Sid's All American

- 80 Glen Cove Ave, Glen Cove, NY 11542

If you're cruising through Long Island, especially near the North Shore, and find yourself craving classic, high-quality American comfort food, look no further than Sid's All American. Located right in the heart of Glen Cove, NY, this spot is much more than just a hamburger restaurant—it's a beloved local institution founded in 2014 by Glen Cove native Ross McCalla, named in honor of his respected grandfather, Sidney Canarick. Sid's All American prides itself on being a hometown, family establishment that commits to using fresh ingredients to deliver the best-tasting food in town, all served up in a fun, friendly, and notably fast-paced environment.

Sid's has earned a strong reputation among New Yorkers for consistently serving up delicious, made-to-order classics. They specialize in a diverse menu of quintessential American fare, ensuring there's a satisfying bite for everyone in the family or friend group. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick lunch, a casual dinner, or a late-night bite, Sid's All American offers a memorable dining experience characterized by great food and a welcoming atmosphere. It’s a go-to destination that perfectly captures a casual, trendy, and retro-style burger stand vibe with an authentic, community-focused spirit, making it a must-visit in the Glen Cove food scene.

The menu is extensive and focuses on quality. Their flagship offerings include various burger options, from the essential Single Burger up to the Homerun Burger (four patties!), perfect for those with a serious appetite. For those seeking alternatives, they feature the Impossible Burger for a delicious plant-based option, as well as a Turkey Burger. Beyond the world of beef, Sid's excels with its chicken and cheesesteak selections. The Fried Chicken Sandwich and the signature Frosted Flake Chicken Tenders have garnered high praise, as have their authentic, hearty Steak Cheesesteaks and Chicken Cheesesteaks, served on fresh-baked hero rolls. Every meal is complemented by their famous hand-cut Fries, which come in creative variations like Cajun Fries, Truffle Fries, and the ever-popular Disco Fries (topped with gravy and melted mozzarella cheese).

But a visit to Sid's All American wouldn't be complete without indulging in their dessert offerings. Their milkshakes are legendary in the community—rich, thick, and fully customizable with a variety of flavors and toppings. One customer review specifically highlights the chocolate milkshake as "rich and very sweet," noting its superiority to watery alternatives. Additionally, they offer a range of ice cream in small, medium, and large sizes, as well as soft serve and delicious Fried Oreos.

Sid's commitment to accommodating all members of the community is another reason for its strong local following. They thoughtfully provide options for those with dietary restrictions, including gluten-free buns for their famous burgers, which customers rave about. One reviewer mentioned that their gluten-free bun was "soft and did not fall apart while eating it," coupled with delicious gluten-free fries and ice cream, making it an incredible find for those with celiac disease.

The atmosphere itself enhances the experience. It's described as casual and trendy, with a fun, retro-style aesthetic. The setting is particularly family-friendly and welcoming to groups, college students, and even tourists. On nice days, the outdoor seating, featuring picnic tables, becomes a popular spot to enjoy a meal. The restaurant is not just a place for a quick bite; it’s a community hub that even offers a food truck service, bringing their classic American fare directly to local events and private parties around Long Island.

Sid's All American is a testament to quality, community, and classic American dining done right. Whether you’re looking for the best burger-and-fries combo, a satisfying cheesesteak, or an indulgent milkshake, this Glen Cove staple offers a consistently excellent experience that keeps Long Island locals coming back for more.

Location and Accessibility

Sid's All American is conveniently located at 80 Glen Cove Ave in Glen Cove, NY. This accessible Long Island location makes it an easy stop for locals and those passing through the area. They offer both a free parking lot and free street parking, taking the hassle out of your visit. Furthermore, the restaurant is committed to accessibility for all guests, offering a wheelchair accessible entrance, parking lot, restroom, and seating.

Services Offered

• Dine-in service with a casual and family-friendly seating area.
• Outdoor seating, including picnic tables, which is particularly popular during warmer months, and even allows dogs outside.
• Takeout and delivery services, including a no-contact delivery option for convenience.
• A diverse menu covering lunch, dinner, and dessert.
• Catering services, including a food truck to bring their menu to your local events and parties.
• Offerings of alcoholic beverages, including beer, wine, and hard liquor.
• A dedicated Kids' Menu and high chairs, making it excellent for families with children.
• Accepts various payment methods, including Credit Cards, Debit Cards, and NFC Mobile Payments.

Features / Highlights

• Specializes in high-quality, fresh-to-order American classics like custom burgers, chicken sandwiches, and Philly cheesesteaks.
• Known for incredibly Fast Service, perfect for a quick and satisfying meal.
• Features an impressive selection of Milkshakes and Ice Cream that are highly praised by customers.
• Offers excellent Gluten-Free options, including a soft and durable gluten-free bun for burgers.
• Has a distinct Casual and Trendy retro-style atmosphere with a focus on sports, great for a fun time with groups.
• Serves Late-Night Food, providing a great option outside of typical dining hours.
• Provides a full bar setup with a selection of Alcohol, Beer, Wine, and Hard Liquor.

Contact Information

Address: 80 Glen Cove Ave, Glen Cove, NY 11542, USA

Phone: (516) 200-9071

What is worth choosing

When planning your visit to Sid's All American, you will find that a few menu items stand out as customer favorites and must-tries. The Grilled Cheese Burger is an innovative and highly recommended choice, described by one customer as “amazing.” It’s a clever combination that replaces the traditional bun with two grilled cheese sandwiches, creating a unique and intensely flavored experience. For side dishes, the Hand-Cut Fries are consistently celebrated for their quality, and you can't go wrong with the elevated versions like the Truffle Fries or Cajun Fries. The sheer variety of loaded fries, including Chili Cheese Fries and Bacon Cheese Fries, also makes choosing a side an adventure in itself.

No order is complete without a sweet finish; the Milkshakes are arguably the establishment's most famous feature. Praised for their rich, non-watery consistency and sweet flavor, they are the ideal dessert. And for a unique savory appetizer, many regulars swear by the Buffalo Onion Petals. Finally, for those on a specialty diet, the accommodating and delicious Gluten-Free Burger Options are a strong reason to choose Sid's, offering a quality experience that can be hard to find elsewhere. Sid's All American in Glen Cove delivers an authentic, satisfying slice of Long Island comfort food that's worth the trip for any New Yorker.

Sid's All American

80 Glen Cove Ave, Glen Cove, NY 11542, USA