Sal's Pizza Mamaroneck

- 316 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, NY 10543

An Introduction to Sal's Pizza Mamaroneck: A Westchester Staple

For residents of Westchester County and beyond, the mention of a true, old-school Italian-American pizzeria conjures images of bubbling cheese, fragrant garlic, and a long counter piled high with specialty slices. In the heart of Mamaroneck, Sal's Pizza Mamaroneck has not just met this expectation; it has defined it for over six decades. This establishment is more than just a place to grab a quick bite; it's an iconic local institution that has cemented its status as a must-visit destination for pizza aficionados in the New York region.

Sal's Pizzeria is celebrated for its commitment to tradition, offering both classic New York-style thin-crust pizza and what many consider to be the absolute best Sicilian slice on the planet. Its atmosphere is that of a quintessential, no-frills pizzeria—a comfortable, casual, and often bustling environment that embodies the spirit of a beloved neighborhood spot. Whether you're a local college student, a family grabbing dinner, or a tourist seeking an authentic taste of Westchester, Sal's delivers a consistent, high-quality, and deliciously satisfying experience.

This review is designed to serve local users in New York by providing a complete overview of what makes Sal's Pizza Mamaroneck a local gem, detailing its location, accessibility, and the full range of services and mouth-watering offerings that keep patrons coming back year after year.

Location and Accessibility

Sal's Pizza Mamaroneck is strategically located on the town's main shopping thoroughfare, making it easily accessible for anyone traveling through the area.

The full address is 316 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, NY 10543, USA. The prime Mamaroneck Avenue location places it right in the heart of local activity.

The establishment takes accessibility seriously, ensuring a welcoming environment for all patrons. The property features a wheelchair accessible entrance, a wheelchair accessible parking lot, a wheelchair accessible restroom, and wheelchair accessible seating, making it convenient for guests with mobility needs.

For those driving, parking options include limited on-site parking and readily available paid street parking along Mamaroneck Avenue and surrounding streets. The presence of ample seating inside means you can comfortably dine in and soak up the cozy, casual pizzeria atmosphere.

Services Offered

Sal's Pizza is a full-service Italian restaurant that caters to modern convenience, offering a variety of ways to enjoy their menu, whether you're dining in or taking your meal to go.

• Dining-in: Enjoy the casual, cozy, and family-friendly atmosphere with ample seating inside, perfect for lunch, dinner, or just a quick bite.
• Takeout: Place an order and pick it up to enjoy at home or work.
• Delivery: Conveniently have your favorite pies and dishes delivered straight to your door. The delivery service also includes a no-contact delivery option for added safety and convenience.
• Drive-Through: A streamlined option for quick, efficient service when you're on the go.
• Catering: Sal's offers catering services, allowing you to bring their iconic pizzas, pasta trays, and Italian entrees to your next group event or party. Small trays typically feed 6 to 8 people, while large trays serve 15 to 20 people, making party planning simple and delicious.
• Payment Options: The restaurant accepts debit cards, and while some older reviews may mention cash-only, modern convenience is now supported.
• Good for Children: The establishment is family-friendly and provides high chairs for the smallest members of your group.

Features and Highlights

What sets Sal's Pizza Mamaroneck apart from countless other pizza spots are its unique offerings and dedication to an efficient, friendly service model, making it a favorite for local crowds, including college students and groups.

• The Legendary Sicilian Slice (Local Specialty): The Sicilian pie is consistently cited as the standout item and the local specialty that sets Sal's apart. Unlike dense, heavy Sicilian styles, Sal's version is renowned for its light, airy dough with a crisp crust and a perfect ratio of milky mozzarella and vibrant sauce.
• Classic New York Style Pizza: In addition to the Sicilian, the regular New York-style pies are celebrated for their ultrathin crust and flavorful blend of cheese and spices, holding up well to toppings.
• Exceptional Specialty Pizzas: The menu boasts a diverse selection of specialty pies and slices, including the unique and popular Salad Slice, the perfectly spicy Buffalo Chicken Pie, and the rich Chicken, Bacon, Ranch (CBR) Pie.
• Fast and Efficient Service: Known for its efficiency, especially given its popularity, the pizzeria excels at fast service, keeping the line moving so you can enjoy your food quickly, even during peak hours like lunch and dinner.
• Full Italian Menu: Beyond pizza, the menu offers a complete range of Italian comfort foods, including heaping portions of pasta, wedges, and hearty entrees like Chicken Parm Dish and Eggplant Rollatini.
• Late-Night & Quick Bite Options: Serving as a great spot for a quick bite, Sal's also offers late-night food options, perfect for satisfying those late-evening cravings.
• Beverage Offerings: The restaurant offers alcohol and beer options to perfectly complement your meal.

What is Worth Choosing at Sal's Pizza Mamaroneck

When visiting Sal's Pizza Mamaroneck, the clear, undeniable choice that both locals and reviewers rave about is the Sicilian Slice. This is the item that has built the restaurant's iconic reputation, described as the best Sicilian slice you will ever eat, featuring a light, almost focaccia-like crust with a satisfying crunch. A strong runner-up is the Buffalo Chicken Slice, praised by customers for being "perfectly spicy" without being drowned in sauce or blue cheese. For a lighter, yet equally unique option, the Salad Slice—a regular crust topped with salad in Italian dressing—is surprisingly popular and a local curiosity worth trying.

In essence, Sal's is a true representation of the classic neighborhood pizzeria, consistently delivering delicious comfort food with a blend of classic recipes and inventive options. It’s a local institution that continues to thrive because it focuses on quality ingredients, generous portions, and a welcoming atmosphere that’s been satisfying New York appetites for decades. When you’re in Mamaroneck, a stop at Sal’s isn’t just a meal—it's a piece of local Westchester history.

Contact Information

For orders, inquiries about their extensive catering menu, or to learn more about their daily specials, you can contact Sal's Pizza Mamaroneck using the following information:

Address: 316 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, NY 10543, USA

Phone: (914) 381-2022 / +1 914-381-2022

Sal's Pizza Mamaroneck

316 Mamaroneck Ave, Mamaroneck, NY 10543, USA