Tesa’s Bagel Café

- 959 4th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11232

Introduction / Overview: Your Authentic Brooklyn Bagel and Coffee Destination

For many New Yorkers and visitors to the borough, the search for an authentic, perfectly crafted bagel leads straight to Tesa’s Bagel Café in Brooklyn. Located at 959 4th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11232, this coffee shop and deli has quickly become recognized as a true neighborhood gem, celebrated for exceeding expectations and providing an impeccable blend of quality food, great beverages, and genuinely friendly service.

Tesa’s Bagel Café is the quintessential neighborhood spot. While categorized as a Coffee shop, it equally excels as an authentic New York deli, famous for serving fresh, chewy on the inside with just the right crisp on the outside bagels. The menu is expansive, offering everything from all-day Breakfast options, classic Bagel or Roll sandwiches with various meats like Turkey Bacon or Pastrami, to stacked Cold Sandwiches and hot specialties like the Philly Cheese Steak and Chicken Cutlet.

Beyond the exceptional food, the café is highly praised for its beverage selection, offering Great coffee (including Espresso, Latte ($4.00), and specialty lattes like Caramel Latte ($4.50)), a Great tea selection, and an impressive array of freshly prepared drinks. Their fresh-squeezed options, such as Squeezed Orange ($7.00) and invigorating custom blends like the ABC juice and Powerful smoothie, are often cited as "to die for." The atmosphere is welcoming, Casual, and run by a friendly, entrepreneurial team, making it a reliable and beloved spot for breakfast and lunch.

Location and Accessibility: A 4th Avenue Neighborhood Gem

Tesa’s Bagel Café is conveniently situated at 959 4th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11232, USA. This address places it on a prominent thoroughfare in a well-trafficked and easily accessible area of Brooklyn, serving the surrounding neighborhoods. The café's location makes it a highly convenient stop for local residents, commuters, and those working in the area who are looking for a quick and high-quality meal or coffee.

The café is designed primarily for quick service but also offers charming amenities. While the seating inside may be limited, customers appreciate the cute little bistro seats with tables outside, allowing for an enjoyable outdoor dining experience in nice weather. This is especially appealing for those grabbing breakfast or lunch and wanting a moment of fresh air.

In terms of service, Tesa’s prioritizes customer convenience with modern and flexible options, including Curbside pickup, No-contact delivery, Delivery, and Takeout. This robust range of service options ensures that whether you are on your way to work or staying in, you can easily access their fresh menu items and beloved bagels.

Services Offered

Tesa’s Bagel Café offers a comprehensive, all-day menu that caters to breakfast, lunch, and everything in between:

• LI: Authentic NYC Bagels and Rolls: Features a wide selection of freshly made bagels and rolls, including various hot sandwiches like Egg & Cheese ($5.00) with choice of meat (Bacon, Sausage, Ham, etc.) and premium options like Fresh Lox ($13.00 - $15.00).
• LI: Specialty Cream Cheese Spreads: Known for flavorful and generously portioned spreads, including Scallion ($5.00), Vegetable ($5.00), Jalapeño Cheddar ($5.00), and the highly-recommended Lox-Spread ($7.00).
• LI: Full Deli Service: Offers stacked, high-quality Cold Sandwiches (Turkey, Tuna Salad, Pastrami ($9.00)) and satisfying Hot Sandwiches and Paninis (such as Grilled Chicken Panini ($12.00) or BLT ($5.00)).
• LI: Comprehensive Coffee Menu: Provides a complete range of coffee shop favorites, including standard Cafe ($1.50), Cappuccino ($4.00), Cortado ($4.00), and specialty items like Iced Caramel Latte ($5.50).
• LI: Fresh-Pressed Juices and Smoothies: A standout offering is their selection of made-to-order, healthy beverages like the Citrus Sunrise juice ($8.00) and nutrient-packed Best Green smoothie ($7.00).
• LI: All-Day Meals: Caters to both Breakfast and Lunch dining needs with items like the Breakfast Plate ($9.00), various flavorful Wraps (e.g., Bandstand ($10.00)), and fresh Salads (e.g., Greek ($8.00)).

Features / Highlights

The success and high rating of Tesa’s Bagel Café are attributed to several unique features and a strong community focus:

• LI: Exceptional Bagel Quality: Customers consistently rave about the perfectly chewy and crisp bagels—a crucial hallmark of authentic New York bagel making—ensuring they "blow your minds."
• LI: Gourmet Cream Cheese Selection: The variety and quality of the cream cheese spreads, particularly the highly-recommended Scallion and Lox-Spread, are a major draw and feature generous portions.
• LI: Latino-Owned and Community-Focused: The business is proudly Christian-owned and operated by an entrepreneur from Guatemala. This gives the café a uniquely friendly and accommodating vibe, often accompanied by Christian Spanish music, and occasionally features specials like complimentary Guatemalan tamales.
• LI: Convenient All-in-One Stop: The café acts as a local general store, selling not just food and coffee but also Latino groceries and fresh deli meats, making it a versatile stop for neighborhood residents.
• LI: Health-Conscious Drink Options: The wide variety of Fresh Juices and Smoothies (like Tesa’s Mango or All Green) is a significant highlight for those seeking fresh, healthy, and natural beverage alternatives.

Contact Information

Tesa’s Bagel Café is ready to serve the Brooklyn community with quality food and friendly service:

Address: 959 4th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11232, USA

Phone: (347) 457-5237

Mobile Phone: +1 347-457-5237

Approximate Hours of Operation: Typically operates with very early morning hours, catering to commuters (e.g., 5:30 AM - 7:00 PM on weekdays, and slightly different hours on Sunday). It is always best to call ahead for the most accurate daily schedule.

What is Worth Choosing: Quality, Freshness, and Impeccable Service

Choosing Tesa’s Bagel Café means choosing an establishment that is truly committed to quality and community, which is why it maintains such high ratings. This is not a fast-food joint; it is a place where the food is consistently super tasty and fresh, and the service is described as impeccable.

What makes Tesa’s stand out is its dual specialization: it perfectly combines the art of the New York bagel shop with the convenience and health focus of a top-tier café. You can get a classic, expertly prepared breakfast bagel (like the essential Fresh Lox sandwich) alongside a nutritious, freshly pressed ABC juice. The dedication of the owner, the generous portions, and the extra touches of kindness, like complimentary specials, solidify its reputation. For anyone in the New York region—especially in Brooklyn—seeking a satisfying, high-quality, Casual meal where they are treated like family, Tesa’s Bagel Café is highly recommended and truly a 10/10 dining experience.

Tesa’s Bagel Café

959 4th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11232, USA