Scottio's Pizza: Valley Stream's Favorite for Classic New York Slices and Italian Comfort Food

Scottio's Pizza Introduce

Scottio's Pizza: Your Go-To Spot for Authentic Pizza and Italian Classics in Valley Stream, NY

For New Yorkers in the know, there's nothing quite like finding that perfect neighborhood pizza joint. It's a place where the sauce is just right, the crust has the ideal chew, and the atmosphere feels like home. Located right in the heart of Nassau County,

Scottio's Pizza

in Valley Stream, NY, has built a reputation as exactly that: a friendly, professional, and reliably delicious spot for all your Italian comfort food cravings.

Scottio's is far more than just a typical slice shop; it's a full-service

pizza restaurant

that offers a comprehensive menu stretching well beyond the standard cheese and pepperoni. From classic pasta dishes and hearty heroes to specialized pizzas and extensive catering options, this establishment serves up the kind of genuine, high-quality food that residents of the

New York region

expect. It’s a cherished local spot, recommended by patrons not just for the quality of the dough and the great sauce, but also for the kind, family-like atmosphere created by Scottio and the entire staff. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick lunch, planning a family dinner, or organizing a large event, Scottio's Pizza delivers a consistently satisfying experience.

Scottio's Pizza: A Slice of Valley Stream History

Scottio's stands out as a genuine institution for

Long Island dining

. They specialize in all the beloved items you'd expect from a top-tier New York pizzeria and Italian kitchen. Their commitment is to offer high-quality food in a relaxed, casual setting, making it a perfect fit for solo diners, families, and anyone looking for a reliable,

quick bite

or a full, comforting meal. Their menu reflects a deep understanding of what makes classic Italian-American food so universally loved—generous portions, fresh ingredients, and time-tested recipes.

Location and Accessibility for Local New Yorkers

Scottio's Pizza is conveniently situated in

Valley Stream, NY

, making it easily accessible for residents across the surrounding

Nassau County

neighborhoods. Their specific address is:

171 Dubois Ave, Valley Stream, NY 11580, USA

For those traveling by car, accessibility is a key factor Scottio's has considered. The location offers

free street parking

, which is a significant convenience in the often-busy Long Island area. Furthermore, the establishment demonstrates a commitment to serving all members of the community by providing a

wheelchair accessible parking lot

, ensuring a hassle-free visit for all patrons. Its location on Dubois Ave places it firmly within the local community, making it an ideal choice for a neighborhood meal without having to travel far. Whether you are driving over to pick up a catering order or just popping in for a slice, the easy accessibility makes Scottio's a practical choice.

Extensive Services Offered

Scottio's Pizza is dedicated to accommodating the diverse needs of the

New York customer

, offering multiple ways to enjoy their delicious food. Their service model is designed for flexibility and convenience, whether you want to eat on the spot or enjoy a meal at home.

Dine-in:
The casual atmosphere makes it a great spot to sit down for
lunch or dinner
with friends or family. It's known to be
good for kids
, making it an excellent choice for family outings.
Takeout:
Perfect for those in a rush who want to grab their order and head home. A quick and efficient way to enjoy your favorites.
Delivery:
Conveniently bringing their entire menu, including hot pizzas, heroes, and entrees, right to your
Valley Stream or Long Island
home or office.
Catering:
Offers a full
Catering Menu
with both small and large trays, ideal for parties, business lunches, or any large gathering. Options include classics like
Chicken Parmigiana
,
Sausage & Peppers
, and large
Tossed Salads
.

They also make payment simple and modern, accepting both

Debit cards

and

NFC mobile payments

Menu Features and Highlights

The menu at Scottio's is a celebration of classic Italian-American cooking, going well beyond the basic pizza offerings. Here are some of the must-try features and highlights that make their menu a local standout:

Specialty Pizzas:
Beyond the traditional
All Cheese Regular and Sicilian pies
, Scottio's offers unique, popular choices such as the
Grandma Pizza
, a thin-crust square pie with fresh mozzarella, crushed tomato, garlic, and basil; the tangy
Buffalo Pizza
; the hearty
Baked Ziti Pizza
; and the uniquely rich
Penne Alla Vodka Pizza
($26.00).
The Classics:
All the staples are here, including a full range of toppings for both their regular and Sicilian-style slices and pies, from
Meatball
and
Sausage
to
Mushroom
and
Anchovies
($23.00 for a regular pie). They also offer
White Pizza
options.
Hearty Entrees and Baked Specialties:
Available for both dine-in and catering, their Entrees are served with a side of Spaghetti or Ziti. Highlights include
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana
($18.00),
Veal Cutlet Parmigiana
($28.00),
Shrimp Parmigiana
($20.00), and
Eggplant Rollatini
($16.00). Baked options feature staples like
Lasagna
($14.00) and the classic
Baked Ziti
($11.50).
Heroes and Pasta:
A robust selection of heroes, like the
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana
($14.00) and
Sausage & Peppers
($12.00), are available. Their Spaghetti menu is extensive, covering everything from
Spaghetti w/Meatballs
($12.00) to
Penne Alla Vodka
($14.99) and
Spaghetti w/Clam Sauce (Red or White)
($13.00).
Delicious Appetizers and Sides:
Perfect starters include
Garlic Knots
(dozen $6.00),
Mozzarella Sticks
($9.00), and various salads, including
Antipasto
($12.00) and
Grilled Chicken Salad
($12.00).
Italian Ices:
A special treat noted by customers, with a great selection of flavors like the amazing
chocolate fudge
, adding an authentic dessert touch to your meal.

Contact and Ordering Information

Ready to place an order or inquire about

catering services

? Scottio's Pizza makes it simple to get in touch.

Address:

171 Dubois Ave, Valley Stream, NY 11580, USA

Phone:

(516) 872-9229 (Primary Line)

Mobile Phone:

+1 516-872-9229

Whether you are calling to place a large

delivery order

or confirming your pick-up time, their dedicated phone lines ensure you can connect with their staff quickly and efficiently.

Why Scottio's Pizza is Worth Choosing in Valley Stream

For residents and visitors in the

Long Island area

, Scottio's Pizza offers a combination of factors that make it a compelling choice for any meal. The foundation of their appeal rests on their genuine commitment to quality. The food is often described as the

best pizza in the area

, specifically praised for the quality of the dough and the flavor of the sauce. This focus on the fundamentals is what sets great New York pizzerias apart.

Beyond the excellent

comfort food

offerings—which cover everything from a

quick slice

to a full-course

veal cutlet parmigiana

—the dining experience itself is a major draw. The atmosphere is

casual

and welcoming, making it a stress-free environment for everyone. Patrons consistently highlight the

kind and family-like staff

as a reason for their loyalty, noting that it is "always a pleasure stopping by this place." This blend of professional service and warm, neighborly hospitality elevates the experience from a simple meal to a genuine community interaction. With excellent accessibility, a wide-ranging menu that caters to both a quick bite and large event

catering

, and a solid reputation for quality, Scottio's Pizza is truly a beloved

Valley Stream pizzeria

worth choosing for your next Italian craving.

Scottio's Pizza Pizza

Appetizers
Large salad $10.00
Antipasto $12.00
Tossed Salad $8.00
Garlic Bread $3.00
Garlic Knots (dozen) $6.00
Garlic Knots Parmigiana (half dozen) $5.00
Sausage or Chicken Roll $8.00
Calzone $8.00
Spinach or Pepperoni Roll $3.00
Mozzarella Sticks $9.00
Gilled Chicken Salad $12.00

Spaghetti
Spaghetti w/Meatballs $12.00
Spaghetti w/Sausage $12.00
Spaghetti w/Garlic & Oil $10.00
Spaghetti w/Meat Sauce $10.00
Spaghetti w/Mushrooms $10.00
Spaghetti Marinara $9.00
Spaghetti w/Clam Sauce (Red or White) $13.00
Ziti w/Broccoli $12.00
Penne Alla Vodka $14.99

Heros
Meatball Parmigiana $12.00
Sausage Parmigiana $12.00
Sausage & Peppers $12.00
Veal Cutlet Parmigiana $20.00
Eggplant Parmigiana $12.00
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana $14.00
Pepper & Egg $10.00
Shrimp Parmigiana $15.00

Entrees (Served w/Spaghetti or Ziti)
Veal Cutlet Parmigiana $28.00
Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana $18.00
Chicken Francese or Marsala $20.00
Eggplant Parmigiana $15.00
Sausage & Peppers Pizzaiola $15.00
Eggplant Rollatini $16.00
Shrimp Parmigiana $20.00

Baked Specialties
Lasagna $14.00
Ravioli $12.00
Manicotti $12.00
Baked Ziti $11.50
Baked Ziti Sicilian (w/Ricotta & Eggplant) $12.00
Stuffed Shells $12.00

Pizza (Regular)
Slice $3.50
All Cheese $19.00
Meatball $23.00
Sausage $23.00
Pepperoni $23.00
Anchovies $23.00
Mushroom $23.00
Peppers $23.00
Onion or Garlic $23.00
White Pizza $20.00
White Pizza (w/Broccoli or Spinach) $22.00
Special Pizza $27.00
Grandma Pizza $20.00
Buffalo Pizza $28.00
Baked Ziti Pizza $26.00
Penna Alla Vodka Pizza $26.00

Pizza (Sicilian)
Slice $3.50
All Cheese $20.00
Meatball $24.00
Sausage $24.00
Pepperoni $24.00
Anchovies $24.00
Mushroom $24.00
Peppers $24.00
Onion or Garlic $24.00

Catering Menu (Small)
Cold Antipasto $41.00
Tossed Salad $36.00
Meatballs $61.00
Sausage & Peppers $56.00
Eggplant Rollatini $61.00
Eggplant Parmigiana $56.00
Chicken Marsala $71.00
Chicken Francese $71.00
Chicken Parmigiana $71.00
Shrimp Parmigiana $82.00
Linguini w/Clam Sauce (Red or White) $52.00

Catering Menu (Large)
Cold Antipasto $61.00
Tossed Salad $51.00
Meatballs $81.00
Sausage & Peppers $86.00
Eggplant Rollatini $86.00
Eggplant Parmigiana $86.00
Chicken Marsala $106.00
Chicken Francese $106.00
Chicken Parmigiana $106.00
Shrimp Parmigiana $137.00
Linguini w/Clam Sauce (Red or White) $77.00

Beverages
Snapple $2.00
Soda (Can) $1.00
Soda (2 Liter Bottle) $3.00

Scottio's Pizza Details

Service options
Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Accessibility
Wheelchair accessible parking lot

Offerings
Comfort food
Quick bite

Dining options
Lunch
Dinner
Catering

Atmosphere
Casual

Payments
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Credit cards

Children
Good for kids

Parking
Free street parking

Scottio's Pizza Photos

Scottio's Pizza Location

Scottio's Pizza

New York Nassau County Valley Stream Dubois Avenue

171 Dubois Ave, Valley Stream, NY 11580, USA

Scottio's Pizza Reviews

An average rating of ★4.4 from 39 user reviews.

pieareaslicesgood luckmeatballsgarlic knotsfillingprice

★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1

4 stars based solely on the fact that they sell Italian ices!!! I reserve the fifth star for when I actually try their food. Great selection of ices and they would have got five stars just for that but there was no rainbow ice..... That having been said, the chocolate fudge flavor was amazing. Please get your ices here and help keep Italian ices in pizzerias!!! Enjoy!
August 13 · kevin abrams
scottios pizza is the best pizza in the area. great dough and the sauce is great. Also scottio and his staff are very kind and family like. always a pleasure stopping by this place and grabbing a slice. 10/10 would absolutely recommend
March 04 · Leo Leeav Faigenblat
All of their slices taste amazing and fresh ! Definitely my favorite pizza shop in the neighborhood. Sicilian is my go to slice!
November 02 · shakaira sanjurjo
Amazing pizza. Best in the valley stream area. HIGHLY RECOMMEND
September 07 · Review Guy
We had the pleasure of being able to grab pizza twice on our trip here. If we are ever back in NYC, the whole family wants to go out of our way to come back. That’s how good the pizza and service is. This is a can’t miss opportunity for amazing pizza!!!
June 22 · Howard Stall