Stella’s Pizzeria

- 283 Broadway, Newburgh, NY 12550

Stella’s Pizzeria: Your Go-To Spot for Authentic Italian and New York Pizza in Newburgh

If you're in the Newburgh, New York, area and looking for a local pizza restaurant that offers more than just a quick slice, look no further than **Stella’s Pizzeria**. Located right on Broadway, Stella’s has established itself as a true community staple, renowned for serving up incredibly delicious and authentic-style Italian food in a warm, family-friendly atmosphere. From enormous, satisfying subs and classic, perfectly cheesy pizza slices to a comprehensive menu of Italian dinners, Stella’s Pizzeria is a place you can rely on for a quality meal, whether you’re stopping in for a quick bite or settling down for a relaxing dinner with family and friends.

Stella’s Pizzeria takes pride in its reputation for delivering great food that keeps locals coming back. Customers frequently praise the **generous portions**—noting that the pizzas and subs are "enormous"—and the genuine taste of their Italian offerings. Whether you're craving a classic plain slice with a perfect crust or a hearty dinner like Chicken Parmigiana or Baked Ziti, Stella's focuses on quality ingredients and authentic preparation. It's a spot where the dedicated staff consistently treats customers like family, making every visit enjoyable.

Location and Accessibility

Stella’s Pizzeria is conveniently situated at **283 Broadway, Newburgh, NY 12550, USA**. The location on Broadway places it right in a key part of Newburgh's local business corridor, making it an easy stop for lunch, dinner, or a quick takeout order. As a neighborhood restaurant, it is well-connected to the local area, serving residents and visitors alike.

When planning your visit, note that parking in the area is managed via **paid street parking**. The City of Newburgh utilizes parking meters in its business districts, including sections of Broadway. These meters typically operate between 8:00 a.m. and 6:00 p.m. on most days, except Sunday, though specific hours and rates can vary by block. You can pay at the on-street meters, which may accept credit cards, debit cards, or the ParkNYC app for convenience.

Accessibility is a priority at Stella’s Pizzeria, ensuring that all community members feel welcome. The establishment is designed with comprehensive **wheelchair accessibility**, including a:

• Wheelchair accessible entrance
• Wheelchair accessible restroom
• Wheelchair accessible seating

This commitment to accessibility ensures a comfortable dining experience for every patron.

Services Offered

Stella’s Pizzeria provides multiple service options to fit your schedule and dining preferences:

• Dine-in: Enjoy a casual and quiet atmosphere with comfortable seating and Wi-Fi access, perfect for a relaxed meal. The setting is notably family-friendly.
• Takeout: For those on the go, counter service and takeout are fast and efficient, allowing you to quickly grab your order and enjoy Stella's food at home or work.
• Delivery: Stella's offers delivery service, bringing your favorite pizzas, Italian dinners, and more right to your doorstep.
• Catering: For events, parties, or large family gatherings, Stella’s offers catering services, helping you feed a crowd with their delicious menu selections.
• Counter Service: Quick and efficient service for takeout orders and fast bites.
• Lunch and Dinner: Full dining options are available for both lunch and dinner crowds.
• Dessert: Be sure to save room for dessert!

Features and Highlights

The menu at Stella’s Pizzeria is extensive, offering a variety of Italian and classic American options with a focus on generous portions and comforting flavors. Highlights of the menu and restaurant features include:

• Authentic and Specialty Pizza: While a plain cheese slice is highly praised for its perfect crust and cheesy flavor, the menu boasts specialty options like the **Meat Lovers Pizza**, **Margherita Pizza**, **Grandma Pizza**, and the **Stella’s De Lux** (with sausage, peppers, pepperoni, mushrooms, and onions). They also offer a 12-inch **Gluten Free Pizza**.
• Hearty Italian Dinners: Beyond pizza, you can enjoy a full Italian meal with offerings such as **Chicken Parmigiana** ($13.00), **Baked Ziti** ($12.50), **Chicken Marsala** ($14.00), **Spaghetti Carbonara** ($13.00), and **Veal Parmigiana** ($14.50).
• Oversized Heroes and Rolls: The menu features substantial 12-inch Hot Heroes, including the popular **Philly Cheese Steak With Peppers And Onions** ($11.50) and **Meatball Parmigiana** ($10.00), alongside a variety of hot and cold specialty rolls like the **Chicken Bacon Roll** ($8.50) and **Stromboli** ($8.50).
• Wide Variety of Menu Options: Catering to all tastes, the menu also includes a range of **Burgers** (like the **Stella's Deluxe Burger**), fresh **Salads** (including **Cobb** and **Buffalo Chicken Salad**), and classic **Appetizers** like Buffalo Wings and Fried Calamari.
• Family-Friendly Atmosphere: Known for being a welcoming spot for families, with the availability of **High Chairs** and a generally **casual** and relaxed dining atmosphere.
• Flexible Payments: Customers can easily pay using various methods, including **Credit Cards**, **Debit Cards**, and **NFC Mobile Payments**.

Contact Information

To place an order for takeout or delivery, or for any inquiries, you can reach Stella’s Pizzeria using the following contact details:

• Address: 283 Broadway, Newburgh, NY 12550, USA
• Phone: (845) 795-8608

The establishment is part of the local community, and their contact information is easily accessible for direct orders.

What is Worth Choosing Stella’s Pizzeria

For Newburgh residents and anyone passing through the region, Stella’s Pizzeria represents a quintessential local Italian dining experience. What truly makes Stella’s a worthwhile choice is its commitment to quality food, value, and community-focused service.

First and foremost, the **food is excellent**. It’s comfort food done right—a quick bite that truly satisfies. Whether you're craving a classic New York-style big slice of pizza, a comforting baked pasta dish, or a massive sub, the quality and taste consistently impress customers. The fact that the pizza and subs are described as "enormous and incredibly delicious" is a testament to the value and hearty nature of their offerings. The perfectly cheesy slices and excellent crust are a significant draw for any pizza enthusiast.

Secondly, the **atmosphere and service** make it stand out. The casual and quiet environment, paired with staff who treat customers like family, creates a consistently positive experience. It’s a local business that genuinely feels like a part of the community, evidenced by the support and positive feedback from various local patrons, including the City of Newburgh's police officers.

Finally, the sheer **breadth of the menu** ensures there is something for everyone, making it ideal for family outings or group orders. From seafood pasta to gourmet burgers, and a vast selection of Italian staples, Stella's ensures a full and diverse meal for any craving. The convenient service options—delivery, takeout, and a fully accessible dine-in area—further cement Stella's Pizzeria as a top choice for authentic, satisfying Italian fare in Newburgh, NY.

Stella’s Pizzeria

283 Broadway, Newburgh, NY 12550, USA