Simmer Down Restaurant & Bakery Introduce
Welcome, New Yorkers, to a deep dive into a beloved local gem: Simmer Down Restaurant & Bakery. Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn at 133 Rockaway Ave, this establishment is a go-to spot for those seeking authentic and comforting Caribbean cuisine. In a city known for its diverse culinary landscape, Simmer Down stands out by offering a taste of the islands right here in the neighborhood. This article is your comprehensive guide to everything you need to know about this restaurant, from its flavorful menu to its convenient services and friendly atmosphere. We'll explore why Simmer Down has become a popular choice for lunch, dinner, and a quick, satisfying bite, catering to solo diners, families, and everyone in between.
The essence of Simmer Down lies in its commitment to traditional flavors and hearty, homestyle cooking. Their menu is a celebration of Caribbean classics, featuring dishes that are simmered to perfection, hence the name. From rich and tender Oxtails to spicy Jerk Chicken, the food here is designed to be both delicious and deeply comforting. For residents of New York who appreciate genuine comfort food, this restaurant offers an experience that feels both familiar and special. The atmosphere is deliberately casual, creating a welcoming and relaxed environment where you can unwind and enjoy a fantastic meal. Our goal is to provide a detailed overview of this specific eatery, giving you all the necessary information to make your next meal a memorable one at Simmer Down Restaurant & Bakery.
Simmer Down Restaurant & Bakery is conveniently located at 133 Rockaway Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11233, USA. Positioned in a vibrant and accessible part of Brooklyn, the restaurant is a focal point for the local community and an easy destination for those traveling from other parts of the city. While specific details on accessibility features such as wheelchair ramps or accessible restrooms are not publicly listed, its presence in a bustling city neighborhood suggests it aims to be a welcoming spot for all. New York's public transportation network makes the area easily reachable, and its street-level location generally provides straightforward access.
The restaurant's location in a residential and commercial area means it is integrated into the daily life of the community. Its presence provides a readily available option for a quick, authentic meal for those living and working nearby. The address itself serves as a clear landmark, making it easy for both regular customers and first-time visitors to find. For those navigating the city, knowing this local spot is at a clear address like 133 Rockaway Ave makes planning a visit simple and efficient, whether you're heading there for a planned dinner or an impromptu lunch.
Simmer Down Restaurant & Bakery provides a range of services tailored to the needs of its New York clientele, focusing on convenience and flexibility. The two primary service options available are designed to cater to different dining preferences.
- Dine-in: The restaurant offers a casual and comfortable setting for guests who wish to sit down and enjoy their meal on-site. The atmosphere is perfect for a relaxed lunch or a satisfying dinner, allowing you to fully immerse yourself in the flavors of the Caribbean.
- Delivery: Recognizing the city's fast-paced lifestyle, Simmer Down offers delivery services. This option allows you to have your favorite Caribbean comfort food brought directly to your doorstep, which is ideal for a busy day at work, a cozy night in, or when you simply don’t want to leave the house.
- Catering: For larger gatherings, events, or office functions, the restaurant provides catering services. Their selection of Main Dishes and Sides makes them a great choice for feeding a crowd with hearty, delicious food that everyone will love.
Simmer Down Restaurant & Bakery has several key features that contribute to its appeal and popularity among local New Yorkers. These aspects highlight its value as a dining destination.
- Casual and Welcoming Atmosphere: The restaurant is known for its casual ambiance, which creates a low-key and comfortable environment for all guests. It’s a no-frills spot where the focus is squarely on the quality of the food.
- Popular for Every Meal: It is a popular spot for both lunch and dinner, making it a reliable option for any time of day. Its reputation as a destination for solo dining further underscores its accessibility and comfort for individuals.
- Authentic Offerings: The menu is centered around comforting, traditional Caribbean comfort food. Whether you're in the mood for a quick bite or a small plate, the offerings are consistently flavorful and satisfying.
- Flexible Dining Options: Beyond lunch and dinner, Simmer Down also offers breakfast and dessert options, making it a comprehensive eatery that can satisfy cravings throughout the day.
- Payments: The establishment accepts a variety of modern payment methods, including credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, providing a seamless and convenient checkout experience.
- Good for Kids: The restaurant is considered a good place to bring children, suggesting a kid-friendly atmosphere and menu options that appeal to a younger audience.
To get in touch with Simmer Down Restaurant & Bakery, whether to ask a question, place an order for delivery, or inquire about catering, you can use the following contact details.
Address: 133 Rockaway Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11233, USA
Phone: (718) 342-6128
When you visit Simmer Down Restaurant & Bakery, the menu offers a rich selection of authentic Caribbean dishes that are worth exploring. The main dishes are the heart of the menu and are where the restaurant truly shines. The Oxtails are a standout item, praised for their rich flavor and tender texture. For a taste of classic Jamaican cuisine, the Jerk Chicken and Curry Goat are excellent choices, offering a perfect balance of spice and savory goodness. The Stew Chicken and Fry Chicken are also popular, providing a milder yet equally delicious alternative. For seafood enthusiasts, the Brown Stew Snapper and Whitening Fish are a must-try, prepared with traditional island flavors.
No meal is complete without the sides, and Simmer Down offers a variety that complements the main dishes perfectly. The Rice and Peas are a staple and a great choice to pair with any of the main meat dishes. The Macaroni And Cheese and Macaroni Salad are comfort food classics that add a familiar touch to the meal. For a different taste, try the Rasta Pasta or the Plantains, both of which are fan favorites. The offerings of quick bites and small plates also make it easy to try a little bit of everything.
What makes Simmer Down a worthwhile choice for a local New Yorker is its dedication to serving authentic, flavorful Caribbean food in a no-fuss, casual setting. The comfort food focus ensures that every meal is hearty and satisfying. The availability of delivery and dine-in options caters to the city's diverse needs, whether you're looking for a relaxing meal out or a quick, delicious dinner at home. Its reputation as a spot for lunch, dinner, and even breakfast makes it a versatile destination. The convenient payment options and kid-friendly atmosphere also add to its appeal, making it a practical and enjoyable choice for a wide range of customers in the New York community.
Simmer Down Restaurant & Bakery Services
Soups
- Cow Foot Large $12.00
Served with pumpkin or red peas.
Main Dishes
- Oxtails
Served with rice, veggies, and platains.
- Jerk Chicken
Served with rice, veggies, and plantians.
- Stew Chicken
Served with rice, veggies, and plantains. Choice of rice and peas, or white rice.
- Curry Chicken
Served with rice, veggies, and plantains. Choice of rice and peas, or white rice.
- Jerk Pork
Served with rice, veggies, and plantains. Choice of rice and peas, or white rice.
- Curry Goat
Served with rice, veggies, and plantains.
- Fry Chicken
Served with rice, veggies, and plantains. Choice of rice and peas, or white rice.
Fish Meal
- Brown Stew Snapper $25.00
Mild and sweet fish.
- Whitening Fish $16.00
- Shrimp $18.00
Sides
- Rasta Pasta $8.00
Colorful pasta with vegetables.
- Macaroni And Cheese $6.00
Macaroni pasta in a cheese sauce.
- Macaroni Salad $7.00
Cold pasta salad made with macaroni noodles.
- Plantains $5.00
- Steam Vegetable $6.00
Cooked using moist heat.
- Rice And Peas $8.00
- Lo Mein $6.00
Egg noodle dish.
- Potato Salad $5.00
Cold dish made from seasoned potatoes.
- White Rice $5.00
Simmer Down Restaurant & Bakery Details
Service options
- Delivery
- Dine-in
- Takeout
Popular for
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Solo dining
Accessibility
- Wheelchair accessible parking lot
- Wheelchair accessible seating
Offerings
- Comfort food
- Quick bite
- Small plates
Dining options
- Breakfast
- Lunch
- Dinner
- Catering
- Dessert
- Table service
Atmosphere
- Casual
Payments
- Credit cards
- Debit cards
- NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards
Children
- Good for kids
Simmer Down Restaurant & Bakery Photos

Simmer Down Restaurant & Bakery Location
Simmer Down Restaurant & Bakery
133 Rockaway Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11233, USA
Simmer Down Restaurant & Bakery Reviews
pricesoxtailjerkcaribbean foodsouprasta pastabeggingplantainsrice and peasdinner
★ 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1Very rude and poor customer service. I went in to just order plantain, the lady working was speaking to me like I’m a beggar when all I wanted was to support a local business. I asked her if she takes card and she said yes, then when we got to the register she said she doesn’t take card. I walked out without purchasing and won’t be going back.
September 25 · MaiWell I can’t speak for the service because i never entered the establishment. However I got a large oxtail with white rice and mac n cheese for about $25. Of course I’ve had better tasting oxtail from others, but what made me take the time out to even write this review is the simple fact that it took an extra 15min for me to eat at least 1/2 of this meal. The amount of thyme stems/roots that I found was noticeably annoying. I couldn’t enjoy ONE BITE of food without removing a rather large “stick” or “stem” of whatever herb was used. Another dishonorable mention would be the Mac n cheese…why is it sweet?
November 03 · Sam D.This place is disgusting! Charged me 9$ for a small jerk chicken however the chicken was days old chicken taken off the grill! Dry and crisp. Damn near charcoal. Do not buy their jerk chicken if you still decide to go. And the funny part is I asked the chef if the chicken is good and he said yes.
July 16 · Imani Wise1 st the attitude of the workers are intimidating,the restaurant is disgusting no upgrades and the price keeps going up and the meal keeps getting smaller the curry goat it fatty and half the meal is curry ginger for $18 is wild and it's not fresh no beef in the red pea soup but want to charge $10 this place is a let down
April 08 · Karoline KortI have been enjoying the fruits of the cooks, servers, and front-end staff's labor for years. Over 5 years. Since becoming a teacher, I am required to leave home earlier, compared to my schedule in previous years. For the past 2 years, I look forward to visiting Simmer Down restaurant to purchase my breakfast.The variety and delicious food selections are abundant. The cook has gifted hands. The servers are pleasant and attentive as I communicate my order. The cashier, usually an assertive, stern Caribbean woman with a serious facial expression and a gentle approach to customers, ensures customers are aware of the cost of orders. She also ensures optimal financial gains for Summer Down, as she could be heard informing her colleagues of the accurate costs of products.Simmer Down is worth visiting for breakfast, lunch, or dinner. I particularly enjoy that music is played throughout the day, rather than the news. Music adds a warm welcome upon entering the restaurant.While I've tried every dish excluding the shellfish, I recommend the vegetable chow mein, curry chicken w/potato, macaroni salad, and plantains. The cornmeal porridge and bread and bun are always fresh and well good.Edit on January 22, 2024: I recommend making all purchases with cash. This establishment apply a surcharge for all debit/credit card transactions. Sometimes up to .89 which is significant compared to other businesses.
January 22 · Ali Moore
More restaurants near me

1556 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11221, USA

156 Howard Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11233, USA

1544 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11221, USA

1510 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11221, USA

93 Howard Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11233, USA

801 Halsey St #1, Brooklyn, NY 11233, USA

194 Ralph Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11233, USA

Cellar of Bakery by Textbook, 874 Hancock St, Brooklyn, NY 11233, USA

874 Hancock St, Brooklyn, NY 11233, USA

Located inside Bakery by Textbook, 874 Hancock St, Brooklyn, NY 11233, USA

1491 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 11221, USA

872 Hancock St, Brooklyn, NY 11233, USA
Categories
Top Visited Sites






Trending Dining Insights Posts





