Sammy boxs

- 1055 St Johns Pl, Brooklyn, NY 11213

For New Yorkers craving an authentic seafood experience, Sammy's stands as a long-time favorite, a destination that has been serving up fresh catches and classic dishes for decades. Located on the picturesque City Island in the Bronx, this restaurant has built a reputation for its commitment to quality and a simple, unpretentious approach to preparing seafood. The formula at Sammy's is straightforward: offer the best and freshest food, prepared with care and served in generous portions. This dedication has made it a go-to spot for those seeking a true taste of the sea without leaving the city.

Sammy's has a rich history, having been established in 2005, following in the footsteps of the former Tito Puente's Restaurant. The ownership, led by Sammy himself, has carried on a tradition of excellence, focusing on fresh, daily-prepared food and a welcoming, casual atmosphere. The menu is expansive, offering a wide variety of options from traditional American seafood to signature Latino dishes and even some land-based favorites for those who prefer turf to surf. Whether you're in the mood for a classic fried platter or an extravagant feast, Sammy's aims to leave you with a satisfied and "overstuffed stomach," as one of their descriptions aptly puts it.

This commitment to quality is what draws both locals and visitors alike. The restaurant has garnered a loyal following, with some customers returning for over 40 years. This longevity and continued popularity are a testament to the consistent quality of the food and service. In a city with countless dining options, Sammy's holds its own by sticking to its core values: quality, value, and a refusal to compromise.

It's more than just a place to eat; it's a destination. The ambiance is casual and welcoming, perfect for a family dinner, a celebratory meal, or a relaxed outing with friends. The restaurant's location on City Island, often referred to as a "seafaring community," adds to the unique dining experience, making it feel like a mini-getaway from the hustle and bustle of the city.

While a search for a Brooklyn address for a "Sammy's Boxs" yields results for a restaurant called "Sammy's Fish and Things," it's important to note that the well-known and highly-rated "Sammy's Fish Box" is located in the Bronx on City Island. This establishment has a long-standing presence and is the one consistently praised by New Yorkers for its seafood. The information provided about the Brooklyn location appears to be a different entity, or perhaps a different name, and the detailed menu, services, and features are all tied to the Bronx location.

Location and Accessibility

Sammy's Fish Box is located at 41 City Island Avenue in the Bronx, NY 10464. Its position at the far end of City Island makes it a destination for those seeking a dedicated seafood experience. For those driving from Manhattan, whether from the East or West side, the most common route is to take the I-95 to exit 8B for Orchard Beach/City Island and follow the signs. Similarly, travelers from New Jersey, Connecticut, or Westchester can easily access the restaurant via major highways. For those coming from Brooklyn or Queens, crossing the Whitestone or Throggs Neck Bridge and getting on the I-95 North will lead you to the same exit. While public transport options are available, a car is often the most convenient way to reach this City Island eatery.

Services Offered

• Dine-in: The restaurant provides a casual and comfortable setting for guests to enjoy their meal on-site. The atmosphere is noted for being relaxed and welcoming.

• Takeout and Delivery: For those who prefer to enjoy their seafood at home, Sammy's offers online ordering for pickup and delivery through services like Grubhub and Seamless. This provides convenience for customers across the city.

• Catering: With its generous portion sizes and expansive menu, Sammy's is a great option for catering events, offering large platters and feasts for groups.

• Full Bar: The establishment features a bar and lounge area, serving a variety of alcoholic beverages including wines, beers, frozen cocktails, and martinis. This makes it an ideal spot for a leisurely meal or a night out.

Features / Highlights

• Extensive Menu: The menu is vast and diverse, featuring everything from classic fried and broiled seafood to Italian specialties, Cajun-style dishes, and steaks. The sheer number of options ensures there's something for everyone, whether you're a seafood purist or looking for a surf-and-turf combo.

• Fresh Ingredients: The restaurant's core philosophy is to use only the freshest food, prepared daily. This commitment is highlighted in descriptions of their seafood, from fresh oysters to wild-caught fish.

• Generous Portions: A recurring theme in reviews and descriptions is the large and hearty portion sizes. Many dishes are noted for being big enough to share or providing leftovers, offering excellent value for the price.

• Signature Feasts: For groups or those with a truly big appetite, Sammy's offers "Fabulous Feasts for 2" such as the Italian Feast, King Crab & Lobster Feast, and Paella de España, which are loaded with a variety of seafood.

• Specialty Dishes: The menu includes unique items like Piri Piri Shrimp, Wood Roasted Fish, and a variety of stuffed and blackened seafood options, showcasing a range of culinary influences.

Contact Information

Address: 41 City Island Ave, The Bronx, NY 10464

Phone: (718) 885-0920

What is worth choosing

When you visit Sammy's Fish Box, you are met with a dizzying array of choices, but certain items consistently stand out. The menu's "Feast" platters are a major draw, providing a spectacular combination of shellfish and other delights. The Super Fried Seafood Combo Platter is a fan favorite for its variety, while the Crab & Lobster Feast is a quintessential choice for special occasions. Many patrons also praise the jumbo fried shrimp and the stuffed shrimp with crabmeat, which are considered signature dishes. The whole baked and fried red snapper are also highly recommended for their fresh flavor and impressive presentation. Beyond seafood, the baby back ribs and ribeye steak receive high marks, proving that Sammy's can also deliver on classic American fare. For those who enjoy a bit of spice, the Bang Bang Shrimp or the Piri Piri Shrimp offer a flavorful kick. Ultimately, what is most worth choosing is an experience—a visit to a classic New York institution that prides itself on simple, high-quality food and a tradition of satisfying every guest who walks through the door.

Sammy boxs

1055 St Johns Pl, Brooklyn, NY 11213, USA