quench thirst and energize without caffeine
Diet Pepsi $3.00
A crisp tasting, refreshing pop of sweet, fizzy bubbles without calories.
Gatorade, Fruit Punch $3.00
A crisp, satisfying taste to quench thirst and energize without caffeine

Sweet desserts
DreamWorks, Blondie $3.00
Black And White Cookie $3.00
Snicker Bar $2.50
Linden, Chocolate Chip Cookie $2.00
Chocolate Dip Cookies 15 Ounce $8.00
Dream Works Brownie $3.00
DreamWorks, Heavenly Bar, Coconut/Chocalate $3.00
Raspberry Filled Sprinkle Cookies 14 Ounce $8.00
Hershey Chocolate Bar $2.50
M&Ms $2.50

Wraps
7 $12.45
In-store Roast Beef, Provolone, Lettuce, Tomato, Roasted Peppers.
3 $10.95
Boars Head, Honey Turkey, Alpine Lace, Lettuce, Tomato, Roasted Peppers, Honey Mustard.
Catering: On A Large Platter $99.00
1 of each of our wraps,cut into half on a large platter
2 $11.95
Boars Head, Smoked Turkey, Fresh Mozzarella, Lettuce, Tomato, Roasted Peppers, Honey Mustard.
1 $10.95
Grilled Chicken, Alpine Lace, Lettuce, Tomato, Roasted Peppers, Honey Mustard.
5 $10.95
Boars Head, Chicken Breast, Alpine Lace, Lettuce, Tomato, Olive and Pepper mix.
8 $12.45
Grilled Chicken, Fresh Mozzarella, Lettuce, Tomato, Honey Mustard, Olive and Pepper mix.
6 $10.95
Tuna or Chicken Salad. with fresh sliced lettuce and tomatoes.
4 $11.95
Boars Head Pepperoni, Salami, Provolone, Lettuce, Tomato, Olive, Roasted Peppers.

Fresh Salads
Grilled Chicken Salad $14.95
Garden salad with kitchen, grilled chicken, tomato, sweet peppers, cranberries
Seafood Salad Plate $13.95
Our tossed garden salad with a scoop of fresh seafood salad, and coleslaw
Catering: Half Tray Garden Salad $39.00
Half tray of our garden salad with balsamic dressing on the side
Our Famous Chef Salad $12.95
Our tossed salad with rolled ham, turkey, American and Swiss cheese
Italian Salad $14.95
Garden salad with , salami, pepperoni, provolone, green, and black olives, sweet peppers, Italian dressing
Chicken Salad Plate $12.95
Our tossed garden salad with a scoop of chicken salad, and coleslaw
Grilled Chicken Caesar $14.95
Traditional, grilled chicken,Romain lettuce, croutons, grated cheese, Caesar dressing
Tossed Salad $8.95
Lettuce, mixed greens, tomato, cucumbers,onions, green, and black olives
Catering :Half Tray, Greek Salad $59.00
Half tray of our Greek salad with fresh herb dressing on the side
Greek Salad $14.95
garden salad with artichoke hearts, feta cheese, sweet peppers, Greek olives, vinaigrette dressing
Tuna Salad $12.95
Our tossed garden salad with a scoop of tuna salad, and coleslaw
Egg Salad Plate $12.95
Our toast garden salad with a scoop of store, made egg salad, and coleslaw

Create your own Deli Sandwich
Baked Virginia Ham $11.00
Fresh Turkey Breast $12.00
Smoked Turkey $11.00
Sweet Soprasatta $12.00
Fresh Grilled Chicken $12.00
Boars Head Deluxe Ham $11.00
Peppermill Turkey $11.00
Italian Mortadella $11.00
Fresh Roast Beef $12.00
Honey, Maple Turkey $11.00
Italian Prosciutto $12.00
Catering;On A Large Platter $99.00
4 turkey sandwiches,4 roast beef sandwiches,4 ham and Swiss sandwiches on rye.mayo, mustard, Russian on the side, on a platter.. please order three hours in advance
Boars Head Corned Beef $12.00
Genoa Salami $11.00
Boars Head Oven, Gold Turkey $11.00
Breaded, Chicken Cutlets $11.70
Boars Head Pastrami $12.00

Sage Deli Details

Service options
Delivery
In-store pickup
Takeout

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible entrance

Planning
Quick visit

Payments
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Sage Deli Photos

Sage Deli Location

Sage Deli

New York Westchester County Mamaroneck Palmer Avenue

394 Palmer Ave, Mamaroneck, NY 10543, USA

Sage Deli Reviews

An average rating of ★4.1 from 90 user reviews.

bacon egg and cheesesaladscoffeelunchpricesales taxroast beef sandwichsubs

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

Great local deli and guys that own it and work there are great and friendly and very helpful. Everything we have ordered from there has been delicious!
August 17 · The Jelloqueen
Friendly helpful employees nice deli to grab a few items food is fresh and well prepared
August 06 · E
I wanted roast beef sandwich not that hard, assumed it would be cooked, it wasn’t I had two my friend was ok I don’t want it raw, went back wanted it cooked he said If I came an hour ago he could have cooked it ? I don’t get itIt wasn’t even 30 minutes. Really couldn’t just throw the meat on grill for two minutes ? Never again here
October 11 · Farouk's Shipping
High quality food. Their deli serves some of the best sandwiches in the area. The selection and variety of gourmet salads and sides is very good. Their catering is good and the price is right. Great for breakfast and / or lunch. Try the Italian combo with roasted red peppers. Their bread is also excellent.
January 11 · Paul Tortorella
Having sage as my local deli for most of my life, has spoiled me for when I have to go to other places. I love to be able to walk in and no matter what I order it will be an impressive sandwich. And it will be prepared exactly the way I want it with never a mistake or inaccuracy. Everybody that works there is friendly, if you've been in there more than once they will more than likely remember you the next time. Just a fantastic local deli.
December 06 · Al DeHeatguy